Case Details
Citation
CHAK KIN SUN AND ANOTHER v. LAM KWOK YUEN AND ANOTHER, HCA 7429/1983
Case Number
HCA 7429/1983
Court
Court of First Instance
(CFI)
Decision Date
11 November 1983
Parties
Applicant(s):

CHAK KIN SUN (a minor, by CHAK CHI KAN, his father and next friend), CHAK CHI KAN

Respondent(s):

LAM KWOK YUEN, SWIRE BOTTLERS LIMITED

For Applicant(s):

On the hearing of the appeal before me two further affidavits sworn by Mr. Miles on behalf of the Defendants were admitted in evidence without opposition from counsel; defend on behalf of the Defendants although the 2nd Defendant or its insurers had always intended to defend the proceedings and to raise the issue of contributory negligence on the part of the 1st Plaintiff. Indeed on the 9th May 1983 the Plaintiffs' solicitors had been informed by Mr. Miles' firm that liability would not be admitted and that his firm was instructed to accept service of the writ. Counsel; unable to conclude that such conduct on a public footway upon which there should be no vehicle manoeuvring amounted to a failure to take reasonable care of himself in the case of a seven year old boy. There being no evidence whatsoever from any other source before me of any other fact relied upon by the 1st Defendant to show contributory negligence on the part of the 1st Plaintiff I conclude that, as Mr. Ribeiro; Ribeiro instructed by Messrs Susan Liang & Co.

For Respondent(s):

Mr. Miles who appeared; I also accept Mr. Ribeiro's submission that this being a situation in which the Defendants are asking for the indulgence of the court there should be some explanation advanced

CHAK KIN SUN AND ANOTHER v. LAM KWOK YUEN AND ANOTHER

HCA 7429/1983

Court of First Instance11 November 1983

Citation

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations