Case Details
Citation
COTTEEN INVESTMENTS LTD v. TOMASES INVESTMENTS LTD AND ANOTHER, CACV 37/1983
Case Number
CACV 37/1983
Court
Court of Appeal
(CA)
Decision Date
3 June 1983
Parties
Applicant(s):

COTTEEN INVESTMENTS LTD

Respondent(s):

TOMASES INVESTMENTS LTD, FIRST HONG KONG CREDIT LTD

For Applicant(s):

That letter was addressed to the 1st Defendant. On 13th March 1982 the Plaintiff commenced an action (1982 No. 2013) against both Defendants for a declaration that it had rescinded the contract and for "damages". There was then correspondence between solicitors, not all of which correspondence is before us. In particular the first letter sent to the solicitors; Counsel for the Plaintiff emphasises that in this letter the solicitors repeatedly referred to "our client" in the singular. In reply the solicitors; the terms of the guarantee dated 11th March were still effective. Mr. Kwok submits that this approach is not open to the Plaintiff on its pleading: the Statement of Claim expressly relies upon the original contract of guarantee and does not set up an estoppel: therefore, if the contract of purchase and sale was rescinded, the original contract of guarantee has come to an end and it is necessary

For Respondent(s):

D. Chang, Q.C. with Mok (F. Zimmern & Co.)

COTTEEN INVESTMENTS LTD v. TOMASES INVESTMENTS LTD AND ANOTHER

CACV 37/1983

Court of Appeal3 June 1983

Citation

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations