Mr. R. Davies, Crown Counsel; Miss B. Chainrai (assigned by D.L.A.)
HCMA 810/1987
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF HONG KONG
(Appellate Jurisdiction)
MAGISTRACY CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 810 of 1987
______________
BETWEEN
THE QUEEN
and
TSE TAT FU
Coram: Hon. Bewley, J. in Court
Date of hearing: 16th December 1987
Date of delivery of judgment: 16th December 1987
JUDGMENT
1. The appellant pleaded guilty to shoplifting and was sentenced to two years imprisonment by Mr. Paterson-Todd at Fanling Magistracy. He was caught rd-handed stealing a wallet on a train at Lowu.
2. The facts are very similar to those in a recent case tried by the same magistrate, in which the sentence was reduced on appeal from 20 months to 12 months imprisonment. See R. v. Hau Tai-wai[1].
3. The appellant is 25. He has six previous convictions.
4. For the reasons given in R. v. Hau Tai-wai the appeal is allowed and the sentence reduced to 12 months.
(E. de B. Bewley) Judge of the High Court
Mr. R. Davies, Crown Counsel, for Respondent
Miss B. Chainrai (assigned by D.L.A.) for Appellant
[1] Mag. App. 769/87