|
DCEC 770/2004
IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE
HONG KONG SPECIAL
ADMINISTRATIVE REGION
EMPLOYEES’ COMPENSATION CASE
NO. 770 OF 2004
____________________________
IN THE MATTER OF
an application between
| |
YUNG CHI MAN |
Applicant |
| |
and |
|
| |
TANG KAN FU
trading as YUN SHING MOTOR SERVICE |
Respondent |
________________________________________
Coram: Deputy District Judge Yau in Court
Date of Hearing: 12th January
2006
Date of Handing Down of Judgement: 6 February 2006
_________________
JUDGEMENT
_________________
Introduction
On
24 may 2001 when the Applicant was repairing a tractor while in the employment
of the Respondent the oil tank of the tractor caught fire and exploded, causing
burnt injuries over 55% of the Applicant’s body.
2.
The Respondent admitted liability.
Application
of the Applicant
3. The
Applicant applies for :
(a) compensation for loss of earning
capacity under section 9 of the Employees’ Compensation Ordinance, Cap 282 (“the ECO”) and to appeal against the
assessment made by the Employees’ Compensation
(Ordinary Assessment) Board;
(b) compensation for temporary incapacity
under section 10 of the ECO and for leave to extend the length of period for
periodical payments under section 10(5);
(c) payment of the medical expenses of the
Applicant under section 10A of the ECO;
4. The
Applicant also asks for leave for the present application to be received and
determined by the court under section 14(4) of the ECO notwithstanding that the
application has not been made in due time as required under section 14(1).
The Respondent has no objection to the application and leave is accordingly
given.
Issues
5. The
Respondent makes it clear to court at the outset that it is arguing against the
extension of the length of period for periodical payments and the Applicant’s
appeal against the assessment made by the Employees’
Compensation (Ordinary Assessment) Board.
6. As
regards the payment of medical expenses the parties agree that the outstanding
amount is $200 and the Respondent agrees to pay it.
7. The
Applicant admits to have received a total of $175,054.35 from the Respondent
but argues that it was periodical payments
under section 10 of the ECO. The Respondent, however, contends that this money was not
only periodical payments but also included advancement of compensation
and is sufficient to satisfy the whole claim of the Applicant under the ECO.
Case of Applicant
8. The Applicant gives evidence in court but does not call any witness. He adopts his witness statement (pages
33 to 46 in the Bundle) as part of his
evidence. He says that he was born
on 18.11.1982 in China. He came to
Hong Kong in 1998 and had received education up to Form 1. He joined the Yun Shing Motor Service,
the garage operated by the Respondent, in 1999 as an apprentice at a monthly
wage of $5,000. He was given a rise in wage after working for 2 years and at
the time of the incident he was earning $5,500 a month with year-end double
pay.
9. On 24.5.2001 when he was repairing a diesel tank an explosion occurred
and he suffered burnt injuries and lost consciousness. He was hospitalised for one and a half
months during which time he underwent 3 skin grafting operations. He later received physiotherapy and
occupation therapy. He was
required to wear pressure garment for 3 odd years until 2004. He was given sick leave from 24.5.2001
to 16.1.2004.
10. The Respondent made periodical payments to him every
month during his sick leave and he had received a total of $175,054.35. The Respondent had never told him that
this money would be deducted from the employee’s compensation and he had in
fact not talked to the Respondent since the accident. The business of the Respondent was closed down in
mid-2002. The Applicant later discovered
that the Respondent had not taken out insurance for him.
11. As
a result of the injuries suffered in the accident the Applicant often feels
itchy at the scars and the reaction of the person has become much slower. When he sweats the scars on the chest will become itchy and painful.
He is afraid of climbing up and down and his balancing ability has been
adversely affected. He had
encountered difficulties in finding work and was only able to secure his present job in October 2005 as a security guard
with a monthly wage of $6,100. He
is only able to handle jobs in which the boss is not so demanding but he admits
that this has nothing to do with his physical conditions.
Case of Respondent
12. Although
the Respondent has not given a witness statement, by consent of the Applicant
and leave of the court he is allowed to testify in court. He says that after the accident he had
talked to the parents of the Applicant and told them he would pay his son in
accordance with the labour law.
The parents said that they were in financial difficulties as they had no
job and had to take care of the Applicant. The Respondent therefore agreed to
pay the full wage to the Applicant, but made it clear that any extra money paid
would later be deducted from the compensation to be calculated in accordance
with the labour law. The Respondent
says that he wrote “labour
injury” on the pay slip because his intention was to have the money deducted from the employee’s compensation
once assessment of the Applicant’s injuries had been made.
13. In
April 2002 the garage of the Respondent was about to be closed down. He informed the Applicant’s parents
about it and said that he would continue to pay the Applicant until the end of
his sick leave. At the request of
the parents of the Applicant he prepared the document at page 142 of the Bundle
(“payment document”). In the
document it was stated that after the closure of the garage the Respondent
would continue to pay $5,500 to the Applicant every month as compensation for
his living expenses until the Applicant was certified by the doctor to have
recovered. The payment document
was returned to the Respondent by the parents after it had been signed by the
Applicant. The Respondent says
that by “compensation for his living expenses” he meant that the money was paid
to the Applicant as compensation.
The Respondent also admits that due to a misunderstanding between
himself and the insurance agent the insurance coverage of the Applicant had
expired when the accident occurred.
Evaluation of Evidence
14. It
is not in dispute that the Applicant has suffered injuries as a result of an
accident while working for the Respondent. His evidence is mostly not disputed. As regards the money paid to him by the
Respondent while he was on sick leave he had never talked to the Respondent
about the nature of such payments and the money had been collected on his
behalf by his parents, mostly his mother.
15. The
Respondent gives evidence that on learning the financial difficulties of the
Applicant’s family he had told the parents of the Applicant that he would be
paying full wages to the Applicant but the extra money paid was to be deducted
from the employee’s compensation after the assessment of the injuries of the Applicant
had been made. The Applicant has chosen not to call any evidence to rebut
the assertion of the Respondent.
The contents of the payment document also serve to support the
Respondent’s contention. The court
is of the view that what the Respondent has told the court is truthful and
reliable and is accepted by the court and that the
money paid was meant to be periodical payments as well as advancement of
compensation.
Assessment Under ECO
16. The
injuries of the Applicant were first
assessed by the Employees’ Compensation (Ordinary Assessment) Board on
16.6.2004 and the permanent loss of earning capacity was assessed at 8% (page
93 of the Bundle). On an
application for review by the Applicant a second assessment was made on
6.10.2004 and the result was varied to 10%.
Medical Reports
17. According
to a number of medical reports the Applicant suffered 55% burnt over his body and was admitted to hospital on
24.5.2001. He had undergone 3 skin
graft operations and treatments for post operation complications. He had also received physiotherapy and
occupational therapy. The wound
had healed well and he was discharged from hospital on 5.7.2004 when he was
clinically stable. As the
Applicant was not concerned about cosmetic surgery the case was closed by the hospital
on 16.1.2004.
18. According
to the occupational therapy reports the Applicant had received scar management
by wearing pressure garment and pressure padding for the trunk and upper and
lower limbs since 14.8.2001. On the maturation of the scars on
different parts of the body the pressure garment had been taken off in stages
and the process was completed in November 2003.
19. The
Applicant underwent a medical examination arranged jointly by the Applicant and
the Respondent on 13.6.2005. According
to this medical report (pages 53 to 82 of the Bundle) the scars had matured and
flattened and they did not affect important parts of the body such as the face,
the neck, the wrist, the hand and the fingers and were not causing significant
functional disturbances.
20. The
colour and texture of the scars could be improved by up to 30% with treatments
of pulsed dye laser. The cosmetic
disability arising from the unsightly scars was estimated to be 20% without
such treatment and 14% with treatment.
The loss of earning capacity arising from the scars was estimated to be
approximately 10%.
Compensation for Loss of Earning Capacity
21. This
is compensation under section 9 of the ECO. Under this head of compensation the Applicant is appealing
against the assessment of 10% made by the Employees’ Compensation (Ordinary
Assessment) Board under the ECO.
22. According
to the medical reports the wounds of the Application have healed well and are
not causing significant functional disturbances. As the scars are unsightly the joint medical report says
that they do not affect important parts of the Applicant’s body.
23. The
Applicant submits to the court that the loss of earning capacity of the
Applicant should be 25%. He cites to court the case of LUI Sheung Lok v Wah Wah Travel Services Limited HCPI 1188 of
1999. In this case the plaintiff,
a driver of 54 years of age, suffered burnt injuries to 15% of his body surface
including the head, neck and both upper limbs while performing driving duties
for his employer. The doctor
examining the plaintiff and the Employees’ Compensation (Ordinary Assessment)
Board both came to the conclusion that the loss of earning capacity sustained
by the plaintiff was 17% and this was accepted by the court. The doctor also assessed the cosmetic
disability of the plaintiff to be 5%.
The Applicant points out that as compared with the plaintiff the
injuries he suffered in the present case are much more severe. He argues that the loss of his earning capacity
should be assessed at 25%.
24. The
arguments of the Applicant are misconceived. For the purpose of assessing the loss of earning capacity
the relevant consideration is not the seriousness of the injuries but the
effect of the injuries on the earning ability of the employee. In the authority cited the plaintiff
had extensive scars on his neck, right arm and hand and right leg, which were a
constant source of itching, discomfort and embarrassment to him even after four
years of the accident. More
importantly, his right arm and hand were weak as flexibility had been
significantly reduced. He was
unable to carry heavy objects.
With the loss of dexterity and increasing pain in his right hand after
working for long hours he had found it difficult to resume driving career.
25. According
to the medical report in the present case the scars of the Applicant are
unsightly and the injuries have not caused him any significant functional
disturbances. This contrasts
significantly with the conditions of the plaintiff in the case cited.
26. In
the present case the doctors in the joint medical examination came to an
assessment of 10% and the Employees’ Compensation (Ordinary Assessment) Board
also came to a similar finding.
Their assessments are of course not binding on this court and the court
has to consider all the relevant evidence and circumstances of the case before
coming to a conclusion. The Applicant says in court that the scars often cause
itching and he gets tired
easily. He, however, admits that
he can walk for more than an hour although his leg may feel a bit stiff
afterwards. He also admits
that he can run although the scar at the heel causes some pain.
27. The
court accepts that itching of the scar, the stiffness of the legs after long
hours of walk and the pain in running will affect the daily life and working
ability of the Applicant. The
court has also borne in mind the Applicant’s assertion,
which is not found in any of the medical reports, that his reaction and balancing power have
been adversely affected. The court
is, however, of the view that taking all the disabilities which the Applicant
suffers into consideration the extent of loss of his earning capacity is far
less than 25% and the court comes to the conclusion that 10% is the most appropriate
and correct assessment. The appeal
of the Applicant against the finding of the Employees’ Compensation (Ordinary
Assessment) Board is accordingly dismissed and the loss of earning capacity of
the Applicant is assessed at 10%.
28. It
is agreed between the parties that the monthly earnings of the
Applicant for the purpose of calculation of
compensation under the ECO is $5,958.33.
The Applicant is now aged 23 and was aged 18 at the time of the
accident. The compensation for the
permanent loss of earning capacity is therefore:
$5,958.33 x
96 x 10% = $57,199.97.
Periodical Payments
29. This
is compensation under section 10 of the ECO and the Application also asks under
section 10(5) for the court’s leave to extend the period of periodical payments
to cover the whole period of the Applicant’s sick leave of 31 months and 22 days. At the outset of the trial the Respondent makes it clear
that it is taking no issue regarding the length of sick leave granted to the
Applicant but is objecting to the extension of the period of periodical
payments. The
Respondent, however, in its
final submission agrees that if the sick leave of an
employee goes beyond 24 months the court should give leave to extend the length
of period for the periodical payments unless there are good reasons not to do
so. The sick leave of the
Applicant is supported by sick leave certificates and with the injuries he has
suffered the length of the sick leave is in the view of the court reasonable. This is also
accepted by the Respondent. Under
such circumstances the court is of the conclusion that it is just and equitableto exercise its discretion to give leave
for the Applicant to be paid periodical payments forthe whole of his sick leave of 31 months
and 22 days in accordance with section 10 of ECO, and
the court so orders.
30. The
Applicant had no work and income during the sick leave. The amount payable under this head is
therefore fourth fifths of $5,958.33 times 31 months and 22 days which makes
$151,262.13
Medical Expenses
31. The
Respondent agrees at the outset of the trial to pay the $200 medical expenses
claimed by the Applicant.
Total Compensation Entitlement
32. The
total amount of compensation the Application is entitled to under sections 9,
10 and 10A is:
$57,199.97
+ $151,262.13 + $200 = $208,662.10
Compensation To Be Paid
33. The
court has already found that the Respondent had paid $175,054.35 to the
Applicant with the intention that the money was meant to be periodical payments
and advancement of compensation.
The Respondent admits that he had only informed the parents of the
Applicant and had not talked to the Applicant personally about it.
34. The
parents had obviously collected the money on behalf of the Applicant, understanding fully what the Respondent had told
them about the nature of the payment.
The evidence of the Respondent which is accepted by the court is that he
had tried to get in touch with the Applicant and had even tried to do so
through the parents, but was unsuccessful. The parents had been authorised to collect the money on
behalf of the Applicant and it must follow that telling them the nature of the
payment constituted sufficient notice for the Applicant. The Respondent had paid the money to
help the Applicant and his family financially and there was no need to have the
Applicant’s agreement to it because it was not an agreement but a manifestation
of the intention of the Respondent, and no prejudice would be occasioned to the
Applicant because he would still be getting full compensation under the ECO.
35. The
money paid was not only periodical payments but also
included advancement of compensation in the amounts of:
$175,054.35
– $151,262.13 = $23,792.22
36. The
periodical payments had already been paid and the advancement of compensation
is to be deducted from the compensation payable under the ECO. The amount of compensation remains outstanding and to be paid is:
$208,662.10
– $151,262.13 –
$23,792.22 = $33,607.75
Interests
37. There
shall be interests on this amount from
the date of accident at half judgment rate until date of judgment and
thereafter at judgment rate until payment.
Costs
38. The
Applicant succeeds in his application for leave to extend the length of period
of the periodical payments and in his claims of medical expenses but fails in
his appeal against the assessment of the Employees’ Compensation (Ordinary
Assessment) Board. The Respondent
fails in its contention that the compensation of $175,054.35
paid is sufficient to satisfy the whole claim of the Applicant. The court is of the view that the
length of time involved in the trial in determining the respective issues in
which the parties have obtained judgment is more or less the same. It is fair that the Applicant and the Respondent each
pay their own costs in the trial. The court
therefore makes an order
nisi that there be no order as to costs in this trial.
| |
(Joseph YAU)
Deputy District Judge |
Mr
MAK Yiu Wah Bilan of Messrs B Mak & Co, assigned by
the Director of Legal Aid, for the Applicant
Mr
TSANG Kwok Fun of Messrs Dickie TSANG & Co for the Respondent
|