Case Details
For Applicant(s):
Ms Nancy Ngai, instructed by Zhong Lun Law Firm LLP
Listing:
LUCKTIME LTD AND OTHERS v. YAM DO KAI PETER, the Executor of the Estate of YAM KUNG YIN SHANG also known as KUNG YIN SHANG (or SHEUNG) also known as KUNG WING HAR, deceased AND OTHERS
LUCKTIME LTD AND OTHERS v. YAM DO KAI PETER, the Executor of the Estate of YAM KUNG YIN SHANG also known as KUNG YIN SHANG (or SHEUNG) also known as KUNG WING HAR, deceased AND OTHERS
[2026] HKLdT 31 · LDCS 1000/2024
LDCS 1000/2024
[2026] HKLdT 31
IN THE LANDS TRIBUNAL OF THE
HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION
LAND COMPULSORY SALE MAIN APPLICATION NO 1000 OF 2024
__________________________
BETWEEN
|LUCKTIME LIMITED (達時有限公司) |1st Applicant |
|ASIA HARBOUR INVESTMENT LIMITED |2nd Applicant |
|(海信投資有限公司) | |
|SOUTH CROWN DEVELOPMENT LIMITED |3rd Applicant |
|(南冠發展有限公司) | |
|ASIA CHARMING LIMITED (昌鳴有限公司) |4th Applicant |
|GENTWAY LIMITED (雋偉有限公司) |5th Applicant |
|SINO ACCORD INVESTMENT LIMITED |6th Applicant |
|(興雅投資有限公司) | |
|FIRST MATE DEVELOPMENT LIMITED |7th Applicant |
|(科美發展有限公司) | |
|GROUP LEADER LIMITED (合英有限公司) |8th Applicant |
|EVER PLANET LIMITED (偉宙有限公司) |9th Applicant |
|FORTRESS STAR LIMITED (仁星有限公司) |10th |
| |Applicant |
|AND | |
|YAM DO KAI PETER, the Executor of the Estate of |1st Respondent|
|YAM KUNG YIN SHANG (任龔燕嫦) also known as KUNG | |
|YIN SHANG (or SHEUNG) (龔燕嫦) also known as KUNG | |
|WING HAR (龔詠霞), deceased | |
|KWAN WAI YUEN (關位源) and |2nd Respondents|
|CHIU WAI CHING ELSA (趙慧貞) | |
|The Personal Representative of JANG BANG (曾邦), |3rd Respondent |
|deceased as Trustee for and on behalf of JANG LOK PING| |
|(曾樂平) and JANG WAI LAN (曾慧蘭) as | |
|Tenants-in-Common | |
|KWAN WENDY (關卓文) |4th Respondent |
|CHAN CHUK (陳竹), CHIN KOY HEY (陳才椅), LEUNG YUK |5th Respondents|
|CHUN (梁玉珍), the Administratrix of the Estate of | |
|CHAN TAK PING (陳德平), deceased and The Personal | |
|Representative of CHAN PUI FUN (陳佩芬), deceased | |
|NINGEE LIMITED (立致有限公司) |6th Respondent |
|KWAN SHUK MAN (關淑文) |7th Respondent |
|KWAN HEI LAM (關羲琳) |8th Respondent |
|Before: |Mr Lawrence Pang, Member of the Lands Tribunal |
|Date of Trial: |18 May 2026 |
|Date of Judgment: |28 May 2026 |
__________________
JUDGMENT
__________________
Background
This is the applicants’ application for an order for sale (“the
Application”), for the purposes of redevelopment under the Land (Compulsory
Sale for Redevelopment) Ordinance, Cap 545 (“the Ordinance”), of all the
undivided shares of and in the following lots (collectively referred to as
“the Lot” where appropriate) with the corresponding buildings (“the
Buildings”) erected thereon:
|Lot No |Address |
|The Remaining Portion of Sub-section|Nos 18, 18A, 20 & 20A |
|13 of Section A of Hung Hom Marine |Whampoa Street |
|Lot No 1 (“1st Lot”) |(“1st Building”) |
|The Remaining Portion of Sub-section|Nos 22, 22A & 24 Whampoa Street |
|15 of Section A of Hung Hom Marine |and Nos 88, 90 & 90A Baker Street|
|Lot No 1 (“2nd Lot”) |(“2nd Building”) |
Standing on the Lots is a pair of 8-storey tenement blocks fronting onto
Whampoa Street, each of which is served by 2 common staircases.
Occupation permit No K15 of the 1st Building was issued on 13 March 1957,
granting permission to occupy its ground floor (“G/F”) for non-domestic
purpose and upper floors for domestic purpose. According to the approved
building plans of the 1st Building dated 5 September 1956, there are two
shops on G/F, one at G/F, 18 Whampoa Street, and another at G/F, 20 Whampoa
Street. The rear side of the two shops, that is 18A Whampoa Street and 20A
Whampoa Street respectively, being separated by the two common staircases
in the middle, are designed for storage purposes.
Each of the upper floors of the 1st Building comprised originally 4
domestic units.
By reference to the Second Schedule to the Deed of Mutual Covenant of the
1st Building dated 20 September 1957, each of the units mentioned above has
been allotted one equal undivided share of the 1st Lot.
On 6 December 2024 when the applicants filed the Notice of Application, the
ownership of the 1st Building is shown as follows:
|Unit Owned |No of Undivided |Name of Applicant |
| |Share | |
|G/F, 18 Whampoa Street |1/32 |Lucktime Limited (1st |
| | |Applicant) |
|1/F, 18 Whampoa Street |1/32 |Asia Harbour Investment |
| | |Limited (2nd Applicant) |
|2/F, 18 Whampoa Street |1/32 |Gentway Limited (5th |
| | |Applicant) |
|3/F, 18 Whampoa Street |1/32 |Yam Do Kai Peter, The |
| | |Executor of the Estate of |
| | |Yam Kung Yin Shang, |
| | |deceased (1st Respondent) |
|Front Portion of 4/F, |½ of 1/32 |Lucktime Limited |
|18 Whampoa Street | |(1st Applicant) |
|Rear Portion of 4/F, 18|½ of 1/32 | |
|Whampoa Street | | |
|5/F, 18 Whampoa Street |1/32 |Sino Accord Investment |
| | |Limited (6th Applicant) |
|6/F, 18 Whampoa Street |1/32 |Fortress Star Limited |
| | |(10th Applicant) |
|7/F, 18 Whampoa Street |1/32 |Lucktime Limited (1st |
| | |Applicant) |
|G/F, 18A Whampoa Street|1/32 |Lucktime Limited (1st |
| | |Applicant) |
|1/F, 18A Whampoa Street|1/32 |South Crown Development |
| | |Limited (3rd Applicant) |
|2/F, 18A Whampoa Street|1/32 |Kwan Wai Yuen & Chiu Wai |
| | |Ching Elsa (2nd |
| | |Respondents) |
|3/F, 18A Whampoa Street|1/32 |The Personal |
| | |Representative of Jang |
| | |Bang, deceased |
| | |(3rd Respondent) |
|4/F, 18A Whampoa Street|1/32 |Kwan Wai Yuen & Chiu Wai |
| | |Ching Elsa (2nd |
| | |Respondents) |
|5/F, 18A Whampoa Street|1/32 |First Mate Development |
| | |Limited (7h Applicant) |
|6/F, 18A Whampoa Street|1/32 |Lucktime Limited (1st |
| | |Applicant) |
|7/F, 18A Whampoa Street|1/32 | |
|G/F, 20 Whampoa Street |1/32 |Kwan Wai Yuen & Chiu Wai |
| | |Ching Elsa (2nd |
| | |Respondents) |
|1/F, 20 Whampoa Street |1/32 |Asia Charming Limited |
| | |(4th Applicant) |
|2/F, 20 Whampoa Street |1/32 |Kwan Wendy (4th |
| | |Respondent) |
|3/F, 20 Whampoa Street |½ of 1/32 |Lucktime Limited (1st |
| | |Applicant) |
| |½ of 1/32 |Chan Chuk, Chin Koy Hey, |
| | |Chan Tak Ping and The |
| | |Personal Representative of|
| | |Chan Pui Fun, deceased |
| | |(5th Respondent) |
|4/F, 20 Whampoa Street |1/32 |Lucktime Limited (1st |
| | |Applicant) |
|5/F, 20 Whampoa Street |1/32 |Group Leader Limited |
| | |(8th Applicant) |
|6/F, 20 Whampoa Street |1/32 |Lucktime Limited (1st |
| | |Applicant) |
|7/F, 20 Whampoa Street |1/32 | |
|G/F, 20A Whampoa Street|1/32 |Ningee Limited (6th |
| | |Respondent) |
|1/F, 20A Whampoa Street|1/32 |Lucktime Limited (1st |
| | |Applicant) |
|2/F, 20A Whampoa Street|1/32 |Kwan Shuk Man (7th |
| | |Respondent) |
|3/F, 20A Whampoa Street|1/32 |Lucktime Limited (1st |
| | |Applicant) |
|4/F, 20A Whampoa Street|1/32 |Kwan Hei Lam (8th |
| | |Respondent) |
|5/F, 20A Whampoa Street|1/32 |Ever Planet Limited |
| | |(9th Applicant) |
|6/F, 20A Whampoa Street|1/32 |Lucktime Limited (1st |
| | |Applicant) |
|7/F, 20A Whampoa Street|1/32 | |
Thus, insofar as the 1st Lot is concerned, the applicants altogether own
70.31% of the equal undivided shares in the 1st Lot.
On the other hand, Lucktime Limited, ie the 1st Applicant, has been the
registered owner of all undivided shares of the 2nd Lot. The 2nd Building
erected thereon was also completed in 1957 with Occupation Permit No K23
issued on 16 April 1957.
Indeed, the 2nd Lot was the subject of an earlier compulsory sale
application, being Lucktime Limited v Cho Kai Fung & Others, LDCS
2000/2018, the sale order of which was granted by the Tribunal on 29
January 2021. Particulars of the 2nd Lot and the 2nd Building thereon can
be found in the contents of that judgment.
The Remaining Respondents
By reference to the table of ownership in §6 above, the applicants
altogether own 70.31% of the equal undivided shares in the 1st Lot. There
are 8 live respondents (collectively referred to as “the Remaining
Respondents”):
|Respondent |Premises |Undivided |Notice of |
| | |share in the |Opposition |
| | |1st Lot | |
|1st Respondent|(“R1”) |3/F, No 18 Whampos Street |1/32 |Withdrawn |
|2nd |(“R2”) |G/F, No 20 Whampoa Street |3/32 |Withdrawn / |
|Respondents | | | |to be |
| | | | |withdrawn |
| | |2/F. No 18A Whampoa Street| | |
| | |4/F, No 18A Whampoa Street| | |
|3rd Respondent|(“R3”) |3/F. No 18A Whampoa Street|1/32 |Missing |
|4th Respondent|(“R4”) |2/F. No 20 Whampoa Street |1/32 |Withdrawn / |
| | | | |to be |
| | | | |withdrawn |
|5th |(“R5”) |4/8 share of 3/F of No 20 |½ of 1/32 |Missing / |
|Respondents | |Whampoa Street | |unopposed |
|6th Respondent|(“R6”) |G/F, No 20A Whampoa Street|1/32 |Withdrawn / |
| | | | |to be |
| | | | |withdrawn |
|7th Respondent|(“R7”) |2/F, No 20A Whampoa Street|1/32 |Withdrawn / |
| | | | |to be |
| | | | |withdrawn |
|8th Respondent|(“R8”) |4/F, No 20A Whampoa Street|1/32 |Withdrawn / |
| | | | |to be |
| | | | |withdrawn |
| | | | | |
More particularly, R1 reached full settlement with the applicants through
mediation on 25 February 2025. Leave was granted to R1 to withdraw his
Notice of Opposition by H H Judge Michelle Lam pursuant to the Order dated
14 March 2025. R1 was also excused from attending the trial.
R3 and the 1st, 2nd and 4th named R5 cannot be found. Substituted service
of the Application on them was effected on 17 October 2025 pursuant to the
Order of H H Judge Michelle Lam dated 8 October 2025. None of them have
showed up after expiration of the 21-day period as specified respectively
in the notices.
Pursuant to paragraphs 1 and 4 of the aforesaid Order, service of the
aforesaid Order, the Notice of Application, Mediation Certificate,
Mediation Notice and all subsequent documents in the present proceedings on
R3 and the 1st, 2nd and 4th named R5 was dispensed with.
According to paragraph 3 of the aforesaid Order, after expiration of 21
days from the publication of the notices mentioned in paragraph 12 above,
R3 and the 1st, 2nd and 4th named R5 shall be bound by the proceedings as
if they have been duly served with the Application in accordance with
section 3(3)(a) of the Ordinance.
Madam Leung Yuk Chun, the 3rd named R5, was subsequently joined pursuant to
an Order dated 25 March 2026 by H H Judge Michelle Lam in her capacity as
the administratrix of the estate of Chan Tak Ping, deceased. Madam Leung
has confirmed to the Tribunal that she will not oppose the Application and
will not attend the trial. She also undertook not to seek costs against
the applicants in these proceedings up to and inclusive of the trial.
Accordingly, Madam Leung was excused by the order of H H Judge Michelle Lam
from attending the trial. It was also ordered that “there be no filing of
Notice of Opposition (Form 33) by the 3rd named R5 in these proceedings”
and that “there be no adducing of any evidence, whether expert or factual,
in opposition to these proceedings by the 3rd named R5.
R2, R4, R6, R7 and R8 are represented by Messrs Peter Mo & Co. They have
entered into Provisional Agreements for Sale and Purchase on 28 April 2026
for selling their properties to A1. The transactions will be completed in
due course. Leave was granted to R2, R4, R6, R7 and R8 to withdraw all
their Notices of Opposition and evidence (whether factual and expert) on 30
April 2026.
Issues for Determination by the Tribunal
The remaining issues to be decided in this case are as follows:
1) Whether the applicants have satisfied the relevant statutory
requirements under the Ordinance and hence were entitled to make
the Application?
2) Whether the redevelopment of 1st Lot is justified due to age
and/or state of repair of the 1st Building in accordance with
section 4(2)(a)(i) of the Ordinance?
3) Whether the applicants have taken reasonable steps to acquire all
the undivided shares in the 1st Lot in accordance with
section 4(2)(b) of the Ordinance?
4) What were the respective market value of the properties according
to paragraph 1(a) in Part 1A of Schedule 1 to the Ordinance
(which is hereinafter termed “EUV”) on the 1st Lot as at 15
November 2024?
5) What should be the redevelopment value (“RDV”) of the 1st Lot as
at 15 November 2024?
6) What should be the RDV of the 2nd Lot as at 15 November 2024?
7) If an order for sale should be granted, what should be the
reserve price (i.e. RDV of the Lots) for the purpose of auction
sale?
SECTION 3 OF THE ORDINANCE – OWNERSHIP OF THE APPLICANTS
At the time of filing of the Application on 6 December 2024, the amendments
to the Ordinance passed in July 2024 came into operation.
By virtue of the newly amended section 3(2)(c) of the Ordinance, the person
or persons who owns or own, otherwise than as a mortgagee, not less than
90% of the undivided shares in a lot may make an application which may
cover 2 or more lots that are adjoining lots (one set of adjoining lots)
even if any of the lots is wholly owned by the majority owner. This is
exactly the case for the captioned application when the applicants have
owned 100% of the 2nd Lot.
Section 3(5) of the Ordinance provides that the Chief Executive in Council
may, by notice in the Gazette, specify a lower percentage in respect of a
lot belonging to a class of lots specified in that notice.
The Land (Compulsory Sale for Redevelopment) (Specification of Lower
Percentage) Notice (“the Notice”) was similarly amended in December 2024.
Section 3 of the Notice lowered the threshold for compulsory sale of
specified classes of lots from 90% to 70%. Those classes of lots include:
“a lot that is not located within a designated area, and with
each of the buildings erected on the lot issued with an
occupation permit at least 60 years but less than 70 years
before the relevant date”
At the time of filing the Application, the Lots were included in the
Approved Hung Hom Outline Zoning Plan No S/K9/28 dated 10 June 2022 and
hence, they were not located within any of the “designated areas” set out
in the Schedule to the Notice. Since the occupation permits of the
Buildings were both issued in 1957, i.e. more than 60 years but less than
70 years before the date of application (i.e. 6 December 2024, the relevant
date under the Notice), the applicable percentage is therefore 70%.
Section 3(8)(c) of the Ordinance also provides that where 2 or more lots
are adjoining lots, the averaging requirement is fulfilled for 2 or more
lots if the average of the percentage of the undivided shares owned by the
majority owner in the lots (“averaged ownership percentage”) is not less
than the specified threshold percentage, where—
i) averaged ownership percentage is derived by aggregating the sum
of the percentages of the undivided shares owned by the majority
owner in each of the lots (if it belongs to a specified class of
lots) multiplied by the area of the corresponding lot (“total
sum”), then dividing the total sum by the total area of all the
lots concerned; and
ii) specified threshold percentage is derived by aggregating the sum
of the percentages specified in section 3 of Cap. 545A for each
of the lots (if it belongs to a specified class of lots)
multiplied by the area of the corresponding lot (“total sum”),
then dividing the total sum by the total area of all the lots
concerned.
The 1st Lot has a site area of 3,400 sq ft while the 2nd Lot has a site
area of 4,675 sq ft. Pursuant to the above, the average ownership
percentage owned by the applicants altogether is 87.5%:
[pic]
I am satisfied that as at the date of the Application, the applicants
altogether owned more than 70% of the undivided shares in the Lots. I am
therefore satisfied the applicants altogether are entitled to make the
present application under section 3 of the Ordinance.
SECTION 4(2) OF THE ORDINANCE - JUSTIFICATION AND REASONABLE STEPS
Section 4(2) of the Ordinance provides as follows: -
“2. The Tribunal shall not make an order for sale unless, after
hearing the objections, if any, of the minority owners of the
lot the subject of the application under section 3(1) concerned,
the Tribunal is satisfied that—
(a) the redevelopment of the lot is justified (and
whether or not the majority owner proposes to or is capable of
undertaking the redevelopment)—
(i) due to the age or state of repair of the
existing development on the lot; or
(ii) on 1 or more grounds, if any, specified in
regulations made under section 12; and
(b) the majority owner has taken reasonable steps to
acquire all the undivided shares in the lot (including, in the
case of a minority owner whose whereabouts are known,
negotiating for the purchase of such of those shares as are
owned by that minority owner on terms that are fair and
reasonable).”
Whether development of the Lot is justified due to the age and/or state of
repair of the Building
However, section 4(2C) of the Ordinance as amended expressly provides that
subsection (2) afore-stated does not apply to a lot which is wholly owned
by the majority owner, ie the applicants in the present proceedings.
Accordingly, the Tribunal is not required to consider whether redevelopment
of the 2nd Building is justified or not.
In respect of the 1st Lot, the applicants have appointed Mr Wong Wing
Cheung, Dennis (“Mr Dennis Wong”) who is a Registered Professional Surveyor
(Building Surveying), Authorized Person and Registered Structural Engineer
to prepare a Condition Survey Report and a Structural Assessment Report
both dated 21 July 2025.
In respect of the age of the 1st Building, Mr Dennis Wong highlighted that
it was 68 years old. Due to changes in statutory requirements, advanced
technology and higher expectation of the owners over the years, the 1st
Building has become substandard and obsolete in respect of the following
aspect when compared to a new building if the site is redeveloped:
• Safety;
• Health and hygiene;
• Comfort and convenience;
• Expectations and enjoyment;
• Environment; and
• Management and maintenance.
More particularly, there are vital deficiencies that cannot be overcome but
have an adverse effect on the users in various aspects, including but not
limited to:
• Provision of escape staircases complying with current
requirements/ standards;
• Provision of barrier free access facilities.
Mr Dennis Wong was also of the view that the 1st Building is in a poor
state of repair. According to him, the costs of essential repairs amounted
to $12,631,247 or $7,523.57 per m2 of the existing Gross Floor Area of the
1st Building. This unit cost is about 46.96% of the unit cost of
$16,019.81 per m2 for re-constructing a new similar building. Mr Dennis
Wong opined that the rectification/ repair costs were relatively high.
Turning to the structural assessment of the 1st Building, Mr Dennis Wong
found a substantial number of defects such as cracks and spalling. In the
open-up inspection, 26/87 or 29.9% of the steel reinforcement bars were
under the classification of “Severe Corrosion”, 67/87 or 77.0% were
seriously corroded according to the classification by Code of Practice of
the Mandatory Building Inspection Scheme (MBIS) 2012. The effect of
serious corrosion can result in a reduction in the load-carrying capacity
of the structural members and impair the building structure as a whole.
In addition, 100% of the slab and 65.5% of the beam samples failed to
satisfy the minimum concrete cover requirement of the Code of Practice for
Structural Use of Concrete 2013 (“2013 Concrete Code”). 88.9% of all
samples failed to satisfy the minimum concrete strength requirement of 20
MPa as specified in the code.
Also, all the samples had carbonation reaching a depth greater than the
concrete cover. This implies that the protective barrier of the
reinforcement bars has been lost, allowing active deterioration/ corrosion
of the reinforcement bars to develop. Similarly, 72% of the test samples
failed to meet the maximum chloride content of 0.35%, some with chloride
contents as high as 3.21%.
Mr Dennis Wong has summarised the structural conditions of the 1st Building
as follows:
|Durability |2013 Concrete |The 1st Building |
|Provisions |Code | |
|Concrete|Slab |Min 30mm |100% of the samples were less than|
|Cover | | |30mm |
| |Beam |Min 35mm |65.5% of the samples were less |
| | | |than 35mm |
| |Column |Min 35mm |27.6% of the samples were less |
| | | |than 35mm |
|Grade of Concrete|Minimum design |Average in-situ concrete cube |
| |concrete cube |strength: |
| |strength = 20 |13.4 MPa for slabs |
| |MPa |9.8 MPa for beams |
| | |15.1 MPa for columns |
|Chloride Content |Max 0.35% |The average chloride content of |
|(by mass of | |all the samples was 0.96% |
|cement) | | |
|Cement Content |Min 290 kg/m2 |The average cement content of all |
| |(for Grade C20) |the samples at 21.9% complied with|
| |(12.08% by mass)|the required minimum cement |
| | |content of 12.08%. Nevertheless, |
| | |11.1% of the test samples failed |
| | |to meet this requirement. |
In view of the above, Mr Dennis Wong considered that the 1st Building had
passed its design working life of 50 years on which basis the requirements
of the 2013 Concrete Code were set up.
There is no expert evidence to rebut the reports complied by Mr Dennis
Wong.
Having considered the reports of Mr Dennis Wong, I accept his expert
opinion. The 1st Building, being erected more than 69 years ago, is in
poor condition and has come to the end of its design life. The design of
the 1st Building has become obsolete over time in many aspects, both
physically and functionally, and fails to conform to modern safety
standards and statutory requirements.
I am satisfied that the 1st Building is in poor state of repair and the
costs of repair to bring the 1st Building to tenantable condition is
disproportionate to the costs of redevelopment. Even if repair works are
carried out, such works will bring about a modest improvement only to the
existing condition of the 1st Building and the 1st Building will continue
remain a sub-standard one.
By reason of the matters set out above, I am satisfied that the
redevelopment of the 1st Building is justified.
Whether the applicant has taken reasonable steps
In assessing the reasonableness of the offers, I have considered the case
of Capital Well Ltd v Bond Star Development Ltd (2005) 8 HKCFAR 578. In
particular, I have considered paragraphs 33 and 36 of the judgment in which
Ribeiro PJ stated: -
“33. In making that assessment the Tribunal is not conducting a
valuation exercise. It does not need to adjudicate upon any
disputes about the correct valuation principles to be applied.
It does not itself arrive at any conclusion as to what figure
represents the correct valuation. It merely needs to be
satisfied that, on the evidence available, the offer falls
within the range of what may broadly be regarded as fair and
reasonable compensation for the interest in question. It is
obviously necessary to recognise that there will often be
differences of opinion on that matter……”
“36. ...... We are of course not suggesting that it is necessary
for the offer to “beat” the valuation as if it were a payment
into court. What the Tribunal must do is to consider whether, in
the circumstances of each case, the offer falls within a band of
what represents a fair and reasonable assessment of the value of
the minority owner’s interest reflecting a proportionate share
of the redevelopment value of the whole site……”
Firstly, at the date of the Application, the applicants already owned
70.31% of the undivided shares of and in the 1st Lot. Ms Nancy Ngai (“Ms
Ngai”), counsel of the applicants, submitted that the applicants could have
applied for an Order for sale of the 1st Lot alone pursuant to section 3(1)
of the Ordinance. Nevertheless, the applicants did not do so. Instead, by
adding the 2nd Lot which had been wholly owned by the 1st applicant in the
Application, a larger site was resulted, rendering a more viable
development and more compensation to the minority owners of the 1st Lot.
Ms Ngai submitted that the applicants had taken not only a fair and
reasonable step but a generous step in favour of the minority owners of the
1st Lot.
Despite the applicants have commenced the Application, they continued to
negotiate with the minority owners of the 1st Lot with a view to purchasing
their properties by negotiation.
I agree also that the settlement finally reached with R1, R2, R4, R6, R7
and R8 provides solid evidence for proving that the applicants have indeed
taken reasonable steps to acquire the undivided shares owned by the
respondents.
I accept that the applicants have not been able to acquire the undivided
shares of and in the 1st Lot owned by R3 and the 1st, 2nd and 4th named R5
solely because they could not (and still cannot) be found.
On 17 April 2026, the 3rd named R5 confirmed that she would not oppose the
Application. Indeed, after the 3rd named R5 turned up, the applicants made
open offers to her for purchasing 1/8 share of 3/F, No 20 Whampoa Street on
2 April 2026 and 24 April 2026 in the amount of $830,000[1] and $870,000[2]
respectively.[3]
These open offers were made by reference to Mr CW Wong’s independent
valuation opinion which will be summarised below. I accept that these open
offers were higher than the value attributable to the 3rd named R5’s
interest in 3/F, No 20 Whampoa Street calculated in accordance with the
statutory formula set out in the Ordinance.
By reason of the matters set out above, I am satisfied that the applicants
have taken reasonable steps to acquire all the undivided shares in the 1st
Lot.
While I am satisfied that the redevelopment of the 1st Lot is justified and
the applicants have taken reasonable steps to acquire all the undivided
shares in the 1st Lot, an order for the sale of both the 1st Lot and the
2nd Lot should be granted in favour of the applicants.
Determination of the EUV of all Units in the 1st Building
Under section 4(1)(a)(i) of the Ordinance, if there is a dispute between
the parties on the EUV of the units in the Buildings on the Lots, the
Tribunal has to determine the values.
Section 4(1)(a)(ii) further provides that, in the case of any minority
owner of the 1st Lot who cannot be found, the majority owner of the 1st Lot
is required to satisfy the tribunal that the value of the minority owner’s
property as assessed in the Application is: -
“(A) not less than fair and reasonable; and
(B) not less than fair and reasonable when compared with the value
of the majority owner’s property as assessed in the
application.”
Mr Wong Chi Wai (“Mr CW Wong”) of Grandmax Surveyors Limited has been
appointed by the applicants to prepare the following reports:
1) Valuation Report dated 4 December 2024 on
• EUV of the properties on the 1st Lot as at 15 November 2024;
• RDV of the 1st Lot as at 15 November 2024; and
• RDV of the 2nd Lot as at 15 November 2024
2) Supplemental Report dated 17 July 2025 on
• EUV of the properties on the 1st Lot as at 15 November 2024;
• RDV of the 1st Lot as at 15 November 2024;
• RDV of the 2nd Lot as at 15 November 2024; and
• RDV of the Lots as at 14 July 2025
3) Supplemental Report dated 26 March 2026 on the RDV of the Lots.
In the Valuation Report of 4 December 2024 (“the Application Report”), Mr
CW Wong explained the method of valuation and the process of his assessment
to arrive at the EUV of each unit of the 1st Building.
In his valuation of the EUV of the domestic units on the upper floors of
the 1st Building, Mr CW Wong adopted the following methodology:
i) He selected 3/F, No. 18 Whampoa Street as the reference unit
(“the Reference Domestic Unit”) for the purpose of valuing its
unit price.
ii) The unit price of the Reference Domestic Unit was first assessed
by making reference to market comparables. He took into account
4 comparable transactions, 3 of which in Bou Lee Building at 145-
163 Bulkeley Street across the other side of Gillies Avenue
South in the vicinity of the Hung Hom district. After making
what he regarded as the necessary adjustments (for time,
location, floor level, age, size, physical condition, view,
lighting & ventilation) for all these comparable transactions,
he took the average of the adjusted unit rates of the
comparables at $63,000 per m2 as the unit price of the Reference
Domestic Unit.
iii) He further considered the floor level, size, lighting &
ventilation, top floor effect and internal conditions of the
Reference Domestic Unit and the remaining domestic units within
the 1st Building and made adjustments to arrive at the EUV of
all the domestic units on the upper floors of the 1st Building.
In assessing the EUV of the ground floor units, Mr CW Wong adopted the
following methodology:
i) He selected Ground Floor, No 20 Whampoa Street as the Reference
Shop Unit.
ii) He then took into account 4 comparable shop transactions in the
Hung Hom district. After making what he regarded as the
necessary adjustments (for time, location, frontage, return
frontage, age, size, layout and headroom) for all these
comparable transactions, he took the average of the adjusted
unit rates of the comparables at $303,000 per m2 as the unit
price of the Reference Shop Unit.
iii) Whereas both the G/F, 18A and 20A Whampoa Street are storage
space instead of shop units having street frontages, being
situated at the rear of the 1st Building accessible only via an
indoor common corridor some 14 metres from the building
entrance, Mr CW Wong applied a discount of 70%.
Mr CW Wong updated the Application Report by another report dated 17 July
2025 (ie the Supplemental Report) in which he revised the EUV of all the
units in the 1st Buildings after taking into account the inspection of more
units in the 1st Building and the updated property index prepared by the
Rating and Valuation Department. In this report, Mr CW Wong found 4 more
up-to-date comparables and repeated the exercise he did in the Application
Report. He arrived however at the same rate of $63,000 per m2 as the unit
price of the Reference Domestic Unit.
Similarly, Mr CW Wong found 2 more up-to-date comparables for the ground
floor shop units. This time, he arrived at $301,000 per m2 as the unit
price of the Reference Shop Unit.
The updated EUV of all the units in the 1st Building as assessed by Mr CW
Wong is set out in the following table:[4]
|Unit / Floor|Whampoa Street |
| |No 18 |No 18A | No 20 |No 20A |
|G/F |$12,437,000 |$4,078,000 |$12,437,000 |$4,078,000 |
|1/F |$3,515,000 |$2,873,000 |$3,623,000 |$2,907,000 |
|2/F |$3,553,000 |$2,997,000 |$3,661,000 |$2,851,000 |
|3/F |$3,483,000 |$2,938,000 |$3,379,000 |$2,710,000 |
|4/F |$3,313,000[5]|$2,966,000 |$3,313,000 |$2,741,000 |
|5/F |$3,142,000 |$2,738,000 |$3,243,000 |$2,684,000 |
|6/F |$3,039,000 |$2,763,000 |$3,039,000 |$2,546,000 |
|7/F |$2,777,000 |$2,492,000 |$2,693,000 |$2,441,000 |
Thus, the total EUV of the 1st Building as assessed by Mr CW Wong as at 15
November 2024 is $117,450,000.
I am satisfied that the value of the respondent unit as assessed by Mr CW
Wong is not less than fair and reasonable; and not less than fair and
reasonable when compared with the value of the applicants’ properties.
RDV for the 1st Lot and the 2nd Lot
Paragraph 2 in Part 3 of Schedule 1 to the Ordinance as amended provides
that, for an order for sale of lots the subject of an application that
covers more than one lot, the proceeds of sale of the lots—
a) are to be apportioned between the lots on a pro rata basis in
accordance with, and subject to paragraph (c)—
i) for a lot governed by a deed of mutual covenant covering
that lot only, the redevelopment value of the lot as
assessed in the application under section 1(b)(i) of Part
1A of this Schedule; and
ii) …
b) are to be apportioned between each majority owner and each
minority owner of a lot on a pro rata basis in accordance with,
and subject to paragraph (c), the values of the respective
properties of each majority owner and each minority owner of the
lot as assessed in the application under section 1(a) of Part 1A
of this Schedule; and
c) where—
i) there has been a dispute referred to in section 4(1)(a)(i) that
has resulted in a variation of those values; or
ii) in consequence of the requirement under section 4(1)(a)(ii) on
the majority owner to satisfy the Tribunal as to the matter
referred to in that section, there has been a variation of those
values,
are to be apportioned in accordance with those values as so
varied.
As a result of paragraph 62 (a)(i) above, Mr CW Wong had prepared
valuations on the RDV of the 1st Lot and the RDV of the 2nd Lot as at 15
November 2024 by means of the residual valuation method. This can be done
by deducting development cost (including construction costs, professional
fees, finance costs etc) and developer’s profit from the estimated gross
development value (“GDV”) of the completed optimum development.
In arriving at the GDV of each hypothetical development, Mr CW Wong had
gathered the relevant sales comparables and repeated the exercises of what
he had done in assessing the EUV of each unit of the 1st Building save that
this time, the sales comparables are sales of relatively new properties.
Mr CW Wong then assessed the construction and demolition costs by reference
to the “Building Cost Data for Private Sector Developments in Hong Kong”
prepared by Rider Levett & Bucknall which is a popular international
quantity surveying consultancy firm in the real estate and construction
industry.
Mr CW Wong also explained that in considering the plenty supply for new
domestic units in the Hung Hom locality, a 20% profit would have fairly
reflected the project risk and return of these hypothetical developments
for either the 1st Lot or the 2nd Lot as at 15 November 2024.
Mr CW Wong arrived at the RDV of the lots at $118,000,000[6] and
$229,000,000[7] respectively.
The significant difference between the two values can firstly be explained
by the difference in site areas between the two lots. According to Mr CW
Wong, the 1st Lot has a net site area of 306.87 sq m while the 2nd Lot has
a net site area of 434.32 sq m. While they fell within an area designated
as “Residential (Group A) 4” on the Approved Hung Hom Outline Zoning Plan
No S/K9/28 dated 10 June 2022, under this zoning designation, a maximum
building height restriction of 100mPD would be permitted for sites with an
area of 400 m2 or more[8]. Otherwise, like that of the 1st Lot, the maximum
building height restriction would be only 80mPD.
In addition, the 2nd Lot, being a corner lot, enjoys shop frontages on two
streets and a higher plot ratio under the Building (Planning) Regulations
as a Class B site.
Reserve Price for the Auction
In his latest valuation report dated 26 March 2026, Mr CW Wong proceeded to
update the RDV of both the 1st Lot and the 2nd Lot, taking into account the
joint redevelopment potential of the Lots on their own by the residual
valuation method.
Mr CW Wong arrived at $580,000,000 which is equivalent to an accommodation
value of $85,904 per m2. A copy of his calculation is attached herein as
Appendix 1[9].
I have gone through Mr CW Wong’s valuation. In the absence of evidence to
the contrary, I am satisfied with his valuation, including the valuation
assumptions he has adopted, the values and the costs parameters he has used
in his valuation.
Based on Mr CW Wong’s valuation, therefore, I decide that the reserve price
for the auction of both the 1st Lot and the 2nd Lot together should be
HK$580,000,000.
Orders
For reasons given in this judgment, I have set out reasons why I am
satisfied an order for sale should be granted and I therefore make the
following orders: -
1) All the undivided shares in both the 1st Lot and the 2nd Lot
together, the subject of the application, be sold by way of
public auction for the purposes of redevelopment of the Lots;
2) Mr Chow Wing Kin Anthony and Ms Chow Shuk Han Anna, nominated by
the applicants, be appointed the trustees (“the Trustees”) to
discharge the duties imposed on them as trustees by the Ordinance
in relation to the sale of the Lots;
3) The Trustees be authorised to charge such remuneration for their
services in accordance with the terms set out in the letter of
Messrs Guantao & Chow, Solicitors and Notaries dated 9 April
2026[10];
4) For the purposes of the sale of the 1st Lot and 2nd Lot together
by public auction: -
a) the sale of the 1st Lot and 2nd Lot be on the
particulars and conditions of sale the same or
substantially the same as those set out in the draft
Particulars and Conditions of Sale[11] to be approved
and initialed by the Tribunal;
b) the reserve price be set at $580,000,000;
c) the respective EUVs of all the properties on Lot 1 as
at 15 November 2024 assessed by Mr CW Wong are fair
and reasonable and the EUVs of the Respondents’
properties as at 15 November 2024 assessed by Mr CW
Wong are fair and reasonable when compared with the
EUVs of the Applicants’ properties as at the same
date assessed by him; and
d) The RDV of Lot 1 ($118,000,000) and RDV of Lot 2
($229,000,000) as at 15 November 2024 assessed by Mr
CW Wong are reasonable and should be accepted;
e) The following valuation opinion of Mr CW Wong should
be adopted for the apportionment of the proceeds of
sale of Lot 1 and Lot 2 in accordance with s.10(3) of
the Ordinance and Paragraph 2(a)(i), (b) and (c) of
Part 3 of Schedule 1 thereto.
i) the respective EUVs of all the properties on Lot
1 as at 15 November 2024; and
ii) the RDV of Lot 1 and RDV of Lot 2 as at 15
November 2024;
5) The Applicants do publish notices once in a Chinese language
newspaper (and in the Chinese language) and once in an English
newspaper (and in the English language) circulating generally in
Hong Kong within 7 days from the date of the sealed judgment to
be made herein by the Tribunal informing R3, 1st, 2nd and 4th
named R5 and all persons claiming to the owners of Lot 1:-
(a) that the Tribunal has made an Order for sale of Lot 1 and
Lot 2;
(b) that Lot 1 and Lot 2 will be sold by public auction; and
(c) where and when a copy of the Order for sale to be made
herein can be obtained.
6) Subject to further extensions that the Tribunal may subsequently
allow upon the application of the purchaser of the 1st Lot and
2nd Lot or its successor in title, the redevelopment of the 1st
Lot and 2nd Lot together shall be completed and made fit for
occupation within a period of 7 years after the date on which the
purchaser of the 1st Lot and 2nd Lot becomes the owner of the
Lots; and
7) Liberty to the applicants, the respondents and the Trustees to
apply to the Tribunal for further directions.
Costs
There be no order as to costs. Unless any parties apply by summons to
vary, the costs order nisi shall be made absolute upon expiry of 14 days
from the date of this judgment.
| |(Lawrence Pang) |
| |Member |
| |Lands Tribunal |
| | |
Ms Nancy Ngai, instructed by Zhong Lun Law Firm LLP, for the applicants
Attendance of the 1st respondent and 3rd named 5th respondent
who were not legally represented was excused
Attendance of Messrs Peter Mo & Co, for the 2nd, 4th, 6th, 7th & 8th
respondents, was excused
3rd respondent and 1st, 2nd and 4th named 5th respondents, absent
Appendix 1
[pic]
-----------------------
[1] See Bundle D3/1579-1584.
[2] See Bundle D4/1626-1631.
[3] See also Annex B of Ms Ngai’s opening submission dated 29 April 2026.
[4] See Bundle F1/1955.
[5] According to Mr CW Wong, the Front Portion and the Rear Portion of 4/F
have become a single unit.
[6] See Bundle F2/2075.
[7] See Bundle F2/2082.
[8] See Bundle F1/1862.
[9] See Bundle F4/2515.
[10] See Bundle D4/1696.
[11] See Bundle D4/1657-1693.
-----------------------
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V