|
DCCC 632/2017
[2018] HKDC 800
IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE
HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION
CRIMINAL CASE NO. 632 OF 2017
-----------------------------------
-----------------------------------
| Date: |
5th July 2018 at 09:45 am |
| Present: |
Mr Christopher WONG, Counsel on Fiat, for HKSAR |
|
Mr WU Chun Shing, instructed by M/s Cheung & Co assignedby DLA for Defendant |
| Offence: |
[1] Burglary (入屋犯法罪) |
----------------------------
Reasons for Sentence
----------------------------
Charge and facts
1. The Defendant pleads guilty to a charge of burglary of a residential unit.
2. At about 1130 h on 27/3/2017, the two occupants left home, a one-storey village house in Fanling surrounded by an iron fence of 2 metres high (“the House”). The gate of the fence was closed but not locked. The front door of the house was locked. There was a set of spare keys in an unlocked drawer beside the front door outside the house. Two IP cameras were installed inside the house.
3. Upon returning, one of the occupants found nothing amiss except for signs of ransacking inside the House. The two IP cameras had been moved. He lost cash of $50,000, two diamond rings (valued at $13,000 in total), one bracelet (valued at $1,500), eight watches (valued at $800,000 in total) from a cabinet inside his bedroom. He also lost cash of $3,500 in a metal box inside the bedroom. The spare key in the drawer was missing. The lost property amounted to $868,000 in total. The case was reported to the police.
4. CCTV of the village and the adjacent house captured the Defendant riding a bicycle in the vicinity at mid-noon and later entering the House. He stayed in the House for 24 minutes. He was wearing a facemask and looking around furtively. His backpack appeared to be full.
5. The IP camera of the House captured him inside and putting on a pair of gloves while standing near the entrance. The IP camera was then moved towards the wall.
6. He was recognized by a police officer on patrol near a game centre in Sheung Shui 2 days later. After caution he admitted to have entered the House on that occasion. He was arrested.
Mitigation
7. The Defendant is aged 32, of F. 5 education level. He lived with his parents. He had 4 records for (theft-related) burglary and 5 records for dishonesty such as going equipped for stealing and theft. Eleven days after he completed his 26 months’ sentence for burglary and theft, he committed the present offence.
8. His counsel Mr. Wu accepts that the Defendant’s recidivism for burglaries and dishonesty crimes as well as the high value of property stolen are each aggravating factors in his sentence.
Sentencing guidelines
9. The starting point is 3 years for burglary of domestic premises for a first offender of full age in the absence of aggravating factors (R v Chan Yui Man CACC 36/1988).
Sentencing the Defendant
10. I take 3 years as the initial starting point. I add 6 months to it due to the high value of the property lost. I add another 3 months for his recidivism for burglary and dishonesty crimes. One-third off for the timely plea of guilty, the sentence is 2 years 6 months. There are no other mitigating factors.
|