Case Details

Citation

TO PUI KUI v. NG OI CHE AND OTHERS, CACV 67M/2014

Case Number

CACV 67M/2014

Court

Court of Appeal

(CA)

Decision Date

27 February 2015

Parties

Applicant(s):

TO PUI KUI, the Administratrix of the estate of NG PO SUM, deceased

Respondent(s):

NG OI CHE, WING LUNG BANK LIMITED, HULTUCKTONG ENTERPRISES LIMITED

Judges

Yuen
Barma
Poon

TO PUI KUI v. NG OI CHE AND OTHERS

CACV 67M/2014

Court of Appeal27 February 2015

Judges:YuenBarmaPoon

CACV67M/2014 TO PUI KUI v. NG OI CHE AND OTHERS

CACV 67/2014

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF APPEAL

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 67 OF 2014

(ON APPEAL FROM HCA NO. 522 OF 2008)

________________________

BETWEEN

	TO PUI KUI, the Administratrix of the estate of NG PO SUM, deceased	Plaintiff
	And
	NG OI CHE	1^st Defendant
	WING LUNG BANK LIMITED	2^nd Defendant
	HULTUCKTONG ENTERPRISES LIMITED	3^rd Defendant

________________________

AND

CACV 156/2014

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF APPEAL

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 156 OF 2014

(ON APPEAL FROM HCA NO. 522 OF 2008)

BETWEEN

	TO PUI KUI, the Administratrix of the estate of NG PO SUM, deceased	Plaintiff
	and
	NG OI CHE	1^st Defendant
	WING LUNG BANK LIMITED	2^nd Defendant
	HULTUCKTONG ENTERPRISES LIMITED	3^rd Defendant
	and
	NG KWOK TAI ANDREW	Party on Costs

_______________________

(Heard together)

Before : Hon Yuen, Barma JJA and Poon J in Court

Date of Hearing: 20 January 2015

Date of Judgment: 27 February 2015

Date of Corrigenda: 18 March 2015

__________________

CORRIGENDA

__________________

Please note the following Corrigenda in the Judgment dated 27 February 2015.

1. Page 15, paragraph 27, “I think that if it had been intended that” should read “we think that if it had been intended that”.

2. Page 17, paragraph 30.3, “to enable the potential s.52A party to apply to be joined” should read “to enable the potential s.52A(2) party to apply to be joined”.

3. Page 19, paragraph 35, “in case I am wrong on the summons” should read “in case we are wrong on the summons”.

4. Page 25, paragraph 48, “unless satisfied that the judge had made an error or law” should read “unless satisfied that the judge had made an error of law”.

Dated this 18^th day of March 2015.

	(Vicky Wong)
	Clerk to Hon Yuen JA

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations

Appeal history

CACV 156/2014
Judgment not in library
On appeal from
TO PUI KUI v. NG OI CHE AND OTHERS
CFI · 3 Mar 2014
On appeal from
TO PUI KUI v. NG OI CHE AND OTHERS
CA · 27 Feb 2015
This judgment
TO PUI KUI v. NG OI CHE AND OTHERS
CA · 27 Feb 2015
On appeal from
TO PUI KUI v. NG OI CHE AND OTHERS
CA · 27 Feb 2015
On appeal from
TO PUI KUI v. NG OI CHE AND OTHERS
CA · 12 Aug 2015
On appeal from
NG KWOK TAI ANDREW v. NG OI CHE AND ANOTHER
CFA · 23 Mar 2016
On appeal from