LE THI GAN v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD[Decision on Leave Application]
[2026] HKCFI 6033 · HCAL 1094/2022
Court of First Instance
HCAL 1094/2022 [2026] HKCFI 6033 IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE CONSTITUTIONAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE LAW LIST NO 1094 OF 2022 BETWEEN Application for Leave to Apply for Judicial Review NOTIFICATION of the Judge’s decision (Ord 53 r 3) Following: Order by Deputy High Court Judge Bruno Chan: The application for leave to apply for judicial review be dismissed. Observations for the Applicant: The Applicant is a 50-year-old national of Vietnam who had previously entered Hong Kong illegally in November 2017 and was subsequently arrested and repatriated to Vietnam in January 2018 did so again some 3 years later on 4 July 2021 and was arrested by police on 6 July 2021. After she was referred to the Immigration Department for investigation, she raised a non-refoulement claim for protection on the basis that if she returned to Vietnam she would be harmed or killed by her many creditors for failing to repay her debts. She was subsequently released on recognizance pending the determination of her claim. The Applicant was born and raised in Village Pha Le, District Thuy Nguyen, Hai Phong, Vietnam. After leaving school she worked by repairing fishing nets to make her living, married her husband and raised their family with their 2 sons in her home village. Since about 1993 she and her husband had resorted to borrowing various loans from the local money-lenders and loan sharks to meet their living expenses and to enable her husband to maintain his fishing activities, but were never able to repay any of their debts over the years, during which they had constantly been chased after by their creditors with threats against them over their unpaid debts that they were often in hiding in various places. In July 2021, the Applicant and her husband then departed Vietnam for China, and from there she by herself sneaked into Hong Kong, and upon her arrest by the police she then raised her non-refoulement claim for protection, for which she completed a Non-refoulement Claim Form (“NCF”) on 18 November 2021 and attended screening interview before the Immigration Department with legal representation from the Duty Lawyer Service (“DLS”). By a Notice of Decision dated 7 January 2022, the Director of Immigration (“Director”) rejected the Applicant’s claim on all the applicable grounds including risk of torture under Part VIIC of the Immigration Ordinance, Cap 115 (“Torture Risk”), risk of her absolute or non-derogable rights under the Hong Kong Bill of Rights Ordinance, Cap 383 (“HKBOR”) being violated including right to life under Article 2 (“BOR 2 Risk”), risk of torture or cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment under Article 3 of HKBOR (“BOR 3 Risk”), and risk of persecution with reference to the non-refoulement principle under Article 33 of the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees (“Persecution Risk”). In his decision, the Director took into account of all the relevant circumstances of the Applicant’s claim and assessed the level of risk of harm from her creditors upon her return to Vietnam as low due to the low intensity and frequency of past ill-treatment from them, that there is no evidence of any real intention of any of her creditors to seriously harm or kill her other than to press her to repay her debts, that in any event these were private monetary disputes between her and her creditors only without any official involvement that state or police protection would be available to the Applicant if resorted to, and that reliable and objective Country of Origin Information (“COI”) show that reasonable internal relocation alternatives are available in Vietnam with a large population of 102 million people spread across a vast territory of more than 330,000 square kilometers that it would not be unduly harsh for the Applicant as an able-bodied adult with working experience to move to other areas of the country away from her home district in large cities such as Hanoi or Ho Chi Minh City where it would be difficult if not impossible for her creditors to locate her. On 17 January 2022, the Applicant lodged an appeal to the Torture Claims Appeal Board (“Board”) against the Director’s decision, and for which she attended an oral hearing on 25 August 2022 before the Board during which she gave evidence and answered questions raised of her claim by the Adjudicator for the Board. On 5 October 2022 her appeal was dismissed by the Board which also confirmed the Director’s decision. In its decision, the Board found material inconsistencies and discrepancies in the Applicant’s evidence that it doubted the credibility of her claim of fear of harm from many money-lenders and loan sharks over many debts for more than 20 years which she had never repaid but which caused her to leave her country to come to Hong Kong to seek protection as wholly incredible and implausible, that even if her account of events prior to her departure of Vietnam were true that there was no reliable evidence of any real intention of any of her creditors to seriously harm or kill her over the many years other than to press her to repay her debts, and that in any event these were private monetary disputes between her and her creditors only without any official involvement that state or police protection would be available to the Applicant upon her return to Vietnam if resorted to as well as reasonable internal relocation alternatives for her to move safely to other parts of the country away from her home district in large cities without any risk of being located by her creditors that her claim for non-refoulement protection failed on all applicable grounds. On 17 October 2022, the Applicant filed her Form 86 for leave to apply for judicial review of the Board’s decision but without putting forth any proper ground for her intended challenge other than just some bare and bald assertions that internal relocation will not help her as those money-lenders and loan sharks have nationwide networks to locate her, and as she is not an active person and with poor health that she will not be able to adapt to new places to find any job to support herself within her home country but without providing any evidential basis to corroborate her such bare assertions. As such, and in the absence of any error of law or irrationality or procedural unfairness in her process before the Board or in its decision being clearly and properly identified by the Applicant, I do not find any reasonably arguable basis for her intended challenge of the Board’s decision. As has been repeatedly emphasized by the Court of Appeal, judicial review does not operate as a rehearing of a non-refoulement claim when the proper occasion for the Applicant to present and articulate his claim is in the screening process and interview before the Immigration Department and in the process before the Board where the evaluation of the risk of harm is primarily a matter for the Director and the Board as they are entitled to make such evaluation based on the evidence available to them that the court will not usurp their role as primary decision makers in the absence of any legal error or procedural unfairness or irrationality in their decisions being clearly and properly identified by the Applicant, as judicial review is not an avenue for revisiting the assessment by them in the hope that the court may consider the matter afresh: Re Lakhwinder Singh [2018] HKCA 246; Re Daljit Singh [2018] HKCA 328; Re Mudannayakalage Chaminda Pushpa Kumara [2018] HKCA 400; and Nupur Mst v Director of Immigration [2018] HKCA 524. In the Applicant’s case, the fact is that it has been established by both the Director and the Board in their respective decisions that the risk of harm in her claim if real is a localized one and that it is not unreasonable or unsafe for her to relocate to other part of Vietnam, there is simply no justification to afford her with non-refoulement protection in Hong Kong: see TK v Jenkins & Anor [2013] 1 HKC 526. Having considered the decisions of both the Director and the Board with rigorous examination and anxious scrutiny, I do not find any error of law or procedural unfairness in either of them, nor any failure on their part to apply high standards of fairness in their consideration and assessment of the Applicant’s claim. Moreover, the Applicant has shortly before the scheduled hearing of her application by a letter dated 15 October 2026 requested to withdraw her application as her problem in her home country has been resolved that she now wants to return to Vietnam. In the premises, as I am for the given reasons not satisfied that there is any prospect of success in the Applicant’s intended application for judicial review, and in view of her latest confirmation of no more problem for her to return to her home country, I accordingly dismiss her leave application and vacate the scheduled hearing for her application on 4 November 2026. Where leave to apply has been granted, Applicants and their legal advisers are reminded of their obligation to reconsider the merits of their application in the light of the Respondent’s evidence ___________________________________________________________________________ Form CALL-1