Case Details
Citation
CHOW CHIU CHEUNG v. HANS JOACHIM BERNICK AND ANOTHER, HCA 371B/1969
Case Number
HCA 371B/1969
Court
Court of First Instance
(CFI)
Decision Date
6 January 1972
Parties
Applicant(s):

CHOW Chiu-cheung and Hans Joachim Bernick Heidemarie Klempin

Respondent(s):

Hans Joachim Bernick Heidemarie Klempin

For Applicant(s):

ordering that the judgment therein against the 1st defendant dated the 16th July 1969 and the assessment of damages of the 18th January 1971 be set aside, and granting leave to the American Home Assurance Company by their agent the American International Underwriters Ltd. (“the company”) to enter an appearance in the name of the 1st defendant or in their own name and to defend the action. At the outset the solicitors; Thereupon the plaintiff sought an order for substituted service and an order for substituted service on the 1st defendant was duly made. Inter­locutory judgment in default of appearance was entered against the 1st defendant on the 16th July 1969. On the 20th of September 1969 an order was made to serve a concurrent summons on the 2nd defendant in Germany. This service proved impossible to effect. The solicitors; The attitude of the plaintiff solicitors in entering judgment and having damages assessed without reference to the company was almost certainly prompted by the fact that as early as the 11th April 1969 the company had indicated to the plaintiffsolicitors that they would look into the matter only when the writ has been served on their insured. They were, to say the least, un­helpful to the solicitors; In the letter of 21st January 1971 to the company the solicitors; inquired whether the company was prepared to satisfy the judgment which had been obtained, failing which, they stated, their client would have no alternative but to commence separate legal proceedings on the judgment against the company. They received no reply to this letter and sent a reminder on the 9th of February 1971. On the 10th March 1971 the solicitors for the insurance company wrote to the solicitors; The solicitors for the insurance company did not write to the solicitorsfor the plaintiff as impliedly promised and the matter rested. In May 1971the plaintiff left the colony to further her studies in the United Statesof America where she now is. She intends to remain there for a period ofthree years. On the 16th September 1971 without any prior notification the solicitors; The insurers brought their application to set aside the judgment on the 3rd March 1938. In the instant case the accident occurred on the 5th May 1968. The writ was issued on the 28th March 1969. Notice was given to the insurers on the same day. Judgmentin default was entered on the 16th July 1969 but damages were not assessed immediately because the solicitors; V. Gittins, Q.C. & P. Lee (Woo & Kwan)

CHOW CHIU CHEUNG v. HANS JOACHIM BERNICK AND ANOTHER

HCA 371B/1969

Court of First Instance6 January 1972

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations