Case Details
Citation
LUI KIT CHIU v. LUI KWOK HIN CHOW, DCMP 90/1976
Case Number
DCMP 90/1976
Court
District Court
(DC)
Parties
Applicant(s):

LUI KIT CHIU

Respondent(s):

LUI KWOK HIN CHOW

Judges
  • 7<sup>th</sup> October, 1971 as a modern marriage by a man and a woman each of whom is not less than 16 and is not married to any other person shall be a valid marriage. The definition in the Ordinance of a modern marriage is not of much help as it states that a “modern marriage” is a marriage celebrated in open ceremony before 2 witnesses as a modern marriage. What the definition says, in effect, is that a “modern marriage” is a modern marriage. In this regard assistance can be obtained from the 2 White Papers on Chinese marriages in Hong Kong published by the Colonial Secretariat in 1960 and 1967, out of which present legislation arose. It is stated in the second of these when dealing with Chinese Modern Marriages (p.10) that “The essential requisite for such marriages in Hong Kong has by popular consent been celebration in an open but otherwise indefined ceremony in the presence of at least 2 unspecified witnesses. This was the main requirement laid down by the Chinese Civil Code, although it should be noted that Articles 980-988 of the Code laid down other requirements in addition (e.g. degress of consanguinity, need for consent of guardian in some cases etc.) and that it was doubtful how far these other requirements have been known or complied with in Hong Kong”. It seems clear than that the “modern marriage” referred to in the ordinance is a Chinese Modern Marriage, as performed in Hong Kong, based upon Article 982 of the Chinese Civil Code.</p>
  • the Chinese courts that, although the form of the ceremony was left to the parties to decide, there was no valid marriage unless some form of ceremony was gone through. (p.125 seq.)</p>

LUI KIT CHIU v. LUI KWOK HIN CHOW

DCMP 90/1976

District Court
Judges:7<sup>th</sup> October, 1971 as a modern marriage by a man and a woman each of whom is not less than 16 and is not married to any other person shall be a valid marriage. The definition in the Ordinance of a modern marriage is not of much help as it states that a “modern marriage” is a marriage celebrated in open ceremony before 2 witnesses as a modern marriage. What the definition says, in effect, is that a “modern marriage” is a modern marriage. In this regard assistance can be obtained from the 2 White Papers on Chinese marriages in Hong Kong published by the Colonial Secretariat in 1960 and 1967, out of which present legislation arose. It is stated in the second of these when dealing with Chinese Modern Marriages (p.10) that “The essential requisite for such marriages in Hong Kong has by popular consent been celebration in an open but otherwise indefined ceremony in the presence of at least 2 unspecified witnesses. This was the main requirement laid down by the Chinese Civil Code, although it should be noted that Articles 980-988 of the Code laid down other requirements in addition (e.g. degress of consanguinity, need for consent of guardian in some cases etc.) and that it was doubtful how far these other requirements have been known or complied with in Hong Kong”. It seems clear than that the “modern marriage” referred to in the ordinance is a Chinese Modern Marriage, as performed in Hong Kong, based upon Article 982 of the Chinese Civil Code.</p>the Chinese courts that, although the form of the ceremony was left to the parties to decide, there was no valid marriage unless some form of ceremony was gone through. (p.125 seq.)</p>

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition