Case Details
For Applicant(s):
Kamlesh Sadhwani, instructed by Messrs Y.W. Mok & Co.
For Respondent(s):
D. Lim, instructed by Messrs Fairbairn Catley Low & Kong
Listing:
YU SIU YIM v. KNIGHT FRANK PETTY LTD
YU SIU YIM v. KNIGHT FRANK PETTY LTD
[2026] HKCFI 6344 · HCPI 349/2024
Court of First Instance
HCPI 349/2024 [2026] HKCFI 6344 IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE PERSONAL INJURIES ACTION NO 349 OF 2024 _______________ Between _______________ Before: Master Elaine Liu in Chambers Dates of Hearing: 13 November 2026 Date of Decision: 13 November 2026 ___________________ DECISION __________________ This is the hearing of the Defendant’s (“D”) Summons for leave to adduce expert evidence on liability from an expert in forensic engineering and material science on the following issues: whether the Carpet as pleaded in the Statement of Claim (“SOC”) was fit for purpose; and whether of the material used for the Carpet, given this type of matting used, could it have formed protruding obstacle/obstacles as alleged and pleaded in the SOC that caused the Plaintiff’s (“P”) fall and injuries sustained thereby. The principles applicable on expert evidence are not in dispute. Expert evidence is admissible under Section 58(1) of the Evidence Ordinance. If a party intends to adduce expert evidence, leave of the court is required: Order 38 rule 36 of RHC. The party who seeks expert direction bears the burden to show that the proposed expert direction is relevant and necessary for the just resolution of the pleaded issues in dispute, and further that there is a probative value of an expert report in the resolution of these disputed issues. The giving of expert direction is part of the case management process. The underlying objectives set out in Order 1A rule 1 of RHC shall be met in the exercise of case management power. The court will not give direction for expert evidence to be adduced simply on the basis that it cannot rule out a possibility of such evidence being relevant, necessary and helpful: Shenzhen Futaihong Precision Industry Co v BYD Co Ltd [2018] HKCA 408; Cheung Yuk Ha v Choi Wan St Joseph’s Primary School [2023] 1 HKLRD 1107. Relevance, necessity and probative value of the proposed expert report shall be evaluated with reference to the issues in dispute as identified in the parties’ pleadings. The relevant facts pleaded by P in the SOC are as follows: On 3 April 2026 at about 1:53 pm, P intended to enter the McDonalds restaurant (“Restaurant”) located on the first floor of the place of accident. To enter the Restaurant, customers would need to ascend a set of staircases from the ground floor (“Staircase”). A 2 metre x 1.5 metre industrial carpet (“Carpet”) was placed in front of the stairs which covered the path from the street pavement to the Staircase. At the time when P was walking towards the stairs, the Carpet was not fastened to the floor nor flattened. This led to a fold forming in the Carpet, creating a protruding obstacle near the first stair of the Staircase. As P walked towards the Staircase, his foot was caught by the protruding obstacle of the Carpet. P lost balance and tripped, falling on the front side of his body. As a result, P suffered personal injuries. Insofar as the condition of the Carpet is concerned, D averred in paragraph 5 of the Defence that: The Carpet was affixed firmly, properly and even on the floor with adhesive tapes along the sides; The surface of the Carpet was even; The condition of the Carpet was sound and dry without any obstructions and barriers. In Reply, P averred in paragraph 3 that: “… the Plaintiff’s foot obstructed in the protruding obstacle formed by folding of the Carpet and the Plaintiff lost his balance and tripped, falling on the front side of his body.” P’s complaint was that the Carpet was not fitted or flattened properly at the material times. P did not challenge the material of the Carpet was unfit for purpose nor contended that the material of the Carpet caused the fold. This was confirmed by P’s counsel at the hearing. In other words, P’s claim is based on the manner in which the Carpet was fitted or maintained, but not the condition of the Carpet. The opinion on whether the Carpet was fit for purpose is not relevant as this is not the issue in dispute. The opinion on the likelihood of the Carpet could form a fold to create a tripping hazard by examining only the materials and specifications of the Carpet does not have a probative value in the resolution of the disputed issue on liability because such opinion does not take into account, for example, the manner in which the Carpet was fitted, the condition of the floor on which the Carpet was laid at the material time, and whether D was negligent in maintaining the Carpet by either causing the fold or failing to remove the fold, if any. Further, D proposed to use a sample of the carpet of the same type and of comparable age of the Carpet (“Sample”) for the conduct of scientific test by the proposed expert. There is no evidence that the condition of the Carpet at the material times is the same as the condition of the Sample which had not been used or fitted in the same way. The test on the Sample is unlikely be of assistance to the court in resolving the issues in dispute, and may add to unnecessary complexity of the issues to be considered at the trial. The Summons should be dismissed and I so order. [submission on costs] There is no reason to depart from the starting point of costs follow the event. Having considered the Statement of Costs produced by P and the parties’ submissions, I order that D pay P the costs of the Summons including today’s hearing forthwith summarily assessed at HK$120,000. I thank Mr Sadhwani and Mr Lim for their helpful assistance. (Elaine Liu) Master of the High Court Mr. Kamlesh Sadhwani, instructed by Messrs Y.W. Mok & Co., for the Plaintiff Mr. Patrick D. Lim, instructed by Messrs Fairbairn Catley Low & Kong, for the Defendant