Case Details
Citation
广东省食品进出口集团公司及另一人 诉 同福酒业(1982)有限公司及另一人, HCA 7759Z/1995
Case Number
HCA 7759Z/1995
Court
Court of First Instance
(CFI)
Judges
  • it was the subject of any enactment.&nbsp; The Act of 1875 did not itself create any right of property in trade marks.&nbsp; As its title itself indicates and its provisions confirm, it simply provided for the registration of trade marks and spelled out the consequences of registration and non-registration upon the proprietary rights of the owner of the trade mark and the remedies available to him for the protection of those proprietary rights.&nbsp; The Act of 1875 must, therefore, be construed in the light of the common law relating to trade marks in 1875.&nbsp; I use the expression ‘common law’ to include the doctrines of equity applied in what at that time was the separate court of chancery.”</p>
  • the application to register, and when that application was made it was not open to the Respondent to claim successfully any right to the mark for herself.”</p>
  • us; but they have this analogy with the present inquiry — that they prove that the rule which denies the existence of copyright in those cases, is a rule established for the benefit and protection of the public.&nbsp; And we think the best protection that the law can afford to the public against such a fraud as that laid open by this plea, is, to make the practice of it unprofitable to its author.”</p>

广东省食品进出口集团公司及另一人 诉 同福酒业(1982)有限公司及另一人

HCA 7759Z/1995

Court of First Instance
Judges:it was the subject of any enactment.&nbsp; The Act of 1875 did not itself create any right of property in trade marks.&nbsp; As its title itself indicates and its provisions confirm, it simply provided for the registration of trade marks and spelled out the consequences of registration and non-registration upon the proprietary rights of the owner of the trade mark and the remedies available to him for the protection of those proprietary rights.&nbsp; The Act of 1875 must, therefore, be construed in the light of the common law relating to trade marks in 1875.&nbsp; I use the expression ‘common law’ to include the doctrines of equity applied in what at that time was the separate court of chancery.”</p>the application to register, and when that application was made it was not open to the Respondent to claim successfully any right to the mark for herself.”</p>us; but they have this analogy with the present inquiry — that they prove that the rule which denies the existence of copyright in those cases, is a rule established for the benefit and protection of the public.&nbsp; And we think the best protection that the law can afford to the public against such a fraud as that laid open by this plea, is, to make the practice of it unprofitable to its author.”</p>

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations