Case Details
Citation
INFINITRON (HONG KONG) LTD v. HIMALAYA (POWER) ELECTRONICS CO LTD, HCA 2219/1983
Case Number
HCA 2219/1983
Court
Court of First Instance
(CFI)
Decision Date
5 December 1983
Parties
Applicant(s):

INFINITRON (HONG KONG) LTD

Respondent(s):

HIMALAYA (POWER) ELECTRONICS CO. LTD

For Applicant(s):

After this", Mr. Chu said "Mr. Chong made enquiries of us about various matters but ceased to ask for payment or to ask us to take delivery." It is worthy of comment that neither he nor Madam Wong nor, indeed, Mr. Chong

For Respondent(s):

On the 28th February 1982 and subsequently, according to Mr. Chong, he had further telephone conversations in which Mr. Chu; In the course of Mr. Chong's evidence he raised what is a relatively minor issue but may have greater significance. Prima facie the issue was relevant to damages and credit. Mr. Chong said at one stage that the switches had been designed by the defendants' engineer and at another stage said they had been designed by Toho. In any event he asserted that they were custom-designed; Then Madam Wong gave evidence. She said "The plaintiffs delivered the goods late". She was there referring to the partial delivery under contract 72130. "That is why the contracts had to be cancelled. Mr. Chong; which is the first matter in dispute, is consistent with the plaintiffs' account. It was not challenged in any way. Mr. Chu's account of the telephone conversations with Mr. Chong was at best equivocal. In the defendants' solicitors' letter there was no mention at all of a meeting on or about the 7th April. On the other side of the balance lies Mr. Chong's assertion that the goods were custom-designed

INFINITRON (HONG KONG) LTD v. HIMALAYA (POWER) ELECTRONICS CO LTD

HCA 2219/1983

Court of First Instance5 December 1983

Citation

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations