Case Details
Listing:
NUR HABIBAH v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE[Decision on Leave Application]
NUR HABIBAH v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE[Decision on Leave Application]
[2026] HKCFI 6280 · HCAL 1974/2023
Court of First Instance
HCAL 1974/2023 [2026] HKCFI 6280 IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE CONSTITUTIONAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE LAW LIST No. 1974 of 2023 BETWEEN Application for Leave to Apply for Judicial Review NOTIFICATION of the Judge’s decision (Ord. 53 r. 3) Following; Order by Deputy High Court Judge To: Leave to apply for Judicial Review be refused. Observations for the Applicant: Introduction This is the Applicant’s application by Form 86 filed on 3 November 2023 for leave to apply for judicial review (the “leave application”) of the decision of the Torture Claims Appeal Board / Non-Refoulement Claims Petition Office (the “Board”) dated 4 August 2023 (the “Decision”) dismissing her appeal against the decision of the Director of Immigration (the “Director”) in his Notice of Decision refusing her application for non-refoulement protection (the “Notice”). The Applicant had requested an oral hearing. A hearing on 8 October 2026 was scheduled and notice of hearing were sent to her by post on 15 September 2026 to her address as stated in her Form 86. The notices has not been returned in the course of mail. The Applicant had never informed the court of any change of address since filing her Form 86. There is nothing to suggest that she had not received the notice of hearing. Attempts were made on the afternoon of 7 October 2026 to contact her by telephone to remind her of the hearing, but the calls were not answered. The Court was satisfied that the notice of hearing had been duly served on the Applicant and that the Court had tried its best endeavour to bring the hearing to her notice. She did not appear at the hearing. Having considered the nature of the application and issues raised, the Decision, the papers, the applicable legal principles and all the circumstances, the Court considered that the leave application may be justly determined on paper without an oral hearing. Background The Applicant is an Indonesian national, now aged 36. She arrived in Hong Kong on 27 September 2020 to take up employment as a foreign domestic helper. She overstayed since 20 December 2022. She was arrested by the police on 27 February 2023 and referred to the Immigration Department. She lodged a non-refoulement claim by written signification on 3 March 2023. In due course, her claim was assessed on all four applicable grounds under the Unified Screening Mechanism (the “USM”), namely: Torture Risk; BOR 3 Risk; Persecution Risk; and BOR 2 Risk. Her claim was rejected by the Director’s Notice. Her appeal against the Notice was dismissed by the Board’s Decision. She now applies for leave to apply for judicial review of that Decision. The Applicant’s case The Applicant’s personal background, the basis of her claim, the arguments she advanced, the finding of the Board and the reasons for its Decision are set out in details in the Board’s Decision. These will not be repeated here. The hyperlink to the Board’s Decision is included below for reference. In gist, she claims, if returned to Indonesia, she will be harmed or killed by a loan shark on account of her failure to repay a loan of 400 million Indonesian rupiahs (“IDR”) her parents had obtained from the loan shark. The Applicant claimed that in 2021 her parents obtained the loan for the purpose of opening a grocery store. They named the Applicant as the surety without her consent. Her parents had to repay 10 million IDR per month as interest and partial repayment of principle over a term of five years. Her parents were cheated by their suppliers and became unable to repay. In early 2022, the loan shark visited the Applicant’s home to press for repayment. Later, he began to call the Applicant to demand repayment. The Applicant answered the calls on one occasion only during which the loan shark threatened her with death if she did not repay. He also sent her threatening messages daily by WhatsApp. The Applicant changed her telephone number following which she did not hear from the loan shark anymore. In 2022, the loan shark manhandled the Applicant’s father causing him to fall and lose consciousness. Her father was hospitalised for about one week. Her family did not report the loan shark’s ill-treatment to the police. They informed the Applicant that the loan shark continued to visit the family home frequently to enquire for her whereabouts. The Applicant feared that he would kill or seriously harm her if she returned to Indonesia. She believed the police would not protect her because she and her family were at fault in failing to repay the loan and the police would not involve themselves in private disputes. She also belief that she could not obtain protection from the authorities without paying them bribe. She did not know if she could obtain protection from women organisations in Indonesia. She did not consider internal relocation feasible as she had no connections in other parts of Indonesia. The Board’s Decision The Board considered the Applicant’s evidence was generally consistent and plausible, but would not go so far as to conclude that all of her claims are probably true. It accepted her testimony to the Board that she had never met the loan shark face to face, that the loan shark’s past ill-treatment is limited to verbal death threats and the loan shark had never physically harmed her. It found no evidence that the Applicant suffered any severe pain or suffering, whether physical or mental, as a result of the loan shark’s past ill-treatment of her and/or any of her family members that would be sufficient to establish any of the applicable grounds under the USM. It found neither the Applicant nor any of her family members had complained to the police or other authorities in Indonesia about any ill-treatment by the loan shark. It found no evidence that the State of Indonesia is aware of or ought to have been aware of the loan shark’s ill-treatment of the Applicant and/or any of her family members or that the state has any adverse interest in her. It found on the basis of objective country of origin information (“COI”) that loan sharking, domestic violence against women and corruption are serious problems in Indonesia, but the government had taken steps to improve the situation. The police operate “special crisis rooms” or “women’s desks” nationwide to receive complaints from female victims and assist them in seeking temporary shelters. There are governmental and non-governmental organizations to assist victims of domestic violence. The Board found Indonesia has a functioning system and machinery for the protection of its citizens and prosecution and punishment of offenders. On balance, it was satisfied that reasonable state protection would be available to the Applicant in Indonesia and there is nothing to indicate that she would be refused assistance if she requested it. It was the Applicant’s and her family members’ decision not to seek assistance from the police. The Board also found the risk of harm facing the Applicant is localised to her home area. Given the geographical and population size of Indonesia, the Board considered it difficult for the loan shark to locate her throughout Indonesia. In view of her age and background, the Board found the Applicant had failed to prove it would be unsafe, unreasonable or would cause her undue hardship to relocate to other areas in Indonesia to avoid the risk of harm. In conclusion, the Board found the risk that the Applicant might suffer serious harm at the hands of the loan shark is low. It further found, should the risk of harm be greater than a low one, there are adequate state protection and other services in Indonesia to protect and assist the Applicant and any risk is further diminished by the availability of internal relocation. Applying the law applicable to non-refoulement protection to the facts it found, the Board found the Applicant had failed to establish her entitlement to protection under any of the applicable grounds under the USM. Legal principles applicable to judicial review The role of the court in judicial review is not to re-assess the non-refoulement claims afresh. The primary decision-makers in a claim for non-refoulement are the Director and the Board. They alone assess the evidence and find facts including those relating to the matters allegedly giving rise to the non-refoulement claim, risk of harm, availability of state protection and viability of internal relocation. The court will scrutinize the Board’s decision, and intervene by way of judicial review, only for errors of law, procedural unfairness or irrationality: see Nupur Mst v Director of Immigration. Grounds for judicial review The Applicant had not advanced any grounds of application in her Form 86 or in her supporting affirmation. She did not attend the hearing before this Court and forewent her opportunity to have the Court’s assistance in exploring possible grounds of application with her. In the absence of specific grounds of application, the Court could only focus its scrutiny of the Decision on errors of law, procedural unfairness or irrationality in the Decision. Overall scrutiny Having rigorously examined the Decision, the papers and the evidence with anxious scrutiny, the Court is satisfied that the Board had correctly set out the law and key legal principles applicable to non-refoulement protection under the USM; the burden of proof and standard of proof; correctly identified the issues and observed a very high standard of fairness. The Board basically assessed the Applicant’s claim on the basis of the case as she had asserted. It made some further necessary finding of facts based on her evidence and the COI. It found on the basis of the COI, that adequate state protection is available in Indonesia. The Court noted that the Board assessed the age of the Applicant was nine years older than her actual age when considering feasibility of internal relocation, but does not consider the mistake has any adverse impact on its assessment of internal relocation or the level of risk facing the Applicant. Then, applying the law applicable to non-refoulement protection to the Applicant’s case and the further finding of fact, it found the Applicant had failed to establish the factual basis to support her claim to protection under any of the four applicable grounds under the USM. These are mixed finding of fact and of the law. Insofar as they are finding of the law, they are absolutely correct. Insofar as they are findings of fact, they are exclusively within the realm of the Board, which the Court on a judicial review will not interfere, save when such finding was made as result of error of law or procedural unfairness or that the Decision is irrational. The Court could detect no error of law or procedural unfairness in the Decision. The Decision does satisfy the enhanced Wednesbury test. It is not Wednesbury unreasonable or irrational. Basically, the Applicant failed to discharge her burden of proving her fears and risks. The Decision is utterly without fault. The proposed judicial review has no realistic prospect of success. Conclusion For the above reasons, the Applicant’s leave application is refused. Dated the 13th day of November 2026 ( Seline Sze ) for Registrar, High Court Where leave to apply has been granted, Applicants and their legal advisers are reminded of their obligation to reconsider the merits of their application in the light of the Respondent’s evidence Form CALL-1