Case Details
Listing:
ATIENZA MCMARY MAHAGUAY v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE[Decision on Leave Application]
ATIENZA MCMARY MAHAGUAY v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE[Decision on Leave Application]
[2026] HKCFI 4556 · HCAL 1043/2023
Court of First Instance
HCAL 1043/2023
[2026] HKCFI 4556
IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE
HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION
COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE
CONSTITUTIONAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE LAW LIST No. 1043 of 2023
BETWEEN
| |Atienza Mcmary Mahaguay |Applicant |
| | | |
| |and | |
| | | |
| |Torture Claims Appeal Board/ |Putative |
| |Non-refoulement Claims Petition Office |Respondent |
| | | |
| |and | |
| | | |
| |Director of Immigration |Putative |
| | |Interested |
| | |Party |
| | | |
| |Application for Leave to Apply for Judicial | |
| |Review | |
| |NOTIFICATION of the Judge’s decision (Ord. 53 | |
| |r. 3) | |
Following:
|( |consideration of documents only; or |
| | |
|( |consideration of documents and oral submissions by the Applicant in open |
| |court; |
Order by Deputy High Court Judge (Non-refoulement Claims) Val Chow:
1. Form 86 be amended on the court’s own motion as follows:-
a. The Torture Claims Appeal Board / Non-Refoulement Claims
Petition Office be named as the Putative Respondent; and
b. The Director of Immigration be named as the Putative
Interested Party.
2. The application for leave to apply for judicial review be
dismissed.
Observations for the Applicant:
Introduction
1. By Form 86 filed on 28 June 2023 (the “Form 86”), the Applicant sought
leave to apply for judicial review (the “Leave Application”) against
the decision of the Torture Claims Appeal Board / Non-refoulement
Claims Petition Office (the “Board”) dated 23 June 2023 (the “Board’s
Decision”).
2. In the Form 86, the Applicant has named the Board as the proposed
respondent and also the proposed interested party. As it is trite
that the Board should be the proposed respondent whereas the Director
of Immigration (the “Director”) should be the proposed interested
party, I make an order to amend the Form 86 accordingly on the court’s
own motion.
3. An oral hearing was requested by the Applicant. It took place before
me on 22 July 2026 (the “Hearing”) and the Applicant attended in
person.
Background
4. The Applicant’s background, the basis and history of her claim and the
arguments she advanced had been set out in detail in the Board’s
Decision, and it is unnecessary for me to repeat the same here. The
hyperlink to the Board’s Decision is included below[1] for reference.
In summary, the Applicant came to Hong Kong to work as a domestic
helper but has remained here notwithstanding the termination of her
employment contract since November 2020. She claims that her life will
be in danger if she returns to her home country because she allegedly
witnessed a murder. She is afraid that she will be harmed by the
murderer (“the Adversary”).
Discussion
5. This kind of leave application is intended to be a filtering process
and elaborate reasons are not necessary, see: Re Zunariyah [2018] HKCA
14 at §23. Hence, the brief reasons for my decision are set out
below.
6. The applicable general principles are trite. It has been repeatedly
emphasised by appellate courts that judicial review does not operate
as a further avenue of appeal. Though in non-refoulement cases, the
Court applies a high standard of fairness to review the decision of
the Board with anxious scrutiny due to the seriousness of the issue at
hand, the Court must not usurp the role of the Board. Assessment of
evidence, country of origin information (“COI”) materials, risk of
harm, availability of state protection and viability of internal
relocation are primarily within the province of the Board. The Court
will not intervene by way of judicial review unless there are errors
of law, procedural unfairness or irrationality in the decision of the
Board, see: Nupur Mst v Director of Immigration [2018] HKCA 524, at
§14.
7. The determination of the merits of a non-refoulement claim is
essentially within the remit of the Director and the Board, who are
the primary decision-makers in the evaluation of the evidence based on
the materials available to them. A court will not usurp their primary
decision-making role in a judicial review, which is not an avenue for
revisiting the assessment by the Board in the hope that the court may
consider the matter afresh in the absence of any legal error. A
finding of fact is exclusively within the realm of the Board, which
this court will not interfere with unless such finding involved an
error of law, procedural unfairness or irrationality: see Re
Lakhwinder Singh [2018] HKCA 246; Re Daljit Singh [2018] HKCA 328; Re
Mudannayakalage Chaminda Pushpa Kumara [2018] HKCA 400; and Nupur Mst
v Director of Immigration [2018] HKCA 524.
8. An applicant, even if unrepresented, is required to properly identify
the grounds of judicial review in the Form 86, and to fully and
frankly disclose all material facts and potential legal answers, see:
Ho Loy & Another v Director of Environmental Protection HCAL 21/2015
(unreported, 22 December 2016) per Chow J (as he was then) at §142.
Where a Form 86 contains only general assertions without particulars
as to underlying facts or matters upon which the Board’s Decision is
said to be erroneous, such assertions are not effective grounds to
support a judicial review, see: Re Haider Khalil [2021] HKCA 223 at
§16.
9. In the Form 86 and her affidavit in support, the Applicant did not
provide any ground of review. At the Hearing, the Applicant confirmed
she had nothing else to add. On account of such failure to put forward
an effective ground of review, the Leave Application should be
dismissed.
10. In any event, having read the Board’s Decision, I do not find any
error of law, procedural unfairness or irrationality which can give
rise to a reasonably arguable case for review.
11. I am satisfied that the Board has given adequate reasons for its
decision and has conducted a meticulous analysis of the evidence put
before it. Amongst others, the Board was plainly correct in finding
that there was no evidence of any real risk of serious harm as the
Applicant’s claim of danger from the Adversary is entirely
speculative. She herself had conceded to the Board that there was no
evidence that the Adversary had suspected that she would report him to
the police about the murder (§§46-47, 63, 73-74).
12. In short, I am not satisfied that the Applicant’s intended challenge
of the Board’s Decision is reasonably arguable with any realistic
prospects of success. Accordingly, I refuse to grant leave for
judicial review.
Conclusion
13. In the premises, I make an order that the Form 86 be amended as
described above and the Leave Application be dismissed.
|Dated the 21st day of August 2026 | |
| | |
| |(Klein Tse) |
| |for Registrar, High Court |
Where leave to apply has been granted, Applicants and their legal
advisers are reminded of their obligation to reconsider the merits
of their application in the light of the Respondent’s evidence
|Notes for the Applicant:| | |
| | | |
| | | |
|If leave has been | | |
|granted, the Applicant | | |
|or the Applicant’s | | |
|solicitors must: | | |
|a) serve on the |Sent to the |Sent to the Putative |
|respondent and such |Applicant |Respondent / the Putative |
|interested parties |on 21/8/2026 |Respondent’s solicitors / |
|as may be directed by | |such Putative Interested |
|the Court the order |Atienza Mcmary |Parties as may be directed|
|granting leave and any |Mahaguay |by the Court / the |
|directions given within | |Putative Interested |
|14 days after the leave |Applicant’s ref. no:|Parties’ solicitors on |
|was granted |Nil |21/8/2026 |
|(Order 53, rule 4A); | | |
| | |Torture Claims Appeal |
|b) issue the originating| |Board/Non-refoulement |
|summons within 14 days | |Claims Petition Office |
|after the grant of leave| |Putative Respondent’s ref.|
|and serve it in | |no.: |
|accordance with Order | |USM 19607 |
|53, rule 5; and | | |
| | |Director of Immigration |
|c) supply to every other| |Putative Interested |
|party copies of every | |Party’s ref. no.: |
|affidavit which the | |QA T/C 1997/21 |
|Applicant proposes to | |(formerly RBCZ 10929/21) |
|use at the hearing, | | |
|including the affidavit | |Department of Justice, |
|in support of | |Senior Assistant Law |
|the application for | |Officer |
|leave | |(Civil Law) |
|(Order 53, rule 6(5)). | |(Civil Litigation Unit 2) |
Form CALL-1
-----------------------
[1]
https://legalref.judiciary.hk/doc/judg/html/vetted/other/en/2023/HCAL001043_
2023_files/the_Board's_Decision.pdf