Case Details
Listing:
BENTIK KAROMAH v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE[Decision on Leave Application]
BENTIK KAROMAH v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE[Decision on Leave Application]
[2026] HKCFI 6031 · HCAL 210/2024
Court of First Instance
HCAL 210/2024 [2026] HKCFI 6031 IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE CONSTITUTIONAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE LAW LIST No 210 of 2024 BETWEEN Application for Leave to Apply for Judicial Review NOTIFICATION of the Judge’s decision (Ord 53 r 3) Following; Order by Deputy High Court Judge To: Leave to apply for Judicial Review be refused Observations for the Applicant: Introduction This is the Applicant’s application by Form 86 filed on 24 January 2024 for leave to apply for judicial review (the “leave application”) of the decision of the Torture Claims Appeal Board / Non-Refoulement Claims Petition Office (the “Board”) dated 27 December 2023 (the “Decision”) dismissing her appeal against the decision of the Director of Immigration (the “Director”) in his Notice of Decision refusing her application for non-refoulement protection (the “Notice”). Background The Applicant is an Indonesian national, now aged 46. She last arrived in Hong Kong on 17 January 2018 to take up employment as a foreign domestic helper. She overstayed since 9 July 2022 after her employment was prematurely terminated. She was arrested by the police on 13 April 2023 and referred to the Immigration Department. She lodged a non-refoulement claim by written signification dated 25 April 2023. In due course, her claim was assessed on all four applicable grounds under the Unified Screening Mechanism (the “USM”), namely: Torture Risk; BOR 3 Risk; Persecution Risk; and BOR 2 Risk. Her claim was rejected by the Director’s Notice. Her appeal against the Notice was dismissed by the Board’s Decision. She now applies for leave to apply for judicial review of that Decision. The Applicant’s case and Board’s Decision The Applicant’s personal background, the basis of her claim, the arguments she advanced, the finding of the Board and the reasons for its Decision are set out in details in the Board’s Decision. These will not be repeated here. The hyperlink to the Board’s Decision is included below for reference. In gist, she claims, if returned to Indonesia, she will be harmed or killed by her husband because of their domestic dispute and by a loan shark for being unable to repay her husband’s debt owing to the loan shark. The Applicant had worked in Hong Kong as a foreign domestic helper since from 1999 to about June 2022. She was married in Indonesia and gave birth to a child with her husband in 2017. During their cohabitation, she was subjected to domestic violence from her husband, which included being emotionally abused and mistreated and occasionally slapped. In about 2016, she became aware that her husband had borrowed a loan from a loan shark and had told the loan shark that she would repay the debt for him. In 2016 or 2017, the loan shark had demanded payment from the Applicant and had slapped her and threatened her with death when she could not pay. After her last return to Hong Kong in 2018, she was told by her neighbour that her husband was living with another woman in their house. She called her husband and confronted him. Her husband confirmed he had taken a second wife and sought her consent. When she refused, he threatened to kill her when she returned to Indonesia. Since losing her employment, the Applicant was unable to remit money to her husband. Both her husband and the loan shark threatened to kill her when she returns to Indonesia if she did not pay. Since June 2022, both the Applicant and her husband changed their telephone numbers. They lost contact with one another since. The Applicant had an ex-boyfriend but had no contact with him since about 2016. She had also developed an on-going relationship with a partner in Hong Kong and is intending to marry in Hong Kong. The finding of the Board The Board was not confident to dismiss the Applicant’s evidence as not credible and for the purpose of the Decision accepted the core aspects of her claims about past events in Indonesia and assessed her claim on that basis. The Applicant had never sought protection from the Indonesian authorities or the police. The Board found on the basis of authoritative and credible country of origin information (“COI”) that there was a functioning system of law and order in Indonesia, including an appropriate system of criminal law with a reasonably effective and impartial police force and justice system. It was satisfied that the Indonesian government had taken reasonable measures to protect the lives and safety of its citizens and that a reasonable system of state protection would be available to the Applicant if she sought assistance and protection from the harm she fears from the loan shark and her husband. Hence, it rejected the Applicant’s claim about the inability and unwillingness of the police to respond to her call for protection as her own assumptions and speculations. It did not consider there are substantial grounds to believe that the Indonesian police would deliberately withhold protection from her in regard to the loan shark and her husband in the claimed circumstances or that there was any state involvement through the conduct of