Case Details

Citation

CHEUNG FAT ENTERPRISES LTD v. HARVEST TREASURE LTD AND OTHERS, FAMV 37M/2016

Case Number

FAMV 37M/2016

Court

Court of Final Appeal

(CFA)

Decision Date

24 August 2016

Parties

Applicant(s):

WISE SUCCESS DEVELOPMENT LIMITED (智成發展有限公司), FUND WIN ENTERPRISE LIMITED (銀勝企業有限公司), LUCKY CHANCE ENTERPRISE LIMITED (福運企業有限公司), CHEUNG FAT ENTERPRISES LIMITED (長發興業有限公司)

Respondent(s):

– CHEUNG FAT ENTERPRISES LIMITED (長發興業有限公司), CHAN PING YING (陳冰瑩), CHAN CHAN KWAN (陳燦堃), CHAN CHUK KWUN (陳竹君)

Judges

Tang

CHEUNG FAT ENTERPRISES LTD v. HARVEST TREASURE LTD AND OTHERS

FAMV 37M/2016

Court of Final Appeal24 August 2016

Judges:Tang

FAMV37M/2016 CHEUNG FAT ENTERPRISES LTD v. HARVEST TREASURE LTD AND OTHERS

FAMV No 37 of 2016

IN THE COURT OF FINAL APPEAL OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

MISCELLANEOUS PROCEEDINGS NO 37 OF 2016 (CIVIL)

(ON APPLICATION FOR LEAVE TO APPEAL FROM CACV 67 OF 2016)

_______________________

BETWEEN

	HARVEST TREASURE LIMITED (溢寶有限公司)	1^st Applicant (1^st Respondent)
	WISE SUCCESS DEVELOPMENT LIMITED (智成發展有限公司)	2^nd Applicant (2^nd Respondent)
	FUND WIN ENTERPRISE LIMITED (銀勝企業有限公司)	3^rd Applicant (3^rd Respondent)
	LUCKY CHANCE ENTERPRISE LIMITED (福運企業有限公司)	4^th Applicant (4^th Respondent)
	– and –
	CHEUNG FAT ENTERPRISES LIMITED (長發興業有限公司)	1^st Respondent (Applicant)
	CHAN PING YING (陳冰瑩)	5^th Respondent (5^th Respondent)
	CHAN CHAN KWAN (陳燦堃)	6^th Respondent (6^th Respondent)
	CHAN CHUK KWUN (陳竹君)	7^th Respondent (7^th Respondent)

_______________________

Before: Mr Justice Tang PJ in Chambers

Date of Hearing and Decision: 24 August 2016

Date of Reasons for Decision: 31 August 2016

Date of Corrigendum: 2 September 2016

_______________________

C O R R I G E N D U M

_______________________

At page 5 paragraph 8 line 2 and at page 7 paragraph 13 line 1, “creditability” should be replaced by “credibility”.

(Ingrid Lam)
(Ms)for Registrar, CFA

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Appeal history

HARVEST TREASURE LTD AND OTHERS v. CHEUNG FAT ENTERPRISES LTD AND OTHERS
LT · 31 Dec 2015
On appeal from
HARVEST TREASURE LTD AND OTHERS v. CHEUNG FAT ENTERPRISES LTD AND OTHERS
CA · 15 Jul 2016
On appeal from
HARVEST TREASURE LTD AND OTHERS v. CEUNG FAT ENTERPRISES LTD AND OTHERS
CA · 22 Aug 2016
On appeal from
CHEUNG FAT ENTERPRISES LTD v. HARVEST TREASURE LTD AND OTHERS
CFA · 24 Aug 2016
This judgment
CHEUNG FAT ENTERPRISES LTD v. HARVEST TREASURE LTD AND OTHERS
CFA · 24 Aug 2016
On appeal from