Case Details

Citation

YUEN OI YEE, LISA v. CHONG KING PO, SALLY AND OTHERS, HCMP 1824A/2005

Case Number

HCMP 1824A/2005

Court

Court of First Instance

(CFI)

Decision Date

4 July 2006

Parties

Applicant(s):

YUEN OI YEE, LISA

Respondent(s):

CHONG KING PO, SALLY, KEN WONG, JACKY HO, KEN HUI

YUEN OI YEE, LISA v. CHONG KING PO, SALLY AND OTHERS

HCMP 1824A/2005

Court of First Instance4 July 2006

HCMP1824A/2005 YUEN OI YEE, LISA v. CHONG KING PO, SALLY AND OTHERS

HCMP 1824/2005

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF APPEAL

MISCELLANEOUS PROCEEDINGS NO. 1824 OF 2005

(ON INTENDED APPEAL FROM DCCJ 7079/2003, DCCJ 7080/2003,

DCCJ 7081/2003, DCCJ 7184/2003, DCCJ 7185/2003, DCCJ 7257/2003,
DCCJ 7258/2003 & DCCJ 2702/2004 [CONSOLIDATED];
DCCJ 378/2005 AND DCCJ 442/2005)

______________________

DCCJ 7079/2003

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

CIVIL ACTION NO. 7079 OF 2003

______________________

BETWEEN

	YUEN OI YEE, LISA	Plaintiff
	and
	CHONG KING PO, SALLY	1^st Defendant
	KEN WONG	2^nd Defendant
	JACKY HO	3^rd Defendant
	KEN HUI	4^th Defendant

______________________

DCCJ 7080/2003

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

CIVIL ACTION NO. 7080 OF 2003

______________________

BETWEEN

	YUEN OI YEE, LISA	Plaintiff
	and
	CHIU WING WAH, WILSON	Defendant

______________________

DCCJ 7081/2003

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

CIVIL ACTION NO. 7081 OF 2003

______________________

BETWEEN

	YUEN OI YEE, LISA	Plaintiff
	and
	CHAN KAM WAH, KENT	Defendant

______________________

DCCJ 7184/2003

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

CIVIL ACTION NO. 7184 OF 2003

______________________

BETWEEN

	YUEN OI YEE, LISA	Plaintiff
	and
	KU LAI CHIU, CINDY	1^st Defendant
	CHAN KWAI HING, CHANNY	2^nd Defendant
	HO SIU KWAN, MANDY	3^rd Defendant
	LEUNG MAN YEE, SOFIA	4^th Defendant

______________________

DCCJ 7185/2003

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

CIVIL ACTION NO. 7185 OF 2003

______________________

BETWEEN

	YUEN OI YEE, LISA	Plaintiff
	and
	CHAN KEUNG	Defendant

______________________

DCCJ 7257/2003

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

CIVIL ACTION NO. 7257 OF 2003

______________________

BETWEEN

	YUEN OI YEE, LISA	Plaintiff
	and
	LEUNG YIK HONG, FRED	1^st Defendant
	LAM CHUN WAI, ANNO	2^nd Defendant

______________________

DCCJ 7258/2003

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

CIVIL ACTION NO. 7258 OF 2003

______________________

BETWEEN

	YUEN OI YEE, LISA	Plaintiff
	and
	TSE MEI PO, MABLE	1^st Defendant
	CHOI YIN KI, ADA	2^nd Defendant
	HO MAY HAR, SANNIE	3^rd Defendant

______________________

DCCJ 2702/2004

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

CIVIL ACTION NO. 2702 OF 2004

______________________

BETWEEN

	YUEN OI YEE, LISA	Plaintiff
	and
	LUI CHUNG TAK	1^st Defendant
	TSUI YIU MING, ALLEN	2^nd Defendant
	KUI SUK YIN, KIMMY	3^rd Defendant

(CONSOLIDATED PURSUANT TO ORDER OF HIS HONOUR

JUDGE A. TO DATED 3RD NOVEMBER 2004)

______________________

DCCJ 378/2005

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

CIVIL ACTION NO. 378 OF 2005

______________________

BETWEEN

	YUEN OI YEE, LISA	Plaintiff
	and
	LEUNG YIK HONG, FRED	1^st Defendant
	HIG-DHP BARBADOS LTD.	2^nd Defendant
	HIG CAPITAL	3^rd Defendant
	DESA INTERNATIONAL LLC	4^th Defendant

______________________

DCCJ 442/2005

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

CIVIL ACTION NO. 442 OF 2005

______________________

BETWEEN

	YUEN OI YEE, LISA	Plaintiff
	and
	CHAN CHI TAK, RINGO	1^st Defendant
	CHAN HON HUNG	2^nd Defendant
	CHAU CHI SANG	3^rd Defendant
	CHIK KIN WING	4^th Defendant
	LAM KAI KUONG	5^th Defendant
	LI CHI KEUNG, DENNIS	6^th Defendant
	LUI CHIU MAN	7^th Defendant
	MOK SHUT YING, JENNY	8^th Defendant
	NGAI PING SUN	9^th Defendant
	YEUNG CHUNG FAT	10^th Defendant
	HIG-DHP BARBADOS LTD.	11^th Defendant
	HIG CAPITAL	12^th Defendant
	DESA INTERNATIONAL LLC	13^th Defendant

______________________

Before: Hon. Rogers V-P and Yuen JA in Court

Date of hearing : 4 July 2006

Date of Decision: 4 July 2006

----------------

DECISION

----------------

Hon Rogers V-P:

1. I shall ask Madam Justice Yuen to give the judgment of the Court.

Hon Yuen JA:

2. On 9 May 2006 we refused to grant leave to Ms Yuen to appeal from a decision of Judge H.C. Wong striking out 8 consolidated actions and 2 other actions.

3. On the same day, Ms Yuen filed a Notice of Motion asking for leave to appeal to the Court of Final Appeal against our order.

4. The Court of Final Appeal has held in HLF v MTC [2004] 3 HKLRD 241 that there can be no appeal against the Court of Appeal’s refusal of leave to appeal. Apparently this authority was drawn to Ms Yuen’s attention at the time she asked to file the Notice of Motion but she nevertheless insisted on making this application, which must be dismissed.

(ANTHONY ROGERS)
Vice-President

(MARIA YUEN)
Justice of Appeal

The Plaintiff, in person, present

Citation

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations

Appeal history

DCCJ 7080/2003
Judgment not in library
On appeal from
DCCJ 7081/2003
Judgment not in library
On appeal from
DCCJ 7184/2003
Judgment not in library
On appeal from
DCCJ 7185/2003
Judgment not in library
On appeal from
DCCJ 7257/2003
Judgment not in library
On appeal from
DCCJ 7258/2003
Judgment not in library
On appeal from
HCMP 1824/2005
Judgment not in library
On appeal from
YUEN OI YEE, LISA v. CHONG KING PO, SALLY AND OTHERS
DC · 27 Jan 2005
On appeal from
袁靄儀 v. 協峰電子有限公司及另一人
CA · 9 May 2006
On appeal from
袁靄儀 v. 協峰電子有限公司及另一人
CA · 9 May 2006
On appeal from
YUEN OI YEE, LISA v. CHONG KING PO, SALLY AND OTHERS
CFI · 4 Jul 2006
This judgment