its own officials or their instigation or through the consent or acquiescence of the state in the conduct of the loan shark and/or her husband. Hence, the Board found Applicant’s fear from the loan shark and her husband does not come within the definition of ‘torture’ in section 37U(1) of the Immigration Ordinance. Hence, the Applicant’s claim under Torture Risk ground failed. The Board accepted that the Applicant had previously been subjected to violence and threats of violence from her husband and the loan shark. It considered there was nonetheless a small but real risk that she would suffer serious physical mistreatment from, by or on behalf of the loan shark and/or her husband, if she returned to her home area in the reasonably foreseeable future. Such mistreatment would be likely to cause her severe pain and suffering within the meaning of ‘degrading treatment’. However, the Board was satisfied that adequate state protection would be available. Given the geographical and population size of Indonesia, it considered the risk would be remote if the Applicant relocates to a location outside her home area on her return to Indonesia. Hence, the Board found she is not entitled to protection under BOR 3 Risk ground. Despite the Board accepted that there was a small but real risk that the Applicant would suffer serious physical mistreatment from, by or on behalf of the loan shark and/or her husband if she returned to her home area in the reasonably foreseeable future, the risk was not for a reason under the 1951 Convention relating to the status of Refugees and its 1967 Protocol. In addition, the Board also found adequate state protection would be available and the Applicant could further avoid the risk by relocated to areas outside her home area, such as Jakarta or Surabaya or Bali. Hence, her claim under Persecution Risk ground also failed. The Board also found there were no substantial grounds to believe that the Applicant would face a real risk of being subjected to the death penalty or being arbitrarily deprived of her life under any of the claimed circumstances or situations or for any other reasons. Hence, BOR 2 Risk is not engaged. Legal principles applicable to judicial review The role of the court in judicial review is not to re-assess the non-refoulement claims afresh. The primary decision-makers in a claim for non-refoulement are the Director and the Board. They alone assess the evidence and find facts including those relating to the matters allegedly giving rise to the non-refoulement claim, risk of harm, availability of state protection and viability of internal relocation. The court will scrutinize the Board’s decision, and intervene by way of judicial review, only for errors of law, procedural unfairness or irrationality: see Nupur Mst v Director of Immigration. Grounds for judicial review The Applicant had not advanced any grounds of application in her Form 86. In her supporting affirmation, she reiterated that her life would be in danger because the loan shark and his subordinates intend to and could inflict serious harm on her. This is in effect a direct challenge of the Board’s finding of fact, which is impermissible. At the hearing, after the legal principle in the preceding paragraph had been explained to her, she confirmed she had no complaints about error of law, procedural unfairness or irrationality in the Decision. In the absence of particularised grounds of application, the Court in an application for judicial review could only focus on errors of law, procedural unfairness and irrationality in the Decision. Overall scrutiny Having rigorously examined the Decision, the papers and the evidence with anxious scrutiny, the Court is satisfied that the Board had correctly set out the law and key legal principles applicable to non-refoulement protection under the USM; the burden of proof and standard of proof; correctly identified the issues and observed a very high standard of fairness. The Board basically accepted her evidence and made certain finding of facts based on her case, the COI and inherent probability. The Applicant could have no complaint against the Board’s finding of facts. The Board’s findings are mixed finding of law and of fact. Insofar as its finding of law is concerned, the Board is absolutely correct. Insofar as its finding of fact is concerned, it is exclusively within the realm of the Board, which the Court in a judicial review will not interfere, save when such finding was made as result of error of law or procedural unfairness or irrationality in the Decision. The Board gave reasons for its finding. On the evidence, it was open to the Board to make the finding of fact as it did. The Court could detect no error of law or procedural unfairness in the Decision. The Decision does satisfy the enhanced Wednesbury test. It is not Wednesbury unreasonable or irrational. Basically, the Applicant had failed to discharge her burden of proving her fears and risks. The proposed judicial review has no realistic prospect of success. Conclusion For the above reasons, the Applicant’s leave application is refused. Dated the 30th day of October 2026 ( Seline Sze ) for Registrar, High Court Where leave to apply has been granted, Applicants and their legal advisers are reminded of their obligation to reconsider the merits of their application in the light of the Respondent’s evidence Form CALL-1