Case Details
Citation
SONCA INDUSTRIES LTD v. THE QUEEN, CACC 1342/1977
Case Number
CACC 1342/1977
Court
Court of Appeal
(CA)
Decision Date
28 February 1978
Parties
Applicant(s):

SONCA INDUSTRIES LTD

Respondent(s):

THE QUEEN

For Applicant(s):

do not seek an adjournment or to recall witnesses." Perhaps it is pertinent to observe that there is no record that the charge, the amended charge, had been read in open court nor was there any explanation of the amended charge given to the appellant at the time. However, there is something on record on page 15 which indicates that the learned Magistrate must have asked whether solicitors; Looking at the facts of this case, it appears that the appellant is a corporation who was represented by solicitors at the hearing. The learned Magistrate handed the amended summons to the solicitors of the corporation and asked him whether he wanted an adjournment or to recall witnesses. Apparently, there was no explanation as to the amended charge being given to the solicitor who appeared; corporation to be represented by one of his staff or any representative at the hearing. One must bear in mind that before the enactment of Section 19(A) was added to the Magistrates Ordinance, a corporation must appear by solicitors or counsel. No representatives would be allowed to represent a legal person. Thus I am of the opinion that at the trial in the court below the solicitor appearing; handed the charge down to the solicitor representing the appellant. Indeed, no explanation was given to solicitors concerned. Looking at it from a common sense point of view, one would have felt that to explain an amended charge or the significance of an amended charge to a solicitor amounts to gilding the lily and that to hand over the copy of the amended charge to the solicitor; Learned counsel mentioned something about the solicitor

For Respondent(s):

below's failing to cite to the learned Magistrate the definition of the term "securely fenced". I am inclined to accept learned counsel's explanation that it was an unfortunate misunderstanding. To the learned Magistrate he might feel, and indeed with some justification that he was misled. Reading the transcript and having the explanation of learned counsel, I can't help feeling that the solicitor appearing

SONCA INDUSTRIES LTD v. THE QUEEN

CACC 1342/1977

Court of Appeal28 February 1978

Citation

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations