GARDIOLA JEANE LAGAC v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE
[2026] HKCA 2100 · CAMP 162/2025
Court of Appeal
CAMP 162/2025, IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION COURT OF APPEAL MISCELLANEOUS PROCEEDINGS NO 162 OF 2025 (ON AN INTENDED APPEAL FROM HCAL NO 952 OF 2017) ____________ BETWEEN Gardiola Jeane Lagac Applicant and Torture Claims Appeal Board/ Putative Non-refoulement Claims Respondent Petition Office and DIRECTOR OF IMMIGRATION Putative Interested Party ____________ Before: Hon G Lam and Coleman JJA in Court Date of Judgment: 6 November 2026 _________________ J U D G M E N T _________________ Hon G Lam JA (giving the Judgment of the Court): Introduction This is an application for extension of time to appeal against the decision of High Court Judge Campbell-Moffat (“Judge”) dated 4 December 2018 refusing to grant extension of time for the applicant to seek leave to apply for judicial review. The intended judicial review is against the decision of the Torture Claims Appeal Board/adjudicator of the Non-refoulement Claims Petition Office (“Board”) dated 12 May 2017. In that decision, the Board dismissed the applicant’s appeal against the decision of the Director of Immigration (“Director”) dated 27 January 2016 not to allow the applicant to re-open her non-refoulement claim which had been deemed withdrawn due to her failure to submit a non-refoulement claim form. On 14 March 2019, the Judge refused to extend time for the applicant to appeal against her decision of 4 December 2018. Background The applicant is a national of the Philippines. She lodged her non-refoulment claim by way of written representation, but she did not submit her non-refoulement claim form by the given deadline. Details of the procedural background and the Board’s reasons for rejecting her appeal are all set out in [2] to [4] of the Judge’s decision dated 14 March 2019. The Judge has set out the grounds advanced by the applicant in support of the application and her reasons for refusal of the application: see [5] – [8] of the Form CALL-1. The renewed application before this Court By summons filed on 20 August 2025, the applicant made an application to this Court for leave to appeal the decision made on 14 March 2019. We shall treat this as a renewed application for an extension of time to appeal against the decision of the Judge dated 4 December 2018 refusing to extend time for leave to apply for judicial review. In the applicant’s supporting affirmation, she simply stated that she was late to appeal and asked for an extension of time. The applicant did not lodge any written submissions in accordance with the directions of the Registrar of Civil Appeals dated 20 August 2025. Pursuant to Order 1A rule 4 and Order 59 rule 14A of the Rules of the High Court (Cap.4A) (“RHC”), we find it appropriate to determine this application on the basis of the written materials without an oral hearing. Discussion With reference to RHC Order 53 rule 4(1), the applicant was late for about 3 months when she filed her initial application by Form 86 on 24 November 2017. In her supporting affirmation, the applicant stated that the decisions of the Director and the Board were made without any hearing and they rejected her case. There was no explanation of her delay. In a separate incident of delay, after the issuance of the Judge’s decision contained in the Form CALL-1, the applicant did not file her notice of appeal to this Court within the 14-day time limit prescribed under Order 53 rule 3(4) of the RHC and was about 1.5 months late when she filed her summons on 30 January 2019 in the Court of First Instance for extension of time to appeal. In her summons and supporting affirmation, the applicant stated that she did not receive the decision from the High Court, that she had to wait for her friend to lend her the filing fee of $1,045, and that she hoped the court would consider her baby son born out of wedlock whose existence was not known to her family. As explained by the Judge at [7] and [8] of her decision dated 14 March 2019, we also do not accept the applicant’s excuse of allegedly not receiving the Form CALL-1 and order mailed to her address as provided to the court by herself, at which she had received other mail from the court. As the applicant failed to give a valid explanation for the delay, the court will not extend time unless there are real prospects of success in the intended appeal. There is a further staggering delay of almost 6.5 years after the Judge’s decision of 14 March 2019, before the applicant applied to this Court by summons of 20 August 2025 for extension of time to appeal. This exceptional and inordinate delay, which is wholly unexplained, throws real doubt on the purpose of the application. We nevertheless briefly address the merits below. The Director’s decision dealt with the re-opening of a non-refoulment claim deemed withdrawn on the failure to return a completed non-refoulment claim form under (the then version of) section 37ZG(3) of the Immigration Ordinance. This section provided that:- “ A torture claim treated as withdrawn under subsection (1) may be re-opened if the person who made the claim provides sufficient evidence in writing to satisfy an immigration officer that due to circumstances beyond the person’s control, the person had not been able to return a completed torture claim form as required under section 37Y(2).” Although this statutory provision refers to “torture claim”, this Court has held that the same constraints also apply to other non-refoulement claims under the administrative provisions governing the Unified Screening Mechanism regime: see Ram Chander v Director of Immigration [2018] HKCA 585 at [9] and Re Sudimah [2019] HKCA 1030 at [14]. The Director considered that the applicant had not provided sufficient evidence in writing as required by this provision for re-opening the claim, because it was clear that she understood her obligation to complete the form in the briefing with the assistance of a Tagalog interpreter, she did not provide any medical document to support her alleged sickness, and it was not accepted that there was difficulty in communication with the representatives of the Duty Lawyer Scheme at any time (“DLS”). The Board dismissed the applicant’s appeal, because it also considered that the applicant had not provided sufficient evidence (1) to show why she was not able to attend an interview with or to contact the DLS by telephone, and (2) to support her allegation of illness by way of medical certificate. As mentioned above at [5], the applicant’s supporting affirmation for the present summons does not provide any explanation for not submitting her non-refoulement claim form nor did she add to the previous grounds. The question of whether sufficient evidence had been provided for re-opening the claim was a matter for the Director and, on appeal, the Board to decide. The court has no power to impugn the Board’s decision unless it is vitiated by some public law error, such as misdirection in law, procedural unfairness, or irrationality in the decision. The applicant has failed to establish or even identify any such public law grounds. In the absence of any such explanation, the Board’s decision could not be impugned. It is not for the Court of First Instance or this Court to substitute its own opinion on that question. The applicant has failed to advance any grounds to show how the Judge is said to have erred in dismissing her application for extension of time to seek leave to apply for judicial review. In conclusion, we share the Judge’s view that there is no merit in the application for extension of time to seek judicial review and, for that reason, time should not be extended for an appeal to be brought against the Judge’s decision. The applicant’s summons dated 20 August 2025 is accordingly dismissed. The Applicant, unrepresented, acting in person
Citation
Court
Procedural posture
Issues
Holdings
Legal principles
Disposition
Appeal history
GARDIOLA JEANE LAGAC v. TORTURE CLAIMS APPEAL BOARD / NON-REFOULEMENT CLAIMS PETITION OFFICE
CA · [2026] HKCA 2100
This judgment