Case Details
Citation
CHUI YING FONG AND ANOTHER v. LEUNG KON SHAU, CACV 3/1974
Case Number
CACV 3/1974
Court
Court of Appeal
(CA)
Decision Date
27 May 1974
Parties
Applicant(s):

CHUI YING FONG AND ANOTHER

Respondent(s):

LEUNG KON SHAU

For Applicant(s):

solicitors wrote to the plaintiffs' solicitors informing them that it was the defendant's view that the plaintiffs were already in breach of the Chinese agreement by their failure to execute a conveyance within the time stipulated in that agreement and stating that it was the defendant's intention not to hold himself bound by that agreement and not to sell the property to the plaintiffs. On the 26th April the solicitors; days from the date of that order. Two days later, on the 6th December, 1973, the defendant lodged a notice of appeal against the decision of the Registrar and the same was set down for hearing upon the 5th January, 1974. On the 28th December, the defendant having in the meantime failed to pay into court the sum of $30,000, Mr. Registrar Mayo (presumably upon the application of the solicitors; these express terms coupled with the fact that, as the defendant averred in his undated replying affidavit of November, that he had informed the plaintiffs that the property was heavily charged in favour of the Far East Bank and that the bank was pressin him for repayment, time became of the essence of the contract when, upon the 31st January, 1973, their solicitors wrote to the solicitors; to ascertain the state of the title. No doubt, they thus ascertained that the land was indeed charged with repayment to the Far East Bank by way of a mortgage and a charging order amounting in total to $137,000 odd, a sum not far short of the total purchase price of the property. Mr. Murphy, with considerable candour, conceded that it may well have been this fact which accounted; Counsel suggested that it was because of this discovery that the solicitors

CHUI YING FONG AND ANOTHER v. LEUNG KON SHAU

CACV 3/1974

Court of Appeal27 May 1974

Citation

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations