|
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL
1986 No. 85
(Criminal)
BETWEEN
THE QUEEN
And
CHUNG Chu-choi
Coram: Hon. Li, V.-P., Silke, J.A. & Power, J
Date of Hearing: 5th August 1986
Date of Judgment: 5th August 1986
-------------------------
Judgment
-------------------------
Li, V.-P.:
1. The
applicant was convicted of two charges, namely incitement to traffic in
dangerous drugs, contrary to Common Law, and Criminal intimidation, contrary to
section 24 of the Crimes Ordinance. These two charges arose out of a series of
incidents that occurred between 27th and 28th June 1985.
It was alleged that the applicant on 27th June incited one Chan
Chun-ho to traffic in dangerous drugs. On 28th June 1985 he
threatened one Yim Yu-fai with an illegal act, namely to fabricate evidence against
Yim with intent to alarm the said Yim Yu-fai. The prosecution evidence can be
summarised as follows.
2. In
the very early hours of 27th June last year the applicant arrested
one Chan Chun-ho, the victim of the first charge, for possession of dangerous drugs
for the purposes of unlawful trafficking. Chan was brought into the police
station. Later he was taken to his home for a search and then brought back to
the report room of the police station. After that Chan was put in a cell.
3. It
was alleged that while he was detained there, the applicant went to solicit and
to incite Chan to supply him with drugs. This was done with a promise that the
applicant would see to it that the charge of possession of dangerous drugs for
the purpose of unlawful trafficking was reduced to one of simple possession,
that the charge of resisting of arrest against Chan would be dropped and that
Chan would be granted bail later in the morning when Chan appeared in court.
4. As
the event turned out the original charge of trafficking of possession for the
purpose of unlawful trafficking was maintained. The charge of resisting arrest
was not dropped but Chan was granted bail. There had been previous arrangement
as to the duty route of the applicant that evening so that drugs could be supplied
to him by Chan.
5. In
the evening of 27th June the applicant was on patrol duty with a
police constable no. 45128 (PW3). They were patrolling around the Tze Wan Shan
area. At one stage the applicant told PW3 to wait for a while because he had an
appointment with one of his informers. Later on the applicant saw Chan and
signalled Chan to follow him. By that time Chan had equipped himself with a
small package of dangerous drugs.
6. The
applicant then led PW3 to a bus stop. They boarded a bus. The applicant told
the bus driver to wait for a while because there was another person coming.
Chan also boarded the bus. It was the applicant who suggested to PW3 that they
go to the upper deck where they seated themselves separately, near the aisle –
one on each side of the bus. Chan sat behind constable 45128, PW3. Applicant
said: Has the matter been fixed up. Thereupon Chan placed a small packet on his
cap. According to PW3 Chan placed the packet in the applicant’s service cap.
According to Chan he placed it in the applicant’s hand. When the packet had
been passed on the applicant signalled Chan to leave the bus. Chan did so. The
two constables continued the journey. Upon a next stop they alighted from the
bus. Before they did there was an episode of the applicant’s asking PW3 for
tissue papers which he then used to wrap the drugs, and threw them out of the
bus to be retrieved later on. But that is of no significance for the purpose of
this appeal.
7. Having
had the drugs in his possession the applicant continued to patrol with PW3. In
the early hours of the morning on the 28th they saw Yim Yu-fai (PW5)
in one of a blocks. The applicant called on Yim Yu-fai asking to inspect his
identity card. Yim took out his wallet. The applicant put the small packet in
his wallet and returned the wallet to him. Then he took Yim into a public
toilet. In that toilet, as witnessed by PW3, he asked Yim to give information
as to the other drug traffickers. Upon Yim’s refusal he threatened Yim that he
would frame him. He then asked for Yim to produce the wallet for inspection
again. From the wallet he took out the packet that he put in earlier, and said
that if he could frame him then he could frame him in the future. He could put
drugs in his home if he did not assist. Upon this threat Yim agreed to oblige
him. The drugs were taken back from Yim’s wallet.
8. At
the close of the prosecution case the applicant elected not to give evidence
but called three witnesses. The first defence witness another police constable,
gave evidence that on a previous occasion qwhen a suspect was arrested by the
applicant and himself a report was made of the arrest. PW3 was also on patrol
but in a different area. PW3 was very upset that his name was not put down as
one of the arresting officers. The insinuation was that PW3 had a grudge, a
small one at that, against the applicant.
