Case Details
Citation
CHUNG TIN KAU v. FONG SHUN TAK, DCPI 1055/2006
Case Number
DCPI 1055/2006
Court
District Court
(DC)
Parties
Applicant(s):

CHUNG TIN KAU

Respondent(s):

FONG SHUN TAK

For Applicant(s):

new solicitors came on the record; reveals disc protrusions and spinal cord compression. Since osteophytes are bony outgrowths associated with what the Government doctors referred to as cervical spondylosis (ie a spinal disorder in which degenerative changes occur in the intervertebral discs) as early as in February 2006, it is unclear why Dr Tsang did not consider/discuss the merits or demerits of degenerative disorder as an alternative explanation; Dr Tsang examined the Plaintiff twice before compiling the Tsang Report. I do not see why, if the Plaintiff were able to rely on the Tsang Report, a just determination of the cause requires constricting the Defendant’s preparation of his case by denying him opportunity to obtain proper neurological report due to the Plaintiff’s stated intention of refusing to undergo further medical examination. As

For Respondent(s):

Mr Benny Wong of Messrs Lau, Chan & Ko

Judges
  • H H District Marlene Ng

CHUNG TIN KAU v. FONG SHUN TAK

DCPI 1055/2006

District Court
Judges:H H District Marlene Ng

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations