Case Details
Listing:
ALEG SATRIO HADI v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE[Decision on Leave Application]
ALEG SATRIO HADI v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE[Decision on Leave Application]
[2026] HKCFI 6284 · HCAL 2018/2023
Court of First Instance
HCAL 2018/2023 [2026] HKCFI 6284 IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE CONSTITUTIONAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE LAW LIST No. 2018 of 2023 BETWEEN Application for Leave to Apply for Judicial Review NOTIFICATION of the Judge’s decision (Ord. 53 r. 3) Following; Order by Deputy High Court Judge To: Extension of time to file the leave application be refused; and Leave to apply for Judicial Review be refused. Observations for the Applicant: Introduction This is the Applicant’s application by Form 86 filed on 13 November 2023 for leave to apply for judicial review (the “leave application”) of the decision of the Torture Claims Appeal Board / Non-Refoulement Claims Petition Office (the “Board”) dated 27 July 2023 (the “Decision”) dismissing his appeal against the decision of the Director of Immigration (the “Director”) in his Notice of Decision refusing his application for non-refoulement protection (the “Notice”). The delay in taking out the leave application The leave application was filed three months and seventeen days after the date of the Decision sought to be reviewed. Under section 21K(6) of the High Court Ordinance and Order 53, rule 4(1) of the Rules of the High Court, a leave application shall be made promptly and in any event within three months from the date when grounds for the application first arose unless the court considers there is good reason for extending the period within which the application shall be made. The leave application was made seventeen days beyond what is usually regarded as having been promptly made. The Applicant has to show good reason for extending the time to file the leave application. As the delay is not very substantial, the Court explored the merits of his leave application before deciding whether to grant him extension of time to file it. Background The Applicant is an Indonesian national, now aged 33. He arrived in Hong Kong on 21 November 2022 and overstayed since 22 December 2022. He was arrested by the police on 4 January 2023 and referred to the Immigration Department. On the same day, he lodged a non-refoulement claim by written signification. In due course, his claim was assessed on all four applicable grounds under the Unified Screening Mechanism (the “USM”), namely: Torture Risk; BOR 3 Risk; Persecution Risk; and BOR 2 Risk. His claim was rejected by the Director’s Notice. His appeal against the Notice was dismissed by the Board’s Decision. He now applies for leave to apply for judicial review of that Decision. The Applicant’s case The Applicant’s personal background, the basis of his claim, the arguments he advanced, the finding of the Board and the reasons for its Decision are set out in details in the Board’s Decision. These will not be repeated here. The hyperlink to the Board’s Decision is included below for reference. In gist, he claims, if returned to Indonesia, he will be harmed or killed by a loan shark for being unable to repay his loan owing to the loan shark. The Applicant had received 12 years formal education and was a construction worker. He is a habitual gambler. In January 2022, he lost about 5 million Indonesian Rupiah in a casino. A loan shark gave him a bundle of money saying that he could repay when he won money in the gambling. He took the money and lost them in gambling. Similarly, the loan shark lent him a smaller sum, which he also lost in the gambling. Then he went home. In May 2022, the loan shark came to the Applicant’s home to demand repayment of the debts. The Applicant said he had no money. The loan shark gave him a month to pay and left. In June 2022, the loan shark came to his home to collect payment. Again, he could not pay. The loan shark warned that interest expenses would be increased if he did not pay. Then he left. In July 2022, the loan shark came to collect payment. Again, the Applicant could not pay. The loan shark grasped the collar of his clothes, threatened to kill him if he could not pay in the following month. Then, he pushed the Applicant to the floor. Between August and October 2022, the loan shark came on four occasions, but the Applicant managed to avoid him by leaving through the back door. On another occasion in October 2022, the loan shark and an underling armed with a long knife came. The loan shark shouted that he would kill the Applicant if the Applicant did not pay. This alerted the Applicant’s brother and his uncle. They told the loan shark that they did not know the whereabouts of the Applicant. Then the loan shark and his underling left without hurting anybody. After the loan shark and his underling had left, the Applicant’s uncle and brother had a quarrel with the Applicant and evicted the Applicant from his home. The Applicant went to live with a friend in Eretan until November 2022 when his brother informed him that the loan shark had come to his uncle’s home and knew that the Applicant was in Eretan. Then, the Applicant fled to Hong Kong. The Applicant had never asked for assistance from the authorities or the police because he thought his dispute with the loan shark is a private dispute and the authorities would not interfere. He did not agree that the police would help him because he had no evidence against the loan shark. He did not believe he could relocate to other cities in Indonesia because he could not earn his means of living and he thought the loan shark and his underlings could track him down no matter where he relocated to. The Board’s Decision The Applicant testified before the Board. The Board assessed his claim on the basis of the case as he asserted, the country of origin information (“COI”) and some necessary finding of fact based on his evidence. It found the Applicant’s dispute with the loan shark is entirely a domestic monetary affair in which neither the Indonesian government nor any public official nor person acting in a public capacity was involved or had assisted or encouraged. It found the pain and suffering inflicted on the Applicant was mild and did not constitute “torture” within the meaning of section 37U(1) of the Immigration Ordinance or attain the minimum level of severity. It considered the force used by the loan shark was mild and the manner of debt collection was soft. It considered the threat of death was just a show of stance and that the loan shark had no intention to seriously harm or kill the Applicant. It did not accept there are substantial grounds for believing that the Applicant will be subjected any proscribed harm. It also found the ill-treatment inflicted on the Applicant was not on account of a reason enumerated under 1951 Convention relating to the status of Refugees and its 1967 Protocol. The Board found on the basis of the COI that adequate state protection would be available had the Applicant requested it. It found it was the Applicant’s choice not to seek police assistance. It also found no evidence in support of any contention that a consistent pattern of gross, flagrant or mass violation of human rights exists in Indonesia. In view of the above finding, the Board did not find it necessary to consider the issue of internal relocation. Applying the law applicable to non-refoulement protection to the facts it found, the Board found the Applicant had failed to establish his entitlement to protection under any of the applicable grounds under the USM. Legal principles applicable to judicial review The role of the court in judicial review is not to re-assess the non-refoulement claims afresh. The primary decision-makers in a claim for non-refoulement are the Director and the Board. They alone assess the evidence and find facts including those relating to the matters allegedly giving rise to the non-refoulement claim, risk of harm, availability of state protection and viability of internal relocation. The court will scrutinize the Board’s decision, and intervene by way of judicial review, only for errors of law, procedural unfairness or irrationality: see Nupur Mst v Director of Immigration. Grounds for judicial review The Applicant had not advanced any grounds of application in his Form 86. In his supporting affirmation, he annexed a statement complaining against the Board for procedural unfairness. He said that these complaints were prepared by his friend, that he understood them and could give elaborations on them. The essence of his complaint is that the Board was not neutral and did not truly consider his claim. It was prepared to dismiss his claim before the oral hearing and using some bad arguments. He also alleged that the duty lawyer assigned to help him was not helpful. Though the lawyer came everyday, he just slept, leaving the Applicant to talk to the interpreter. However, not only was he unable to provide elaborations on the complaints, he denounced them. He said he was satisfied with the services of the interpreter and had no complaint against the duty lawyer. He disagreed with the complaints and could not explain why his friend wrote those complaints for him. The Court has seen identical complaints in other leave applications. These complaints appear to be formatted grounds which may not have any bearing on the factual circumstances in the instant case. In the absence of specific grounds of application, the Court could only focus its scrutiny of the Decision on errors of law, procedural unfairness or irrationality in the Decision. Overall scrutiny Having rigorously examined the Decision, the papers and the evidence with anxious scrutiny, the Court is satisfied that the Board had correctly set out the law and key legal principles applicable to non-refoulement protection under the USM; the burden of proof and standard of proof; correctly identified the issues and observed a very high standard of fairness. The Board basically assessed the Applicant’s claim on the basis of the case as he had asserted. It made some further necessary finding of facts based on his evidence and the COI. It found on the basis of the COI, that adequate state protection is available in Indonesia. On the evidence, it was open to the Board to make the finding as it did. Then, applying the law applicable to non-refoulement protection to the Applicant’s case and the further finding of fact, it found the Applicant had failed to establish the factual basis to support his claim to protection under any of the four applicable grounds under the USM. These are mixed finding of fact and of the law. Insofar as they are finding of the law, they are absolutely correct. Insofar as they are findings of fact, they are exclusively within the realm of the Board, which the Court on a judicial review will not interfere, save when such finding was made as result of error of law or procedural unfairness or that the Decision is irrational. The Court could detect no error of law or procedural unfairness in the Decision. The Decision does satisfy the enhanced Wednesbury test. It is not Wednesbury unreasonable or irrational. Basically, the Applicant failed to discharge his burden of proving his fears and risks. The Decision is utterly without fault. The proposed judicial review has no realistic prospect of success. Conclusion As the proposed judicial review has no realistic prospect of success, it would be futile to grant the Applicant extension of time to file the leave application. Hence, both extension of time to file the leave application and the leave application are refused. Dated the 13th day of November 2026 ( Seline Sze ) for Registrar, High Court Where leave to apply has been granted, Applicants and their legal advisers are reminded of their obligation to reconsider the merits of their application in the light of the Respondent’s evidence Form CALL-1