9. The
second defence witness, also a constable, referred to what happened in the
small hours on the morning of the 27th June when Chan was detained
in no. 3 cell. He saw through a glass panel that PW3 was talking to Chan. There
no evidence as to the nature of the conversation. According to PW3 Chan asked
him when he could be granted bail, and PW3 was concerned. There was the
insinuation that there could have been an opportunity on the part of PW3 who
was then on cell duty to speak to Chan that he was the real culprit by
suggesting to Chan the supply of drugs.
10. The
third defence witness was another police constable who gave evidence that he
was one of another group of police officers in the vicinity outside one of the
blocks in Tze Wan Shan where the inspection of the identity card belonging to
Yim took place. He said it was PW3 who was talking to Yim. The applicant was
some 6 feet away behind them writing something. This evidence was a suggestion
that it could have been PW3 who was threatening Yim. This contradicted the
evidence of PW3 that it was the applicant who inspected Yim’s wallet.
11. The
judge having heard all the evidence came to the conclusion that he could rely
on the evidence of Chan and PW3 and he rejected the evidence adduced by the
defence. He convicted the applicant.
12. Grounds
of appeal have been filed. The first two grounds criticise the judge for having
treated evidence which was non corroborative as corroborative evidence and
having reversed the process of considering accomplice evidence.
13. In
his Reasons for Verdict the judge said at p.4:
Both
PW1 – Chan and PW3 were subjected to intensive cross-examination but were not
shaken and maintained what they had told the Court in chief.
Then
the judge went on to talk of corroboration of the evidence of PW1 – Chan who
supplied dangerous drugs to the accused. Treating Chan, quite properly, as an
accomplice. He went on to say:
That
corroboration was there in abundance. There was no doubt that he had been
arrested by the accused; had been in the Report Room area at the material time
when the bargain between him and the accused was struck; that he had arranged
to meet the accused on the evening of the 27th June in Tze Wan Shan
Estate; had boarded the bus and on that bus handed the accused a packet
containing a granular substance which according to PW1 was a dangerous drug.
PW2 – the bus driver and PW3’s evidence provides corroboration.
14. The
judge did say that both PW1 and PW3 were subjected to the intensive
cross-examination and were not shaken. This can only be interpreted as the
judge finding the evidence of Chan and PW3 reliable because later on he said:
I realised it would be dangerous to convict the accused
on the uncorroborated evidence of PW1 but as I have already said, his evidence
was very substantially corroborated and notwithstanding such corroboration I
found PW1 to be a truthful witness and I believed what he had told this Court.
We
understand the word ‘notwithstanding’ as meaning that even without
corroboration he would have convicted the applicant because he found PW1 – Chan
a truthful witness. This coupled with the earlier remark it cannot be said that
the judge looked for corroboration first so as to support his finding that PW1
was a reliable witness. PW3’s evidence required no corroboration.
15. As
to evidence of corroboration, the fact that Chan was arrested by the applicant
was never in dispute. That he had been in the report room at the material time
again was not disputed. The only dispute was that there was no corroborative
evidence as to the bargain. But one must look at the subsequent events to draw
the inference. It was the evidence of PW3 that the applicant told him he was
waiting for an informer in evening of the 27th. Secondly, there was
the evidence the two of them boarding the bus, and it was the applicant who
asked the driver to wait because there would be another person coming. Thirdly,
there was evidence that Chan supplied the applicant with drugs on the top of
the bus. It would be against common sense to say that without incitement Chan
took the initiative to supply drugs to the constable. The alternative would be
that PW3 and Chan conspired together to frame the applicant. That would mean
Yim Yu-fai had also joined in to commit perjury by supply evidence of
subsequent events. The judge quite properly said that PW3’s evidence provided
corroboration. There is nothing in the grounds one and two.
16. The
judge did not rely entirely on PW2’s evidence as the only corroboration. He said
it was PW2 and PW3 the evidence of both which provided the corroboration
because it was PW2 who said there were two uniform police officers who boarded
the bus and one of them asked him to wait and PW3 said it was the applicant who
asked.
17. Another
ground was that the judge erred to find PW1 a truthful witness. A list of
reasons had been advanced to show how the judge was wrong. These are basically
jury questions. The judge as a judge of fact, having seen and viewed the
witnesses, was entitled to come to his conclusion.
18. Another
complaint is that the judge failed to evaluate the three defence witnesses. In
his reason for verdict he said the accused elected not to give evidence but
called three short witnesses in an attempt to support the suggestion which were
made during the cross-examination of PW3 that it was PW3 who was really the
guilty party and not the accused. He further said:
I had the benefit of hearing the evidence and observing
the witnesses.
This
indicates that he had heard all the evidence, considered all the evidence and
observed all the witnesses. We cannot say that the judge did not evaluate the
evidence of the defence witnesses.
19. There are also complaints about the judge failed to consider the
discrepancies in evidence as between PW1 – Chan and PW3. These were referred to
the judge by counsel in counsel’s closing address as were the differences as
between Yim and PW3. It cannot be said with justification that the judge had
not considered them. On the discrepancies as between Yim and PW3 the judge
said:
……
of course there were a number of discrepancies between what he told the court
and what PW5 told the court concerning the second charge; for example where PW5
actually was when first approached by the accused and PW3 that night, where the
search and conversation between the accused and PW5 took place. Such
discrepancies are only to be expected when one takes into account the lapse of
time between the offence and the trial, but none of those discrepancies was of
such a nature that the judge had considered it as to lead me to believe that
PW3 and PW5 ahd told the court other than the truth.
20. Criticism
was made that the judge never set out discrepancies and evaluate each of them.
In our opinion the judge, giving his reason for verdict, is not obliged to do
so. Counsel contends that the judge must give reasons, indicating that he
sufficiently considered the evidence and all the points as raised by the
defence.
21. We
can do no better than refer to the case of Chan King Man v. The Queen(1),
a recent decision of this Court. In that case a number of the previous cases
were considered. The learned Chief Justice cited the dictim of Blair-kerr, J in
the case of R v R.E. Low(2). I shall not repeat it since that passage is
set out at p.113 of Chan King Man(1). The Chief Justice said (at p.114):
We
were referred also to Law Keung v R(3), and appeal from the decision of
a Magistrate to the High Court in which the then Chief Justice expressed
himself, obiter, on the obligation of a district judge.
Then
he set out the extract of the judgment and went on:
This
passage imposes a heavier, and different, burden on a District Judge than that
suggested by the Full court in LAW Tin-cheung(4) or LOW(2).
LAW Tin-cheung and LOW(2) should, in our view, be followed and not LAW
Keung(3).
The judgment which was the subject of the
appeal before us, covered twelve pages of closely spaced typescript. The judge
went further than the section requires him to do. A short statement of Reasons
for Verdict seldom needs to be as extensive as this .
22. We
are not suggesting that a district judge should give very scanty reason for
verdict and without comment. The present case was a simple one. The evidence
was straight forward if one applied one’s common sense. The judge in a 4 ½ page
judgment had given his reasons, after setting out the gist of evidence in
total. He had considered every point. The Ordinance does not require him to set
out every single point of the evidence or every single discrepancy. We are
satisfied that he has given his reasons and we cannot find fault with his
process of reasoning. For these reasons the application for leave to appeal
against conviction is refused.
23. We
have to consider now the application for leave to appeal against sentence. In
this respect we do feel that the five years overall sentence is too high. Both
offences were directed to one end, albeit by two separate illegal acts. In
imposing sentence the learned trial judge over-emphasised the separateness of
the two offences. In the circumstances we feel that an overall sentence of four
years is appropriate. For this reason we grant leave to appeal against
sentence, treat the application as the appeal proper. The appeal is allowed to
the extent the sentence of three years in respect of the first charge be
reduced to two and to be served consecutively with the sentences of two years
in respect of the second charge, making a total of four years in all.
|
|
(SIMON F.S. LI)
Vice President
|
Mr Sedgwick Q.C. & Mr. M.K. Wong (Michael O’Cock & Partners) for
Appellant
Mr T. Jenkin- Jones (Crown Prosecutor) for Respondent
(1) (1980) HKLR
105 (2) (1961) HKLR 13 (3) Crim. App.
625/72 (4) (1970) HKLR
105
|