Case Details
Citation
KOMAIA DECCOF AND CO SA AND OTHERS v. PERUSAHAAN PERTAMBANGAN MINYIK DAN GAS BUMI NEGARA, CACV 8/1981
Case Number
CACV 8/1981
Court
Court of Appeal
(CA)
Decision Date
26 February 1982
Parties
Applicant(s):

KOMAIA DECCOF & CO., S. A, COLLIN NAVIGATION CO., S. A, KOMALA DECCOF & CO. (a firm)

Respondent(s):

PERUSAHAAN PERTAMBANGAN MINYIK DAN GA BUMI NEGARA (PERTAMINA)

For Applicant(s):

QC did not dispute contention (iii), but he hotly contested contentions (i), (ii), (iv) and (v). The proper inquiry, he said, was a 2, not a 3-stage inquiry. Mr. Gatehouse's stages 2 and 3 being part of the same process. There was no need at stage 2 to imply anything as precise as a term into a contract and no onus lay upon the defendant. The overall onus lay on the plaintiff, and it was

For Respondent(s):

It is also significant to our mind that the defendant has not sought positively to dispute this allegation. The documents produced by Miss Fung and particularly Exhibits 1 and 2 to her affirmation, speak of a great volume of trade having been done between the plaintiffs and the defendant. If any part of that trade had been done from an address other than Hong Kong it would have been very easy indeed; Robert Alexander, Q. C. & Andrew Li (Denton, Hall & Burgin)

KOMAIA DECCOF AND CO SA AND OTHERS v. PERUSAHAAN PERTAMBANGAN MINYIK DAN GAS BUMI NEGARA

CACV 8/1981

Court of Appeal26 February 1982

Citation

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations