Case Details
Citation
THE QUEEN v. HO YEE CHUNG AND OTHERS, CACC 134A/1983
Case Number
CACC 134A/1983
Court
Court of Appeal
(CA)
Decision Date
18 May 1984
Parties
Applicant(s):

THE QUEEN

Respondent(s):

HO Yee Chung, CHAN Tak-kwong, LEUNG Chi-ho

For Respondent(s):

in any of these statements anything that could properly be regarded as corroborating the testimony of Chu as to the actual killing of Tung Kwa. Unless that testimony could be regarded as substantially the truth of what happened, it was simply not within the jury's power to decide how the robbery of the gun or the killing of Tung Kwa had come about. Although before us it was implicit in Mr. Alderdice's argument; more celebrated killing might give himself and the 4th defendant some bargaining power with the police. At the trial, Mr. Kwong for the 1st defendant sought to have evidence of the confession by the 4th defendant to the killing of Tung Kwa introduced in support of his client's allegation that he was not the person responsible for the killing. This was strongly opposed by Mr. Sparrow for the 4th defendant. Mr. Alderdice; At the conclusion of the hearing, we allowed the applications of all three applicants and order that they should be re-tried upon a fresh indictment. We directed also that that indictment should include charges of robbery and murder against the 1st and 4th defendants but that as against the 2nd defendant the charges should be robbery and manslaughter only. Mr. Alderdice

THE QUEEN v. HO YEE CHUNG AND OTHERS

CACC 134A/1983

Court of Appeal18 May 1984

Citation

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations