|
DCCC 801/2011
IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE
HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION
CRIMINAL CASE NO. 801 OF 2011
----------------------
----------------------
| Before:
|
H.H. Judge E. Yip
|
| Date:
|
23rd September, 2011 at 11:43 a.m.
|
| Present:
|
Mr KWOK Wing-lung,Senior Public Prosecutor, of the Department of Justice, for HKSAR
|
|
|
MrCHENG Kwun Chau Derek, of M/s. Cheng & Wong assigned by DLA for the Defendant
|
| Offence:
|
Trafficking in a dangerous drug (販運危險藥物)
|
-----------------------------
Reasons for Sentence
-----------------------------
Charge and facts
1. The defendant pleads guilty to trafficking in a dangerous drug, namely 14.15 g of a mixture containing 6.34 g of heroin hydrochloride. In the evening on 19 May 2011, he was intercepted by the police on the street with the said drug in a bag inside his trouser pocket. He had over $2,000 on him.
2. Upon arrest and caution he said:
(1) The drug was for self-consumption and treating friends;
(2) He had bought it at $4,000 from horse-race winnings;
(3) He was on the way to a methadone clinic nearby to treat a friend to part of the drug;
(4) He used to consume drugs 3 times a week, costing him about $200 each time.
3. The estimated retail value of the drug was near $9,700.
Defendant’s personal circumstances and mitigation put forward
4. He is now 57 years of age, of P3 education. He was unemployed before arrest. He has been on public assistance for quite a number of years. His wife has been wheelchair-bound after a stroke. They have a son. Their daughter-in-law is expecting a baby next year. He has been a drug addict for 40 years. He has a lot of criminal convictions. Only 2 of them, dated back in 1973, are relating to drug trafficking.
Sentencing guidelines for trafficking in heroin
5. There are guidelines laid down by the Court of Appeal in The Queen v Lau Tak Ming [1990] 2 HKLR 370 for trafficking in heroin. For up to 10 g of narcotics, the sentence shall be 2 – 5 years.
Sentencing this Defendant
6. From the Defendant’s own version, he used to spend $200 each time thrice a week on drugs. It means the drug could have lasted nearly 7 weeks. He has no earnings but public assistance to spend on drugs. Of course, I understand that he had bought the said drug out of horse-race winnings in this instance. I doubt whether he had the presence of mind to plan the respective portions for self-consumption vis-à-vis trafficking before arrest. The latent risk for trafficking was clearly high. Whether more for self-consumption or for trafficking, the drug shall attract a sentence of 2 – 5 years.
7. I take a starting point of 3 years in the light of an apportionment between self-consumption and trafficking I deem more favourable to the Defendant. One-third off due to the plea of guilty, the sentence is 2 years in the absence of further mitigating factors.
|