Case Details
Citation
SUN'S ENTERPRISE LTD v. PARKER INTERNATIONAL CONSULTANTS LTD, HCA 4435/1980
Case Number
HCA 4435/1980
Court
Court of First Instance
(CFI)
Decision Date
12 November 1981
Parties
Applicant(s):

Sun's Enterprise Limited

Respondent(s):

Parker International Consultants Limited

For Applicant(s):

Mr. Liebhart of the defendant was unable to suggest any cause

For Respondent(s):

It is inconceivable that any businessman would gain the impression of a concluded agreement in Taipei when he, Mr. Sun, had to come to Hong Kong subsequently for the contract to be finalized and signed. Then, Mr. Sun claimed that Mr. Liebhart, Miss Connie Lee and Mr. Johnson Yang (or. Yaug) all instructed him to embark on immediate bulk production. It would not be commercially viable; width could serve as sample. Even if the 4 yards allegedly cut by Mr. Yang in Taipei had been the source of the swatches in these two letters of the defendant, they could not have been intended or accepted for approval of samples instead of quality reference. These two letters, "P1" and "P1(2)" did not even purport to refer to any approval. Lastly, it would indeed be unusual; Miss Chua instructed by Hampton, Winter & Glynn

SUN'S ENTERPRISE LTD v. PARKER INTERNATIONAL CONSULTANTS LTD

HCA 4435/1980

Court of First Instance12 November 1981

Citation

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations