Case Details
Citation
AU JUEN v. KIU FUNG INVESTMENT CO LTD, CACV 41/1972
Case Number
CACV 41/1972
Court
Court of Appeal
(CA)
Decision Date
19 February 1973
Parties
Applicant(s):

Madam AU JUEN Administratrix of the estate of CHEUNG CHIU

Respondent(s):

KIU FUNG INVESTMENT COMPANY LIMITED

For Applicant(s):

There was no sufficient evidence, and it was admitted by the solicitor who appeared on behalf of the Claimant that there was no sufficient evidence, to support the claim. It has been suggested before us that the learned judge did not discharge his duty and that it was his duty to call evidence if he thought that there was not sufficient material upon which he could base his decision. Counsel who appears; does not create the duty which it is suggested was upon the learned judge and no such duty is upon any judge as an inherent part of his function. A judge under our law is a referee. It is his function to listen to the evidence which is placed before him. He is given power in many cases to call evidence if he thinks fit, but in a case such as this it was manifestly not his duty to instruct the solicitor

AU JUEN v. KIU FUNG INVESTMENT CO LTD

CACV 41/1972

Court of Appeal19 February 1973

Citation

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations