Case Details
Citation
EXTRAMONEY LTD AND ANOTHER v. CHAN, LAI PANG & CO (a firm), HCA 8437/1987
Case Number
HCA 8437/1987
Court
Court of First Instance
(CFI)
Parties
Applicant(s):

EXTRAMONEY LIMITED, CARRIAN HOLDINGS LIMITED (in liquidation)

Respondent(s):

Defendants CHAN, LAI PANG & CO. (a firm) (By Original Action) ____________ AND BETWEEN CHAN LAI, PANG & CO. (a firm) Plaintiffs and EXTRAMONEY LIMITED, CARRIAN HOLDINGS LIMITED (in liquidation), THE ATTORNEY GENERAL REPRESENTING THE COMMISSIONER OF INLAND REVENUE, CARRIAN FINANCE LIMITED, CARRIAN REALTY LIMITED, CARRIAN JOINT VENUTRE LIMITED, THOMAS BRIAN STEVENSON, WILFRED KEITH TIMSO, JOHN WILLIAM CRAWFORD

For Applicant(s):

the claim underwent not inconsiderable metamorphosis. In its final incarnation which materialised on or about l0th March 1993 by way of a statement of Claim with red and green amendments and violet deletions, the Plaintiffs rely on a number of different causes of action which I shall summarise below. I use the expression "deletion" since Mr. John Griffiths Q.C. who appears; furnished with documents and information which verified the aforesaid entry, namely, statements of a stock brokerage firm known as Okasan International (Asia) Limited ("Okasan") showing market acquisitions of CIL shares which, when later sold, generated the Disputed Profit, Extramoney's internal memoranda and journal entries as well as information orally supplied by Mr. Tan acting; John Griffiths, Q.C., and Mr. Clifford Smith (instructed by Messrs. Simmons and Simmons)

For Respondent(s):

Mr. Robert Andrews, Senior Crown Counsel

EXTRAMONEY LTD AND ANOTHER v. CHAN, LAI PANG & CO (a firm)

HCA 8437/1987

Court of First Instance

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations