母親 對 父親
[2026] HKFC 168 · FCMC 9875/2024
Family Court
FCMC 9875 / 2024
[2026] HKFC 168
香 港 特 別 行 政 區
區 域 法 院
婚姻訴訟案件編號2024年第9875宗
——————————
母親 呈請人
及
父親 答辯人
——————————
主審法官︰ 區域法院暫委法官彭家光內庭聆訊(非公開)
審訊日期︰ 2026年1月9日、12至16日、2026年5月26至29日、6月1日至2日
呈請人結案陳詞︰2026年6月25日
答辯人結案陳詞︰2026年6月25日
判決書日期︰2026年9月1 5日
-------------------------
判 決 書
( 管養權 )
-------------------------
這份發布的判案書已經適當編輯,以防止可能泄露訴訟各方和所提及的兒童的身份,同
時也根據日期為2026年10月9日的勘誤作出修正。
1. 本席簡稱呈請人為「母親」,答辯人則為「父親」。
2.
這是一高衝突的個案。本審訊有關三名家庭子女管養權,母親要求家庭子
女的單獨管養權,父親則認為法庭應將家庭子女共同管養權頒與訴訟雙
方。
背景
3.
母親現年44歲,持大學學位,曾在銀行和跨國集團公司工作,現報稱是全
職家庭主婦。父親現年55歲,持大學學位,曾在英國營商,現時在香港
經營公司,從事投資股票及物業。在2012年,訴訟雙方認識。在2013年
,訴訟雙方同居。在2013年,大兒子出生,現年12歲。在2015年,訴訟
雙方註冊結婚。在2015年10月,訴訟雙方搬到位於港島之前婚姻居所居
住。在2015年,二仔出生,現年11歲。在2018年,女兒出生,現年8歲。
本席在下文統稱三名家庭子女為「家庭子女」。
4.
在2024年9月12日,母親提出離婚呈請。同時,母親將傳票存檔,要求法庭
頒令將家庭子女之單獨管養權、照顧和管束權頒予母親,又申請禁制令
,要求法庭頒令禁止父親騷擾母親及家庭子女。在2024年9月13日,母親
從學校接走家庭子女,離開婚姻居所搬到酒店暫住。
5.
經訴訟雙方各自承諾不會在對方探視家庭子女時進行任何錄影或錄音,又
經父親在不承認任何責任的情況下承諾不會以任何形式騷擾母親或家庭
子女,在2024年11月5日,區域法院勞杰民法官頒令︰-
1) 聆訊押後至2025年1月3日上午10時作進一步指示聆訊;
2)
家庭子女的管養權、照顧及管束權及探視事宜押後至2025年3月17日上午9時3
0分作審前覆核;
3) 直至法庭有進一步命令,父親獲得臨時受監管日間探視如下︰
1)
大仔、二仔和女兒每名每星期不少於1小時的分別探視(包括親身及/或視
像探視);
2)
實際探視時間、地點及安排(包括探視是否親身探視或視像探視)由社工
作出安排;
4)
社會福利署(下稱「社署」)就家庭子女的現況及臨時探視的建議提交緊急的
社會福利調查報告;
5)
社署就家庭子女的管養權 、照顧及管束權及探視提交社會福利調查報告;
6)
社署臨床心理學家提交有關雙方及家庭子女的心理報告,包括(i)他們的心理
健康狀況;(ii)每名家庭子女與雙方各自的關係 ;(iii)
合適的照顧及/或育兒安排 ;(iv)
就管養權、照顧及管束權及探視的建議;(v)任何建議家庭子女或雙方接受
的兒童治療、家庭治療或其他治療;
7) 批准父親將其證人供詞存檔和送達;
8) 批准母親將回覆誓章存檔和送達;
9) 如非得到法庭許可,雙方均不得再存檔誓章;
10) 雙方須存檔及送達其表格J;
11) 家庭子女限制離境;
12) 此命令的蓋印副本送達入境處;
13) 指示訴訟雙方出席共享親職課程;
14) 此命令施加罰則通知,免除親身送達;
15) 雙方均須親自出席下次聆訊;
16) 此聆訊訟費保留。
6.
在2024年12月5日 ,何慧縈聆案官頒令批准母親不披露自己及家庭子女的
地址。
7.
社署就訴訟雙方有虐兒行為的指稱作出調查。在2024年12月16日,召開懷
疑虐待兒童多專業個案會議 ,與會人士認為父親對大仔和二仔存在虐兒
行為,就母親對兩名兒子存在一些攻擊性行為,經調查後,並沒有作出
母親有虐兒行的結論。
8.
在2024年12月30日,父親申請法庭許可,就父親探視困難針對母親發出交
付覊押傳票許可申請。
9.
經母親向法庭及對方同意及承諾,她會於2025年1月3日下午4時前簽署大仔
及二仔的親子聯繫/交接服務同意書,又經母親向法庭及對方同意及承諾
,在沒有承認她曾有作出任何阻撓的情況下,她不會阻撓社工與3名家
庭子女聯繫及根據2024年11月5日命令安排父親的臨時受監管日間探視。
在2025年1月3日,勞法官頒令父親根據2024年11月5日命令的臨時探視安
排維持不變。
10.
在2025年1月,父親與家庭子女開始在親和坊進行監管探視。在2025年2月
11日,法庭頒暫准離婚令。在2025年2月11日,勞法官就父親單方面申請
提出交付羈押許可發出便箋,指示父親應先以其他可行方案尋求解決探
視問題。在2025年2月,瑪麗醫院譚醫生診斷大仔患有創傷後壓力症並建
議暫停探視。由2025年2月15日起,大仔的受監管日間探視暫停至今。
11. 在2025年3月25日,父親以傳票作出申請,要求大仔停止接受Dr.
Chau的治療及訴訟雙方須委任一名心理學家給家庭子女提供治療。
12. 在2025年4月2日,勞法官頒令如下︰-
1. 許可母親繼續安排大仔接受Dr. Chau 的治療直至法庭另有命令為止;
…
6.
訴訟各方須各自提名一位提供治療給家庭子女的臨床心理學家供法庭考慮。
13. 在2025年5月19日,勞法官頒令︰
父親2025年3月25日的傳票(「心理學家傳票」)
1.
就心理學家傳票的第1、3及4段(有關私家單一共聘專家的費用)不作命令;
2.
委任潘博士作為三名家庭子女治療心理學家(「治療心理學家」),治療的目
標包括以下;
1) 優先為家庭大仔提供治療;
2) 改善家庭子女的心理健康、創傷復原、對父親的恐懼與情緒復原;
3) 改善父親與家庭子女的關係;
4) 改善父親與家庭子女的探視安排;
三名家庭子女接受心理治療的範疇及參與程度及形式等由治療心理學家決定
。
3. 母親及父親須分別支付治療心理學家的所有費用的10%及90%;
4. 心理學家傳票不作訟費命令;
家庭子女臨時照顧安排
5. 更改2024年11月5日的命令如下︰
1)
父親獲得二仔及女兒逢星期六早上每人不少於一小時的受監管日間探視。
探視在親和坊進行,實際時間及安排由親職協調員及/或親和坊作出安排
;
2)
父親就大仔的受監管日間探視由大仔的心理學家潘博士及親職協調員安排
(包括是否進行探視及探視(如有的話)的實際時間及安排);
其餘指示
6.
批准雙方存檔及送達誓章,回應政府臨床心理學家報告及社會福利調查報告;
7. 未經法庭許可,雙方不能存檔進一步誓章;
8. 雙方須存檔經同意的事實爭議事項陳述書;
9. 雙方須就委任親職協調員進行協商;
10. 母親及父親須分別支付親職協調員的所有費用的10%及90%;
11. 委任莫律師作為調解員;
12.
家庭子女的管養、照顧及管束及探視的事宜於2025年9月5日進行由調解員協助
的排解子女糾紛聆訊;
13. 母親及父親須分別支付調解員的所有費用的10%及90%;
14.
訴訟雙方須共同以書面向法庭報告調解的進展或結果。調解員須向法庭存檔及
送達予雙方一份簡短報告;
15. 母親須更新子女事宜文件冊;
16. 訴訟雙方須呈交法庭及送法對方書面陳詞及公開建議;
17. 訴訟雙方須存檔及送達表格H3;
18. 訴訟雙方及調解員須親身出席排解子女糾紛聆訊;
19. 倘若排解子女糾紛聆訊失敗,下列命令生效;
1) 訴訟雙方須存檔及送達各自就審訊預計所需時間證書;
2)
家庭子女的照顧、照顧及管束及探視的事宜之審訊定於2025年12月16日(
預留12月17、18、19、22及23日);
3) 審前覆核定於2025年10月17日進行;
4) 社會福利署須存更新社會福利調查報告;
5) 母親須更新子女事宜文件冊,而該文件冊將用作審訊文件冊;
6) 訴訟雙方須呈交法庭及送法對方書面陳詞及公開建議;
7) 訴訟雙方均須親身出席審前覆核及審訊;
8) 社會工作主任及臨床心理學家須出席審訊;
20. 是次審前覆核聆訊訟費歸於訟案中。
14.
在2025年6月2日,訴訟雙方同意委任蔡律師為親職協調員。在2025年9月5
日,訴訟雙方在勞法官席前進行第一次由調解員協助的子女糾紛排解聆
訊。在2025年9月5日,勞法官頒令訴訟雙方須於2025年10月6日或之前參
與不少於6小時由莫律師和調解員主持的調解。
15. 在2025年9月19日,父親被落案控4條虐兒罪,有關︰(1)
2021年5月4日涉及二仔的行為[1];(2)
2021年7月9日涉及大仔和二仔的行為[2];和(3)
2021年8月1日涉及二仔之行為[3]。
16.
在2025年10月17日,訴訟雙方在勞法官席前進行第二次由調解員協助的子
女糾紛排解聆訊。很可惜,訴訟雙方仍未能解決就家庭子女管養權的分
岐。在2025年10月17日,勞法官頒令定於2026年1月9日舉行有關子女事
宜的審訊(預留6天)。
17.
在2026年1月9日(審訊第一天),本席指出,在審訊文件內有1份一位精神
科蔡醫生日期為2023年10月5日之報告[4]指出母親患創傷後遺症和被虐
者候群症 ,但母親並無法庭許可提交這份專家報告。其後,父親代表李
大律師申請要求剔除報告,而母親代表余資深大律師則打算申請法庭許
可提交蔡醫生之報告和傳召蔡醫生到庭 ,本席指示雙方就以上一點爭議
儘快提交傳票(如有的話),支持誓章和陳詞,法庭會在審訊第二天處
理有關事宜,本席又指出若母親精神狀況是爭議事項,應考慮援引單一
共同專家證據。
18.
在審訊第一天,資深大律師代表母親作出申請,要求法庭考慮直接與家庭
子女會面,但經過詳細考慮後,在審訊第二天母親撤回了這個請求。
19.
在2026年1月12日(審訊第2天),父親提交了傳票,要求法庭頒令就母親
精神狀況採納單一精神科醫生專家證據。母親接受單一共同專家的做法
,但訴訟雙方就單一共同專家有不同人選,本席將傳票聆訊押後至2026
年1月16日(審訊第6天)。在2026年1月14日,母親以傳票申請法庭頒令
批准政府臨床心理學家及/或社會工作主任準備有關大仔的探視的進度或
其他報告時,與精神科醫生連醫生聯絡及/或考慮連醫生的意見。
20.
在2026年1月16日(審訊第6天),經閱讀訴訟雙方之補充誓章及聆聽訴訟
雙方代表大律師之陳詞後,本席作出以下三個命令︰
命令(1)︰
1. 母親獲得3名家庭子女的單獨照顧及管束權;
2. 就家庭子女的探視︰
1)
父親獲得二子及女兒逢星期六每人不少於一小時的受監管日間探視。探視
在親和坊進行,實際時間及安排由親職協調員及/或視和坊安排;
2)
暫停父親就大仔的受監管日間探視,相關探視由社會工作主任及親職協調
員安排(包括是否進行探視及探視(如有的話)的實際時間及安排)。
命令(2)︰
1.
許可母親提交日期為2026年1月14日的傳票,及存檔及送達母親的傳票及母親
2026年1月12日的第十二份誓章;
2. 許可父親存檔及送達父親2026年1月16日的第十一份誓章;
3. 送達的時間予以節略;
4. 就母親的傳票不作命令;
5.
委任麥律師作為親職協調員以促進父母共親溝通,及改善父親與家庭子女的關
係 ;親職協調員的費用由呈請人支付10%,答辯人支付90%,相關費用在附
屬濟助程序中予以考慮;
6.
雙方須由本命令起計14天內以共同信件形式向親職協調員發出聯合指示,並把
本案之社會福利調查報告、社會福利處臨床心理學家報告、法庭委任單一共
聘精神科醫生的報告(如適用)及本命令的副本提供予親職協調員;
7.
指示政府臨床心理學家於2026年5月15日或之前就大仔的心裡狀況提交進度報
告。在準備報告時,政府臨床心理學家可以諮詢潘博士的意見及就勞杰民法
官於2025年5月19日的命令列出的治療目標的進展作諮詢;指示社會工作主
任於2026年7月15日或之前就大仔的探視事宜提交更新報告;
8.
雙方可於收到社會工作主任的進度報告的14天內排期在勞法官席前就大仔的探
視事宜進行聆訊(預留30分鐘);
9. 呈請人的傳票及本命令的訟費不作命令。
命令(3)︰
1.
許可父親提交父親的傳票 ,及存檔及送達父親的傳票及父親2026年1月12日的
第十份誓章;
2. 送達的時間予以節略;
3.
就家庭子女的管養權的審訊押後至2026年5月26日上午10時,並預留2026年5
月27、28、29日及6月1、2日;
4.
指示社會工作主任石主任於2026年5月26日、2026年5月27日及2026年5月28日
出席審訊;
5.
委任黃醫生作為單一共聘專家(「單一共聘專家」)該單一共聘專家的費用先
由呈請人支付10%,答辯人支付90%,相關費用歸於子女事宜訟案中;
6.
法庭根據《高等法院規則》第38號命令第4A(2)(a)條委任單一共聘專家即黃醫生
進行對母親精神狀況的評估 ,包括但不限於母是否患有或曾經患有創傷
壓力症(PTSD)及/或受虐婦女綜合症(Battered Woman
Syndrome),如有的話相關狀況的成因及影響(例如是否影響母親與父親共
享親職之能力),並就上述精神評估撰寫報告;
7. 指示單一共聘專家於2026年5月26日及2026年5月27日出席審訊;
8.
雙方須由本命令起計14天內以共同信件形式向單一共聘專家發出聯合指示,並
把本案之社會福利調查報告、社會福利處臨床心理學家報告及本命令的副本
提供予單一共聘專家;
9.
有關的單一共聘專家的報告須於2026年3月27日或之前完成,並由父親存檔法
庭;
10.
單一共聘專家的報告必須遵行《實務指示5.2》(第20段),並須根據《高等法院
規則》第38號命令第37C條,作出符合行為守則的聲明(參考《高等法院規則
》附件b);
11.
雙方須把該單一共聘專家的報告送達政府臨床心理學家、社會工作主任石主任
及潘博士;
12. 父親的傳票及本命令的訟費歸於子女事宜的訟案中。
21.
在大約2026年2月6日,雙方律師來信法庭說,訴訟雙方無法就黃醫生的聯
合指示信件的內容達成共識 。本席暫委的職份在2026年1月16日完結 ,
至2026年3月23日,本席才有機會知道2026年2月6日之來信。在同日,本
席指示排期在2026年3月31日舉行聆訊,跟進2026年1月16日之命令(3)之
第(5)、(6)、(7)、(8)、(9)段事項。
22.
在2026年3月19日在東區裁判署父親承認控方案情 ,以自簽保守行為了結
針對他的虐兒控罪。
23.
在2026年3月31日 ,本席得悉就給黃醫生的聯合指示信件,訴訟雙方之主
要爭議在母親不同意黃醫生之工作範圍,母親堅持黃醫生之評估為母親
只是否患創傷後遺症和受虐婦女綜合症 ,但不會就母親精神狀況作評估
,父親則認為黃醫生應包括就母親精神狀況作評估。
24.
母親認為 ,若許可黃醫生除評估母親是否患創傷後遺症和受虐婦女綜合症
以外,還就母親精神狀況作評估,並不合理也對母親不公平。本席注意
到,在2026年1月16日之命令,本席已發出許可黃醫生進行對母親精神狀
況作出評估,母親也並沒有就該命令提出上訴,所以對為何母親依然有
以上的爭拗深感不解。母親代表余資深大律師說,當母親事務律師將草
擬命令存檔時,草擬命令是包括了委任黃醫生進行母親精神狀況評估等
字句的,但法庭書記將這些字句刪去了,所以母親便有上述的立場。針
對所謂法庭書記刪去相關字句一事,本席毫不知情。但無論如何,本席
認為母親一方在這一點的做法是本末倒置,母親代表律師既然清楚明白
,2026年1月16日命令的內容已包括就母親精神狀況作評估,應向法庭書
記澄清,說明有關刪去相關字句的做法並不恰當,而不是將錯就錯,更
藉此與父親一方作無理之糾纏。
25. 又在2026年3月31日之聆訊 ,代表母親資深余大律師陳詞︰-
1. 母親就黃醫生的獨立性及父親與黃醫生的溝通手法有嚴重關注,尤其︰
1)
父親在雙方未就聯合指示的內容達成協議或法庭作出裁決前,在未得到母
親的同意的情況下,擅自把所有審訊文件冊文件給予黃醫生;
2)
父親亦在未先得到母親的同意的情況下,告知黃醫生雙方就聯合指示的內
容的分歧;
3)
黃醫生更在法庭沒有給予指示或先徵詢或通知母親的情況下,擅自去信法
庭就聯合指示內容給予意見。其信件內容偏頗及站邊,在未完全理解法
庭要求的情況下已妄下判斷支持父親的立場,欠決中立性。此做法不符
合程序;
4) 直至現時,黃醫生沒有回覆母親2026年3月10日的電郵。
2.
母親認為上述所有行為有失公允 ,令母親對黃醫生的中立性完全失去信心。
3. 母親因此已經明確表示不同意接受黃醫生的精神評估。
4.
父親的立場似乎為母親必須接受黃醫生的精神評估 。母親認為父親的立場沒
有法律基礎。
5. 法庭沒有權力命令一名不同意接受醫療評估的成年人接受評估。
6.
母親強調其反對接受黃醫生的精神評估的理由合理 ,而且處理家庭子女的照
顧安排的案件不應被暫緩。
7.
母親曾考慮應否提出申請轉換單一共聘專家的人選 ,但不希望影響2026年5
月26、27、28、29日及6月1、2日的審訊日期或有進一步延誤 。母親及家庭
子女已經因為訴訟探受影響,尤其母親為家庭子女的照顧者,她希望案件可
以盡快有定奪。
8. 因為,母親的立場為︰
1)
母親一向主張雙方就家庭子女的重大問題根本不能有效溝通、合作或信任
,而母親因為父親的嚴重的虐待而患有創傷後壓力症及被虐待者候群症
是其中一個因素。法庭當初委任單一共聘專家是因為從審訊文件冊剔除
蔡醫生的報告。
2)
就母親切實因為父親殘酷的虐待(不論對母親或家庭子女)而患有創傷後
壓力症及被虐待者候群症一事,母親會邀請法庭考慮在審訊文件冊的文
件及政府臨床心理學家的證供。母親確認不會依賴已經被剔除的蔡永傑
醫生的報告。
3)
當然,母親的案情依然為雙方不能有效溝通、合作或信任,因此單獨管養
權在此案較為合適。母親會繼續依賴審訊文件冊中及審訊的事實證供。
4)
基於上述,就法庭2026年1月16日有關父親2026年1月12日的傳票的命令第
5至11段,母親建議解除黃醫生作為單一共聘專家的委任。
5)
換句話說,在2026年5月及6月的審訊,首先由社會工作主任石主任作供,
然後母親及父親分別作供。
26.
在2026年2月26日,黃醫生向訴訟雙方代表律師發電郵查詢是否有一些文件
可供黃醫生在會見當事人前閱讀。在同一天,父親代表律師將審訊文件
冊的連結和2026年1月16日之命令以電郵送黃醫生,電郵副本送母親代表
律師。在同一天母親代表律師回覆黃醫生,因訴訟雙方未有共識,暫不
能送文件給黃醫生,又在同一天稍後時間,母親代表律師電郵黃醫生表
明反對父親在未經雙方同意下將文件連結送黃醫生,電郵副本送父親代
表律師。在2026年3月2日,黃醫生電郵母親代表律師說她尚未開啟文件
冊的連結,電郵副本送父親代表律師。在2026年3月4日,父親代表律師
電郵黃醫生告之母親代表律師不反對將文件冊連結送黃醫生,又在電郵
提及訴訟雙方正在敲定聯合指示之內容,但訴訟雙方就黃醫生之工作之
範圍仍存在前述之分歧,電郵送父親代表律師。在2016年3月10日,黃醫
生去信法庭,寫[5]︰
Re: FCMC No. 9875/2024 - Request for Formal Instructions as
Single Joint Expert and Extension of Deadline for Submitting a
Psychiatric Report
I am writing in my capacity as the appointed single joint expert
psychiatrist in the above divorce proceedings, where the
Petitioner (the wife) requires a psychiatric assessment.
Nature of Psychiatric Assessment
A psychiatric assessment cannot be limited to a single presumed
diagnosis, such as Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), as
this would compromise clinical accuracy. Instead, it requires a
comprehensive evaluation of the Petitioner’s overall mental
health, including history, symptoms, and collateral information,
to determine the best-fit diagnosis or diagnoses according to
DSM-5 criteria. Focusing narrowly risks overlooking comorbid
conditions, alternative explanations, or broader psychopathology
relevant to the court’s considerations.
Status of Battered Wife Syndrome
“Battered Woman Syndrome” is not a formal, recognized mental
illness in the DSM-5. It is regarded as a psychological pattern
or a subcategory of PTSD arising from prolonged intimate partner
violence, rather than a standalone disorder. Any assessment
must therefore adhere to established DSM-5 categories without
presupposing this non-DSM entity.
27. 就母親對父親代表律師和黃醫生的批評,本席有以下的看法︰-
1) 所有電郵都是公開透明的;
2)
黃醫生查詢及索閱文件,以供在會見當事人前閱讀,是正常的做法,並無不妥
;
3)
父親代表律師在未徵詢母親意見前 ,便將文件冊連結交黃醫生,行為魯莽,
但並無惡意,從不久後母親表示不反對文件冊送黃醫生看來,行為也並沒有
造成任何不公之處;
4)
父親告知黃醫生訴訟雙方就聯合指示內容的分歧,相信其目的為向黃醫生交代
為何遲遲訴訟雙方未能發出聯合指示的原因,相信也並無惡意,也看不到有
造成任何不公之處;
5)
法庭委託之專家有責任在其專業範圍內協助法庭[6]。相信黃醫生2026年3月1
0日之來信 ,目的在協助法庭解決訴訟雙方的分歧,內容表達其專業意見也
言之成理,絕非母親一方所說內容偏頗,站邊或妄下判斷。
28.
經小心考慮以上各點後 ,本席不接納解除黃醫生作為單一共聘專家的要求
。在2026年3月31日,本席頒令︰
1.
母親須根據《高等法院規則》第20號命令第11條規則修訂2026年1月16日有關委
任黃醫生作為單一共聘專家(「單一共聘專家」)的命令,列明單一共聘專
家的報告範圍;
2.
延長雙方以共同信件形式向單一共聘專家發出聯合指示的時間至2026年4月2
日;
3. 延長單一共聘專家完成報告的日期至2026年5月14日 ;
4. 今天的聆訊的訟費歸於子女事宜的訟案中。
29.
在2026年4月1日,母親律師寫信給父親律師,表明母親不會接受黃醫生檢
查。
證據
30.
訴訟雙方都提交了多份誓章。母親親自作供,並沒有傳召證人。父親除親
自作供外,傳召了兩位家佣(RW1,
RW3)和家庭司機(RW2)替他作供。社署梁主任提交了日期為2024年12
月11日之緊急社會福利調查報告,和2025年5月9日之社會福利調查報告
,社署臨床心理學家黃姑娘提交了2025年5月6日之報告,社署石主任提
交了2025年11月18日之更新社會福利調查報告。法庭聽取了梁主任、黃
姑娘和石主任的證供。在2026年5月15日,黃姑娘提交了就大仔探視事宜
之進度報告,經雙方同意本席頒令,2026年5月15日的進度報告可於審訊
引用而無需黃姑娘再次出席審訊作供。
母親的案情
31.
母親是一名愛錫子女、稱職、有耐性及能為子女提供安全感及穩定成長環
境的母親。在婚姻期間,母親及家庭子女長期及持續受父親言語上、身
體上及精神上的暴力對待,母親提供了不少錄音或錄影片段,以支持她
的說法,母親自身亦因為父親的對待而患有創傷後壓力症及被虐待者候
群症 ,母親在其誓詞詳細描述父親在婚姻期間如何經常虐打、侮辱、咒
駡、長時間訓話及威嚇家庭子女 母親及家庭子女是長時間在如此高壓的
迫害及令人恐懼、擔心、焦慮的環境下戰戰兢兢的生活。
32.
在2020年,大仔開始因專注力不足往瑪麗醫院求診。在2022年,大仔展現
情緒低落及強逼症症狀,瑪麗醫院轉介大仔接受瑪麗醫院接受臨床心理
學服務。在2024年,二仔開始因專注力不足往瑪麗醫院求診。在2024年
8月,臨床心理學家Dr. Chau
指出大仔除了患有過度活躍症及專注力不足外 ,還因為父親的家庭暴力
而有創傷後壓力症。在2024年9月13日,為了保護孩子,母親與家庭子女
離開前婚姻居所,並提出離婚呈請。母親否認父親所說她有外遇的說法
。
33.
自母親與家庭子女離開前婚姻居所後 ,訴訟雙方除了曾短暫地以WhatsA
pp
通訊外,雙方至今完全沒有直接對話或溝通,並只有在出席法庭聆訊時
才會碰面。在相關WhatsApp通訊,父親以極度羞辱及打擊、造謠損害母
親名譽的WhatsApp短訊恐嚇及侮辱母親。母親批評父親在此案件開展後
所作出的行為。
34.
母親批評父親把此案件焦點轉移為「修復父親及家庭子女的關係」,及要
求母親克服她對父親的恐懼。母親認為,法庭的首要考慮應為幫助家庭
子女從父親長期虐待下的身心復原創傷,保障他們在穩定及安全的環境
中健康長大,並確保家庭子女的重大事宜能夠適時及合理地處理。
35.
母親認為,訴訟雙方不能夠有效地溝通,父親並不合適與母親共同管養家
庭子女,訴訟雙方也不能夠未來在家庭子女的重大問題上實際互相合作
、信任,從而共同作出理性的決定。共同管養根本不實際可行,法庭不
應該只為鼓勵雙方克服他們的分歧而勉強給予共同管養令,最終令家庭
子女的利益受損。
36. 在開案陳詞階段,母親的公開建議如下︰-
A.
經母親承諾,她會就家庭子女的重大事宜(包括教育、醫療及宗教事宜)通知
父親,並徵詢和考慮父親的意見;
B.
又經母親承諾 ,她會於7天內存檔家庭子女離開香港司法管轄區的承諾書 ,
承諾若法庭要求母親把家庭子女帶回香港司法管轄區,母親會遵從;
37. 法庭頒令如下:
1. 母親擁有家庭子女的單獨管養權;
2. 母親擁有家庭子女的單獨照顧及管束權;
3.
父親擁有二仔及女兒逢星期六早上每人不少於一小時的受監管日間的界定探視
。探視在親和坊進行,實際時間及安排由親職協調員及/或親和坊安排。若
父親的界定探視因為父親不能控制的原因取消(包括但不限於二仔及女兒旅
遊、需要準備考試等),母親須與親和坊安排補償探視;
4.
暫停父親與大仔的受監管日間的界定探視權,有待潘博士、連醫生及/或親職
協調員進一步評估及建議;
5.
除下述情況以外,2024年11月5日勞法官的命令第11段有關家庭子女離境限制
繼續生效︰
(a)
母親獲得一般許可不時帶同家庭子女(任何一位兩位或全部)離開香港
司法管轄區作短暫旅遊不多於72小時;
(b)
母親獲得一般許可在每年暑假帶同家庭子女(任何一位兩位或全部)離
開香港司法管轄區作旅遊總共不多於45天,而母親須於出發前7天知會
父親相關旅遊的目的地國家及日期;
(c)
除暑假外,母親獲得一般許可每年不多於4次在其他家庭子女的學校假
期帶同家庭子女(任何一位兩位或全部)離開香港司法管轄區作短暫
旅遊,每次總共不多於14天,而母親須於出發前7天知會父親相關旅遊
的目的地國家及日期;
(d)
批准家庭子女(任何一位兩位或全部)不時離開香港司法管轄參加學校
遊學團,而母親須於出發前7天知會父親相關遊學團的目的地國家及日
期;
6. 此命令的蓋印副本送達入境處;
7. 頒下為期12個月的監管令;
8. 社會福利調查主任須於第11個月向法庭呈交進度報告;
38. 在結案陳詞階段,母親更新其公開建議為︰-
A.
經母親同意及確認 ,她會就家庭子女的重大事宜(包括教育、醫療及宗教事
宜)透過親職協調員通知父貌,並徵詢和考慮父親的意見;
B.
又經母親同意及確認 ,她會透過親職協調員每個月與父親分享家庭子女在生
活、學習及心理方面的狀況;
C.
又經母親承諾 ,她會於7天內存檔家庭子女離開香港司法管轄區的承諾書 ,
承諾若法庭要求母親把家庭子女帶回香港司法管轄區,母親會遵從;
D.
又經母親承諾 ,她會在帶同家庭子女離境前透過親職協調員把旅程日子及目
的地國家通知父親;
法庭頒令如下︰
1. 母親擁有家庭子女的單獨管養權;
2.
除下述情況以外,2024年11月5日勞杰民法官的命令第11段有關家庭子女離境
限制繼續生效︰
(a)
母親獲得一般許可不時帶同家庭子女(任何一位、兩位或全部)離開香
港司法管轄區作短暫旅遊、遊學團、學術交流等;
3.
若父親的界定探視因為家庭子女旅遊而被取消,母親須與親和坊安排補償探視
;
4. 此命令的蓋印副本送達入境處。
父親的案情
39.
父親接受就本案而言,訴訟雙方的主要分歧在單獨管養和共同管養之爭議
,父親要求共同管養家庭子女。父親說,母親是成功商人,但生活糜爛
(’erosive
lifestyle’),又有酗酒的問題,因為有男朋友,所以密謀離婚,但父
親並不爭議母親有照顧家庭子女的能力,也同意法庭頒令將家庭子女的
照顧和管束頒予母親。
40.
父親說,母親誇大所謂父親家庭暴力行為,將個別事件放大,目的在描黑
父親,以此作為呈請離婚和申請法庭按《家庭及同居關係暴力條例》頒發
禁制令,又以她是被虐待者為托詞,拒絕與父親共享親職,一年來更不
斷向警方作投訴,最終令警方起訴父親虐兒。父親又說,婚姻期間,母
親也常責罵和體罰家庭子女。
41.
父親說,外祖母和母親有一個扭曲的家庭觀念,就是孩子成長並不需要一
個父親形象,為母親要求單獨管養,不惜千方百計不斷進行訴訟,目的
在令父親從庭子女的生命消失掉。父親說,母親教唆子女拒絕父親、
疏離父親與家庭子女的關係,外祖母亦有在子女前講父親之壞話。父親
又說,有見他已同意進行受監管探視,和聘用親職協調員協助訴訟雙方
就子女事宜講通和合作,母親拒絕共同管養並不合理。
42.
父親說,家庭子女出生後,他一直參予照顧他們,直至訴訟雙方分居,父
親在誓章交代了不少他和家庭子女的親子活動。父親認為,母親設計陷
害父親,令父親中斷與家庭子女之聯系,直至2025年1月經法庭介入後,
父親才可以在親和坊進行受監管探視。
43.
父親指,自分居後,家庭子女莫名其妙地對他愈來愈仇視,舉例來說︰
i)
大仔︰在2025年1月25日第二次探視 ,大仔威脅父親說若父親不離開,他會自
殺;在2025年2月8日第三次探視,大仔忽然跑樓梯離開親和坊。此後,大仔
再沒有參與父親的探視;
ii)
二仔︰在2025年1月16日第一次探視,二仔和父親是有傾有講,二仔更坐在父
親膝蓋上;在2025年2月8日的探視期間,大仔忽然離開親和坊,二仔跟隨,
其後二仔也拒絕返回親和坊繼續父親的探視 ;在2025年3月23日的探視,二
仔對父親的態度明顯地變差,他對父親說父親有婚外情(父親否認),又說
他害怕父親會打他。
iii)
女兒︰在初期,父親對女兒的探視尚算順利,可是到了2025年3月22日第7次探
視,女兒對父親說她害怕父親會打她。
iv)
現時︰父親仍依時到親和坊進行探視,自2025年3月,大仔已再沒有出席親和
坊探視,二仔和女兒會出席,但期間他們拒絕和父親交談或進行任何直接接
觸。
44.
父親知道大仔和二仔都明確地向調查主任表示希望由母親單獨管養,女兒
因為年幼關係,對共同管養、單獨管養並無明確的看法,雖然三名家子
女對父親都有頗為負面的印象,但父親認為在很大程度上,這是因為他
們受到母親的不良影響所致,他也認為大仔和二仔其實並不瞭解單獨管
養、共同管養這些概念。
45.
父親說,社署臨床心理學家黃姑娘在報告指出,母親自身的恐懼令她難以
明白維持父親與家子女關係的重要性,又因她情緒問題,母親能夠提供
給家庭子女的情緒支援不多,令家庭子女甚為無助。黃姑娘建議母親面
對她對父親的不滿和恐懼,走出陰霾,去創造和父親在子女事宜上互助
合作,共享親職的條件。父親說,這正是父親的訴求。梁主任和石主任
都建議法庭將共同管養頒予訴訟雙方,父親希望法庭採納調查社工的建
議。父親說,父親、母親都是受高等教育知識份子,父親不但堅定的疼
愛家庭子女,也願意改善他教養子女的手法,再加上親職協調員協助,
父親相信父親、母親是有條件共享親職,共同管養家庭子女。
46. 父親傳召了家傭(RW1,
RW3)和家庭司機(RW2)作供,就他的證人所說,父親疼愛家庭子女,
也不會輕易體罰他們或亂發脾氣。
父親的公開建議
47. 父親採納石主任的建議為其公開建議︰-
i) 將家庭子女之共同管養權頒予訴訟雙方;
ii) 委任親職協調員;
iii) 將家庭子女照顧和管束頒與母親;
iv)
父親每星期六對二仔和女兒不少於1小時之受監管探視,在共享視職支援中心
進行;
v) 父親對大仔之探視暫停,有待治療專家和親職協調員之評估和建議;
vi) 父親對所有家庭子女之探視由治療專家和親職協調員不時作出檢討。
48.
作供時,父親更新其公開建議,表示他依然願意按在2025年10月第二次子
女糾紛排解聆訊時草擬的同意傳票的內容[7]解決訴訟雙方就管養權的糾
紛。扼要來說,有關是一個有條件的共同管養安排,在其中就教育,醫
療和家庭子女短暫離境等事宜母親都有決定權。在結案陳詞階段,父親
提交了更新公開建議如下︰
A. 經訴訟雙方確認,為免生疑問,以下的承諾及命令繼續生效︰
(1)
2024年11月5日勞杰民法官的命令有關(i)雙方不會在對方與家庭子女在
探視時進行任何錄影或錄音;及(ii)父親及受其委派的人士、代理人或
其他人以任可形式毆打,滋擾及騷擾母親及家庭子女(包括但不限於對
母親及家庭子女作出責罵及/或粗言穢言及/或侮辱性說話)的承諾;
(2)
2025年5月19日勞杰民法官的命令(「19.05.2025命令」)有關父親及受
其委派的人士、代理人或其他人不會接觸及聯絡母親或外祖母聘用的家
傭、司機及員工的承諾;
(3)
2025年5月19日命令有關委任潘博士作為家庭子女的治療心理學家的命令
;
B.
又經訴訟雙方確認,雙方確認以家庭子女的需求、福、最大利益 ,和家庭
子女的健康快樂及能夠在安寧的環境下並可以得到母親的照顧下成長為前提
;
共同管養權有關教育的條件
C.
又經訴訟雙方確認,若大仔及二仔被下列學校取錄,雙方同意讓大仔及二仔轉
校 。若有超過一間學校取錄大仔及二仔,雙方同意以以下優先次序安排大
仔及二仔入讀下述學校︰
(1) XX國際學校
(2) YY國際學校
(3) ZZ書院
(4) AA學校
(5) BB國際學校
(6) CC國際學校
(7) DD學校-
D. 又經訴訟雙方確認,所有轉校的文件由母親簽署;
E.
又經母親承諾,若她收到上述第C段的學校的錄取通知(如有的話),她須於
收到相關通知的3天內將相關通知提供給父親;
F. 又經訴訟雙方確認,就家庭子女的公開試︰
(1) 雙方首選讓家庭子女報考國際文憑大學預科項目(IBDP)(「IB」)
;
(2)
若家庭子女的學校不容許家庭子女報考IB,雙方可透過親職協調員作討
論,最終若未能達成協議,則由母親決定為家庭子女升學所需而報考的
公開試;
G.
又經訴訟雙方確認,雙方繼續用原有的用戶及密碼登入家庭子女的學校的網上
系統。如父親就任何通告有意見,他可透過親職協調員知會母親,母親需要
考慮,但所有學校通告最終由母親簽署;
H.
又經訴訟雙方確認,若任何一方希望直接聯絡學校,該方可以自行與學校作出
安排;
I.
又經訴訟雙方確認,就家庭子女的選科事宜,雙方以尊重孩子的選擇及考慮到
大仔及二仔過度活躍症的情況為前提。雙方可透過親職協調員作討論及就此
徵詢學校的意見,最終若雙方未能達成協議,則由母親決定;
J.
又經訴訟雙方確認,就家庭子女的補習班及課外活動/興趣班,雙方以尊重孩
子的選擇、興趣、愛好及學業需要及考慮到大仔及二仔過度活躍症的情況為
前提。雙方可就此事宜透過親職協調員作出討論,最終若雙方未能達成協議
,則由母親決定;
K.
又經訴訟雙方確認 ,有關所有由學校或教育署支援家庭子女的學業的安排(
包括會見專業人士),雙方可透過親職協調員作討論及就此徵詢學校的意見
,最終若雙方未能達成協議,則由母親決定;
L.
又經訴訟雙方確認 ,就家庭子女出席及參與任何由學校安排的境內及境外遊
學或學術交流或比賽(如有的話),雙方先透過親職協調員作討論及就此徵
詢學校的意見,最終若雙方未能成協議,則由母親決定;
M.
又經訴訟雙方確認 ,雙方有共識家庭子女將來會到外國升學(如有合適的學
校錄取),雙方屆時再就實際安排透過親職協調員作討論;
共同管養權有關醫療的條件
N.
又經訴訟雙方確認,如家庭子女有一般醫療需要(如傷風感冒等),醫生的人
選由母親決定及知會父親;
O.
又經訴訟雙方確認 ,如家庭子女有緊急醫療需要,母親須盡早通知父親,而
母親徵詢醫生的意見及父親的意見(如有的話),母親有最終決定權並簽署
所有文件。母親須通知父親相關的醫生的人選 。若任何一方希望直接聯絡
相關醫生,該方可以自行作出安排;
P.
又經訴訟雙方確認 ,如家庭子女需要看專科或牙醫,雙方可透過親職協調員
就醫生人選作討論,最終若雙方未能達成協議,則由母親決定。若母親為家
庭子女安排會見專科或牙醫,母親需要通知父親相關專科或牙醫的人選。若
任何一方希望直接聯絡相關專科或牙醫,該方可以自行作出安排;
Q.
又經訴訟雙方確認 ,按照醫生的建議讓大仔接受口腔復健手術。若任何一方
希望直接聯絡相關專科或牙醫,該方可以自行作出安排;
R. 又經訴訟雙方確認︰
(1)
讓大仔繼續接受連醫生的治療,並讓二仔接受連醫生的過度活躍症的治
療(如有需要);
(2)
若任何一方希望直接聯絡連醫生或瑪麗醫院,該方可以自行作出安排;
家庭子女短暫離境的安排
S.
又經母親承諾 ,他們會於本命令7天內存檔家庭子女離開香港司法管轄區的承
諾書,承諾若法庭要求把家庭子女帶回香港司法管轄區,他們會遵從;
其他管養權事宜
T.
又經訴訟雙方確認 ,若雙方就其他上述沒有涵蓋有關家庭子女的重大事宜不
能達協議,雙方將可透過親職協調員作討論;
經雙方同意,法庭現頒令如下︰
1. 受制於上述第A至R及T段,訴訟雙方擁有家庭子女的共同管養權;
2. 受制於上述第S段及除下述況以外 ,2024年11月5日
勞杰民法官的命令有關家庭子女離境限制繼續生效︰
(1)
母親每年不多於5次帶同每名家庭子女(任何一位兩位或全部)離開香港
司法管轄區作短暫旅遊不多於72小時;
(2)
母親每年暑假不多於1次帶同每名家庭子女(任何一位兩位或全部)離開
香港司法管轄區作旅遊不多於45天,而母親及父親須於出發前7天透過親
職協調員知會對方相關旅遊的目的地國家旅程及日期;
(3)
母親每年不多於2次在家庭子女的學校假期帶同每名家庭子女(任何一位
兩位或全部)離開香港司法管轄區作短暫旅遊,總共不多於14天,而訴
訟雙方須於出發前7天透過親職協調員知會對方相關旅遊的目的地國家旅
程及日期;
3. 此命令的蓋印副本送達入境處;
4. 頒下為期12個月的監管令;
5.
社會福利調查主任須於第11個月向法庭呈交進度報告,探討有關父親的學期及
假期期間的探視是否有增加的空間;
6. 此命令施加罰則通知,免除親身送達;
7. 所有關於子女事宜的訟費不作命令,包括所有已保留訟費。
主要爭論點
49. 訴訟雙方預備了一份「事實爭議事項陳述書」,包括以下事項︰-
1.
在婚姻期間和分居後,父親是否有對母親作出身體上及精神上的暴力或滋擾行
為?
2.
在婚姻期間和分居後,父親是否有對三名家庭子女作出身體上及精神上的暴力
或滋擾行為?
3. 母親及父親是否能夠就家庭子女事宜溝通或有效溝通?
4. 雙方各自照顧家庭子女的能力
5. 法庭應給予家庭子女的想法及意願多少比重?
6. 經考慮上述各點後,三名家庭子女的管養權及照顧及管束權應如何安排?
7. 經考慮上述各點後,考慮上述,三名家庭子女的探視應如何安排?
8. 三名家庭子女的離境限制應否有任何修訂?
50.
在2026年1月16日,本席頒令將3名家庭子女之照顧和管束頒予母親,又就
父親探視作出了安排,目前留下的爭議在法庭應頒發一個單獨管養給母
親,還是一個訴訟雙方共同管養的命令,及三名家庭子女的離境限制應
否有任何修訂。
法律原則
51. 就獨有管養權或共同管養令的含意,上訴法庭法官夏正民在PD v
KWW[8]一案中指出︰「享有獨有管養權的父或母其中一方有權就子女的
教育、宗教培養及課外學習等事宜作出最終決定,但必須先諮詢及充分
合理考慮另一方提出的意見。雖然沒有管養權的一方並無否決權,但他
/她可向法庭申請就任何分歧作出裁決。」林文瀚法官在同一案指出︰「
獨有管養權和共同管養權之間只有一線之隔」。這裁決縮窄了獨有管養
令和共同管養令之間的差距削減了勝者全得的做法,希望這意味著受影
響之處會因而減少,及需要爭取管養權的理由減少。
52.
換言之,有管養權的父或母一方可到家庭子女的一些主要問題作出決定,
例如在醫療、教育及宗教信仰問題上作出決定,但是擁有管養權一方的
父或母並沒有絕對及獨立於另一方的權力,並沒有管養權的一方父或母
是有權被諮詢,若雙方未能解決,爭拗須由法庭處理。
53.
就法庭如何考慮是否給予共同管養,夏正民法官在同一判案書的第52至5
7段有以下的論述︰-
52. Today, although there has been no change in our law similar
to many other common law jurisdictions, orders of joint custody
are in no way exceptional. This is because it is accepted that,
in principle, such orders are in the interests of children.
53. In all but the most exceptional circumstances, the effect of
divorce on the children of the marriage, especially children of
tender years, is deeply felt. In all but the most exceptional
circumstances, such children desire that they should continue to
be protected and guided by both parents. The case before us is
an example.
54. In the result, in the best interests of the child, the fact
that, as a result of the breakdown of the marriage, relations
between the parents are strained is not of itself a reason to
refuse to make a joint order of custody. Nor is the fact that
the parent to be given care and control does not agree. Such
orders look to the future. They will govern a limited area of
exchange between the parents, albeit one of the greatest
importance.
55. Accordingly, the issue for the judge is whether, with the
court proceedings concluded, it is reasonably anticipated that
the parents will be able to agree on the questions of importance
that will determine the upbringing of their child, both
recognizing that, as difficult as it may be for them, this
process of co-operation is in the best interest of the child.
56. In determining this issue, the judge is entitled to proceed
on the presumption that competent, loving parents possessed of
sufficient objectivity to be able to make rational decisions in
the interests of the child will be able to co-operate with each
concerning matters of importance in the upbringing of the child.
57. At all times, of course, the welfare of the child remains
the first and paramount consideration. As this Court has
recognised (see, for example, Y v P [2009] HKFLR 308), there may
be occasions when the ability of the parents to reach any
rational accord in respect of important matters concerning the
upbringing of their child is so deeply undermined that to compel
attempts at co-operation will not protect the interests of the
child but only leave the child more vulnerable.
54.
故此,法庭在考慮是否給予共同管養權或獨自管養權時首要的考慮是家庭
的子女的最佳利益,若父母之間並不存在一個合理預期他們可以互相合
作而共親的話,共同管養很可能並不符合家庭子女之最佳利益。若共同
管養明顯不可行,法庭不會只為鼓勵父母克服他們的分歧而仍然給予共
同管養令,勉強父母合作,很可能只會影響子女的利益。
55.
在處理證供以前,本席先簡介就有關家庭子女管養權事宜適用的法律原則
。香港法例第192章《婚姻法律程序與財產條例》第19條規定︰-
19. 對受婚姻訟案影響的子女提供管養及教育的命令
1)
法庭可在下列時間,作出其認為是適宜的命令,以便為任何18歲以下的
家庭子女提供管養及教育 ——
a)
在任何離婚、婚姻無效或裁判分居的法律程序中,於作出最後判令之
當時、之前或之後;
b) ……
56.
至於法庭在考慮這些申請時所依賴的一般準則,則是依據香港法例第13章
《未成年人監護條例》第3條的規定︰-
3. 一般原則
1)
有關未成年人的管養或敎養問題,以及有關屬於未成年人或代未成年人
託管的財產的管理問題,或從該等財產所獲收益的運用問題 ——
a)
在任何法院進行的法律程序中(不論該法院是否第2條所界定的法院)
——
i)
法院須以未成年人的最佳利益為首要考慮事項,而考慮此事項時
須對下列各項因素給予適當考慮 ——
A)
未成年人的意願(如在顧及未成年人的年齡及理解力,以及有
關個案的情況後,考慮其意願乃屬切實可行者);及
B)
任何關鍵性資料,包括聆訊進行時社會福利署署長備呈法院的
任何報告;及
ii)
在上述管養、敎養、財產管理或收益運用等問題上,法院無須從
任何其他觀點來考慮父親的申索,是否較母親的申索為優先,
或母親的申索是否較父親的為優先;
b) ……
母親所享有的權利及權能,與法律賦予父親的相同,而父親及母親
雙方的權利及權能同等,並可由其中一方單獨行使;
57.
除以上的法律以外,香港家事法庭也慣常會考慮一些特別的因素。這些因
素在英國及澳洲的家事法例中,是以一個法定清單的形式出現,在香港
則還未有所謂法定清單。這些因素包括︰
(a)
如能查明有關兒童的意見,須因應他的年齡和理解能力考慮他的意見;
(b) 他的身體、感情和教育方面的需要;
(c) 他環境上的改變可能對他造成的影響;
(d)
他的年齡、成熟程度、性別、社會和文化背景,以及其他法庭認為有關
的特點;
(e) 他曾經遭受或有機會遭受的傷害;
(f)
他的父親、母親和法庭認為與問題有關的人,能在什麽程度上滿足他的
需要;
(g) 該兒童與父親、母親和其他人的關係的性質;
(h) 該兒童的父親和母親對兒童和對父母身份的責任所表現的態度;
(i) 法庭根據法例在有關法律程序中可行使的權力範圍;
(j)
該兒童與父母任何一方保持聯系的際困難和費用,及以此等困難和費用
對兒童與父母雙方維繫關係和定期保持直接聯繫的權利會否有重大影響
;
(k) 法庭認為有關的其他事實及情況;
(1) 涉及兒童或其他家庭的任何成員的家庭暴力。
58.
以上的清單雖然並非香港法律,但法庭認同這些相關的考慮因素,將會有
助法庭去裁定怎樣的安排才能保障家庭子女最佳利益 [9]。由於每件案
件的事實都有所不同,因此並不是清單中的所有項目都一定適用於每一
件案件。就本案而言,本席不會就以上每點都作出討論,而只會在相關
及可行的情況下,就以上清單中所列的因素來考慮本案的事實,從而考
慮何種安排最能符合兒子的最佳利益。
討論
59.
如前所指出 ,法庭須考慮社署臨床心理學家黃姑娘及調查社工梁主任和石
主任的報告。
社會福利署臨床心理學家的報告
60.
社會福利署臨床心理學家黃姑娘在審訊第一天作供 ,她並沒有就管養權作
出明確的建議。在2025年5月6日之報告,黃姑娘有以下的建議︰-
80. Taking the above observations into consideration, I have
the following recommendations:
81. The mother’s fear and grievances toward the father pose
significant obstacles to her ability to support her children
and to foster effective co-parenting and joint custody. It
is recommended that she address her fears, possibly through
professional counseling, to enhance her mental capacity for
managing her relationship with the father and to support her
children. This, in turn, can facilitate the continuity of
the father-children relationship and help her understand the
children’s feelings and needs during this transition.
82. The mother needs to recognize the importance of
maintaining the father-children relationship, rather than
merely encouraging visitation for its own sake. She should
weigh the psychological and developmental needs of the
children against her concerns about potential harm when they
remain in contact with their father. It is her choice to
consider giving the father an opportunity to repair his
relationship with the children. If her fears remain
unmanaged, co-parenting and joint custody will likely be
challenging.
83. It is advised that the mother and maternal grandmother to
avoid exposing the children to any information related to the
divorce proceedings.
84. Although the father is aware of the need to change his
parenting approach, he should strive to understand the
children’s feelings and needs from their perspective, rather
than adopting his own adult viewpoint. He should avoid
dismissing the children’s feelings with logical reasoning and
instead show acceptance. It is strongly advised that he
cease any use of corporal punishment, sharing of news/facts
or use of threats that may induce fear, as these methods can
be threatening to the children and further damage their
relationship. The father is encouraged to learn more adaptive
and positive parenting skills and to accept the children’s
emotions.
85. Furthermore, it is crucial to enhance the sense of safety
for both the mother and the children to facilitate the
resumption of communication. The father should refrain from
any intrusive means of overseeing the children’s lives, as
this will only perpetuate their fear.
86. For access arrangements, defined and supervised access for
the 2nd son and the daughter is recommended. Given the eldest
son current extreme reluctance to engage with the father,
regular in-person access may be challenging. The father could
explore alternative methods of contact with the eldest son,
such as sending messages, emails, or letters, allowing the
eldest son the choice to read and respond. He should express
his acceptance and care in these communications, reassuring
the eldest son of his love and support, and encouraging him
to reach out if needed.
87. Regarding psychotherapy options for the children, due to
the complexity of this case, it is recommended that
professionals experienced in handling high-conflict divorce
cases be involved to gain a comprehensive understanding of
the family dynamics. If possible, it would be beneficial for
these professionals to have access to this report to aid
their understanding of the situation.
社會福利調查主任的報告
61.
在勞法官作出2024年11月5日的命令後,梁主任開始本案的調查工作,在2
024年12月11日提交了一份緊急社會福利調查報告。在2025年5月9日的社
會福利調查報告,梁主任報告中第12段至第28段詳細地記錄了由2025年
1月至2025年3月期間父親在親和坊探視家庭子女的情況。
62. 經過調查後,在2025年5月9日之報告,梁主任有以下之總結和建議︰
Remark and Recommendation
59. This was a high-conflict case involving the Mother’s
provision of information of her being a victim of intimate
partner violence. During the social investigation, the
eldest son, had all along refused seeing his father as
exacerbated by his hyper-aroused emotions and clinginess to
his mother. Observing from the mother-child interaction,
there were cues, such as the eldest son rushing to pat his
mother’s back when the latter coughed and the mother-son
going hand-in-hand at SCSC on 17 January 2025; the eldest son
holding his mother tight and preventing the latter to leave
him on 25 January 2025; and the eldest son showing to Ms LI
of video clips of familial disputes in his mother’s phone and
asking the reasons for his mother not having the custody on 8
February 2025, implying the caring but also co-dependent
relationship between the Mother and the eldest son in
protecting each other. Commensurating with Ms WONG/DCP’s
observation, the Mother’s fear in the Father could have been
generalized to the Children. Hence, it was reasonable to
believe that he Mother’s fear in the Father could have
present the eldest from seeing and connecting with the
Father, besides the eldest son’s personal fear as assessed by
multi-disciplines for his PTSD.
60. Besides the eldest son, the 2nd son and the daughter had
shown their refusal and reluctance in seeing the Father
although there had once been episodes of “Connection” with
their father. To elaborate, “Connection” referred to the
Father – the 2nd son access session on 16 January 2025 during
which there was natural and dual-way interaction without
observing any fear or anxiety throughout the entire session.
“Connection” also referred to the daughter who had shown her
tendency to glancing her father in her first access session
on 10 January 2025 and the father-daughter time during the
“Easter eggs hunting games” session on 15 March 2025.
Despite the once “Connection” between the Father with the 2nd
son and daughter respectively, it discontinued in subsequent
assess sessions with these two children recurrently recalling
the Father’s previous physical punishment vaguely and the
“dumping’ out of XX holiday house. It was known that common
reactions towards parents’ divorce in children of four to
eight years old included feeling caught in the middle of the
parents and blaming one of the parents for separation and
letting out anger towards him/her. Those in children of nine
to twelve years old included making moral judgement on
parents’ behavior and judging that one was “good” and the
other was “bad”. Their self-esteems were lowered because of
the unfavorable image of the parents. The observations on
the 2nd son and the daughter, especially their change of
behaviours and attitude after the “connection”, commensurated
with these reactions. Worse still, the 2nd son and the
daughter in the access session on 12 April 2025 when seeing
tile photo album, had shown signs of ‘denying’ or ‘rejecting’
their past living with their father. The parental divorce
did not only impose emotional distress on the 2nd son and the
daughter, but also challenging their identity development
which was believed to be painful and unhealthy, if not
damaging, to their growth and development.
61. In addition to each of the Children’s individual
experience and response, their perception, behavioural and
emotional responses with parental divorce were intertwined by
the siblings’ interaction among themselves. For instance,
the eldest son appeared to have taken the lead that the 2nd
son and the daughter followed with not seeing the Father
during the access session on 25 January 2025. Another scene
happened on 8 February 2025 when the 2nd son blamed and
slapped the daughter for staying long at the SCSC. More so,
the 2nd son shared to Ms LI that out of all negative comments
against the father, some were ungroundedly fed in upon
siblings’ discussions.
62. This case was also complicated by the ongoing disputes
with the area of child maltreatment. While elements of child
maltreatment shed information on parent-child relationship
and the parents’ parenting styles, it was neither the sole
nor the most determining factor in facilitating the present
social investigation. On the other hand, it was never
conducive to the Children’s psycho-emotional wellbeing and
development should the negative side of the father-
child(ren)relationship be recurrently brought-up which was
considered as hindering them to move forward and develop
positively. While understanding the Mother’s fear held for
the Father, the Mother should avoid re-capturing with the
Children about the Father’s history of child maltreatment.
At the same time, the Mother, as the residing parent, should
be obliged to genuinely support and encourage the access
involving re-building of father-children relationship apart
from ensuring the Children’s physical presence at the SCSC.
Simultaneously, it was very undesirable, if not harmful,
should the mother-children relationship be called for re-
examination of incidents of child maltreatment because such
meant to the Children that their mother, also their perceived
source of protection and secure attachment figure, be
attacked that the Children’s vulnerability would be triggered
to further distant themselves from the Father.
63. While disputes over the area of child maltreatment should
be set aside as for the Children’s sake, the respective
parents’ parenting style should be addressed. Despite there
were cues that the Mother’s fear could have impacted the
Children’s perception. Views, behavioural and emotional
response to the Father, it was observed that the Children had
good relationship and close bonding with their Mother who had
exhibited her positivity and child-centered skills in
relating and communicating with each of the child as well as
moderating the Children’s siblings’ dynamics. Reciprocally,
the Children had shown their willingness to reach out for
their mother. On the contrary, the gathered social
information collectively revealed that the Father’s parenting
was less effective in such a way of adopting lengthy verbal
reasoning in a lack of addressing the Children’s emotional
needs. For instance, the Father reasoned in details when the
2nd son appealed to Father not to lecture him during the
first access on 16 January 2025. For another instance, the
Father explained in details to daughter when the latter
questioned why she was dumped out from the XX holiday home
previously during the access on 15 March 2025. Besides, the
Father’s asking if the 2nd son did not want him during the
access session on 12 April 2025 revealed his lack of
awareness and sensitivity to the Children’s emotional
vulnerability. The Father required sharpened sensitivity and
skills to shift from his own perspective to taking the
Children’s shoes in re-building the father-children
relationship.
64. After all, it was identifiable that the Children were
experiencing complicated negative emotions and responses amid
parental divorce in association with the Mother’s perceived
threats in the Father, the Father’s ineffective parenting in
the building a positive father-children relationship, their
individual experiences and coping, as well as the siblings’
dynamics. To safeguard the Children’s psycho-emotional
growth and strengthen their positive coping with the changing
family relationship, instead of drilling in the past for the
parental battle, it was deemed beneficial that all the family
children and the parents be received counseling and/or
psychological treatment in the context of facilitating
ongoing co-parenthood and building of healthy and positive
parent-child relationship with both parents.
65. Given the lack of trust and poor communication between the
parents, they were not communicating or exchanging essential
information effectively that the currently available multi-
disciplinary services appeared to be fragmented and
untransparent. Yet, the parents had shown their receptiveness
to receiving external support, such as the SCSC, to
facilitate their communication, especially the access
arrangement. Viewing the complexity of this case, a single
joint expert (“SJE”) and/or his/her team with ֹexpertise in
custody and co-parenting to provide counseling and/or
psychological treatment would be deemed more effective.
Parenting coordination (“PC”) service could also be
essentially helpful for supporting joint custody. The
parents’ consent for the SJE and/or the team and PC service,
if so ordered, and other multi-disciplinary services,
including public and private medical and health care sectors,
the schools and the SCSC, to exchange information was
necessary.
66. Should there be agreement between the parents on a SJE and
a PC, if so ordered, it was considerably supportive that the
Mother be granted the care of control of all the Children
given the secure mother-children bonding and the present
stable living. Meanwhile, the access arrangement for the 2nd
son and the daughter had already been regularised on every
Saturday at the SCSC that such could be maintained, but also
subjected to the review and recommendation by the SJE and PC
for future possibility of stepping-up of access. The access
plan for the eldest son could be subject to the
recommendation of the SJE and the PC with SCSC being kept
fully informed of the recommendations.
67. Not the least, it was remarkable that the Children had
been well maintained on stable schooling despite the family
conflicts. Apart from acknowledging both parents in ways
that the Mother had strived her efforts in supporting the
Children for their schooling and the Father had never
enforced seeing the Children at their schools, as well as
their joint support for the one-on-one teacher for the eldest
son which such efforts was largely supportive, it was
important for the parents to understand and provide ongoing
reassurance to the Children that the school was a
compartmentalised and safe place to safeguard the Children’s
learning and social living out of the context of familial
dispute.
68. Concluding from the above, I would like to recommend the
following:
• The parents be granted interim joint custody of all the
children on their agreement with a SJE and PC service be
arranged.
• The Mother be granted interim care and control of all the
children on her agreement with a SJE and PC service be
arranged.
• The Father be granted interim defined access for the 2nd
son and the daughter on every Saturday morning, with no
less than one hour for each child under supervision, at the
Specialised Co-parenting Services Centre serving the
residential boundary of the Children.
• The access arrangement of the eldest son be recommended by
the SJE and PC.
• The access of all the Children be reviewed by the SJE and
PC.
63.
梁主任說 ,提交報告時她的建議為中期共同管養,但現時她建議法庭將共
同管養頒與訴訟雙方。
64.
在大約2025年5月,石主任接手本案的調查工作 。在2025年11月18日的更
新社會福利調查報告。就父親探視家庭子女之近況,石主任報告︰-
Access Condition Since Previous Court Hearing
18. As stipulated in the Order made on 19 May 2025, the eldest
son’s access was subjected to arrangement of Dr. Poon/Treating
Clinical Psychologist (Dr. POON/TGP) and the Parenting Co-
ordinator (PC). During this adjournment period, the eldest son
did attend regular treatment sessions with Dr. POON/TCP.
·Throughout the treatment sessions with Dr. POON/TCP.
Throughout the treatment sessions, he expressed that he was not
ready to meet his father. Thus, no access between the eldest
son and his father was conducted so far.
19. For the 2nd son, and the daughter, they kept attending day
supervised access not less than one hour for each of them at
every Saturday.
20. According to the social worker of SCSC, the 2nd son and
daughter have progressively established routines during the
access. However, the 2nd son still maintained distance from
direct contact with his father. He only engaged with social
worker of SCSC in relation to the paternal materials. He
demonstrated capacity, for reflection but expressed significant
resistance to have face-to-face interaction with his father,
describing emotional distress regarding the father-son
relationship. For the daughter, she has developed a consistent
pattern of engaging with gifts and cards in the reception area;
showing particular interest in creative activities and games.
While she avoided physical proximity to her father; her growing
comfort within the SCSC environment was noted. Despite of
having limited direct interaction with the father, the children
have shown increasing engagement with them materials such as
gifts, cards or games as prepared by the father. They were
demonstrating a cautious process of re-familiarisation.
65. 石主任無法就父親與家庭子女之親子互動進行觀察︰-
Observation of Father-Children Interaction
31 As there was no direct contact between the children and
the father, observation on the father-children interaction could
not be conducted.
66. 按石主任的觀察,母親和家庭子女之間之關係是緊密的。
30. Throughout the visit, all three children demonstrated
politeness when interacting with their mother and appeared
cheerful and engaged. The interaction between the Mother and
her children was also affectionate and responsive. The Mother,
on the other hand, showed consistent emotional availability and
responded calmly to her children’s needs. The 2nd son and the
daughter also embraced their mother naturally while the mother
provided reassurance in a nurturing manner.
67.
石主任也接觸了其他相關人士以多瞭解家庭子女之現況,詳情見報告第(
55)至(63)段。
68.
石主任也建議共同管養權和委任親職協調員,她有以下的結論和建議︰-
Conclusion and Recommendations
64. To conclude, during this adjournment period, while the
parents remained high- conflict, the three children fortunately
exhibited signs of increasing stability in both their academic
and emotional condition. However, communication between the
parents was still very difficult, and mutual trust had yet to be
rebuilt. The mother reported that the father continued to make
false accusations against her, intending to weaken her childcare
abilities. The father, on the other hand, strongly believed
that the mother was using the children to gain advantage in the
divorce proceeding and the ·situation further complicated by
over-involvement of the maternal grandmother.
65. Regarding the custody, the mother insisted on having sole
custody of the children, stating that she could no longer
cooperate with the father, even with a PC. She did not believe
that the father would change and felt that he consistently
failed to consider the children’s best interests. As the father
failed to gain any insights into his problems while she has
always been the one managing the children’s academic and medical
issues, she argued that granting her sole custody was to their
best interest. This would allow her to manage the children’s
affairs without being adversely affected by the father’s
uncooperative attitude. On the contrary, the father requested a
joint custody of the children to continue fulfilling his
parental responsibility, which he deemed important for the
children’s development. He viewed that with the facilitation by
a PC, he was prepared to exchange all relevant information and
resources concerning the children with the mother.
66. Since moving out of the matrimonial home in September
2024, the mother has remained the children’s primary caregiver.
She has actively arranged various activities for them based on
their interests and needs and has maintained regular and
proactive communication with respective schools. The children
also expressed satisfaction with the current living arrangement
and a preference for residing with their mother. The mother
therefore sought sole care & control of the children which was
also aligned with the children’s views. Indeed, given the
affectionate and responsive relationship between the mother and
children, maintaining the existing cate arrangement is deemed
the most appropriate to maintain stability in the children’s
lives.· The father acknowledged that the children were not
willing to live with him at this stage and therefore did not
object to this arrangement.
67. Concerning the access arrangement, the mother understood
the importance of maintaining the father-children relationship.
However, citing the father’s past abusive behaviour towards the
children, his lack of insight into his problems, and his
unstable emotional condition, she argued that for the children’s
safety, the current supervised access for·the 2nd son and the
daughter should continue without overnight stays. Furthermore,
as the eldest son has not yet addressed his traumatic
experiences with his father, she believed that it was better to
suspend access between them for the time being, pending further
assessment. The father, however, strongly requested a stepped-
up access plan consisting of five stages, with the ultimate goal
of having holiday access with his children.
68. Both parents expressed a desire to remain involved in
their children’s upbringing. The mother has demonstrated stable
and effective caregiving, while the father has participated
constructively for the most part during access. However, unless
they can manage their mutual antagonism, their children will
continue to suffer from it. Both the clinical psychologists, Ms
WONG/Clinical Psychologist of Social Welfare Department, and Dr.
POON/TCP observed that the parents need to manage their own
feelings, especially to reduce mutual blame and increase their
motivation for genuine co-parenting. The mother needs to
address her fears, while the father needs to learn more adaptive
and positive parenting skills and to accept the children’s
emotions.
69. Although the children’s readiness for expanding the access
is limited by their emotional responses and parental hostility,
they were eager to receive gifts from their father, and no
obvious emotional disturbance was observed during the access.
It also appears that the children are somewhat confused,
believing that joint custody would necessitate meeting or even
living with their father. As such, therapy or counselling could
encourage the parents to develop empathy and understanding for
their children’s feelings and needs, and to differentiate
between their own thoughts and feelings and those of their
children.
70. Moreover, it is also important to note that the Court’s
paramount consideration is the best interests and welfare of the
children. Both parents deeply love their children and have,
within their respective capacities, provided sufficient material
and educational support. As a result, the children have lacked
for nothing in their daily lives, schooling, or medical care.
In view of this, completely depriving the father of his parental
right and responsibilities at this stage may not serve the
children’s long-term interests and could deny them the benefits
of affection and involvement from both parents.
71. The mother’s deep concerns about sharing parental
responsibility with the father, caused by past conflicts and
incidents of abuse, are understood. However, granting her sole
custody does not necessarily prevent the father from questioning
major decisions. He could still raise legal challenges through
judicial processes, potentially leading to prolonged litigation,
intensified family conflict, and secondary psychological harm to
the children.
72. Therefore, rather than attempting to avoid disputes by
excluding one party, it would be preferable to establish a
structured cooperative framework. A neutral decision-maker,
i.e., a Parenting Coordinator, could meeting with the parents
periodically to develop a schedule of the children’s activities
and each parent’s participation. This would channel the
father’s involvement through a safe and controlled mechanism.
Even though the parties have been unable to secure a suitable PC
so far, for the children’s sake, they should continue their
efforts to find one. Moreover, when parents can manage conflict
through structured communication, a joint custody arrangement
can teach children constructive conflict-resolution skills and
how to balance competing viewpoints.
73. Taking all of the above into consideration, the
investigating officer recommends the following:
i) The parents be granted joint custody of all the children,
with the appointment of a Parenting Coordinator;
ii) The mother be granted care & control of all the
children;
iii) The father be granted defined access for the 2nd son
and the daughter on every Saturday morning, for no less
than one hour per child under supervision at a specialised
co-parenting service centre;
iv) The access arrangement for the eldest son be
suspended, pending for further assessment and
recommendation by the therapist and/or the Parenting
Coordinator; and
v) The access arrangement for all children be subject to
review by the therapist and/or the Parenting Coordinator.
69. 石主任在審訊第7天作供。在庭上,石主任維持共同管養權的建議。
三名家庭子女的意見
70. 在2025年5月6日的報告,黃姑娘指出︰-
Custody Wishes
35. The eldest son expressed his urgent desire for custody to
be granted to his mother (“等唔到聽日”). He stated that he
would feel as though he would die if his father obtained
custody. He mentioned that he learned about custody online and
felt safe only when his father did not have legal control over
him. He believed that without this legal control, he could
completely cut ties with his father and finally feel safe. The
eldest son also shared that it upset him to see his mother
suffering during the divorce proceedings
(“媽咪失眠,黑眼圈...我好憎呢件事令媽咪好痛苦”). He recounted
seeing her read legal documents at night and overhearing
conversations between her and his maternal grandmother. He
wished he could help his mother obtain custody
(“好希望快啲完,可以點樣幫助媽咪拎到custody”). Although his
mother did not allow him to read the legal documents, he
admitted he still tried to understand them. The eldest son
exhibited strong feat and hatred toward his father. He
empathized with his mother’s situation and sought to involve
himself in the custody case to support her.
…
Custody Wish
47. The 2nd son expressed a wish for sole custody to be
granted to his mother. He admitted to secretly reading legal
documents and learned the term “sole custody” from YouTube. He
believes that sole custody is necessary because he wishes to
travel to Bali again, having thoroughly enjoyed his last trip
there in August 2024. He stated, “媽媽攞sole
custody,唔駛爸爸同意先去Bali”. When the undersigned followed
up by asking what would happen if the father agreed to their
travel plans, the 2nd son firmly maintained that he did not
believe his father would allow him to go to Bali, stating,
“你覺得佢(爸爸)會想我地開心?”. This reasoning for preferring
sole custody appears relatively inadequate.
71. 按黃姑娘的報告,女兒並沒有就管養權表達明確的意見。
72. 在2025年5月9日的報告,梁主任指出︰-
Views of the Family Children
56. The three Children were last seen during a home visit in
late March 2025. During the visits, the eldest son and daughter
approached the SWO voluntarily. The eldest son took the
opportunity to voluntarily tell the SWO that he had improved
academic results especially in his science subject and he had
been having a good living now that he did not want to see his
father. In between, the eldest son was keen in showing his
bedroom and his other ideas contributed for the new home. He
had shown himself enjoying the living environment and was
relaxed. The daughter enthusiastically engaged the SWO to play
with her without mentioning anything else. She ran around and
appeared relaxed and joyful. The 2nd son was seen individually
after his private tutorial lesson. He initially appeared quiet
and reserved, but soon gave slight social smiles when talking
about finishing the examinations with satisfactory academic
results achieved. He went on sharing his bedroom decoration and
told that there was not anything else he would like to share to
the SWO.
73. 在2025年11月18日的更新社會利調查報告,石主任指出︰-
Views of the Children-in-question towards Custody, Care &
Control and Access
The oldest son
45. Individual office interview with the eldest son was
conducted on 13 September 2025 and 30 October 2025. Upon
entering the interview room, the eldest son immediately
expressed his dissatisfaction towards his father. He repeatedly
mentioned his father’s violent behavior against him in the past
and questioned why there were so many professionals to arrange
him to meet with his father. He stated that being asked to see
his father means to send him to death 「送佢去死」, as he knew
that his father was not sincere towards him. He feared that if
one day he were to meet or live with his father, his father
would only torture him. He stressed that his current memories
of his father were exclusively left with the unhappy ones.
46. Conversely, the eldest son repeatedly emphasised that his
present life was happy and joyful, as he lived like a normal
child, no longer under his father’s abusive behaviour. His
mother all along managed his academic and medical affairs while
the father had no involvement. His mother provided him with
exceptional care especially teaching him emotional regulation,
resulted in his progressive emotional improvement. For instance,
when his classmate committed suicide on 1 September 2025, he
stated that without his mother’s care, he feared that he might
have exhibited similar behavior. Additionally, his mother would
discuss with him on every matter in relation to him, such as
tutoring arrangements. His mother also maintained communication
with his school to arrange for a shadow teacher, which
facilitated his academic progress.
47. The eldest son reiterated that his father never considered
his welfare, but just wanted to take revenge on them. Just like
the Shanghai school trip, which his father refused to cooperate
with the school making him feel greatly embarrassed arid nearly
loss of the opportunity to participate in it. Furthermore, his
father opposed to the continuation of his treatment with Dr.
CHAU/CP who actually served as his bridge with the school.
Although he met Dr. POON/TCP during this period, he just
entertained his mother’s request and also did not want to upset
Dr. POON/TCP.
48. Therefore, the eldest son expressed a wish for his mother to
have his sole custody care & control. Regarding the access, he
stressed that he would not have contact or communication with
his father, even via telephone or video calls. He did not think
that his father would make any change. Nevertheless, he
accepted the gifts and red packets from him every week,
especially the red packet, which he regarded as his father’s
responsibility in providing child support to them.
The 2nd son
49. During the individuals interviews with the 2nd son on 21
July 2025 and 30 October 2025, he also repeatedly told his
father's past abusive behavior as soon as he entered the
interview room. He stated that, in his memory, his father would
constantly curse and hit him. He furthered that if his father
was granted his custody, it would be as good as sending him to
death.
50. The 2nd son said that while his parents sometimes discussed
his academic matters, his father usually disregarded his views.
For instance, he had a long wish to transfer to the school of
the eldest son or the daughter. But his father ignored him and
even scolded him with foul language.
51.·Regarding the weekly access at SCSC, the 2nd son said that
he did not like such arrangement because it disturbed his rest
time. During his October, he began to feel pressured by Ms
LI/SCSC, who urged him to admit that his mother had also hit
him. However, he could not give an account of it. Nonetheless,
he no longer trusted Ms LI/SCSC. After explanations, the 2nd
son expressed no strong objection to continuing access at SCSC
but he preferred a shorter period of time so that he could have
more time for rest and to enjoy leisure activities. Although he
looked forward to the red packets and gifts from his father
during weekly access, he viewed that this was his father’s
responsibility to provide child support for them.
52. Therefore, the 2nd son also wished his mother to have his
sole custody and care & control. Regarding the access
arrangement, he did not strongly object to maintaining the
current arrangement but hoped that each session could be
shortened to about 45 minutes.
53. During the first individual office interview on 21 July
2025, the daughter appeared rather reserved and quiet, needing
some time to warm up. Regarding her parents’ situation, she
briefly stated that she liked her mother and enjoyed her
existing life but did not like-her father or visiting him.
However, she did not provide any specific reasons for it.
54. In the second interview on 30 October 2025, the daughter
appeared more relaxed. But she still simply described her
father as “terrible” and said that her mother was a “good and
lovely” mother, adding that everything with her mother was good.
She reiterated that she liked her current life. For the access
arrangement, the daughter simply said that, she did not want to
wake up so early to go to the SCSC but was happy to have the
gifts from her father.
74.
在作供時[10],李大律師問到有關兩名兒子對所謂共同管養或單獨管養的
瞭解,黃姑娘答︰
答︰ … 其實好明顯佢都係 -- 究竟佢知幾多呢,我打個question mark
嘅,係喇,即係 --
即係嗰個因為要去峇里旅行,即係所以就希望sole
custody ,呢個reasoning
都係比較特別嘅,係喇。咁就大仔佢嗰一個 -- 佢話好想要sole
custody,佢嘅reason就係佢覺得咁先係一個completely 嘅cut off
,佢先至feel safe 。
75.
本席同意 ,黃姑娘所說二名兒子對所謂共同管養或單獨管養,只是一知半
解。作供時[11],石主任補充說,會面時,大仔有明確地對她說要母親
有‘Sole
custody’,二仔有說相似的說話,但不記得當時是說中文或英,女兒比
較靦腆。只說想與母親生活。做報告時,三名家庭子女分別為12歲、10
歲和8歲,石主任說,不肯定他們是否懂得共管養或單獨管養之分別。但
值得注意,石主任認為,無論如何,他們的意見是重要的考慮因素,因
為法庭是在處理他們切身的事情。
曾經受或有機會遭受的傷害
涉及兒童或其他家庭的任何成員的家庭暴力
76.
母親指,父親在婚姻期間經常大駡及威嚇母親 ,多年來不時有喝駡和體罰
家庭子女的行為[12]。她提交了多段錄音和視頻及其謄本作為物證包括
︰-
母親之第一份誓章之證物
|1. |TKK-5[13] |2022年8月20日據稱父親大罵母親的錄音片段 |
|2. |TKK-6[14] |2023年4月30日據稱父親叫母親跳樓的錄音 |
|3. |TKK-7[15] |2023年7月1日據稱父親說要同母親分開的錄音 |
|4. |TKK-8[16] |2021年5月4日據稱父親打二仔的片段 |
|5. |TTK-9[17] |2021年7月9日據稱父親打兩名兒子的兩個錄影片段 |
|6. |TKK-14[18]|2024年5月19日的錄音,母親第二份誓章之證物 |
|7. |TKK-20[19]|日期為2021年4月1日的錄影片段 |
|8. |TKK-21[20]|日期為2021年7月9日的錄影片段 |
|9. |TKK-22[21]|日期為2021年8月21日的錄影片段 |
|10. |TKK-23[22]|日期為2022年12月1日的錄影片段 |
母親之第七份誓章之證物
|11. |TKK-92[23]|2021年5月4日的前姻居所閉路電視的段錄影片段(母親|
| | |在大仔的房間陪伴大仔温習,據稱父親因為一些小事責|
| | |罵大仔) |
|12. |TKK-93[24]|2021年5月4日的前婚姻居所閉路電視的錄影片段(據稱|
| | |父親在吃早餐的時候對女兒大聲訓斥) |
|13. |TKK-94[25]|2021年5月4日的前婚姻居所閉路電視的錄影片段(母親|
| | |在下午與大仔及二仔平靜地在客廳裡温習) |
母親之第十份非宗教式誓章之證物
|14. |TKK-125[26|據稱一段母親與前家庭傭工XX在2023年10月16日的對 |
| |] |話 |
77.
父親否認虐兒,又提交了3位家傭的證人供詞,反駁母親的說法。在2024
年12月16日,懷疑虐待兒童多專業個案會議出席會議成員除了警方外,
其餘成員一致同意父親對大仔及二仔身體上及精神上的虐待成立。在20
25年9月19日,父親被控4條虐兒罪在2026年3月19日,父親在東區裁判署
承認控方實情,自簽保守行為。在作供時母親一方在庭上播放了多段母
親提交之影音片段,內容見謄本文件冊,本席不在此重覆。
78. RW1 在審訊第三天作供。在2015,RW1 受僱母親,二仔出生後RW1
主力照顧二仔。RW1說,父親是一位細心的好父親,雖然工作忙,但仍肯
花時間和家庭子女相處,又經常帶子女外出遊玩,家庭子女也尊敬和熱
愛父親,父親子女關係緊密。就母親對父親對母親及家庭子女有多番暴
力行為的說法,RW1反對母親的說法,也就母親所例舉的一些例子作出反
駁。母親提交了大仔2023年6月1日的日記[27],見大仔寫了一首詩,內
容說父親會掟東西、打他、打碎(Smash)東西,更形容父親是一怪物(m
onster)。RW1
說,當時她聽到母親在大仔房間引導大仔寫一些父親負面的東西。
79. RW2 在審訊第四天作供。RW2是家庭司機。RW2
說,她替父親工作,8年來從未見過父親有暴力行為,父親關懷家庭,又
肯花時間陪伴子女。
80. RW3
在審訊第五天作供。由2023年1月,RW3受僱母親為家傭。RW3反對母親說
父親脾氣差及暴力對待母親和家庭子女的說法。她說,父親十分顧家,
又關懷和愛護家庭子女,有時子女有不檢行為,父親也只會假意用手打
手板或用一些軟物假意打他們的小腿來教訓他們。RW3說,父親不會體罰
他們。RW3又說她見到母親在引導大仔寫在2023年6月1日日記上之詩句。
81.
本席認為,從母親提交之影音證據可見,父親有脾氣差及暴力對待母親和
家庭子女的行為。綜合全部證據,本席信納,父親在婚姻期間有如以上
幾段影音所見聞大罵母親及威嚇母親和家庭子女體罰家庭子女的行為。
82.
然而,審視本案所有證據,本席認為,並無證據母親確診患創傷壓力症或
受虐婦女綜合症。
83.
父親也指母親在婚姻期間有打罵家庭子女之行為[28]。父親傳召了家傭指
證母親。
84. RW1
說,母親有酗酒的習慣。在家庭子女前經常表現得情緒不穏和有攻擊性
,經常對家庭子女加以精神及身體上之虐待,RW1舉出了以下之事例,她
說︰
i) 2020年5月14日,母親在房內用案尺打二仔的腿和臀部,RW1
提交了顯示二仔腿和臀部的瘀痕的照片[29];
ii)
2021年8月13日,母親用桌尺打二仔的背和腎部,令二仔多個身體部位紅腫和
輕微出血。RW1提供了二子傷勢之相片[30];
iii)
2022年3月22日母親用手多次打二仔的背、頭和拉他的耳朵,RW1提供了二仔向
RW1講述事情經過的視頻[31],和一張有關二仔當天之傷勢之照片[32];
iv) 2022年3月23日,母親大力拉二仔的耳朵,RW1
提交了有關二仔當天傷勢之照片[33];
v)
2023年6月20日,母親在房中打二仔之背和臀部,RW1提交了有關在房外錄得過
程的聲音的視頻[34];
vi)
2023年10月15日,母親因功課問題對二仔大喊大叫,RW1提交了相關錄音[35]。
85.
RW2也說,母親有酗酒的習慣,經常體罰家庭子女,對二仔尤其如是。在2
022年夏天,母親和家庭子女在外晚飯完畢。RW2開車接他們,聽到母親
對二仔動怒,不停責駡他,二仔對母親說他不喜歡母親,母親大聲喝二
仔,叫他落車。二仔受驚,在車中不停大哭。RW1也說她目睹母親多次在
車中喝駡大仔和用力打他的頭。母親喝酒後的行為會變得更為有攻擊性
和暴力,母親經常用‘笨蛋’和‘愚蠢’等不好的說話侮辱家庭子女和傭人
,母親又會指導家庭子女憎恨父親。RW2
說,她經常目睹母親在車中指導家庭子女拍視頻,和引導他們用甚麼說
話來向父親作出投訴,更在錄影前叫他們多次演讀。
86.
RW3也說,母親有酗酒的習慣,在子女前會表現不穩定和攻擊性的脾性,經
常令子女悲傷流淚。RW3說,她親身經歷RW1所說2023年6月20日和2023年
10月15日之事情,同意RW1所說事情經過。RW3又提交了一張稱由RW1在2
024年9月18日拍攝二仔腳上的瘀痕的照片[36]。
87. 父親和其證人又提供了多條錄音和錄影片段作為物證,父親說︰-
父親第一次誓章之證物
|7. |CSF1-24[37] |由RW1錄影之視頻,據稱二仔向RW1承認母親打二仔令 |
| | |他感到痛楚 |
|8. |CSF1-25[38] |由RW1錄影之視頻,據稱為母親在責罵和打二仔 |
RW1 誓章之證物
|9. |VCM-5[39] |2015年2月7日有關母親之新聞報導之視頻 |
|10. |VCM-8[40] |2022年3月22日之視頻 |
|11. |VCM-11[41] |2023年6月20日之視頻 |
|12. |VCM-12[42] |2025年10月15日之視頻 |
父親第五份誓章之證物
|13. |CSF-5-9[43] |CSF-1-22之謄本 |
| | |2024年9月16日之錄音和謄本 |
88. 母親作供時,父親一方在庭播放了一些影音片段,包括︰
1. CSF1-24︰2022年3月22日,RW1與二仔的談話,當時二仔為6
歲多,內容二仔對RW1說因數學功課問題,母親打二仔的背、拉耳仔和毃頭
多次,令二仔怠到頭痛;
2. CSF1-
25︰2023年6月20日,RW1在二仔房門外錄得之聲音,RW1之證供為母親在房
內體罰二仔;
3. VCM-
12︰RW1提交之錄音,RW1說,在2023年10月15日,母親因功課問題對二仔聲
叫喊,又要二仔抄書10次。
89.
母親不接受她有體罰家庭子女的說法。母親反駁,RW1在2022年3月22日之
談話中引導二仔的說話,所以其內容並不可靠,又否認2023年6月20日錄
音中的女聲是母親,亦不承認2023年10月15日錄音中的女聲是母親。
90.
母親提交了RW2在2023年大約10月或11月發給父親的WhatsApp短訊[44]︰
“Sir the one I tell you is whatever happen [RW1] and me is in
your side. Pls be very careful once you scold or shout or
hitting the kids because Madam do the recording. The helper
heard that [the eldest son] is asking her Mom when she will
divorce you but [the mother] stop [the eldest son] because the
helpers ae around…”
91.
本席接受,短訊內容見RW2有偏幫父親之嫌。再者,自辭職後,RW1、RW2
和RW3現在都受僱父親,他們又曾多次向警方、勞工處和勞資審裁處對母
親作出投訴。在這樣的背景下,本席明白應小心處理RW1、RW2和RW3之證
供之可信性。但綜合所有證據,尤其是在庭上播放之錄音片段,本席認
為無疑,以上幾段錄音/錄影的事情都是發生在前婚姻居所,又經小心考
慮全部證供,本席接納RW1所說,CSF1-25和VCM-
12其中的女聲是母親的聲音,又經小心考慮CSF1-24和CSF1-
25的內容後本席信納如其內容所示母親在當時有體罰二仔之行為,也信
納如 VCM-12
所示母親在當時因功課問題對二仔大聲喊話。綜合來說,本席信納婚姻
期間母親也有體罰家庭子女之行為。
92.
雖然母親在過去有打罵家庭子女之行為 ,父親接受母親有照顧家庭子女之
能力。家庭子女現由母親照顧和管束。從石主任2025年11月18日的進度
報告可見,在母親照顧下,家庭子女的近況不錯[45]。
93.
在2026年5月15日的進度報告,黃姑娘也說,大仔情況也比前有所改善︰
Clinical Interview with the eldest son
3. The eldest son attended the interview accompanied by the
Mother. During the interview, the eldest presented s more
settled compared to the previous court assessment conducted a
year ago. He initially engaged in conversation in the interview
room and later requested to move to the playroom, where he
showed interest in interacting with the sand tray. While the
platy activity appeared to provide some comfort, his demeanor
shifted at times - :particularly when discussing his knowledge
of court proceedings during which he became restless and alert.
94.
綜合以上各點 ,本席認為家庭子女現在母親照顧下情況不錯,再遭受家暴
、傷害的機會並不大。
95. 又值得注意,在2025年5月9日的報告,梁主任說︰-
62. This case was also complicated by the ongoing disputes
with the area of child maltreater. While elements of child
maltreatment shed information on parent-child relationship and
the parents’ parenting styles, it was neither the sole nor the
most determining factor in facilitating the present social
investigation. On the other hand, it was never conducive to the
Children’s psycho-emotional wellbeing and development should the
negative side of the father-child(ren) relationship be
recurrently brought-up which was considered as hindering them to
move forward and develop positively. While understanding the
Mother’s fear held for the Father, the Mother should avoid re-
capturing with the Children about the Father’s history of child
maltreatment. At the same time, the Mother, as the residing
parent, should be obliged to genuinely support and encourage the
access involving re-building of father-children relationship
apart from ensuring the Children’s physical presence at the
SCSC. Simultaneously, it was very undesirable, if not harmful,
should the mother-children relationship be called for re-
examination of incidents of child maltreatment because such
meant to the Children that their mother, also their perceived
source of protection and secure attachment figure, be attacked
that the Children’s vulnerability would be triggered to further
distant themselves from the Father.
96. 在2026年5月15日的進度報告黃姑娘說︰-
Child Abuse Allegation
49. Rather than continuing to debate the facts of
whether child abuse did or did not occur at the hands of either
parent, the focus should be placed on the present needs of the
children. If the focus remains solely on debating past events,
there is little psychological value in determining sole or joint
custody. Such a debate would risk prolonging a distressing
process for not only the eldest son but all three children,
potentially leaving them caught in a long-term cycle of conflict
and uncertainty. Therefore, both parents are encouraged to
prioritize helping the children regain a sense of safety and
stability.
For the Mother, it would relieve the children from the
distressing debate surrounding allegations of child abuse if she
could move away from the pursuit of collecting further evidence
against the Father or attempting to demonstrate to the court
that he was not loving or caring. Redirecting her focus toward
the children’s present well-being, rather than continuing such
disputes, would help create a more stable environment and
support the children in regaining a sense of safety.
97.
本席同意梁主任和黃姑娘以上的看法,這就是到了今天,訴訟雙方應放下
彼些就對方在過去的虐兒行為的爭論。
身體、感情和教育方面的需要;
年齡、成熟程度、性別、社會和文化背景,以及其他法庭認為有關的特點
98.
大兒子、二兒子和女兒現年為12歲、10歲和8歲 。由2020年至今,大仔接
受瑪麗醫院精神科臨床心理學家、精神科醫生服務現時約每1至2個月1至
2次。由2024年至今,二仔接受瑪麗醫院精神科服務,現約每4個月1次。
在2024年7月,大仔經學校轉介接受Dr. Chau
兒童臨床心理學家服務,每星期1至2次,至2025年3月停止。由2024年1
0月至今,經Dr.
Chau介紹,大仔接受精神科連醫生服務,在2024年10月至2025年2月期間
,約一個月數次,現約每月1次。在2025年5月19日,法庭頒令委任潘博
士為三名家庭子女治療心理學家,在2025年7月至11月期間,大仔約每兩
星期1至2次,其後暫停,直至2026年4月,由2026年4月至今見過次。二
仔和女兒分別在2025年10月,2026年4月見過潘博士。母親向法庭承諾參
予及配合潘博士的治療。由2025年10月至今,母親接受精神科譚醫生服
務,大約1至3個月1次。父親在2024年10月至11月期間見過一位醫生4次
,檢查父親精神狀況及父親與家子女關係。
99. 梁主任作供時,李大律師與她有以下之問答︰
問︰
大家都係希望畀最好嘅嘢大仔咁喺呢一單案入面,你覺得一個joint
custody order 會係幫到,會係害咗大仔會係a bit of both
,會係樣樣?可唔可以講我哋聽?
答︰
唔,大仔嘅狀況的確係有艱難嘅,係喺我嘅前提之下,我總一定係會覺
得joint custody,希望小朋友係絕對透過joint
custody呢一樣嘢。當然中間亦都好緊要嘅,就係父母點樣去deliver
joint custody 呢個concept畀小朋友知道,係喇。
問︰ 唔,唔。
答︰ 而讓小朋友明白父母都 – 或多或少都算係equally
參與喺佢哋生命入面,呢個係一定重要嘅。係喇,我喺呢個前提之下
,即係再睇即係大仔嘅狀況,我覺得即好艱難嘅因為原因就係首先
– 即係大仔本身就係即係嗰個 –
即係ADHD嘅狀況似乎都係艱難喇,第二就係我了解到,似乎佢喺佢而
家嘅行為表現,即係喺一啲即係佢嘅behaviours出嚟嘅,真係好抗拒
爸爸。而呢一個抗拒睇到嘅就係無論佢verbally
佢有repeated地講一傷害自己嘅情況,姑勿論佢有冇做,係喇,有做
當然好擔心,冇做我哋都會擔心,係喇。
問︰ 唔。
答︰ 咁第二,就係佢表達到一啲狀況狀,就係佢即係個 --
即係情緒狀況好唔好喇,包括以致影響埋佢嘅 –
即係學校嘅表現喇。第三,就係我都好關注一樣嘢,就係其實係 --
似乎喺我搜集番嚟嘅資料入面,同埋喺我自己同大仔嘅 –
即係見面、接觸入面呢,大仔係好consistently同唔同嘅profession
al都講話「我唔能夠見爸爸」,而佢見爸爸佢就會dot dot
dot,即你有好多唔好嘅影響喇。呢一樣嘢就有 -- 我有一個嘅即係
-- 即係關注,如果係一個即係joint custody. . .
問︰ 唔。
答︰ ...
而父母又唔能夠,或者冇人能夠好清楚地解釋到畀大仔知道,呀,其
實呢個係乜嘢意思,爸爸即係點樣參與,媽媽係點樣繼續參與嘅話呢
,我會有一個好大嘅關注,就係大仔點樣去perceive
唔同嘅professional 畀佢嘅協助,呢個係 --
係喇,所以我諗抱歉,我真係唔答到。
問︰ 唔,係。
官︰ 我想澄清頭先證人妳話dot dot dot dot,係咩嘢嚟㗎?
答︰ 即係話包括可能佢講好多 --
即係當佢好consistently同唔同嘅專業講自己唔想見爸爸。
官︰ 唔,唔。
答︰ 而引申到好多負面嘅東西,可能...
官︰ 唔,你嘅講法就話若果會 -- 若果見就dot dot
dot,咁我想知道呢啲dot dot dot係咩嘢嚟。
答︰ 呀,就係講緊嗰堆負面嘅 -- 即係佢覺得自己有好多負面嘅 --
即係譬如「我會死呀」…
官︰ 唔,唔。
答︰ … 「我會即係瞓唔到覺呀,我會做一啲行為去傷害爸爸」等等。
官︰ 即係會傷害佢自己,亦都...
答︰ 會傷害爸爸。-
100.
梁主任在審訊第二天作供,在庭上,梁主任維持共同管養權的建議,她認
為父母在共同委任單一專家和親職協調員幫助下,有能力做到共親。
101.
本席也認同,維持一個有意義的父親與家庭子女關係,對他們的福祉是重
要的。
102. 黃姑娘在2025年5月6日之報告說︰
71. Although the Mother acknowledges the children’s blood ties
to their father and encourages access visits, her fears seem to
obscure her understanding of the importance of maintaining those
relationships. The eldest son, in particular, expressed anxiety
about losing his father figure, highlighting the developmental
needs for paternal connection. It is common for boys,
especially as they enter adolescence, to seek acceptance from
their father, which crucial for the development of their self-
esteem.
103. 梁主任在2025年5月9日的報告指出︰-
61. In addition to each of the Children’s individual experience
and response, their perception, behavioural and emotional
responses with parental divorce were intertwined by the
siblings’ interaction among themselves. For instance, the
eldest son appeared to have taken the lead that the 2nd son and
the daughter followed with not seeing the Father during the
access session on 25 January 2025. Another scene happened on 8
February 2025 when the 2nd son blamed and slapped the daughter
for staying long at the SCSC. More so, the 2nd son shared to Ms
LI thֹat out of all negative comments against the father, some
were ungroundedly fed in upon siblings’ discussions.
104.
本席同意 ,二名家庭子女之間之互動關係這需要加以注意的一個特點。
105.
大仔和二仔都有特殊需要,在2026年5月15日就父親探視大仔安排的進度報
告,黃姑娘在報告結論和建議說︰-
41. Although the eldest son currently presents as emotionally
more stable, it remains notable that he demonstrates heightened
alertness during parental disputes and continues to hold strong
negative perceptions of the Father. These entrenched views may
pose long-term psychological risks if not addressed.
Accordingly, any future custody arrangements should prioritize
the eldest son’s emotional security, gradual trust-building, and
the minimization of conflict exposure, ensuring that his best
interests remain central to all decisions.
106. 對黃姑娘以上的建議本席是接受的。
父親、母親和法庭認為與問題有關的人,能在什麼程度上滿足家庭子女的需要;
家庭子女與父親、母親和其他人的關係的性質;
父親和母親對家庭子女和對父母身份的責任所表現的態度。
107.
這是一宗高衝突的個案 ,父母雙方對對方都有極大的負面觀感和情緒。梁
主任、石主任和黃姑哴均形容母親與家堥子女的關係為自然、親密及良
好[46]。
108. 目前來說,家庭子女對父親都甚為抗拒[47]。
109.
父親認為母親有外還,更傳召RW1、RW2和RW3替他就此作供。RW1說,202
3年5月20日,RW1接母親電,要求RW1替她在家中找事後丸。母親回家後
,RW1告之這些藥丸所在,母親隨即吞下一粒,RW1又說,她隨後見和母
親頸項左邊有一疑似愛咬(love
bite)的小紅瘀痕。RW1提交了一張所謂事後丸的照片[48]。RW2說,在2
023年5月20日,她開車接回母親從一私人住宅回家,母親上車後滿身酒
氣,表現得緊張和焦燥不安,又聽到母親致電RW1吩咐RW1替母親在家中
找避孕丸。RW3說,在2023年6月,母親因遺失了她的藍芽耳機向幾名家
傭大發脾氣,RW3推想母親應是在2023年5月20日把藍芽耳機遺下在男朋
友家中。
110.
就2023年5月20日的事件,母親說[49],她服食就2023年5月20日的事件,
母親說她服食Norcolut(一種荷爾蒙藥的成分)是因為子宮內膜息肉問
題而並非避孕。在2023年5月20日只有外出做皮膚護理,晚上約7時便回
家,沒有喝酒,亦沒有任何頸部的痕跡,相關的指控全是父親及家傭捏
造的。
111.
母親是否有外遇,在本審訊而言,絕非一個主要爭論點,又無論如何,按
現有證據,本席認為並無足夠證據說明母親是否有所謂外遇。
112.
父親說,母親本可採取較為和平及理性的替代方案來處理婚姻問題,但她
卻選擇了一種極度戲劇的方式來結束這段婚姻。母親這場策劃的後果,
讓三名年幼的子女不得不承受並反覆接觸多個不同機構及專業人士的介
入,包括︰(1)警方;(2)懷疑虐待兒童多專業個案會議;(3)社會工作主
任;(4)臨床心理學家;(5)多次會見Dr. Chau
及連醫生以及(6)潘博士,其目的顯然不僅僅在於達致離婚本身,更在於
長遠地切斷父親與子女之間的聯繫,使關係難以修復,甚至徹底斷裂。
113.
在父親方面,從訴訟開始他便認定母親密謀離婚多時,精心部署去誇大婚
姻其間父親家暴行為和母親及家庭子女受到的言語上,精神上及身體上
的傷害,又向家庭子女灌輸父親的負面資訊,又申請法庭禁制令地址保
密,以隔斷父親與家庭子女的連系[50]。搬離婚姻居所後不久,更經律
師要求父親不直接聯終絡母親[51]。母親否認所謂密謀離婚的指稱,但
母親接受[52],早在2023年9月,母親已考慮離婚安排子女見臨床心理學
家又委托律師預備了一份誓章,內容涉及多次父親虐兒行為的事件。母
親在2024年9月12日提出離婚呈請和禁制令申請傳票,在2024年9月13日
單方面從學校接走家庭子女,搬進酒店,又替家庭子女在2024年9月16日
至17日請病假,這一連串行動明顯地涉及事前不少準備和安排,所以父
親產生所謂母親密謀離婚的觀感,本席認為,這是可以理解的。但本席
注意到,在2024年9月17日,母親以WhatsApp把代表律草擬的同意傳票[53]
,內容包括家庭子女的中期照顧,和父親的中期探視安排,發送給父親
考慮,父親卻並沒有就此草擬的同意傳票給予任何回覆,若父親當時能
積極地回應,不排除父親和家庭子女可儘早作出中期探視安排,母親其
認為大仔不適宜與父親親身探視,也只是依循專業人士(Dr.
Chau、連醫生及瑪麗醫院譚醫生)的建議。所以,本席對父親所說母親
處心積慮隔斷父親與家庭子女連系的說法,並不認同。
114.
父親說,一直以來他與家庭子女的關係良好[54],又提交了多段視頻,以
支持他的說法,包括︰-
|1. |CSF1-14 |父親與大仔之音頻短訊之錄音和截圖 |
|2. |CSF1-16[55]|父親與大仔之音頻短訊 |
|3. |CSF1-17[56]|二仔收錄之音頻,內容為父親在教導二仔 |
|4. |CSF1-20[57]|父親誓章第50段中提及之音頻和視頻 |
|5. |CSF1-21[58]|(i) 父親讀大頭妹故事給女兒聽之音頻(由二仔錄音) |
| | |(ii) 女兒裝作駕駛到XX找父親之視頻 |
| | |(iii) 父親與女兒之相片和視頻 |
115. 在2025年5月6日的報告,黃姑娘有以下結論︰-
68. Both parents demonstrate care for the children and wish to
support them through the family transition.
116.
雖然她不接受一直以來父親與家庭子女關係良好的說法。作供時,母親接
受父親家庭子女有親密愉快的時刻。
117.
經小心考慮全部證據,本席接受父親是關懷家庭子女,也盼望能支持子女
未來的發展。
118.
父親指出,2023年6月1日大仔在日記上的詩[59],有母親圈改的字跡。父
親認為母親不斷在催眠大仔去相信大仔有破壞傾向,和相信這些破壞傾
向是由他對父親之恐懼所驅使。本席認為,母親圈改大仔的詩,不足為
奇,所說母親不斷在催眠大仔,只是父親十分主觀的觀點,亦並無可信
納的客觀證據作支持。對父親所說母親不斷催眠大仔,本席並不認同。
119.
大仔向來因為過度活躍症而需要定期瑪麗醫院看精神科醫生。於約2022年
尾,大仔的精神科醫生說大仔可能患上抑鬱症,並為大仔排期看理醫。
在2024年7月,大仔基於其專注力問題經學校建議轉介與臨床心理學家D
r. Chau
會面。心理學家認為大仔除了患有過度活躍症及專注力不足外,還因為
父親的家庭暴力而有創傷後壓力症的症狀。Dr. Chau 2024年8月10日
的心理報告[60]說︰-
On an emotional level, the eldest son navigates a complex
landscape of ADHD, low self-esteem, and anxiety. Despite his
challenges, he approaches each day with resilience and
determination. His ADHD brings a whirlwind of thoughts and
emotions, making focus a constant battle. Coupled with his
struggles with self-worth, the eldest son often doubts his
abilities and finds it hard to recognize his strengths. Anxiety
weaves through his days, creating a sense of unease and fear of
the unknown. In addition to his ADHD challenges, the eldest son
further endures ongoing psychological and emotional stress from
his father’s insensitive, harsh parenting. In this intricate
emotional landscape, the eldest son’s insecurities shape his
interactions and perceptions of the world around him. He finds
solace and reassurance in his mother, leaning on her for support
and stability in moments of turmoil. His overreliance on her
for comfort speaks to a deep need for security and connection in
a world that often feels overwhelming and uncertain.
Based on his current symptoms and difficulties, the eldest son
continues to meet the DSM 5 diagnostic criteria for Attention-
Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder - Predominantly Inattentive
Presentation with Moderate Severity (DSM 5 F90.2)
In addition to ADHD, the eldest son further meets the diagnostic
criteria for Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (DSM-5 F43.10).
Specifically, the eldest son has direct exposure to and
witnessing of domestic violence at home on his siblings and
mother, recurrent and intrusive distressing memories of the
events. He further displays persistent avoidance of his father
and a persistent negative emotional state of fear and shame.
During the testing, he clearly exhibited hypervigilance and
irritable mood. These behaviors and symptoms are secondary to
his ADHD diagnosis.
120. 在2024年9月21日 Dr
Chau再次與大仔會面,在2024年9月27日,撰寫第二份大仔的心理報告[61]
,內容包括︰
The eldest son demonstrates an understanding of the assessment’s
purpose. He expressed feeling a sense of Increased freedom
since moving from the matrimonial residence and reduced stress
stemming from his father’s presence. The eldest son explicitly
stated his reluctance to return to the former family home due to
his emotional comfort in the current living situation.
The eldest son disclosed a history of physical abuse hy his
father, with the most significant incident occurring October
2022, resulting in public humiliation and increased fear towards
his father, which led to him being seen by a psychologist at
Queen Mary Hospital due to concerns of depression in June 2023.
During the session, the eldest son exhibited high anxiety
regarding potential encounters with his father, experiencing
intrusive and distressing thoughts that manifested physically
through headaches and dizziness.
The eldest son admitted to episodes of heightened frustration
without clear triggers, occasionally leading to thoughts of self-
harm, although he denied any active suicidal intentions. His
primary concern revolves around the fear of his father obtaining
custody and locating their current residence, exacerbated by
recent termination of domestic help services which provided a
sense of security.
Summary and Recommendations
The assessment report highlights significant concerns regarding
the eldest son’s well-being, necessitating specialized
intervention. It is strongly recommended that the eldest son be
referred to a child psychologist specializing in child abuse and
post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) for immediate therapeutic
support.
Given the traumatic experiences detailed in the report, it is
crucial that the eldest son does not have unsupervised contact
with his father under any circumstances. Supervision should be
maintained to ensure the eldest son’s emotional and physical
safety throughout any interactions with his father.
121.
父親又提交了一段在2024年9月18日,RW1與女兒談話的音頻[62],父親說
在其間女兒對RW1說,母親對女兒說,父親計劃綁架女兒,又替她轉學去
一間垃圾學校。雖然母親否認其事,但從音頻內容整體來看,本席接受
母親或婆婆有對女兒說類似的說話。
122.
父親說,一向他與兩名兒子有在手機上以WhatsApp聯絡,最後在手機見大
仔上線是在2024年9月13日,見二仔最後上線是2024年10月2日[63],父
親為這是母親一手促成,以切斷父親與兩名兒子聯絡。對此母親否認。
母親說,因為手機有定位設置大仔不想父親知道大仔位置,所以停止上
線,二仔的手機遺下在前婚姻居所,再出新手機,也停止了上線。
123.
父親指母親疏離父親與家庭子女關係,令父親與子女之關係在母親與子女
離開前婚姻居所後急轉直下,父親特別指出,[64]在2024年12月11日的
緊急社會調查報告,梁主任報告︰
4. Shortly after the start of the interview, the eldest son said
he was well-prepared for the interview and urged the
Investigating Officer to ask him questions. He said that the
Investigating Officer would represent him, and clarified such as
not being with his father although he also shared about feeling
lost and not knowing where he belonged to. the eldest son shared
that he, as the family child, should decide on the custody but
not the court. He continued to tell that his father was an evil
because his father physically punished him by using a belt and a
squash cricket cover. The eldest son did not provide further
details of physical punishment, but continued that his father
had beaten him since he was two years old without knowing how he
remembered such. The eldest son furthered that he did not have
any good memory with his father while commenting his mother to
be good without deliberating any example. the eldest son
reinstated that he could not meet his father because his father
would beat him to dying. He repeated that he would jump from
height if he was to meet his father. The interview session ended
when the eldest son told he was hungry and left the activity
room by himself. During the one-hour of interview, the eldest
son was engaged, expressive but jumpy in topics.
...
6.Soon after entering into the activity room, the younger son,
the 2nd son, chose a game, sat down and voluntarily shared that
he did not want to live with his father because the latter
always beat him with short and long rulers, water bottles and
squash cricket cover, besides lecturing him and asking him to
pour alcohol for the Father. The 2nd son told that his father
had once beaten him to wounding while he did not remember any
details such as the latest and the most serious incident. The
2nd son shifted to share his father throwing his younger sister
outdoor of the holiday home in XX, New Territories, during last
Christmas when the 2nd son recalled his father poking his head
on the same night. The 2nd son told that he did not have any
happy or neutral memory with his father, whilst he was happy
with his mother who brought him fishing shrimps a short while
ago. Expressing his worry with the coming school examinations,
the 2nd son told that he anticipated his mother bringing him to
the Ocean Park after the examinations had finished. At first,
the 2nd son revealed to have happy memories in the Ocean Park,
but immediately changed to saying that there was no happy memory
in the Ocean Park when answering that his father had been to the
Ocean Park with him. The 2nd son said that his father had never
bought him any present or rewarded him and told the
Investigating Officer to ask his mother for such question. The
2nd son told that he was fearful with his father kidnapping,
beating and lecturing him that he did not want to meet his
father, although he said that there could be reasons for not
doing homework if he met his father. The 2nd son showed his
attentiveness throughout the nearly one-hour of interview and
gave responses relevantly.
...
8.The youngest daughter, brought along with a rabbit and
requested her mother's presence for about 30 minutes before she
agreed to stay alone with the Investigating Officer. Once her
mother had left the playroom, the daughter spontaneously shared
that her father threw her out of the XX holiday home during cold
weather. She voluntarily sketched a picture on her accord. The
daughter supplemented that her father always said bad things as
well as scolding her verbally. She continued telling that her
father always used something to beat her and her brothers
without recalling what objects were used. She then told that her
father sometimes beat all children altogether and sometimes
separately. She said she did not know any further details and
then immersed into her play. The daughter expressed that her
mother was the best because the latter always cheered her up,
whilst she did not mention when was the playtime or happy time
with her father. Throughout the 35-minute of individual
interview, the daughter appeared relaxed as shown from her
creative play with a lot of physical movements and singing
during playing.
124.
父親認為家庭子女未待調查主任發問,便主動的說出一件件母親在誓章中
提及的有關父親負面的事情,可見母親在子女會見調查主任前引導了子
女見面時的說話,所以子女對調查主任所說,也可能不是在表達他們之
真感受,而只是在複述母親的說話。
125. 黃姑娘在2025年5月6日報告說:-
65. Ms. LI noted that she paused visitations in February 2025
after discovering that details of the children's interactions
with the father were recited in legal documents. Additionally,
the eldest son shared information about their father's extra-
marital affairs, while the eldest son showed Ms. LI a video of
the father's temper on their mother's phone. All three children
reportedly complained about their father to her, indicating that
they were aware of and actively engaged in the parental divorce
conflict.
126.
母親否認有教唆子女行為。從家庭子女在以上與梁主任會有的整體表現來
看,本席認為的確很可能,母親在家庭子女與梁主任該次之會面之前,
有作出引導子女在會面談話內容和涉案家庭子女在父母的爭拗之中的行
為。當然,母親應避免這樣的行為。
在考慮全部因素後究竟法庭應頒一個怎的命令
127. 父親主張法庭應頒佈一個共同管養的命令父親特別指出,SEB v
ZX[65]中就共同管養權作出以下解讀︰
“15. Sometimes orders for joint custody are aspirational. They
are made in the hope that the parties’ will be able to work
towards co-operating with each other in the future.”
128.
父親又主張,在考慮應否頒發共同管養權時 ,法庭應考慮上訴庭夏正民法
官在PD v KW 一案的判詞,重點在第54段︰
“…the fact that, as a result of the breakdown of the marriage,
relations between the parents are strained is not of itself a
reason to refuse to make a joint order of custody. Nor is the
fact that the parent to be given care and control does not
agree. Such orders look to the future. They will govern a
limited area of exchange between the parents, albeit one of the
greatest importance.”
129.
父親一方指 ,婚姻期間父親一直參予家庭子女教育及醫療等福利事宜,也
一直積極參予家庭子女教育及醫療等福利事宜,也一直積極參予家庭子
女之日常生活。現時訴訟雙方劍拔弩張的情況,只是婚姻破裂所導致的
結果 ,而非源於雙方於婚姻期間本已缺乏共同管教子女或有效溝通的基
礎所導致,法庭不應因而拒絕一個共同管養命令。
130.
母親說[66],父親在2013年已經開始同方式暴力對待母親和家庭子女,令
母親和家庭子女經常提心吊膽並痛苦地生活。向來在家中有安裝閉路錄
影[67],母親在庭上播放了TKK-5,TKK-6,TKK-7三段錄音,母親說︰-
(1)
在2022年8月20日,父親在XX因為不滿母親不與他的朋友吃飯而大吼大罵及威
嚇母親,父親的態度讓母親感非常恐懼、害怕和擔心。母親播放了2022年8
月20日的錄音[68]。該片段長達近24分鐘,本席留意到︰
|第2-5分鐘 |父親不停罵母親而母親不停叫父親「唔好搞啲細路|
| |」 |
|第7:40 - 8:30 |父親說他喜歡温水煮蛙,他沒有打過一單管司是輸|
|分鐘 |的誰跟他鬥都會好後悔 |
|第15:00 - |父親說︰你點著我的火未必能撲熄 |
|16:20分鐘 | |
|第16:30-17:30 |父親說︰我唔會就你,我點解要就你,我都要人就|
|分鐘 |,你同我一齊咁多年我就過啲咩人...你點著我, |
| |核子彈爆炸 |
|第19:55-20:15 |父親說︰我唔會受氣架嘛,我受過咩人仔呀...我 |
|分鐘 |講左幾百次,唔係你哋,我唔知幾開心 |
|第22:10-22:30 |父親說︰喂我乜都做得出架...你想做乜都得,你 |
|分鐘 |就係唔好惹我,你惹我你自己計過條數 |
(2)
母親說,在2023年4月30日,父親在家發脾氣,並告訴母親他不允許本人帶二
仔參加一個同學的生日會。母親求父親容許二仔出席,並問大他如何才能二
仔參加生日會,父親回答說若母親從婚姻居所跳下去便可以。
131. 母親播放了2023年4月30日的錄音[69],本席注意到在大約第2:10-
2:50分鐘,有以下訴訟雙方之對話︰
|男聲 |It’s fucking totally shit ...唔係佢... ( ... 聽不清 |
| |... ) |
|女聲 |俾佢去啦好唔好?你點先肯比佢去啊( 男聲1︰跳樓啦你) |
| |你講咩話?(男聲1︰跳樓啊)你講多次,你叫我做乜嘢? |
|男聲 |乜嘢嘢啊而家? |
|女聲 |你頭先講咩,叫我做咩嘢嘢?你叫我跳樓?我有無聽錯? |
(3)
在2023年7月1日,父親跟母親說他希望與母親分開。母親在庭上播放了2023
年7月1日的錄音。本席留意到以下對話︰
|00:56-3:47|母親︰總之啲細路係邊度我就係邊度︰ |
| |父親︰唔好講啲模稜兩可嘅嘢,我唔係懵架我同你講清 |
| |楚 |
| |母親︰咩叫做模稜兩可呀... 你叫我去媽咪度,咁細路 |
| |呢 |
| |父親︰過埋去囉 |
| |母親︰即係叫我帶埋細路走係咪呀 |
| |父親︰你話要帶咪帶囉,我打慣仗,隨時準備, 「你要計 |
| |條數,唔好......偷雞唔到蝕揸米 |
| |本人︰你咩意思呀.......不如你唔好模稜兩可,你講清 |
| |楚你咩意思啦 |
| |父親︰我覺得我同你呢,生活唔到 |
| |本人︰咁細路點樣呀 |
| |父親︰打囉,有得傾嘅時候咪傾埋佢囉,唔好傾嘅時候同 |
| |我玩下法律囉。總之我唔會好似你個阿嫂咁樣,我唔會容|
| |許呢樣嘢,俾埋錢你養老公,你做唔到架,分分鐘你蝕俾我|
| |本人︰你話你同我生活唔到,咁我淨係想問,咁細路你想 |
| |點樣,總之我就一定要照顧細路嘅,我一定要睇住啲細路 |
| |同細路一齊嘅 |
| |父親︰睇下條件點囉 |
| |本人︰咩叫睇吓條件點呀,你講清楚 |
| |父親︰:我唔會好似你個阿嫂咁㗎,唔會有呢個情況出現 |
| |㗎我相信 |
| |本人︰我以前阿嫂就係要湊住XX,咁你依家係,咁我要求 |
| |係要湊住啲細路,咁你係咩意思呀 |
| |父親︰你自己湊就你自己搞掂,我自己湊就我自己搞掂, |
| |就咁簡單 |
| |本人︰即係你意思,你係咩意思呀講清楚啦不如 |
| |父親︰你自己湊你自己搞掂 |
| |本人︰咩叫我自己湊我自己搞掂 |
| |父親︰你自己養呀,改埋姓我都無所謂,我自己湊呢就我 |
| |搞掂。 |
|03:50 - |父親︰你叻啦。你搞我唔過㗎,無人搞得過我,XX(父親 |
|04:45 |的父親)......佢而家食緊......抑鬱藥呀,搞我呀嘛, |
| |佢幾多年呀......我都同你講細水長流,邊個係我上面瀨|
| |一刀,我要凌遲佢......求生不得求死不能,我同你講過 |
| |啦,我話父親的父親,去左求生啦。唔好傷害我,我就唔傷|
| |害你,就係咁簡單。 |
|07:40 - |父親︰你而家做啲嘢,啲嘢我睇係眼內㗎嘛,你同我呢算 |
|08:06 |唔贏我噢我同你講,你算唔贏我㗎,你唔好搞啦,你搞我唔|
| |到,你搞唔掂呢我就有一招咋嘛, 我同你鬥燒囉,燒到而 |
| |家拿,睇下邊個死先...你永遠都磨滅唔到嘅人生烙印係 |
| |你身上 |
132.
父親說,母親一方提出有關婚姻爭執的音用為證據,並於庭上花費相當長
的時間播放該等內容,這無非是為了詆毁父親的品格,除此之外並無其
它作用。父親說︰
(1)
從母親取得該些錄音的背景及方式而言,明顯屬其為自身利益而作出的行為。
有關錄音並非在雙方知情及到等情況下進行,而是由母親單方面策劃,父親
在完全不知情的情況下被錄音,母親則可控制錄音時的言行及情緒表達,促
而塑造較有利於其立場的內容 。此種證據形成方式存在明顯不公平,應審
慎看待其證明價值。
(2)
該錄音片段所呈現的 ,極其量為父親於婚姻關係中因感到失望及缺乏尊重而
流露的情緒反應 ,此等情緒表達屬特定情境下之自然反應 ,並不足以據此
推論父親全然喪失或無法履行其作為父母之一方所應承擔之共同教養責任。
(3)
上述情況均屬過住(甚至數年前)發生的事件及個別事件。父親承認,父母在
處理衝突時有需要作出適節,共同意應尊重家庭子女的觀感及情緒需要 ,
亦打算改善與子女及母親之溝通模式,包括聽取親和坊職員的專業意見,學
習如何改善親職關係。
133. 對此,本席有以下之看法︰
1)
並無爭議,前婚姻居所有攝錄機由父親裝置,母親提交之影音片段乃是前婚姻
之攝錄機收錄的片段 ,所以對父親所說父親是在完全不知情的情況下被錄
音的說法 ,本席並不同意;
2) 也無爭議,前婚姻居所攝錄機在2022年故障不能錄影,但仍可錄音;
3)
父親說,母親所提交所謂父親對母親的多段錄音片段,其實只是婚姻期間生活
部份片段不足以反映整體的實際情況,又說他在片段中母親的說話亦只是他
在情緒高漲時之負氣說話。本席認為母親提交的影音片段所顯示的不同事例
,前後經歷不同時間,不是一時一刻之個別事件,平情而論 ,有關內容應
是反映了父親的內心所想,不論父親是否會付諸行動,其說話所傳遞的訊息
,令母親受驚嚇而在內心心中產生對父親害怕,本席認為可理解。
134.
母親重覆強調,婚姻期間,父親已不住地在言語上精神上身體上以不同的
暴力方式對待家庭子女和母親、令他們經常提心吊膽地生活,自分居後
,更不斷以無理的行為給母親及家庭子女施加壓力,無視家庭子女懼怕
他的根源,他仍然無視其行為及態度,繼續作出令母親及家庭子女害怕
的行為,母親實在無法與父親同管養,雙方也不可能合作共親。
135.
本席注意到,從大約2024年9月30日開始,父親用甚難聽的說話來恐嚇母親
,包括︰
(1) 2024年9月30日[70]
“真正的理由我知的。
因為男人鐘意四圍唱...仲有相...鐘意同人家分享。
尊重你的孩子... ?尊重你自己?”
(2) 2024年10月1日[71]
我覺得我而家好污糟晒....令人作嘔....我哋啲仔女都俾你整到污槽睛···
我要洗一千次澡....都洗唔乾淨...”
(3) 2024年10月2日[72]
“原來大把人看過,最近的更精彩....你問你朋友拿相吧、何止相.......
噁心!尋刺激,人家影了你都不知...但有些可能你都知的...有啲仲俾人笑你
鐘意用vibrator....這些東西都會喺電子媒介無限巡迴...將來點面對孩子
?
怪不得你哪裡經常生瘤又流血....原來你那麼嘔心!我要立即去驗血,梅毒都
可以潛伏10年!都唔知你有咩病,我感覺好污糟!”
(4) 2024年10月11日[73]
“If you honest and tell the fact what did U do since last year,
I just want U to tell me from yourself, then I will accept that,
since it is a fact now, then I can have a bigger space to talk
about the kids “future living arrangement. I may surprise U of
how much space I can give about kids” arrangement with U.
But I can not accept the allegations U made in your documents. I
will fight to the end.
Again, I know everything, I just want to U to tell the real
thing”
(5) 於2024年10月12日[74]
“You think about this, as mentioned, it is better you tell me
what you did, the real reason behind, as said I will surprise U
of what U will get, including the custody matter. Then No need
to go throw the years long battle, which is harmful to all
sides.”
(6) 於2024年10月13日[75]
“離不離婚,你跟人睡了多少次(小孩將來肯定會欣賞到你「伴侶」
給你拍的傑作)、已不是重點。(但你想離婚,也不能屈我、砌我生豬肉,明明
你對我唔住,你屈我,我一定回報你,就算走到天涯海角、十年、二十年!)
...
離婚官司就是揭瘡疤... 你有沒有揭瘡疤?你家人有沒有揭瘡疤?
一揭起上來就「牽一髮動全身!」到時就火燒山!整個山頭都會著火.....何
止這單小小的離婚官司?
這是實際問題,不是面子問題,根本沒有選擇。
請認真考慮,傾還是不傾?”
(7) 於2024年10月14日[76]
“What I have on hand 唔一定用嚟打離婚.......還有好多地方用的著!
再講多次,Udon't know what I have on hands....
Again....若你認為我吹水即管試吓。
你同人搞咗幾多次?你真係當我傻....我已經同你講過好多次....你俾你「
伴侶」在小圈內周圍傳播!小圈可以變大圈!
你對我唔住!對啲仔女唔住!你簡直嘔心!
...天涯海角幾多年我都會嚟回報你...”
(8) 於2024年10月14日[77]
“你要揭續.....你要考慮清楚你有多少瘡疤?你家人有多少「瘡疤?」壞人才
有瘡疤你不要扮好人了!
你破壞我和孩子的關係....我一定去到盡對付「壞人!」 10年20年...”
“Again you don't know what I have on hands...
你好多以為自己信得過的老朋友...不知幾樂意提供資料!”
“不是人家在笑你...我們怎知道.... Vibrator!”
(9) 於2024年10月15日[78]
“你最近有沒有用,我們都知道......是你「近年」的拍檔在笑你...在分享
………是純X你………………人家都在「特別」社交平台分享你的經驗....你自己去找
找查查,不要說我吹水!又說我作大.....
都話男人最喜歡share...稍為一查就知道.....
若要人不知除非己莫為!何況個個男人鐘意四圍吹!我都提醒過你 ....”
(10) 於2024年10月15日[79]
“...這離婚官司不是你想像咁簡單的!你好快就知道!捲出嚟的東西可能比你
想像更大!
不要拿石頭揼自己的腳....我說過你不知石頭有幾重?你不知腳有幾痛?”
“真係實在很多你們的老朋友支持....我妹見了林律師,他專程來見了我們.
...巨細無遺的把你們的歷史作了詳盡說解.....林律師是誰啊?你們應該好
清楚啊。”
(11) 於2024年10月16日[80]
"Did U check? On that planform? They said the bruise on ur inner
upper leg were caused by hard pressed when he vigorously Fx U!
Yeah 1 remember I asked about that bruise...."
136.
在2024年9月13日,母親與家庭子女搬離前婚姻居所,並帶同RW1及是一位
家佣T到酒店暫住。母親說,於2024年9月16日母親獲酒店通知有數名警
員到酒店找母親。RW1
說,T的朋友為T報警,原因為擔心T在僱傭合約列出的工作地址以外的地
方工作。母親立即通知僱傭公司為兩名家傭更改其工作地址。其後一名
女警員到家庭子女的房間看看家庭子女的情況。於2024年9月18日,母親
再次獲酒店通知有數名警員到酒店找母親,警方告知母親RW2在一名律師
陪同下報警,指母親非法禁錮RW1。
137.
在2024年9月18日RW2辭職,在庭上[81],RW2同意當時有律師陪同報警,但
說律師並非由父親安排,而是由一個朋友轉介給她,又說沒有人支付律
師費用。在2024年9月28日,RW1[82]到邊境警署報案 ,指母親虐兒。在
2024年10月3日,RW1[83]、RW3[84]和另一位前家用L到中環警署報案指
母親虐兒。在2024年10月4日,母親解僱RW3。在2024年11月5日,父親向
法庭承諾不會直接或間接騷擾母親及家庭子女。在大約2024年底至2025
年初,父親先後聘用RW1、RW2、RW3為家傭和司機。現時父親1人居住,
本席同意母親所說,他一個聘用3名家傭及長機似乎並無必要。在2025年
2月20日,RW1、RW3、T及一名9年前已辭職的家傭向入境處投訴母親[85]
。在2025年4月7日,RW1向勞工處指控母親於2024年7月1日用燙斗襲擊她
,令她燙傷[86]。在2025年5月,RW1入禀勞資審裁處指稱母親欠她食物
津貼、假日補償、長期服務金及遣散費[87]。在同月RW3向勞工處指稱母
親欠她薪金、假日補償及機票費用。又在同月,T向勞工處小額薪酬索償
仲裁處興訟指稱母親欠她代通知金、假日補償及機票費用。母親說,她
需要花費大量精神、心機及資源來應付這些投訴和法律程序。在2025年
6月17日,勞資審裁處的聆訊,RW1和母親同意以港幣$3,000和解案件[88]
。其後,RW3決定不繼續其申索[89]。在2025年7月3日勞工處小額薪酬索
償仲裁處的聆訊,T同意撤回其申請[90]。約在2026年3月18日父親律師
去信母親律師他所知母親被拘捕及起訴虐兒[91]。在2026年4月27日,父
親律師再度出信重覆同一指稱[92]。分別在2026年4月27日和2026年5月
22日,母親律師回信不認其事[93]。母親澄清,至今勞工處或警方並沒
有對母親有任何拘捕或檢控行動。母親認為以上一連串事件都是父親一
手策劃的,目的在向母親找麻煩,向母親報復。對此,父親否認。家傭
也否認父親有參予其事。RW1說,在2024年9月13日,母親突然要求RW1和
其他家傭離開婚姻居所到酒店暫住,又不准許他們離開酒店,就算是出
外買一些個人衞生用品也不可以,至9月16日,RW1和其他家傭漸漸感到
害怕,於是他們發短訊給朋友,說受到非法禁錮,朋友報案,警方到酒
店作出調查。RW1和RW3又說,他們是出於關心和愛護家庭子女,所以就
母親虐兒報警。各家傭分別向勞工處,勞資審裁處作投訴,更是爭取權
益之行動。母親認為RW2不會有經濟能力聘請私人律師,也不相信她會特
意聘請律師,就此事為RW1報警。母親認為這些報警之事件是由父親安排
。RW1不爭議她並無經濟能力聘請私人律師,就她所說朋友介紹律師而又
不需要付律師費的說法,本席認為不合情理,也不可信。再者,不談母
親是否曾有虐兒行為,也不論家傭向勞工處、勞資審裁處作投訴是否爭
取權益行為,這一連串的明顯地有組織的行動剛好發生在母親帶同家庭
子女入住酒店之後的幾個月之內,本席認為並非偶然,從整體證供衡量
,本席接受母親所說,一連串的報警、投訴等行動,應是父親在背後組
織和策劃,目的在給母親添麻煩。
138.
大仔學校在2025年10月舉辦上海遊學團 ,父親同意大仔參予,但反對母親
及外婆同行,在這樣的情況下,因大仔特殊需要,學校認為需要大仔之
影子老師(Shadow
teacher)同行,這位影子老師在大仔在校事務上照顧大仔已有多個月,
但父親又說因為他不認識這位影子老師,反對這位影子老師同行。大仔
學校Portal上載有90份由影子老師發出報告大仔在學校的進度的報告[94]
,但父親卻不知道,本席認為若父親日常有跟進兒子在校之資訊,不應
會對影子老師不認識,事件糾纏了大約一個月,不但替訴訟雙方添上不
需要的麻煩,也令大仔擔心他會否不能參加遊學團,父親始終拒絕影子
老師同行,最後學校自行拍板決定[95]影子老師同行,而大仔可以參加
遊學團[96]。石主任作供時確認,學校就此事感到麻煩,大仔更因父親
的不合作而感到不開心、尷尬及反感[97]。
139.
本席也接受,以下事例也可見自婚姻破裂以來,訴訟雙方在互相溝通和家
庭子女事宜上的合作遭遇到的難處︰-
1)
在母親離開後 ,父親把她留在前婚姻居所的個人物品丟棄僅餘一雙球鞋。本
席不接受RW3說,母親自2023年起續搬走物品[98]的說法。
2)
並無爭論 ,婚姻期間父親一直支持次子報考XX,但2024年10月母親帶子女離
開後,父親改變態度要求母親先和他商量,否則他反對二仔報考XX[99],母
親就80萬債券反覆催問[100],但父親並無回覆。本席接受,當時二仔只佔
候補名額,尚未獲分配學位,但父親一概不覆的態度,本席認為無論如何並
非應有之合作態度。
3)
在2024年12月30日,因探視困難,父親向母親展開交付覊押法律程序。在20
25年2月11日,勞法官以便箋指示父親考慮以其他合理方法去應付探視上的
問題。如前所見,父親探視困難的因由錯綜複雜,如勞法官指示,父親本應
先考慮其他方法務實地面對探視上的困難,動不動便採用交付覊押程序,本
席認為並不是理想的做法。
4)
在大約2025年中,父親分別單方面更改大仔和二仔學校平台的登入密碼[101]。
5)
2025年暑假母親要求帶子女外遊兩星期,父親反對。父親的說法是法庭在20
25年5月19日委任潘博士為三名家庭子女之治療心理學家 ,子女應留港修補
父親與家庭子女關係。本席認為,子女短暫在暑期外遊,不應會妨礙潘博士
的治療工作,本席不接父親以上的說法。
6)
在2025年7月15日,父親透過一律師行去信,指母親造謠中傷父親 ,又稱父親
打算就此向母親展開法律行為包括交付覊押程序。[102]
7)
在2025年9月19日父親被落案起訴襲擊兩名兒子,保釋條件之一是不得直接或
間接騷擾或影響控方證人 。兩名兒子是控方證人 ,但父親分別在2025年在
9月20日及10月11日,透過親和坊向二仔寫卡,內容包括「請不要誇大說爸
爸虐待你」之類字眼。[103]
8)
在2026年4月30日,父親律師去信母親律師,指母親擅自將法庭2026年1月16
日之命令圖片以電郵送給大仔學校,違反《婚姻訟訴規則》第121條。[104]
9)
訴訟雙方接連不斷的以律師信就小事(女兒接觸媒體、二仔眼傷、護照更新、
賽馬會附屬卡)[105]互相糾纏,這些全屬本應透過親職協調員的簡單處理
的事務。
140. 父親主張法庭應採納梁主任和石主任共同管養之建議。
141. 黃姑娘作供時[106],代表父親李大律師問黃姑娘︰-
問: 妳會唔會同意,我代表爸爸講緊 joint custody 喇,呢一個擁有--
雙方都擁有joint custody,呢一個作為一個正面嘅訊息畀兩個--
畀兩個仔,對佢哋嗰個心理上嚟講,對佢哋嗰個福祉嚟講係唔係一個正面
嘅事情?
黃姑娘答︰
答: 呢個係一個好難答嘅問題。
...
答:
係喇,82段,係喇,我明白即係李大狀講緊81段都有一啲相關。其實你見我
個報告其實冇好明言係 joint custody 定係 sole custody
係比較合適嘅。係喇,咁即係當然有個原因我係咁樣去寫喇。因為其實如
果正常普遍大部分嘅個案呢,即係其實都係 joint
custody,對於小朋友嘅無論即係佢哋自己去理解呢樣嘢喇,或者佢哋成個
發展喇,就嗰種嘅 well-being
喇,其實一定係相對比較合適嘅。只係一啲好少數嘅個案 sole
custody 會比較合適,例如就係一啲--以我所知就係一啲好 abusive
嘅 case 喇,非常非常之 abusive 喇,或者令到小朋友真係有好多嘅
danger喇,有好危--有好多好 immanent 嘅 risk 喇,
咁呢個狀態之下就會可能 sole custody
係真係可以保障到小朋友嘅安危嘅。
係喇,或者有一啲係即係父母之間佢哋自己去
agree咗,可能係方便佢哋移民諸如此類,先至會係 sole
custody,呢個其實即係一個大方向嚟嘅,係喇。咁但係而家個狀況就係,
喺呢一個即係個案入面,爸爸媽媽其實 joint custody
係咪一樣可行嘅嘢囉,係喇,反而係個可行性。係喇,因為如果你問真係好
整體去講,我當然係support joint
custody嘅。但係我睇到而家個情況就係,其實我都有寫到,其實亦都好坦
白講,我覺得呢個係媽媽方面可能係需要去努力嘅部分都多嘅,係喇,就係
媽媽點樣樣去handle 自己嘅一啲--即係唔好介意我咁講,去 handle
自己嘅呢個即係 emotion 喇,自己嘅狀況,同埋佢點樣去 support
到小朋友,因為而家其實爸爸對於小朋友嘅接觸真係好少,
所以相對就係媽媽嗰方面可以點樣去 handle
到自己嘅情緒或者加埋小朋友嘅情緒可以比較合適一點呢,其實呢個
joint custody 先係會--同埋 co-parenting
先會比較可以真正實行到囉,係喇,即係如果你問我合適嘅,一定係joint
custody 比較合適,不過實唔實行到係另一另外一回事喇。
142. 代表母親余資深大律師對黃姑娘則有以下之問答[107]︰-
問:
但係我想問一問,係唔係喺妳嘅分析入面,因為妳見過佢哋咁多個喇...
答: 唔。
問: ...其實 sole custody 都有佢個好處嘅,喺呢件個案?
答: 可以咁講嘅。
問: 或者妳可唔可以解釋有乜嘢好處呀,喺呢件個案?
答: 我諗係如果 sole custody 嘅話,會讓媽媽嗰個 sense of safety
會比較高一啲嘅。
問: 點解呢?
答: 例如如果有一啲 major decision,當然喇,就算有 sole custody
都好,咁當然都好鼓勵父母之間會去溝通喇,係咪?咁但係如果真係有一啲
嘢好需要 make
decision,而佢哋又真係有好分歧嘅一啲狀況嘅話,咁呢個 sole
custody 係相對比較容易啲 come to 一個 decision嘅。
問: 咁就處理咗先喇?
答:係喇,處理咗先喇,係喇,即係有一啲嘢可以即係順暢一點喇。係喇,即
係亦都會讓可能即係媽媽覺得個照顧小朋友方面嘅掣肘冇咁多喇,係喇,
咁樣樣,咁
問: 咁除咗呢一個好處呢?
答: 咁同埋--即係頭先我講過,即係都係啲 co-parenting 上面可以--
即係可以減。省喇,讓媽媽 feel safe喇。
問: 係,係,係。
答: 係喇,咁就仲有另一個我諗就係 access
上面嘅嘢喇,即係我唔知可唔可以咁樣去 speculate
喇,即係如果真係有 sole custody 話我唔知道小朋友曬個 access
仲可以即係維持到幾耐,呢個其實我都會諗嘅。咁如果小朋友係真係好似
大仔咁樣講一個 total cut off嘅話,咁佢嗰刻會覺得自己個 sense
of safety 好似比較多一啲,首先,雖然佢而家都已經冇去
access㗎喇。係喇,
即係呢一啲部分可能係會讓到即係媽媽同三個小朋友嗰個 sense of
safety會比較高一啲囉,係喇。
問: 個sense of safety 亦都會係直接影響小朋友曬個
perception,妳講緊扣實係個小朋友個 perception?
答: 呢個係。
問: Okay,咁會唔會多一個考慮點,就係如果媽媽有 sole
custody,可以減低咗一啲不必要嘅衝突,令到啲小朋友覺得安心咗喇?
答: 係。
問: 點解呢件個案妳覺得 sole custody 有呢啲嘅好處呀?
答: 因為呢個真係 sole custody 嘅好處囉,咪就係呢個個案囉。
問: 明白,明白。
答: 因為因為有啲難答。
問: 明白。
答:
係喇,同埋尤其是好感受到,就係因為主要係媽媽喇,另外都連帶住小朋友
喇佢哋嗰個 fear 好大。
問: 唔。
答: 係喇,所以真係如果 sole custody 可以--即係可以 enhance
到呢個 sense of safety囉,可以讓佢哋覺得--
可以畀佢有自己嘅空間多啲,我估呢一個對佢哋嗰個 recovery
係會好一啲嘅。
問:
反而而家我哋睇番,即係溝通又唔到呀,繼續喺度即係有衝突呀,會唔會係
更令到啲小朋友嗰個擔心或者嗰個安全感低咗呢?
答: 會,所以呢個先係我咁難 make 個 recommendation 嘅原因。
問: 我都睇到妳係好艱難,我直情見到妳眼眉中間有皺紋...
答: 係。
問: ...所以我就問清楚。
答: 唔。
問: 當然喇,如果法庭倒頭來決定係 sole
custody,如果呀吓,因為唔係我定喇...
答: 唔。
問: ...都可以繼續維持呢一個 access㗎?
答: 係。
問: 而實際上如果喺 sole custody
入面啲小朋友覺得安全感高咗,其實會唔加容易同爸爸彌補到嗰啲關係呢
?
答: 係有機會嘅。
問: 因為佢會--即係佢起碼個磨擦少咗,啲小朋友個信心就大咗喇會...
答: 唔。
問: ...對爸爸?
答: 大前提係一定要即係個 access
要可以繼續進行到喇,同埋爸爸都唔好因為咁樣 B 而洩氣囉,如果真係-
-真係冇辦法喇,let's say evil,即係 sole custody
嘅話,係喇,爸爸都--即係希望鼓勵爸爸都唔好放棄囉,係喇。
問: 當然,當然,因為當然個目的唔係話要切斷嗰個關係。
答: 唔。
問:
問題只係希望可以喺一個安全嘅環境,等啲小朋友覺得安全,而增加改善
同爸爸嗰個關係嘅。
答: 唔。
問: 就好過喺 joint custody
如果大家個溝通溝通唔到,不停喺度爭拗,啲小朋友可能就會將嗰件事歸
咎於個爸爸?
答: 係嘅。
問: 有呢個風險㗎其實,喺呢件...
答: 係有呢個...
問: 喺呢個個案?
答: 係有呢個風險嘅,係。
問: 唔該
143. 作供時[108],李大律師問和梁主任回答如下︰-
問:
哪,爸爸喺呢個訴訟入面有一個好大嘅擔心,亦都有同妳講嘅,就係話佢好
擔心媽媽嗰個目的就係唔要咗佢,cut off
咗佢,打走咗佢,就小朋友又好,媽咪又好,就呢世就唔使再 deal with
呢個爸爸喇。
答: 唔。
問: 妳首先第一題問題,妳理唔理解爸爸有一個咁樣樣嘅擔心呀?
答: 唔,都可以係理解嘅。
問:
下一題問題,就係妳覺得咁樣樣嘅情況之下,爸爸有呢一個擔心係一個佢
自己諗多咗吖,定係一個都係一個合理嘅擔心嚟㗎?
答: 我覺得係合理嘅擔心,given喺一個 access
嘅狀況之下見唔到小朋友。
問: 咁呢樣同妳對嗰個--我知妳而家建議咗 joint custody 喇,有冇--
有冇關係㗎,有冇關連呀,即係爸爸呢一個擔心,有冇喺妳個考慮入面呀?
妳 recommend joint custody
嘅時候,有冇考慮埋爸爸好擔心,就係如果係一個 sole
custody呢,媽媽就好似--就好似明正言順咁去 cut off 佢喇。
答: 我諗我考慮 joint custody 個 prospective
都係多啲咪小朋友嘅角度,佢個成長需要,係,我冇我別去即係考納(考慮
?)話爸爸話好擔心呀,sole custody,佢就等於 being kicked off
呢個大人嘅prospective.
問: 即係反而就話妳而家建議呢個 joint custody 係--
妳係考慮小朋友嘅福祉為先,係咪?
答: 唔,冇錯。
問: 唔,當然妳都 qualify
咗妳嘅答案幾次喇,就係話好睇佢哋嗰個共親同埋嗰個溝通喇。
答: 係。
問: 咁而家知道有專業人士幫手,不過又未真係睇到個終點係點喇。
答: 係。
問: 係咪?即係你嘅答案係咁嘅意思吖嘛。
答: 係。
問: 咁我想問妳,妳嘅觀察關於爸爸共親嗰個能力係點呀?
答: 我覺得如果有一個--即係keep 住有一個 professional 嘅
intervention 或者 assistance,爸爸係有能力去做 co-
parenting嘅。
問: 由妳自己自聞目睹喇,妳都喺探視幾次見到...
答: 唔=
問: ...爸爸有冇一個想進步嘅心呀?即係就住共親嚟講?
答: 有嘅。
問: 有冇一個能力嚟睇呀,有冇一個 ability,進步嘅空間?共親,爸爸?
答: 我都相信有嘅given係見到爸爸都係積極,同埋keep住有同 Ms
Li去溝通嘅
144. 接著,余資深大律師與梁主任有以下之提問和回答︰-
問: Okay,
okay,嚀,另一個議題我想請教妳,就係妳知道喺呢件個案件面,有小朋友
認為--唔好理佢真定假,認為--
有呢個觀感,就係曾經爸爸係對佢好差。
答: 唔。
問: 無論精神上,肉體上。
答: 係。
問:
好差。咁如果佢哋有呢一個觀感,而爸爸唔適當地處理呢一種嘅觀感,仲
要畀合爸有一個管理佢哋嘅權,會唔會更加傷害呢個小朋友?
答: 唔。
問: 我諗妳都聽過黃姑娘嗰個證供喇。
答: 係。
問: 妳覺得會唔會呢?
答:
所以喺我嘅報告入面,我亦都有提及其實爸爸都要再去學習佢嗰個即
parenting 咁樣囉。
問: 其實--
係,其實報告妳都講得好清楚嘅,就係話爸爸似乎對佢個parenting
態度喇,係未能夠認真去處理,認真去對待,但需要改善,對嘛?
答: 我會咁樣演繹,喺我嘅報告入面,我嘅理解就係爸爸未必有好大嘅--
即係我哋叫做即係 insight 去知道自己嗰種 parenting
原來未必係即係咁 child-centered 或者 child focus嘅。
問: 唔,唔。
答: 係,佢係想--佢喺佢嘅 prospective
之下,佢覺得佢自己個parenting approach 係一個 good
intention嘅,係喇。咁但係似乎喺小朋友feedback,即係喺我哋嘅觀察同
埋 assessment入面,似乎就係未能夠去及到child focus
嘅。但係我睇到爸爸其實係--佢係即係--即係--所以佢--
好建議佢係要即係接受一啲嘅--
即係專業嘅介入,係喇,希望佢可以理解點樣為之一個叫 child-
centered 嘅 approach去同小朋友相處。
問: 總之就係喺妳準備妳嘅報告嘅時間...
答: 唔。
問: ...爸爸就仲未能夠理解,或者改善到點樣一啲所謂由 child-
centered
即係去從細路仔嘅角度去點樣樣去接受佢哋嗰個感受,嗰個教育方法。
答: 可以係嘅,係咁樣理解,唔。
問: 當然係停留喺妳係準備呢個報告嗰個時間喇。
答: 係,係。
問:
嗱,我又想問一問,香港其實嗰啲協調員,PC呢,都唔係好多嘅,係咪嘅認知
。
答: 係,我唔肯定。
問: 妳唔肯定,okay,香港嘅--
或者從妳嘅經驗喇,香港處理一啲咁高度衝突嘅案嘅PC,會唔會好多時都
辭職㗎?
答: 我都唔知道。
問: 妳都唔知,唔該,嚀,呢一度我哋就聽到黃姑娘嗰日作供講嘅事喇。
答: 唔。
間: 我哋亦都睇到黃姑娘就呢個 label
都幾為難。我想問一問妳,從妳嘅角度, 果係 sole custody...
答: 唔。
問:
...對呢幾個小朋友有冇好處?尤其是呢個個案入面,因為呢個個案係相當
特嘅一個個案,我相信妳會接受。
答: 唔。
問: 或者妳講畀法庭聽。
答:
我嘗試咁樣去表達我嘅諗法,我唔敢話有冇好處,因為我覺得如果講得好
處, 係一個 future-oriented 嘅東西喇。
問: 唔。
答: 係嘅。咁我只能夠講,如果喺一個 sole
custody入面,我諗小朋友對於由小朋友嘅角度去睇嘅話...
問: 當然喇。
答: ... 佢哋好快可能會感受嘅, 就係好多決定好似即時respond
到我喇, 係喇,我諗呢個係 from小朋友嘅prospective
(perspective?),
好快睇到嘅東西嚟。咁而當小朋友覺得喺時間性上面可能咁快可以--
即係可以被answer,或者被關注到佢嘅需要的時侯,我諗呢個就係所謂嘅
--所謂嘅好處喇, 係喇。咁但係喺一個--即係調番轉,我都要 address
嘅,就係喺小朋友嘅成長人面,我從來仍然都係堅持同埋覺得,即係佢哋係
需要了解雙方父母都係有積極參與喺佢哋嘅生命入面,
呢個對佢哋成長嘅韌力係好重要嘅,
我覺得,係。咁所以如果佢喺一個即係-
-現階段好快佢就知道呀「我啲嘢解決到喇」,當然呢個可能喺小朋友
prospective (perspective?)係好處。但係長遠佢--
即係喺佢嘅人生入面佢缺乏咗,原來知道因為 born to
be父母,就應該係參與喺佢人生嘅事項入面喇。係呀,咁一路長大,我會有
個關注,就係其實呢個係咪即係所謂嘅即係好呢,咁樣囉。
問: 唔,唔。
答: 所以係唔好意思,我唔--我唔--真係有啲艱難嘅。
問: 我知道有啲艱難。
答: 真係好艱難。
145.
父親關心子女,又希望能在將來支持他們的發展。梁主任和石主任都建議
共同管養。但本席注意到,梁主任和石主任的建議,均建基於一個明確
先決條件,就是必須有親職協調員。本席認為,不言而喻,這親職協調
員也需要能夠在個案中發揮到協調的作用。在2025年6月25日,訴訟雙方
同意委任蔡律師為親職協調員[109],在2025年7月23日,即不到一個月
以內,父親出信表示希望聘請其他人士為親職協調員[110],母親反對[111]
,在2025年8月初,父親卻告訴石主任因為工作態度不同,他已停止蔡律
師的服務[112],在2025年9月5日之聆訊,父親同意重新聘用蔡律師[113]
。其後,蔡律師向母親表示可以作為調解員處理本個案,母親拒絕[114]
,在大約2025年10月16日,蔡律師辭職[115]。由始至終 ,蔡律師並沒
有替訴訟雙方進行任何就子女事宜協調的工作。
146.
在2026年1月16日,法庭委任麥律師作為親職協調員,在2026年5月22日麥
律師電郵母親[116],說因為父親聲稱自己不能支付相關的費用,共希望
尋求非政府志願機構的服務,父親又沒有就麥律師為期3個月的工作計劃
給予意見,所以麥律師會停止服務。在2026年5月25日,父親律師出信說
,父親在2025年5月22日,當日下午4時05分已再電郵麥律師,答應會付
費用和接受為期3月之計劃。麥律師經法庭委任,但父親卻打算單方面停
止麥律師的服務,事前既無尋求法庭的指示,也無事前就母親商量,本
席認為做法極之不理想。
總結和頒令
147. 上訴法庭在WSM v
FSY[117]案指出,社會福利署調查報告,是法庭需考慮的重要資料,以
決定甚麼是孩子的最佳利益。如果法官不依靠調查報告的建議而另行決
定,給予的理由往往就是拒絶接納建議的原因。調查報告並非一種特殊
的重要資料,提出的建議也不是需要反駁的法律推定。在每宗案件法官
都需要按照事實背景作出獨立考慮,決定是否接納報告全部或部份的建
議,又或者是不接納建議,歸根究底,裁定是必須以孩子的最佳利益為
依歸。回顧過去,明顯地訴訟雙方都無善用親職協調員的服務而親職協
調員也並無發揮到任何應有之功效。黃姑娘、梁主任、石主任都表示訴
訟雙方之間存在溝通上極大的困難及互不信任。本席認為,從以上所列
各項事例,無疑訴訟雙方能在子女福利事宜上互相合作有着很大的困難
,而這並非如父親所說現時訴訟雙方劍拔弩張的情況,只是婚姻破裂所
導致的結果。又在親職協調員的功效成疑的情況下,本席認為共同管養
的可行性也大打折扣,所以對兩位調查主任所說訴訟雙方在親職協調員
協助下有能力共同管養的說法也有所保留。
148.
法庭在考慮是否給予共同管養權或獨自管養權時首要的考慮是家庭子女的
福利 /
最佳利益,除非雙方有互相合作的合理前景,否則法庭不一定給予共同
管養權,互相合作的合理前景的標準,可以指雙方沒有存在太多分歧,
及有真正證據顯示雙方為了孩子著想彼此可以真正的合作。故此,共同
管養是否可行,很大程度上取決於父母是否可以合作,如果雙方沒有互
相合作合理前景,判予共同管養權可能會導致災難性的情況違反孩子的
福利 /
最佳利益。若果共同管養明顯不可行,法庭不大可能只為鼓勵雙方克服
他們的分歧而仍然給予共同管養令,勉強父母合作,只會令子女的利益
更加受損。
149.
父親明顯不了解為何子女抗拒他 。父親只是將問題歸咎因母親和婆婆抯撓
和疏離行為致家庭子女有抗拒的表現;總之問題不在父親身上。
150.
父親極力爭取家庭子女共同管養權。在一般情況下,父母雙方離異,一個
共同管養權命令,俾父母能夠共同參予日後子女管養方面的事宜 ,符合
子女最佳利益︰見PD v KWW (Child Joint Custody)
[118]。從本案件的發展情況和訴訟雙方在審訊時的表現來看,他們分別
對對方都存在很大的成見,親職協調是否能協助又存疑。經小心考慮以
後,本席認為他們對另一方的猜疑將令他們無法有效溝通或互相合作。
151.
本席認為,父親仍不了解問題癥結的所在,雙方有嚴重的溝通問題,就這
問題而言本席採納上訴法庭羅傑志法官在Y v P (Custody)[119]
一案中確認了的法律原則︰即如父母雙方不能日後在子女的重大問題上
務實的互相合作,從而作出理性的決定,一個共同管養權的命令並不符
合子女的最佳益。以上的原則得上訴庭夏正民法官(該時的官階)在DP
對 KKW
一案中引用。就本案來說,訴訟雙方根本並沒有合作的基礎,因此本席
認為一個共同的管養權命令在本案並不適合。
152.
小心考慮本案全部情況後,本席認為將家庭子女的單獨管養權頒予母親,
符合家庭子女的最佳利益。
153.
母親同意應讓父親與家庭子女保持聯繫,不致因父母離異而剝奪兒子享受
父愛的權利。母親說,理解即使獲得單獨管養權,她仍有責任就家庭子
女的重大事宜通知父親並諮詢他的意見。
154.
黃姑娘在2025年5月6日之報告說,母親恐懼和焦慮,會令她忽略了維持父
親與家庭子女關係會帶來的益處[120],對此母親實需要對此加以注意。
155.
然而,母親還是配合父親探視安排的。在2025年5月9日的社會福利調查報
告,梁主任轉述親和坊李姑娘說︰
Views of Ms LI/SCSC
58. Ms LI confirmed that both parents had respectively completed
the co-parenting courses of six hours in January 2025. Reviewing
the interactions and observations over the past few months, Ms
LI commented that the Mother had shown herself supportive in
bringing the two younger children to attend the access sessions
although there were times, especially during the initial access
sessions, that the Mother had appeared to be highly anxious with
the Children’s safety during the father-children access that her
emotional state might inadvertently reinforce the Children's
fears. ...
在2025年11月18日的報告,轉述李姑娘石主任說︰-
62. On the other hand, the mother, the Mother facilitated the
children's attendance and verbally encouraged them to engage
with paternal gifts. She simultaneously expressed strong
concerns about the children's emotional well-being after
visitation. ...
156.
母親同意及確認,她會就家庭子女的重大事宜,包括教育、醫療及宗教事
宜透過親職協調員通知父親,並徵詢和考慮父親的意見,又會透過親職
協調員每個月與父親分享家庭子女在生活、學習及心理方面的狀況;一
直以來,母親也能夠大致上配合法庭的安排帶同二仔和女兒出席親和坊
與父親探視。本席相信,縱使母親獲單獨管養,父親也將會能夠保持和
家庭子女的聯繫。
157.
本席希望父親不要因為法庭將家庭子女的單獨管養權交給母親,視為他個
人的失敗。沒有家庭子女的單獨管養權,並不代表他對有關子女將來的
福祉的重大決定沒有任何的發言權。雙方都須明白,如父親發覺子女的
利益受損,他是有權就此要求法庭作出指示的。當然,父母雙方應理性
的以協商的方式去處理問題,而不是動輒興訟。如雙方真是就每一個子
女的問題都要以訴訟方式來解決 ,這會對子女造成巨大的壓力,這肯定
不是家庭子女之福。
158.
父親說,他參加親職課程,又向親和坊的社工學習親子和共親之道,明白
到從前嚴厲的管教方法並不合,也在學習合宜的與家庭子女相處的技巧
和方法,強調雖然探視不太成功,亦不符合他的期望,但他屢敗屢試,
一年多來準時到親和坊又會準備小禮物、心意咭,希望能籍這些方法來
打動家庭子女,突破探視困難。
159. 在2025年5月6日的報告,黃姑娘說︰-
74. While the Father shows awareness and willingness to
reflect on his parenting methods to cater the individual
characteristics of the children, he still struggles with
empathizing and understanding the children’s feelings. He often
uses adult reasoning and his own experiences to interpret their
responses, having difficulty to ;recognize the fear and
discomfort his parenting methods may instill. His reliance on
educating the consequences and corporal punishment may be viewed
as threatening by the children.
…
76.With nearly no communication between the parents and the
intense custody conflicts, it is not surprising that the Father
would seek updates on the children in his own way. However, his
methods can sometimes be intrusive, such as obtaining
information from the children’s driver. Given that the mother
and the children already demonstrate significant fear, this
behavior may further exacerbate their anxiety.
…
85.Furthermore, it is crucial to enhance the sense of safety for
both the mother and the children to facilitate the resumption of
communication. The father should refrain from any intrusive
means of overseeing the children’s lives, as this will only
perpetuate their fear.
160. 在2025年5月9日之報告,梁主任說︰-
58. Ms LI confirmed that both parents had respectively completed
the co-parenting courses of six hours in January 2025. ...
Reportedly, the Father had shown his willingness and commitment
to engage in the access sessions but he might need to adopt a
more gradual approach in consideration of the children’s
emotional readiness.
161. 在2025年11月18日之報告,石主任說︰-
61. Ms LI/SCS furthered that the Father demonstrated consistent
commitment through meticulous preparation of session materials
(gifts, cards, activities), often seeking social workers’ input.
He followed SCSC’s protocols, maintained appropriate physical
boundaries during sessions, and participated constructively in
post-visitation reviews. He generally attributed children’s
resistance to maternal influence while showing some capacity to
consider their emotional perspective.
162. 在2026年5月15日的進度報告,黃姑娘說︰-
The Father
45. It is acknowledged that the Father has demonstrated
persistent effort in reaching out to the children, including
Aiden though no in person access could be arranged at this time
being. These efforts have contributed to a softening in Aiden's
negative stance toward him, and it is encouraged that he
continues with this approach. The Father is reminded to follow
the guidance of the social worker Ms. Carol LI in preparing
cards and gifts, ensuring that these gestures remain
constructive and supportive.
46. At the same time, the Father's communication patterns have
contributed to tension with the Mother. His silence in response
to the Mother's legal letters, combined with his occasional
correspondence that appeared reactive, mood-driven, or focused
on minor daily matters, has reinforced the Mother's perception
of him as uncaring and obstructive, thereby contributing to her
increased stress. This dynamic has further strained their
relationship and hindered co-parenting. It is therefore
recommended that the Father avoid non-responsiveness to formal
communication and refrain from using legal letters for minor
tasks or as an outlet for emotional expression. Constructive use
of mediation and the support of a parent coordinator should be
prioritized to facilitate healthier communication and
cooperation.
47. Furthermore, attention is drawn to the tone and wording the
Father employs in communication with external parties, such as
the school. At times, his manner has been perceived as rude or
overly forceful, which risks creating misunderstanding and
opposition. Such communication style may inadvertently harm
relationships among all parties and negatively affect the eldest
son. Importantly, this might create unnecessary misunderstanding
for the eldest son toward the father, thereby further worsening
the father-son relationship. In turn, fostering positive
collaboration with external parties will benefit the father-son
relationship. Careful and respectful communication is advised to
prevent unnecessary conflict and misunderstanding and to
safeguard the eldest son's best interests.
48. The father's genuine concern for the child's safety is
acknowledged; however, when expressed in an excessive manner, it
risks creating misunderstandings with both the children and the
mother. This dynamic may hinder efforts to rebuild the
relationship, particularly with the eldest son. It is therefore
recommended that the father address these worries through
effective communication with the Mother and relevant parties,
supported by a mediator or parent coordinator.
...
51. For the Father, it is important to acknowledge the hurts
experienced by the children, even if he perceives those
incidents as insignificant or common. Recognition of the
children's distress is essential to rebuilding trust and
relationship, and to fostering their emotional well-being.
52. It is recommended that the Father receive professional
support, potentially from Dr. POON, to strengthen his ability to
communicate effectively with the Mother and external parties.
Such support could also help him reflect on his parenting
practices and develop the skills necessary to rebuild
relationships with his three children.
163.
父親肯花時間去學習又聽從親和坊社工的指導,希望能改進他的管教方法
和親子技巧,這些都是好的。但本席盼望,父親也能多注意和跟進,黃
姑娘在2026年5月15日進度報告,所給他的建議。
164.
母親爭取法庭取消限制子女離境安排,父親反對。家庭子女持美國護照、
英國護照,本席認為父親對取消限制離境安排有顧慮並非無理,所以也
不打算領令取消限制離境安排。母親爭取取消子女離境限制,主要是子
女渴望外遊。經討論後,訴訟雙方原則上接受︰-
1)
母親可每年不多於5次帶同每名家庭子女(任何一位兩位或全部)離開香港司
法管轄區作短暫旅遊不多於72小時 ,母親須於出發前7天透過親職協調員知
會父親相關旅遊的目的地國家旅程及日期;
2)
母親可在每年暑假不多1次帶同每名家庭子女(任何一位兩位或全部)離開香
港司法管轄區作旅遊不多於45天,母親須於出發前7天透過親職協調員知會
父親相關旅遊的目的地國家旅程及日期;
3)
母親可每年不多於2次在家庭子女的學校假期帶同每名家庭子女(任何一位兩
位或全部)離開香港法管轄區作短暫旅遊,總共不多於14天,母親須於出發
前7天透過親職協調員知會父親相關旅遊的目的地國家旅程及日期;
165.
父親也表示他會配合母親以同意申請方式就家庭子女每次外遊向法庭申請
離境許可。
命令
166. 本席現頒發命令將家庭子女單獨管養權給予母親。
其他
167. 最後,本席就本審訊訴訟程序進行之情況有以下之評述︰-
1)
母親在第二份誓章提交了蔡醫生日期為2023年10月5日之精神狀況報告[121],
蔡醫生當時診斷母親患創傷後壓力症及被虐者候群症 ,母親將蔡醫生報告
包括在審訊文件冊裡面。在審訊第一天,本席指出母親並無法庭許可提交這
份專家報告,而除非經區域法院許可或所有各方均同意 ,否則不得在任何
訟案或事宜審訊時援引專家證據。父親方面隨即反對母親提交蔡醫生報告。
[122]在審訊第二天,本席頒令剔除蔡醫生的報告,又在審訊第六天按父親
申請頒令委任黃醫生為單一共聘專家對母親狀況作評估。訴訟雙方法律團隊
都不察覺到母親並無許可便打算在審訊中引用蔡醫生報告,本席認為這是難
以理解的失誤 ,也正因蔡醫生的報告剔除而需要委任黃醫生重新做報告,
因為需要安排足夠時間給黃醫做報告,又需要給石主任、父親和母親在作供
前有機會知道黃醫生的診斷,本席不得不押後了石主任、父親和母親作供之
安排,案件也押後至2026年5月26至29日續審。訴訟雙方法律團隊以上的失
誤,令法庭及訴訟雙方都浪費了寶貴的審訊時間。
2)
在2026年1月16日,本席已發出許可黃醫生進行對母親精神狀況作出評估 ,但
母親事務律師竟然正正為黃醫生是否可對母親精神狀況而不單單就母親是否
患創傷後遺症和被虐候群症作評估而爭持不下兩個多月,期間書信往來洋洋
灑灑連附件共幾十頁[123]。對此,本席更是感到難以理解。
3)
訴訟雙方都指責對方總是透過律師書信處理有關家庭子女福利的大小事宜,包
括不少瑣碎的事。在過去差不多兩年時間訴訟雙方往來不少於120封信件 ,
其中內容一般來說,大都都有關處理家庭子女福利的大小事宜,而雙方卻都
從來未有善用親職協調員的服務。訴訟雙方是否都應反躬自省而並不是只指
責對方?本席希望日後訴訟雙方能多利用親職調解員之協助。
4)
就母親事務律師2026年5月22日的信件[124],在信中母親事務律師指父親向黃
姑娘承認父親向母親發出2026年3月18日和2026年4月27日兩封信目的為向母
親「“revenge”(平反)」。事實上 ,黃姑娘在報告[125]中清清楚楚地寫
︰ “However, he subsequently acknowledged that the letter was
also intended as a form of vindication (「平反」)for himself,
…”。為何 “vindication” 會變成 “revenge”
,本席看不到合理解釋。父親說,他對“revenge”的說法十分不滿。對此,
本席認為可以理解。
5) 此外,尚有不少問題,母親事務律師應多加注意︰-
i)
實務指示5.6明文規定,拉杆拱形活頁文件夾和環型活頁文件夾切忌放進
過多的文件,絕不應超過250頁,但本審訊之A、B1、B2、B4文件冊,
都遠超250頁,B2和B4更是超過500頁,使用上來十分笨重和不便;
ii)
在供法庭用之審訊文件冊內,不少原彩色照片,都只提供了黑白影印本
,這也造成了不便;
iii) 在審訊期間,母親事務律師的手提電來電嚮機,打擾了審訊程序;
iv)
在預備續審時,本席覺察到母親事務律師尚未草擬法庭在2026年1月16
日作出的三個命令,查問下,事務律師答他「唔記得咗」!?
訟費
168.
就子女事宜,本席認為應作無訟費命令,包括保留訟費。這一個暫准命令
,如雙方在判案書頒發後的14天內沒有任何申請,有關的暫准訟費命令
將轉為絕對命令。
(彭家光)
區域法院暫委法官
呈請人︰ 由鄭煥新、蔡秀蓮律師行轉聘余承章資深大律師、臧藿瀞大律師代表
答辯人︰ 葉永青、稀連達律師行轉聘李傲寰大律師代表
-----------------------
[1] 控罪書[C449]
[2] 控罪書[C450-451]
[3] 控罪書[C452]
[4] 審訊文件冊 B228-272
[5] 文件冊C342-C344
[6] 高等法院規則第38號命令第35A條規則
[7] 文件冊B1409-B1492
[8] [2010] 4 HKLRD 191, 198-201, 206-207
[9] H v N [2012] 5 HKLRD 498, [26][27][28]
[10] 審訊第一天下午
[11] 審訊第7天
[12] 母親第一份誓章文件冊31-50;母親第二份誓章文件冊A63-
65;母親第七份誓章文件冊A248-250
[13] 審訊文件冊B9謄本文件冊1-18
[14] 審訊文件冊B10謄本文件冊19
[15] 審訊文件冊B11謄本文件冊23-29
[16] 審訊文件冊B12謄本文件冊30-31
[17] 審訊文件冊B13謄本文件冊32-33
[18] 審訊文件冊B54謄本文件冊34-42
[19] 審訊文件冊B127謄本文件冊43-45
[20] 審訊文件冊B128謄本文件冊46-47
[21] 審訊文件冊B129謄本文件冊48
[22] 審訊文件冊B130謄本文件冊49
[23] 審訊文件冊B886謄本文件冊52-56
[24] 審訊文件冊B886謄本文件冊57-58
[25] 審訊文件冊B886謄本文件冊59-64
[26] 審訊文件冊B1337-1339謄本文件冊65-67
[27] 文件冊B378
[28] 父親第一份誓章,文件冊a104-106,RW1 誓章文件冊A135-
139,父親第五份誓章,文件冊A211
[29] “VCM-6”
[30] “VCM-7”
[31] “VCM-8” (”CSF 1-24”)
[32] “VCM-9”
[33] “VCM-10”
[34] “VCM-11”(”CSF I-25”)
[35] “VCM-12”
[36] “ACT-2”
[37] 審訊文件冊B438謄本文件冊11
[38] 審訊文件冊B439謄本文件冊12
[39] 審訊文件冊B467-8謄本文件冊13
[40] 審訊文件冊B473謄本文件冊11
[41] 審訊文件冊B478謄本文件冊12
[42] 審訊文件冊B479謄本文件冊14
[43] 審訊文件冊B784-786謄本文件冊15
[44] ‘TKK-27’,文件冊B193-198
[45] 見石主任進度報告[8]至[17]
[46] 政府臨床心理學家[A325/§55];梁主任[A352/§44 &
A359/§63];石主任[A373/§§27-30]
[47] 政府臨床心理學家A319/§34,A322/§43,A324/§51
[48] “VCM-3”
[49] 母親第五份誓章,文件冊A180
[50] 父親第一份誓章文件冊A106-108,父親第五份誓文件冊A209-212
[51] 律師信日期2024年10月22日,文件冊C19
[52] 母親第一份誓章,文件冊A48
[53] 母親第二份誓章文件冊A66,’TKK-26’ 及187-192
[54] 父親第一份誓章文件冊A95-101
[55] 審訊文件冊B374,謄本文件冊2-3
[56] 審訊文件冊B375,謄本文件冊4
[57] 審訊文件冊B422-425,謄本文件冊5-6
[58] 審訊文件冊B426-431,謄本文件冊7-9
[59] ‘VCM-12’,’CFI-18’,文件冊B378
[60] TKK-12,文件冊B36, 37
[61] ‘TKK-28’, A199-201
[62] CSF1-22,審訊文件冊B432,謄本文件冊10
[63] 父親第一份誓章文件冊A95
[64] 父親第五份誓章,文件冊A209-212
[65] [2007] HKFLR 165
[66] 母親第一份誓章文件冊32-48
[67] 自約2022年因為攝錄機故障不能錄影,但仍可錄音。
[68] TKK-5
[69] ‘TKK-6’
[70] TKK-24第31頁
[71] TKK-24第31頁
[72] TKK-24 第32頁
[73] TKK-24 第42頁
[74] TKK-24 第43頁
[75] TKK-24 第44頁
[76] TKK-24第45頁
[77] TKK-24第47頁
[78] TKK-24第48頁
[79] TKK-24第48-49頁
[80] TKK-24第49頁
[81] 審訊第4天
[82] 文件冊B276, 279
[83] 文件冊B276
[84] 文件冊B290
[85] 文件冊B1037
[86] 文件冊B983-1003
[87] LBTC 2092/2025
[88] 文件冊B1198-1199, B1068
[89] 審訊第5天
[90] 文件冊B1070-1073
[91] 文件冊C362
[92] 文件冊C282-283
[93] 文件冊C384, C439
[94] 文件冊B1408
[95] 文件冊B1408
[96] 訴訟雙方來往信件見文件冊C183-203
[97] 審訊第7天
[98] 第5天審訊
[99] 文件冊B1021
[100] 文件冊C328, C359
[101] 文件冊C/96-104, B4/1278
[102] C227-228
[103] 文件冊B1246, B1253-1254
[104] 文件冊C389-390
[105] C271-272, C273, C274, C275, C429-431
[106] 審訊第一天下午
[107] 審訊第一天下午
[108] 審訊第二天下午
[109] 文件冊C148
[110] 文件冊C148
[111] 文件冊C150
[112] 石主任更新報告,文件冊A381/§59
[113] 文件冊A270-7
[114] 文件冊B4,1357
[115] 石主任更新報告A381/§59
[116] 文件冊C443
[117] CACV 352/2004, 27/7/2005, [22]-[24]
[118] [2010] 4 HKLRD 191
[119] [2009] HKFLR 308
[120] 黃姑娘2025年5月6日的報告[14][59][69][70][72][81][82]
[121] ‘TKK-33’ B228-272
[122] 第38號命令第36條規則
[123] 文件冊C286-358
[124] 文件冊C439
[125] 進度報告文件冊A392/§20
-----------------------
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V
由此
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V