Wong Pit Hing
Shum Fong
CACV 14A/1947
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF HONG KONG
APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPEAL No. 14 of 1947
-----------------
AND
Transcript of the shorthand notes taken of the oral judgment delivered by His Honour Mr. Justice E.H. Williams on 13 November, 1947
Coram: Sir Henry Blackall and Mr. Justice E.H. Williams.
Date of Judgment: 13 November 1947
JUDGMENT
1. I am quite satisfied that when I was giving my order of the 31st October, I was making it with reference to the subtenants in occuption at that time. Definitely that was my judgment and it is of interest to note that some time before the 9th December, I had asked, through my clerk, that the solicitors of the landlord should supply me with a list of all subtenants of the promises and on the 3rd December I received the list. That list was discussed with me on the 9th December when I was apportioning the premises and I then had the exact number of persons, 14 as against 8 members of the landlord's family and it was because there were 14 persons altogether i.e. 4 subtenants and their families that I decided that these rooms should be given up. I was dealing with the subtenants who were there at the time that the Tenancy Tribunal gave their decision. The Tenancy Tribunal expressed the desire that the subtenants on the premises should not be disturbed by the order which they made evicting the principal tenant.
13.11.47