Case Details
Citation
MIRADOR MANSION OWNERS AND TENANTS ASSOCIATION LTD AND OTHERS v. CHAN TAK TAI AND OTHERS, HCA 539/1967
Case Number
HCA 539/1967
Court
Court of First Instance
(CFI)
Decision Date
25 April 1970
Parties
Respondent(s):

Tenants Association Ltd. 1st Plainitiffs (1) and Hari naraindas Marilela (2) Wadhwmal Leknraj Sitlani and (3) Rochiram Jhamandas Sitlani (4) Jhamatmal Ghanoomal Sakhrani (5) Angie Gutierrez (6) Wong Shoot Yan (7) Lea Pea Ying (8) Li Shun Cheung and Tang Mu Lan (9) Ho Wing See and Ho Wing Yin (10) Imperial Hotel Limited (11) Pierre Mardulyn (12) Goddard & Co. Limited (13) Sung Tsen Young (14) Leung Shun Yin (15) Cheung Ping Hang (16) Esther Maria Sequeira (17) Antonio Braz de Carvalho (18) Hassan Sedick (19) Shzu Tsuey (20) Filomeno Angelo Rozario (21) Chan Yu Ceng Nguk (22) Edith Anita Campos (23) Chen Chong Sung (24) Chan Wing Kin (25) Lam Yuen Wah (26) Ip Ling Sheung (27) Lee Wah (28) Archibald David (29) Verun Keswani (30) Chan Kwai Ying (31) Wang Chih Chung (32) Patrick Go (33) Wong Wa Po (34) Jeane Lee (35) Agnes Feng (36) Hau But Hing (37) Chan Lai Fat (38) Mak Chow and Mak Voon (39) Tsui Wan Shan (40) Frank Poon Chung Yin (41) Gopaldas Hiranand on behalf of themselves and all co-owners of Mirador Mansion except the, 2nd Plaintiffs, Chan Tak Tai, Chan Shiu Tong a partner thereof, Chan Pak Yeung, Stephen Chan, Tsui Ming, Chan Pui Kee, Mrs. Ann Smith, H.L. Yang, Madam Charlotte Sim, Chan Bing Ching, N.J. Chien, Lee Kam Fong, Chan Ching Chun, Shirley Chen, Chung Chun Jin, Poon Cho Fook, Joseph Sit, Wong Kam Yuen, Hasso G. Moorjani, Fung King Man, Chiu Lai Suen, Yip Wai Lam, Chan Tsit Man and Villma Ng, Chan Oi Ling, Chan Shu Sang, Chow Joi Yan, Chiang Shan Chee, S.M. Chien, Ho Man Kui, Ho Chun Wah, Leung Chung Kong, Henry Heng Hsu, Heung Ki Lam, Jose See Sen and Marianne Quon Joe, Lo Ka Chung and Lo Hung Cheuk, Nien Yi Lee, Tung Yi Chen, Wong Lai Fong, Margaret Tsang, Wong Leung Yau, Hung Man Ying, Leung King Shau, Lai Yuk Wah, Woo Chung Ming, Chung Ho Yin, Hung Wai Ching, Chow Wing Fat, Cheung Fai Sheng, Peters Gift Centre (a firm), Wong Man Kwong trading as Hong Kong Gift Centre (a firm), China Leatherware Co. (a firm), Lam Kee Pui trading as Pui Kee (a firm), Wong Kwok Kwan trading as Wing Fung (a firm), Pak Kee (a firm), Lam Yu and Lam Chum together sued in their firm name of Mirador Electrical Co, Chen Pak Yeung, Liu Kow Chieng, Chen Lee Yuen, Chen Lee Sung and Lily Chen sued in their firm name of Kowloon Curio Bazaar, Wah Nam Store (a firm), Wong Suoi Nguong and Chong Yue Yin used in their firm name of Yan Kee, Chih Luen Press (a firm), Arts Palace (a firm), The Spring Co. (a firm), Shun Kee Coffee Store (a firm), Wong Hing Chuan trading as Alejo Trading Company (a firm), Hoe Hin Investment Co. Ltd, Au Lock Tung, Mrs. Sylvia Lu Yen, Madam Chan Wei Lan, Madam Irene Goh, Ngai Ching Yung, Fung Tze Shing, Chan Koon Ping, Lee Shun Ching, Leung Yuk Ying, Chan Wai Fong, Tam Wong Tak and Tam To Ming, Ho Ngan Yiu, Catherine Chan, Lee Wai Chun, Fong Kee Yen, Ng yip Nin, Ko Wai Song, Ho Jen Ven, Cheng Siu Ying, Ng Wing Yue, Lam Yee, Yeung Sok Mun, Liang Pao Lien, Lung Chen, Lo Kam Fai, Lam Fun, Lucy Lu, Cheung Ming Git, Ho Ting Fong, Chang Kiang Han Von, Tai Chiu Fai, Lau Chan To, Wong Koon Ching, So Pik Kee, Wan Kam Choy, Ho Chi Keung, Ng Shu Kam, Chan Sau Ping, Chau Ying, L.Y. Lai, Francis Yeung Hsin, Li Tse Ling, Tse Kwok Hung, Lo Fong, Lee Wai Ching, Liu Wa Hee and Lee Po Chan, Chow Sam Mui, Fu Shao Yuen, Mary Winyard, Wu Wai King, Chan Lai Ching, Tong Sau Ying, Chai Wai Leong, Au Yeung Shiu Chun, Yee So Ven, O.P. Seth, Yao Ting Fong, Chan Sin Yu, Lam Yiu Cheung and Chow Ching Wan, Chan Teck Chye Co. Ltd, Lung Tong Miu Hing, Li Kuen, Lu Mei Ying, Li Ching, Chui So Lan, Lam Tak Yau and Ng Chee Yung, Law Shun Tsai, Lam Chun Yuen, Lee Wai King, Wu Pei Chi, Chou Po, Leung Hong, Lee Wah, Fok Wing Sheung, Keung Hor Wai, Tse Yiu Sang, Pak Yin San, Tsang Shui Yau, Priest Luet Chun, Wong Kin Wah, Ho King Ying, Ho Kit-chun, Dah Yuan Real Estate Co. Ltd, Lee Yuk Ying, Mak Hon Fat, Mok Po Lin, Yeung Shiu Lan, Ng Tin Chu, Liu Ping Wah, Har Yut Wah, Paul Cheung, Wong Yu Ko, Tam Lai Ping, Chan Chi Pen, Lo Wei, Peter Ho Chung Ming trading as Polly's Co. Emporium, Tailor, Ching Suit Man trading as Lebanon

MIRADOR MANSION OWNERS AND TENANTS ASSOCIATION LTD AND OTHERS v. CHAN TAK TAI AND OTHERS

HCA 539/1967

Court of First Instance25 April 1970

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition