HKSAR v. RASMINA GORETHEA SAMNA
[2026] HKCFI 6168 · HCCC 196/2024
Court of First Instance
HCCC 196/2024 [2026] HKCFI 6168 IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE CRIMINAL CASE NO 196 OF 2024 ----------------- HKSAR v Rasmina Gorethea Samna ------------------ Before: Hon Toh J Date: 18 September 2026 at 10.33 am Present: Ms Winnie Mok, SPP of the Department of Justice, for HKSAR Ms Elizabeth Herbert, instructed by H Y Leung & Co LLP, assigned by DLA, for the accused Offence: Trafficking in a dangerous drug (販運危險藥物) --------------------------------- Transcript of the Audio Recording of the Sentence in the above Case --------------------------------- COURT: The defendant has pleaded guilty to one count of trafficking in a dangerous drug, namely 777 grammes of a crystalline solid containing 589 grammes of methamphetamine hydrochloride. Now, the facts are not difficult, it happens unfortunately very frequently in Hong Kong, in that on 19 February 2023, the defendant had arrived in Hong Kong from Ethiopia, and the flight originated from Madagascar, it went via Addis Ababa in Ethiopia. And she was intercepted, and at the time of interception, she was carrying a black suitcase and a brown handbag. And upon checking, the brown handbag was emptied and there was a false compartment inside and the drugs were found in the false compartment. And the drugs were subsequently examined and found to be, the weight and value of the drugs is estimated to be HK$377,622. And the defendant was, of course, interviewed in a video-recorded interview in the presence of a French interpreter, and her itinerary showed that she was supposed to stay in Hong Kong between 19 and 28 February. The defendant is aged 30 at that time and has no criminal record in Hong Kong. She told the police that at the time of her arrest she was a singer, and it is a fact that the defendant had pleaded guilty subsequently after she was committed to this court. And Ms Herbert has made a mitigation at the previous hearing on behalf of the defendant and said everything she could possibly say on her behalf, in that she came from an impecunious family and the father abandoned the family, and she struggled in school and worked as a backup singer in order to support her family. And her mother went on to have two more children, and her mother passed away in 2021. And so the defendant was left to take care of the additional two children as well. And she, in order to support the family, had secured a job as a domestic helper in Kuwait, but her boyfriend destroyed her passport and so she could not leave. So she had to take out a loan, and eventually because of the financial difficulties, she had agreed to carry these drugs to Hong Kong. There is also a letter from the chaplain in prison, whilst in prison, as to her continuing education, and how she has helped to encourage and help those around her. And the reverend states that she has a penitent attitude, and her character has been transformed and so he begs for leniency. The fact of the matter is that in Hong Kong, we have a rather open border, and so the court and the Customs and police are fighting a constant battle against drug traffickers bringing drugs into Hong Kong. And so anyone bringing drugs into Hong Kong, it should be well known around the world now, is that they will be faced with very serious consequences and heavy sentences in order to try and deter those who are tempted to do this evil trade in exchange for money. The only mitigating factor in this case is that she pleaded guilty, and as Ms Herbert correctly pointed out, she is entitled to one-quarter deduction because of that guilty plea. It is also a fact that the Court of Appeal has laid down guideline sentences for trafficking in ‘Ice’, which is methamphetamine hydrochloride. And in the case of, as Ms Herbert submitted, the case of Huang Ruifang in 2025, the Court of Appeal had revised the guideline for sentencing of between 300 grammes to 600 grammes of ‘Ice’ is a sentence of between 15 to 18 years in prison. And in this case, the applicant, the defendant, has with her 589 grammes of ‘Ice’. And it is mathematically worked out by Ms Herbert as 17 years and 10 months’ imprisonment. But there is also the international element. And it is a fact that when considering the starting point, as was correctly pointed out by Ms Herbert, the court should take into account the international element as well, rather than imposing an extra sentence for the international element. And so in this case, I would adopt a starting point of 18 years’ imprisonment. The assistance that was rendered, detailed by, I think, in Father Wotherspoon’s constant battle as well to inform people around the world about the sentences in Hong Kong being severe, it contains a letter which is supportedly written by the defendant, stating, asking others not to participate in this kind of trade. I, of course, take that into account too when I impose the 18 years’ imprisonment as a starting point. And as I said, I accept that the defendant deserves a one-quarter discount because of her plea. So the 18 years deducted by one-quarter gives a remaining of 13 years and 6 months. So the defendant will go to prison for 13 years and 6 months. I/we certify that to the best of my/our ability and skill, the foregoing is a true transcript of the audio recording of the above proceedings .......................................... Wan Kwan Chak Tolaigus Date: 28 September 2026