THE QUEEN
NG POON
Mr Johnny Chan, C.C
Mr Paul Wu (M/s T.C. Lau & Co)
HCMA 1073/1995
HCMA001073/1995
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF HONG KONG
(Appellate Jurisdiction)
MAGISTRACY APPEAL NO. 1073 OF 1995
------------------
-------------------
Coram : Hon. Duffy, J. in Court
Date of hearing : 14 December 1995
Date of handing down judgment : 19 December 1995
----------------------
J U D G M E N T
1. This was an appeal against a conviction for assault occasioning actual bodily harm and a suspended sentence of 3 months therefor.
2. As the decision of the learned Magistrate was based purely on his assessment of the credibility of the witnesses involved, and as I could find no error in the manner of his approaching his decision, I could not interfere with it. I dismissed the appeal against conviction.
3. On the matter of sentence, I was persuaded that a fine was an adequate penalty in the present case. There are no guidelines in these matters, but I felt that unless it was absolutely necessary to impose a custodial sentence, that should not be done. I therefore substituted a fine of HK$8,000 for the 3 month suspended sentence. I gave 7 days to pay. The appeal was allowed accordingly.
Representation:
Mr Johnny Chan, C.C., for Crown
Mr Paul Wu (M/s T.C. Lau & Co) for Appellant