Case Details
Citation
CHOI HUNG & SONS TRANSPORTATION CO LTD v. TAT MING AIR FORWARDING LTD, HCA 4671/1981
Case Number
HCA 4671/1981
Court
Court of First Instance
(CFI)
Decision Date
10 October 1983
Parties
Applicant(s):

CHOI HUNG & SONS TRANSPORTATION CO. LTD

Respondent(s):

TAT MING AIR FORWARDING LTD. trading as TOPMAN EXPRESS (HK) CORPORATION

For Applicant(s):

The plaintiffs had expected to make some $10;000 profit from the implementation of their contract with the defendants; a profit which, Mr. Tao conceded, had almost been wiped out by the 2nd May due to the late arrival of the Golden Park. If no berth was immediately available in Whampoa the fulfilment of their obligations might have resulted in a loss; nominal damages and a declaration that the defendants are liable to indemnify the plaintiffs against Mr. Chan's claim in a sum not exceeding $48,000. There will also be judgment

For Respondent(s):

On or about the 18th April Mr. Tao, Mr. Chan and the defendants' representative Mr. Ching visited Whampoa to look for a berth. According both to Mr. Tao and to Mr. Chan the expedition was inconclusive though Mr. Tao told me the Chinese Authorities wanted $100,000. For what he was not quite sure. Mr. Chan said this payment was; Insofar as the plaintiffs' claim is concerned I would hesitate to draw any inference adverse tad the defendants based on silence. Mr. Fung described a telephone conversation in which Mr. Tao said he was prepared to settle for "tea money". Insofar, however, as the defendants received a warning letter from Transgroup also dated the 25th May and claim a breach by the plaintiffs of what was

CHOI HUNG & SONS TRANSPORTATION CO LTD v. TAT MING AIR FORWARDING LTD

HCA 4671/1981

Court of First Instance10 October 1983

Citation

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations