Case Details
Citation
SO SUM-CHUEN v. THE QUEEN, CACC 731/1974
Case Number
CACC 731/1974
Court
Court of Appeal
(CA)
Decision Date
11 November 1974
Parties
Applicant(s):

SO Sum-chuen

Respondent(s):

THE QUEEN

For Applicant(s):

is doubtful but produced they were and as a result of his perusal of those records the learned magistrate observed that they revealed that the arresting detective constable's account differed in some respects from the evidence of his colleagues but went on to say that he did not consider that his evidence had been so discredited that he should rule that there was no case to answer. There is here, as Mr. Winter

For Respondent(s):

the learned magistrate appeared to consider that the fact that the knife was tested for finger prints (no finger prints were found upon it) militated against the appellant in that if he had not genuinely been seen holding the knife no finger print test would have been made since the result would have done nothing to onsure his conviction and might have led to his acquittal. Mr. Carolan; whom they were chasing or had given up the chase and added that the likelihood of either of these possibilities occurring was lessened by virtue of the fact that the constables were armed and therefore had an advantage over those being chased. Having failed to understand this point and being apprehensive that I was being unduly imperceptive, my apprehension was ...(illegible) that allayed when Mr. Carolan

SO SUM-CHUEN v. THE QUEEN

CACC 731/1974

Court of Appeal11 November 1974

Citation

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations