Case Details

Citation

GRANDE HOLDINGS LTD v. CHRISTOPHER HO WING ON, HCA 565M/2013

Case Number

HCA 565M/2013

Court

Court of First Instance

(CFI)

Decision Date

8 October 2013

Parties

Applicant(s):

GRANDE HOLDINGS LIMITED

Respondent(s):

the 64 companies listed as the 2nd to the 65th Plaintiffs in Schedule 1 and CHRISTOPHER HO WING ON, CHRISTOPHER HO WING ON

Judges

Leung

GRANDE HOLDINGS LTD v. CHRISTOPHER HO WING ON

HCA 565M/2013

Court of First Instance8 October 2013

Judges:Leung

HCA565M/2013 GRANDE HOLDINGS LTD v. CHRISTOPHER HO WING ON

HCA 565/2013

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

HIGH COURT ACTION NO. 565 OF 2013

________________________

BETWEEN
	GRANDE HOLDINGS LIMITED	1st Plaintiff
	(PROVISIONAL LIQUIDATORS APPOINTED) and the 64 companies listed as the 2^nd to the 65^thPlaintiffs in Schedule 1
	and
	CHRISTOPHER HO WING ON	1st Defendant
	and the 9 persons listed as the 2nd to the 10th Defendants in Schedule 2

________________________

Before: Deputy High Court Judge Leung in Chambers

Date of Hearing and Decision: 8 October 2013

Date of Reasons for Decision: 9 October 2013

________________________

C O R R I G E N D U M

________________________

Kindly note that the following corrections in the Reasons for Decision handed down by High Court Deputy Judge Leung on 9 October 2013:

Page 2, paragraph 1 and line B should be amended as “…serve the writ on the d ~~444~~efendants.”.

Page 4, paragraph 13 and line L should be amended as “…the writ despite the ~~plaintiff’s~~ defendant’s notice.”.

Dated this 17 October 2013.

	(Jessica P.W. To)
	Clerk to High Court Deputy Judge Leung

Schedule 1
AKAI ENTERPRISES LIMITED	2^nd Plaintiff
BRIGHTON MARKETING LIMITED	3^rd Plaintiff
CAPETRONIC FAR EASTERN HOLDINGS LIMITED	4^th Plaintiff
DEVON TECHNICAL SERVICES LIMITED	5^th Plaintiff
DEXKEN LIMITED	6^th Plaintiff
EASTWOOD INDUSTRIES LIMITED	7^th Plaintiff
HI-TECH PRECISION PRODUCTS LTD	8^th Plaintiff
HI-TECH PRECISION SERVICES LIMITED	9^th Plaintiff
HONGKEW HOLDINGS LIMITED	10^th Plaintiff
LAFE HOLDINGS LIMITED	11^th Plaintiff
MILL SET LIMITED	12^th Plaintiff
NAKAMICHI VISION 21 LIMITED	13^th Plaintiff
POLYCROWN COMPANY LIMITED	14^th Plaintiff
PRIMETIME WORLD LIMITED	15^th Plaintiff
RABCO INVESTMENTS LIMITED	16^th Plaintiff
SANSUI HONG KONG LIMITED	17^th Plaintiff
SOUND FAIR ELECTRONICS COMPANY LIMITED	18^th Plaintiff
SOUND VIEW INTERNATIONAL LIMITED	19^th Plaintiff
THE ALPHA CAPITAL LIMITED	20^th Plaintiff
TOMEI INDUSTRIAL (HOLDINGS) LIMITED	21^st Plaintiff
TWD INTERNATIONAL LTD	22^nd Plaintiff
CAPETRONIC DISPLAY DEVICES HOLDINGS LIMITED	23^rd Plaintiff
CAPETRONIC TECHNOLOGY LIMITED	24^th Plaintiff
E-ZONE GROUP HOLDINGS LIMITED	25^th Plaintiff
GRANDE N.A.K.S. LTD	26^th Plaintiff
HI-TECH INTERNATIONAL LIMITED	27^th Plaintiff
HI-TECH PRECISION PRODUCTS LIMITED	28^th Plaintiff
INNOVATIVE CAPITAL LTD	29^th Plaintiff
N.A.K.S. INTERNATIONAL LTD	30^th Plaintiff
NAKAMICHI ENTERPRISES LIMITED	31^st Plaintiff
PHENOMENON AGENTS LIMITED	32^nd Plaintiff
S & T INTERNATIONAL DISTRIBUTION LIMITED	33^rd Plaintiff
SANSUI ACOUSTICS RESEARCH CORPORATION	34^th Plaintiff
SANSUI ELECTRIC CO., LTD.	35^th Plaintiff
SANSUI ENTERPRISES LIMITED	36^th Plaintiff
SUPER BRAND GLOBAL LIMITED	37^th Plaintiff
THE ALPHA CAPITAL SERVICES LTD	38^th Plaintiff
THE GRANDE CAPITAL GROUP LIMITED	39^th Plaintiff
THE GRANDE EXPLORER LTD	40^th Plaintiff
THE GRANDE (NOMINEES) LIMITED	41^st Plaintiff
THE GRANDE RESTAURANTS LIMITED	42^nd Plaintiff
THE GRANDE (SECRETARIES) SERVICE LIMITED	43^rd Plaintiff
TOMEI INTERNATIONAL (B.V.I) LIMITED	44^th Plaintiff
TOMEI KAWA ELECTRONICS INTERNATIONAL LIMITED	45^th Plaintiff
TWD INDUSTRIAL COMPANY LIMITED	46^th Plaintiff
TWD INTERNATIONAL LIMITED	47^th Plaintiff
TOMEI TECHNOLOGIES LTD	48^th Plaintiff
UNIJOY LIMITED	49^th Plaintiff
AFFIRMED ELECTRONICS PTE LTD	50^th Plaintiff
AKAI SALES PTE. LTD (IN PROVISIONAL LIQUIDATION)	51^st Plaintiff
CAFE AL FRESCO PTE LTD	52^nd Plaintiff
CAPETRONIC GROUP PTE. LTD.	53^rd Plaintiff
CAPETRONIC MULTIMEDIA DEVELOPMENT PTE. LTD.	54^th Plaintiff
EAST COAST WORKS PTE LTD	55^th Plaintiff
E-ZONE (BALESTIER) PTE LTD	56^th Plaintiff
E-ZONE (LIAT TOWERS) PTE LTD	57^th Plaintiff
E-ZONE ENGINEERING PTE. LTD.	58^th Plaintiff
E-ZONE MANAGEMENT PTE LTD	59^th Plaintiff
HONG KONG ABERDEEN SEAFOOD RESTAURANT PTE LTD	60^th Plaintiff
NAKAMICHI CORPORATION LIMITED	61^st Plaintiff
NAKAMICHI RESEARCH(S) PTE LTD	62^nd Plaintiff
GRANDE N.A.K.S PTE LTD (FORMERLY KNOWN AS SANSUI (SINGAPORE) PTE LIMITED	63^rd Plaintiff
THE GRANDE GROUP LIMITED	64^th Plaintiff
TOMEI (SINGAPORE) PTE LTD	65^th Plaintiff

Schedule 2
ADRIAN MA CHI CHIU	2^nd Defendant
CHRISTINE ASPREY LAI SHAN	3^rd Defendant
HENRY CHONG CHIN SHANG	4^th Defendant
HERBERT TSOI HAK KONG	5^th Defendant
JOHNNY LAU WING HUNG	6^th Defendant
LAM CHUCK FAI	7^th Defendant
MARTIN LAN WRIGHT	8^th Defendant
MICHAEL ANDREW BARCLAY BINNEY	9^th Defendant
PAUL LAW KWOK FAI	10^th Defendant

GRANDE HOLDINGS LTD v. CHRISTOPHER HO WING ON

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations