|
DCCC 217/2010
IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE
HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION
CRIMINAL CASE NO. 217 OF 2010
----------------------------
-----------------------------
|
Coram:
|
HH Judge S. T. Poon
|
|
Present:
|
Mr. Alvin Chui of the Department of Justice for HKSAR.
Mr. Wong King Fai Samson of M/S Tang, Wong & Cheung for Defendant.
|
|
Offence:
|
(1) Using a false instrument.
使用虛假文書,違反香港法例第200章《刑事罪行條例》第73條。
(2) Possessing false instruments.
管有虛假文書,違反香港法例第200章《刑事罪行條例》第75(1)條。
|
----------------------------
Reasons for Sentence
----------------------------
1. The Defendant pleads guilty to 1 count of “Using a false instrument” and 1 count of “Possessing false instruments”.
2. On 14th January 2010 the Defendant presented a forged Master Card to the salesperson of the Duty Free Shop in Tsimshatsui for payment of some cosmetic products in the amount of HK$12,680. The salesperson suspected that the Master Card was a forged one and enquired with the card centre. The card centre confirmed that it was a forged card and the salesperson made a report to the police. The Defendant was caught with another 5 forged credit cards on arrest.
3. The Defendant is a Malaysian. He is now 26 years old. According to him, he has a wife and 2 sons in Malaysia and his wife has deserted the family after knowing his arrest. The sons are just 1 and 3 years old and he was the sole bread-winner of the family.
4. Mr. Wong, solicitors for the Defendant, submitted that there is no evidence in this case suggesting the Defendant being part of a syndicate, nor is there any international element. I agree.
5. The present case is similar to the facts of HKSAR v. Tu I Lang Cr App 464/2006. In Tu I Lang, the defendant was a Taiwanese, he used a forged credit card to purchase a mobile phone and 2 more forged credit cards were found on him upon arrest. The Court of Appeal viewed that it was a “small scale credit card offence” and reduced the starting point of 4 years imprisonment adopted by the District Court to one of 3 years.
6. Although the number of forged credit cards involved in the present case is a few more than that in Tu I Lang, I see no reason not to adopt a similar starting point in this matter.
7. I note that the Defendant has a clear record in Hong Kong and the situation of his family. However, I do not think that they are substantial mitigating factors in view of the seriousness of the offence. The only material mitigation is in fact his guilty plea.
8. I adopt the starting point of 3 years imprisonment for each charge. Taking into account the guilty plea and the totality principle, the Defendant is sentenced to 2 years imprisonment for each charge and the terms of imprisonment are to run concurrently.
| |
S. T. Poon
District Judge |
|