Case Details

Citation

HKSAR v. HUI RAFAEL Junior also known as HUI SI-YAN RAFAEL AND OTHERS, CACC 444EM/2014

Case Number

CACC 444EM/2014

Court

Court of Appeal

(CA)

Decision Date

16 February 2016

Parties

Applicant(s):

HKSAR (香港特別行政區), KWOK Ping-kwong Thomas (郭炳江), CHAN Kui-yuen also known as Thomas CHAN (陳鉅源), KWAN Francis Hung-sang also known as KWAN Francis (關雄生)

Respondent(s):

HUI Rafael Junior also known as HUI Si-yan Rafael (許仕仁)

HKSAR v. HUI RAFAEL Junior also known as HUI SI-YAN RAFAEL AND OTHERS

CACC 444/2014 · CACC 444EM/2014

Court of Appeal16 February 2016

CACC444EM/2014 HKSAR v. HUI RAFAEL Junior also known as HUI SI-YAN RAFAEL AND OTHERS

CACC 444/2014

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF APPEAL

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 444 OF 2014

(ON APPEAL FROM HCCC NO. 98 OF 2013)

____________

BETWEEN

	HKSAR (香港特別行政區)	Respondent
	and
	HUI Rafael Junior also known as HUI Si-yan Rafael (許仕仁)	1^st Appellant/ 1^st Defendant
	KWOK Ping-kwong Thomas (郭炳江)	2^nd Appellant/ 2^nd Defendant
	CHAN Kui-yuen also known as Thomas CHAN (陳鉅源)	3^rd Appellant/ 4^th Defendant
	KWAN Francis Hung-sang also known as KWAN Francis (關雄生)	4^th Appellant/ 5^th Defendant

____________

Before : Hon Yeung, Lunn VPP and Pang JA in Court

Date of Hearing : 2-5 November 2015

Date of Judgment : 16 February 2016

________________________

C O R R I G E N D A
________________________

The following amendments are made to the Judgment dated 16 February 2016:

1. Paragraph 120, line L “even thought he had been working for them unofficially” should read as “even though he had been working for them unofficially” ;

2. Paragraph 244, line R “This ground of appeal has no merit ought not to have been advanced” should read as “This ground of appeal has no merit and ought not to have been advanced”;

3. Page 115, line I “The judge’s ruling admitting into evidence of the out-of-court statement” should read as “The judge’s ruling admitting into evidence the out-of-court statement”;

4. The representation of the 2^nd appellant (D2) should read as “Ms Clare Montgomery, QC, Mr Gary Plowman, SC and Mr Benson Tsoi, instructed by Davis Polk & Wardwell, for the 2^nd appellant (D2)”.

Dated the 22nd day of March 2016.

	(Kate Fan)
	Clerk to Hon Lunn VP

Citation

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Appeal history

HKSAR v. MA SIN CHI AND OTHERS
CFI · 9 Dec 2013
On appeal from
HUI RAFAEL JUNIOR, also known as HUI SI-YAN RAFAEL AND OTHERS
CFI · 15 Jul 2014
On appeal from
HKSAR v. KWOK PING KWONG THOMAS
CA · 16 Mar 2015
On appeal from
HKSAR v. CHAN KUI YUEN also known as THOMAS CHAN
CA · 28 May 2015
On appeal from
HKSAR v. MA SIN CHI AND ANOTHER
CA · 30 Jun 2015
On appeal from
HKSAR v. HUI RAFAEL Junior also known as HUI SI YAN RAFAEL AND OTHERS
CA · 5 Aug 2015
On appeal from
HKSAR v. HUI RAFAEL Junior also known as HUI SI YAN RAFAEL AND OTHERS
CA · 5 Aug 2015
On appeal from
HKSAR v. CHAN KUI YUEN also known as THOMAS CHAN AND ANOTHER
CA · 11 Sept 2015
On appeal from
HKSAR v. KWOK PING KWONG THOMAS
CA · 11 Sept 2015
On appeal from
HKSAR v. HUI RAFAEL Junior also known as HUI SI-YAN RAFAEL AND OTHERS
CA · 16 Feb 2016 · CACC 444/2014
This judgment
HKSAR v. HUI Rafael Junior also known as HUI SI-YAN RAFAEL AND OTHERS
CA · 16 Feb 2016
On appeal from
HKSAR v. HUI RAFAEL Junior also known as HUI SI-YAN RAFAEL AND OTHERS
CA · 26 Feb 2016
On appeal from
HKSAR v. HUI RAFAEL Junior also known as HUI SI-YAN RAFAEL AND OTHERS
CA · 22 Mar 2016
On appeal from
HKSAR v. MA SIN CHI AND ANOTHER
CA · 17 Jun 2016
On appeal from
HKSAR v. MA SIN CHI AND ANOTHER
CA · 11 Jul 2016
On appeal from
HKSAR v. MA SIN CHI AND ANOTHER
CA · 11 Jul 2016
On appeal from
HKSAR v. HUI RAFAEL JUNIOR also known as HUI SI-YAN RAFAEL
CFA · 12 Jul 2016
On appeal from
HKSAR v. MA SIN CHI
CA · 22 Sept 2016
On appeal from
HKSAR v. MA SIN CHI
CA · 20 Oct 2016
On appeal from
HKSAR v. HA, BUT YEE
CFA · 8 Nov 2016
On appeal from
HKSAR v. CHOI LOK YIN, KINGSTON
CA · 14 Mar 2017
On appeal from
HKSAR v. HUI RAFAEL JUNIOR also known as HUI SI-YAN RAFAEL
CFA · 14 Jun 2017
On appeal from