Case Details

Citation

CONVOY GLOBAL HOLDINGS LTD AND OTHERS v/ CHO KWAI CHEE ROY AND OTHERS, HCA 2922/2017

Case Number

HCA 2922/2017

Registry reference: HCA2922M/2017

Court

Court of First Instance

(CFI)

Decision Date

19 September 2018

Parties

Applicant(s):

CONVOY GLOBAL HOLDINGS LIMITED, CONVOY COLLATERAL LIMITED, CSL SECURITIES LIMITED

Respondent(s):

CHO KWAI CHEE ROY, WONG LEE MAN QUINCY, MAK KWONG YIU MARK, YAN YE KAI BYRON, FONG SUT SAM ROSETTA, LAM CHI KEUNG, MA YIU HO PETER, CHAN NGAI SANG KENNY, NG MEN KIT BILLY, LEE DEREK HO YIN, CHAN LAI YEE CHRISTIE, POON HOR YEE AMY, MA CHUN MING, CHAN SZE LOON ALFRED, HON SIU HONG, LAM CHI YUNG PAUL, WONG MAN SEK, NG YAO KWOK, CHAN WANG FAI ANDY, CHEUNG WAN HUNG GILBERT, LING KOON WAH, EVER ROBUST HOLDINGS LIMITED, CHINA GREEN (HOLDINGS) LIMITED, CLASSICTIME INVESTMENTS LIMITED, FASTEK INVESTMENTS LIMITED, CHO KWAI YEE KEVIN, KWOK HIU KWAN, CHEN PEI XIONG, HUI KA WAH RONNIE, ATHENA POWER LIMITED, CAPITAL MATE LIMITED, CHINA DYNAMIC ENTERPRISES LIMITED, LUSTER WEALTH LIMITED, PERFECT GROWTH LIMITED, TOWN HEALTH CORPORATE ADVISORY, CHAN KA CHUNG, LIN CHEUK FUNG, LING WAI HOI, POON CHUN YIN

Judges

Harris

CONVOY GLOBAL HOLDINGS LTD AND OTHERS v/ CHO KWAI CHEE ROY AND OTHERS

[2018] HKCFI 2111

Court of First Instance19 September 2018

Judges:Harris

HCA2922M/2017 CONVOY GLOBAL HOLDINGS LTD AND OTHERS v/ CHO KWAI CHEE ROY AND OTHERS

HCA 2922/2017

[2018] HKCFI 2111

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

ACTION NO 2922 OF 2017

_____________________

BETWEEN
	CONVOY GLOBAL HOLDINGS LIMITED	1^st Plaintiff
	CONVOY COLLATERAL LIMITED	2^nd Plaintiff
	CSL SECURITIES LIMITED	3^rd Plaintiff
AND
	CHO KWAI CHEE ROY	1^st Defendant
	WONG LEE MAN QUINCY	2^nd Defendant
	MAK KWONG YIU MARK	3^rd Defendant
	YAN YE KAI BYRON	4^th Defendant
	FONG SUT SAM ROSETTA	5^th Defendant
	LAM CHI KEUNG	6^th Defendant
	MA YIU HO PETER	7^th Defendant
	CHAN NGAI SANG KENNY	8^th Defendant
	NG MEN KIT BILLY	9^th Defendant
	LEE DEREK HO YIN	10^th Defendant
	CHAN LAI YEE CHRISTIE	11^th Defendant
	POON HOR YEE AMY	12^th Defendant
	~~MA CHUN MING~~	~~13^th Defendant~~
	~~CHAN SZE LOON ALFRED~~	~~14^th Defendant~~
	HON SIU HONG	15^th Defendant
	LAM CHI YUNG PAUL	16^th Defendant
	~~WONG MAN SEK~~	~~17^th Defendant~~
	NG YAO KWOK	18^th Defendant
	CHAN WANG FAI ANDY	19^th Defendant
	CHEUNG WAN HUNG GILBERT	20^th Defendant
	LING KOON WAH	21^st Defendant
	EVER ROBUST HOLDINGS LIMITED	22^nd Defendant
	CHINA GREEN (HOLDINGS) LIMITED	23^rd Defendant
	CLASSICTIME INVESTMENTS LIMITED	24^th Defendant
	FASTEK INVESTMENTS LIMITED	25^th Defendant
	CHO KWAI YEE KEVIN	26^th Defendant
	KWOK HIU KWAN	27^th Defendant
	CHEN PEI XIONG	28^th Defendant
	HUI KA WAH RONNIE	29^th Defendant
	ATHENA POWER LIMITED	30^th Defendant
	CAPITAL MATE LIMITED	31^st Defendant
	CHINA DYNAMIC ENTERPRISES LIMITED	32^nd Defendant
	LUSTER WEALTH LIMITED	33^rd Defendant
	PERFECT GROWTH LIMITED	34^th Defendant
	TOWN HEALTH CORPORATE ADVISORY	35^th Defendant
	AND INVESTMENTS LIMITED
	CHAN KA CHUNG	36^th Defendant
	LIN CHEUK FUNG	37^th Defendant
	LING WAI HOI	38^th Defendant
	POON CHUN YIN	39^th Defendant

_____________________

Before:

Hon Harris J in Chambers

Date of Hearing:	5 September 2018
Date of Decision:	19 September 2018

_________________________

C O R R I G E N D U M

_________________________

1. In the following instances “the 3^rd Defendant” should be replaced by “the 3^rd Plaintiff”:

(a)   at para 3(4);

(b)   at para 4, on line E of page 5;

(c)   at para 11, on line D of page 9; and

(d)   at para 21, from line J to line K of page 12.

2. At para 4, on line H of page 5, “clam for equitable compensation” should read “claim for equitable compensation”.

3. At para 23, from line O to line P on page 13, the word “to” should be added immediately before “be a clear shortcoming in the claim….”

Dated this 3^rd day of October, 2018.

	(Janice Li)
	Clerk to Hon. Harris, J.

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations

Case Details

Citation

CONVOY GLOBAL HOLDINGS LTD AND OTHERS v/ CHO KWAI CHEE ROY AND OTHERS, HCA 2922/2017

Case Number

HCA 2922/2017

Registry reference: HCA2922M/2017

Court

Court of First Instance

(CFI)

Decision Date

19 September 2018

Parties

Applicant(s):

CONVOY GLOBAL HOLDINGS LIMITED, CONVOY COLLATERAL LIMITED, CSL SECURITIES LIMITED

Respondent(s):

Judges

Harris