Case Details

Citation

CHEUNG PUI YUEN AND OTHERS v. WORLDCUP INVESTMENTS INC AND OTHERS, CACV 389M/2006

Case Number

CACV 389M/2006

Court

Court of Appeal

(CA)

Decision Date

3 August 2007

Parties

Applicant(s):

CHEUNG PUI YUEN, CHEUNG PHEI CHIET, CHEUNG POH CHOO, WONG POH GEAK also known as CHEUNG POH GEAK, CHEUNG YEE CHING, CHEUNG POH LUCK also known as KWAN POH LUCK, CHEUNG POH CHIT also known as LAU POH CHIT also known as LAU CHEUNG POH CHIT, CHEUNG POH CHEOK (suing for and on behalf of the Estate of CHEUNG Kung Hai, Deceased)

Respondent(s):

WORLDCUP INVESTMENTS INC, DORAN LIMITED, PROFIT-TAKING COMPANY INC, FOUR PILLARS INVESTMENTS LIMITED, MEGABEST SECURITIES LIMITED, CHIN LAN HONG

CHEUNG PUI YUEN AND OTHERS v. WORLDCUP INVESTMENTS INC AND OTHERS

CACV 389M/2006

Court of Appeal3 August 2007

CACV000389M/2006 CHEUNG PUI YUEN AND OTHERS v. WORLDCUP INVESTMENTS INC AND OTHERS

cacv 389/2006

in the high court of the

hong kong special administrative region

court of appeal

civil appeal no. 389 of 2006

(on appeal from HCA NO. 1138 of 2005)

______________________

IN THE ESTATE OF CHEUNG KUNG HAI, DECEASED

BETWEEN

	CHEUNG PUI YUEN	1^st Plaintiff
	CHEUNG PHEI CHIET	2^nd Plaintiff
	CHEUNG POH CHOO	3^rd Plaintiff
	WONG POH GEAK also known as CHEUNG POH GEAK	4^th Plaintiff
	CHEUNG YEE CHING	5^th Plaintiff
	CHEUNG POH LUCK also known as KWAN POH LUCK	6^th Plaintiff
	CHEUNG POH CHIT also known as LAU POH CHIT also known as LAU CHEUNG POH CHIT	7^th Plaintiff
	CHEUNG POH CHEOK (suing for and on behalf of the Estate of CHEUNG Kung Hai, Deceased)	8^th Plaintiff
	and
	WORLDCUP INVESTMENTS INC.	1^st Defendant
	(incorporated under the laws of the Republic of Liberia)
	DORAN LIMITED	2^nd Defendant
	(incorporated under the laws of the Republic of Liberia)
	PROFIT-TAKING COMPANY INC.	3^rd Defendant
	(incorporated under the laws of the Republic of Liberia)
	FOUR PILLARS INVESTMENTS LIMITED	4^th Defendant
	(incorporated under the laws of the British Virgin Islands)
	MEGABEST SECURITIES LIMITED	5^th Defendant
	(incorporated under the laws of the British Virgin Islands)
	CHIN LAN HONG	6^th Defendant
	(sued as Executor and Trustee of the Estate of CHEUNG Kung Hai, Deceased)
	CHEUNG KEE WEE	7^th Defendant
	(sued as Executor and Trustee of the Estate of CHEUNG Kung Hai, Deceased)
	CHEUNG LIN WEE	8^th Defendant
	(sued as Executor and Trustee of the Estate of CHEUNG Kung Hai, Deceased)

______________________

Before : Hon Rogers VP, Le Pichon JA and Sakhrani J in Court

Dates of Hearing : 1 - 3 August 2007

Date of Handing Down Judgment : 5 September 2007

______________________

C O R R I G E N D A

______________________

Please note the following amendments in the Judgment handed down on 5 September 2007:

Between lines N and O of paragraph 72 on page 27, the sentence

“…registered share to each of the testator Madam Chin all dated…”

should read

“…registered share to each of the testator and Madam Chin all dated…”

At line K of paragraph 90 on page 36, the word

“usual” should read “unusual”.

Dated this 19^th day of September 2007.

(Phemie Chan)
Clerk to Hon Le Pichon JA

Citation

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations

Appeal history

CHEUNG PUI YUEN AND OTHERS v. WORLDCUP INVESTMENTS INC. AND OTHERS
CFI · 22 Sept 2006
On appeal from
CHEUNG PUI YUEN AND OTHERS v. WORLDCUP INVESTMENTS INC AND OTHERS
CA · 3 Aug 2007
This judgment
CHEUNG PUI YUEN AND OTHERS v. WORLDCUP INVESTMENTS INC. AND OTHERS
CA · 3 Aug 2007
On appeal from
CHEUNG PUI YUEN AND OTHERS v. WORLDCUP INVESTMENTS INC. AND OTHERS
CFA · 14 May 2009
On appeal from
CHEUNG PUI YUEN AND OTHERS v. WORLDCUP INVESTMENTS INC. AND OTHERS
CFA
On appeal from