Case Details
Citation
CHIU BUTT-YORK v. CHIU KWOK-LIM AND OTHERS, CACV 97/1979
Case Number
CACV 97/1979
Court
Court of Appeal
(CA)
Decision Date
6 June 1980
Parties
Applicant(s):

CHIU Butt-york

For Applicant(s):

dispute in the New Territories in High Court Action No. 810 of 1979 in which the respondents were the plaintiffs and the appellant the 1st defendant. The action was heard before Mr. Commissioner Penlington (as he then was) from the 4th October to 26th October, 1979. On the 31st October oral judgment was given in favour of the respondent. On the 22nd November, 1979 reasons for the judgment were given. Solicitor; then lodged notice of appeal on the 10th December 1979. The judgment and order was perfected, filed by the respondents' solicitor on the 16th January, 1980 and served on the appellant on the 17th January, 1980. No further step was taken by either party. On the 17th March, 1980 the respondents' solicitor wrote to the appellant's solicitor giving seven days; of the Supreme Court Rules together with his affidavit in support which gave no reason for the delay at all. The appellant's solicitor also wrote to the respondents' solicitor requesting their consent to the application. On the same day the respondents' solicitor replied to the effect that he would take instructions from his clients. On the 17th April the respondents' solicitor wrote to the solicitor; In order to explain the reasons for the delay solicitor; that necessary steps would be taken for setting down the above appeal. These facts were known to the respondents and their solicitor. There is no question of the respondents or their solicitor not knowing that the appeal would be set down for hearing. The sole reason for the delay was due to an oversight on the part of the appellant's solicitor who said he "overlooked" the matter. This default learned counsel; B. Bernacchi, Q.C. and P. Fung (Arthur Au & Co.)

For Respondent(s):

need only refer to one affidavit filed by the solicitor; R. Neville Thomas, Q.C. and A.H. Sakhrani (T.S. Tong & Co.)

CHIU BUTT-YORK v. CHIU KWOK-LIM AND OTHERS

CACV 97/1979

Court of Appeal6 June 1980

Citation

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations