HUI LONG TING v. AU SIU CHUNG AND ANOTHER
[2026] HKCFI 3937 · HCPI 218/2022
Court of First Instance
HCPI 218/2022
[2026] HKCFI 3937
IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE
HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION
COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE
PERSONAL INJURIES ACTION NO 218 OF 2022
(TRANSFERRED FROM DCPI 707 OF 2020)
BETWEEN
|HUI LONG TING |Plaintiff |
|(late a minor but now of full age) | |
| and |
|AU SIU CHUNG |1st Defendant |
|HOI PING CHAMBER OF COMMERCE SECONDARY SCHOOL |2nd Defendant |
Before: Hon Leung J in Court
Date of Hearing: 11 December 2025
Date of Judgment on Assessment of Damages: 10 July 2026
ASSESSMENT OF DAMAGES
1. The plaintiff (“Hui”) was seriously injured in a traffic accident back
in 2017 during a country park outing organised by his school, the 2nd
defendant (“the School”). The 1st defendant (“Au”) was the rider of
the bicycle which struck and injured Hui in the accident. By his
mother and next friend (“the Mother”), Hui commenced action to claim
damages against Au and the School. Interlocutory judgment has since
been entered against Au for damages to be assessed with costs. The
claim against the School has subsequently been settled while the
School has also entered judgment against Au for contribution or
indemnity.
2. This is the assessment of damages.
BACKGROUND
3. Hui was born on 16 April 2005. The accident happened on 6 November
2017 when he was a 12-year-old Form 1 student of the School, taking
part in the outing organised by the School at the Tai Po Country Park,
New Territories. Au was riding his bicycle which struck Hui who was
crossing the road in the vicinity. Hui was seriously injured and lost
consciousness.
4. As a result of the accident, Au was charged with and convicted of
careless cycling under section 46 of the Road Traffic Ordinance in
November 2018.
5. With legal aid, the Mother, as the next friend of Hui, commenced
action in the District Court on 20 March 2020 for damages against Au
as the responsible cyclist and the School in its loco parentis
capacity at the time (DCPI 707/2020).
6. On 1 June 2020, the School filed notice of contribution and/or
indemnity against Au in respect of any liability to pay damages and
costs to Hui attributable to the breach on the part of Au.
7. Au did not enter appearance. On 15 September 2020, interlocutory
judgment for damages to be assessed with costs was entered in favour
of Hui against Au.
8. On 14 July 2022, DCPI 707/2020 was transferred to this level of court.
Hence the present action.
9. Hui reached the age of majority in April 2023. On 18 August 2023, Hui
filed a notice to adopt the present action in his own name. In
January 2024, legal aid was granted to Hui while that previously
granted to the Mother was discharged.
10. In January 2024, Hui and the School came to terms in settlement of the
present action between them[1].
11. On 3 June 2024, the School obtained judgment for
contribution/indemnity against Au. The order was in terms of any sum
which Hui may recover against the School. The reality upon the
settlement between Hui and the School would mean that the entitlement
of the School to seek contribution/indemnity against Au must now be
subject to its terms of the settlement with Hui. There is no issue of
finding to be made between Hui and the School or between the School
and Au in this hearing. Indeed the School did not appear.
12. However, on 26 August 2024, legal aid to Hui was discharged, and Hui
filed his notice to act in person on 4 September 2025.
13. Au was absent from the present hearing. Satisfied with the service of
notice of hearing, this court saw no reason for preventing him from
proceeding in the absence of the other parties.
14. As of late 2024 and now, the quantum claimed as pleaded amounts to
about HK$27 million.
INJURIES AND TREATMENTS
15. After the accident, Hui was admitted to the Prince of Wales Hospital
(“PWH”) in the following condition:
a) Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) of 6/15 (E1V2M3);
b) Stable vital signs and sluggish bilateral pupil response at 2mm
on both sides;
c) Parafalcine acute subdural hematoma with traumatic subarachnoid
haemorrhage in the basal cisterns and intraventricular
haemorrhage;
d) Bilateral cerebral edema and multifocal intraparenchymal
haemorrhage of the right cerebellum;
e) Fractures of the right temporal and occipital bone; and
f) Complete collapse of left lower lobe of the lung and right lower
lobe lung contusions.
16. Insertion of external ventricular drain was performed. In view of
high intracranial pressure, CT scan was carried out, which showed
evolving right epidural hematoma underneath the temporal bone fracture
and further evolution of the cerebellar hematoma. Right transverse-
sigmoid junction sinus obstruction related to the comminuted fracture
of the right temporal bone was found. A second operation was
performed on the same day for the evacuation of the epidural hematoma
and evacuation of the haemorrhagic cerebellar contusion.
17. After surgeries and sedation therapy, Hui’s intracranial pressure
became stable. However, due to episodes of post-traumatic seizures
and respiratory distress caused by the lung collapse and contusion,
Hui had to be put under intensive care and reintubation.
18. On 7 November 2017, the ophthalmologist diagnosed that Hui suffered
from right 6th and 7th cranial nerve palsy. After reviewing the CT
scan on 9 November 2017, the doctor found that Hui has a left superior
orbital hematoma with surgical emphysema with no orbital fracture.
19. Hui had a development of pseudo meningocele at the posterior fossa,
which required prolonged drainage of cerebro-spinal fluid. This was
eventually repaired on 4 December 2017.
20. Hui finally regained consciousness on 15 December 2017, which was more
than 5 weeks after the accident.
21. On 26 February 2018, CT scan still showed hydrocephalus with the same
ventricular size as what the CT scan showed in mid-January 2018.
However, further operation to address that was declined by Hui’s
parents due to uncertain beneficial effect.
22. Hui was discharged on 20 April 2018, which was 5.5 months after
admission. Upon discharge, Hui could walk, requiring only minor
support. He was cognitively well and able to communicate fluently.
He was followed up in out-patient physiotherapy and occupational
therapy.
23. Until late April 2019, Hui had undergone 54 sessions of occupational
therapy at PWH. Hand function assessment on 3 December 2018 showed
that his bilateral hand function was still below norm for both hands.
Occupational therapy concluded by mid-July 2019. Assessment in mid-
July 2019 suggested that Hui had moderate deficit in memory but
satisfactory performance in other cognitive domains. He was therefore
advised to continue home based training in cognition, activities of
daily life (ADL) and hand function after full resumption of schooling.
24. Physiotherapy at Queen Elizabeth Hospital (“QEH”) started in mid-April
2018. By mid-October 2019, Hui reported no functional limitation in
his ADL. However, muscle power of his face, right upper limb and
lower limb remained similar as when he commenced physiotherapy. He
could perform single leg standing for 10 seconds and walk unaided and
independently. By the end of 2019, Hui had attended 57 sessions of
physiotherapy.
25. Pure tone audiogram performed on 26 July 2018 at the Ear, Nose and
Throat (ENT) Department of PWH suggested that Hui had a moderate to
severe sensorineural hearing loss. This later improved to a mild to
moderate degree. He also had swallowing difficulty. Between early
September 2018 and the end of 2019, Hui had attended 8 sessions of
speech therapy. He scored aphasia quotient of 99.4/100 in the
Cantonese Aphasia Test. His swallowing function was said to have
improved so that he could tolerate a regular diet and thin liquid
consistency without overt aspiration signs. He remained mildly
dysarthric, characterized by mild imprecise articulation and
monotonous speech production. Oro-motor and speech training
continued.
26. The Mother has also taken Hui to electro-acupuncture with Chinese
herbal medicine prescriptions for 35 sessions between late January
2018 and early November 2018. The registered Chinese medicine
practitioner noted that Hui became able to use his muscles normally
and walk and run stably. His facial paralysis and hearing loss was
mitigated, and he was able to drink water without choking.
27. Hui also attended clinical psychological assessments at the Adolescent
Medical Centre on 2 August 2018, with two follow-up sessions on 14
January 2019 and 18 July 2019. At the last appointment, Hui reported
that he was motivated to make further improvement in his academic
performance and rehabilitation training. He managed to cope with his
homework, and he felt less stressful. The Mother has adjusted her
expectation regarding his progress in rehabilitation training. On
this basis, it was agreed that no further clinical psychologist
appointment would be necessary.
28. In early March 2024, Hui experienced attack of muscle spasm, and
consulted Dr Fung Chin Fai, a neurologist (“Dr Fung”).
Electroencephalogram (EEG) examination at St Teresa’s Hospital
revealed normal result. Hui consulted the doctor again in early
April 2024 for repeated muscle spasm, and was given medication for
epilepsy.
MEDICAL EXPERT EVIDENCE
29. Reports from medical experts of multiple disciplines have been
commissioned for the purpose of quantum. The neurology experts
examined Hui when he was 15 years old. The experts of the other
disciplines examined Hui and produced their reports when Hui was
16 years old. The neurological expert instructed on behalf of Hui had
the chance to examine Hui again when he was about 19 years old and
about to graduate from secondary school.
Neurological experts
30. Dr Yu Yuk Ling (“Dr Yu”) and Dr Kan Yiu Ting (“Dr Kan”) were
respectively instructed on behalf of Hui and the School. The
neurological experts conducted the joint neurological examination on
29 December 2020, and compiled their joint expert report dated
23 February 2021. The experts shared the following opinion.
31. Hui suffered extremely severe brain injury as a result of the
accident. The experts considered that it was near miracle that Hui
managed to survive, and substantial neurological sequelae was
inevitable. Hui’s cognition and highest integrative function have
been impaired. He suffered from significant degree of speech
difficulty. His impairment of mood, behaviour and personality was
significant rendering him a somewhat stranger to his family and those
familiar to him. His experience of minor headache and giddiness were
symptoms of post-concussion syndrome. His impairment of balance and
dexterity as the result of the cerebellar injury led to a reduction of
efficiency in conducting daily living tasks, hampering with his study
and destroying his hobby and sport activity. There were sensory
disturbances in his trigeminal nerve. His injured right facial nerve
has resulted in facial disfigurement, and the right facial nerve palsy
resulted in lagophthalmos. He experienced mild hearing impairment.
While the complaint about previous episodes of epilepsy in the early
post-injury phase was noted, the experts found that Hui was seizure-
free at the time of the joint examination.
32. The experts opined that Hui has reached maximal medical improvement.
His neurological impairment amounted to 37% of whole person, and was
likely permanent. Considering his pre-accident high academic
achievements and awards, the experts observed that the significant
impairment has diminished Hui’s intelligence, which would result in
his inability to enter top tier university and profession of high
earnings in the future. Given his physical condition, Hui was not
considered to be capable of heavy labour or craftsmanship of high
calibre. All these might leave him with the prospect of resorting to
low-earning sedentary occupations in the future such as security guard
and warehouse clerk. On this basis, and in quantitative terms, the
loss of earning capacity was projected to be 70%. Observing that Hui
was ambulatory and could self-feed, the experts considered that
reduction of his life expectancy would be unlikely.
33. With leave of the court, supplemental expert report was obtained from
Dr Yu. In his report dated 30 May 2024, Dr Yu noted the more recent
complaints of Hui. Hui complained about headache daily, lasting for
about 30 minutes each time. That disturbed his sleep and therefore
concentration in his study. Daily dizziness also happened, lasting
for about 30 minutes each time, particularly during the time when he
prepared for public examination.
34. Dr Yu reported that under the Montreal Cognitive Assessment – Hong
Kong Version (HK-MoCA), Hui’s neurological status has improved, when
comparing with the examination results back in December 2020. This
was due to his effort put into the training of his language, cognitive
and limb function. However, Dr Yu opined that the residual
neurological deficits would remain, including neurocognitive and neuro-
behavioural impairments, dysphasia, epilepsy, right facial paresis
with lagophthalmos, right hand clumsiness, truncal ataxia, headache
and dizziness. Regarding that, Dr Yu also noted the recent diagnosis
of Dr Fung, as mentioned above, about Hui’s post-traumatic epilepsy in
the form of complex partial seizure, and his prescription of anti-
epileptic drug for Hui.
35. On the basis of his latest conditions, Dr Yu assessed Hui to be
suffering 22% impairment of the whole person. This shows his
substantial improvement since the last assessment when Hui was a
few years younger. However, in the light of his post-traumatic
epilepsy, Dr Yu recommended follow up at neurological clinics every 3
months. Dr Yu withheld further assessment of Hui’s loss of earning
capacity in the light of his pending public examination result then.
However, he added his recommendation against career entailing danger
in the event of seizures due to the post-traumatic epilepsy.
ENT expert
36. Dr Au Wing Wah (“Dr Au”) was appointed as the single joint ENT expert
on behalf of Hui and the School. Physical examination was carried out
on 10 August 2021. The expert report was dated 14 September 2021.
37. Upon physical examination and assessment, Dr Au opined that Hui had
incomplete right facial nerve palsy and right hearing impairment.
38. The right facial nerve palsy was the direct result of the accident.
This caused inability to close his right eye completely, with 2/5
remaining unclosed during the examination, as well as slight deviation
of the angle of his mouth to the left, which was more visible when he
smiled or talked. Dr Au opined that such disabilities would likely be
permanent without improvement. As a remedy, Dr Au suggested nerve
grafting but the process would be invasive and unpredictable. The
parents were noted to be reluctant to such surgical intervention.
From the ENT perspective, impairment was assessed to be 5% of whole
person.
39. Evidence of air and bone conduction were found during the latest
hearing test, and Dr Au opined that Hui was profoundly deaf in his
right ear. The disability would not improve, which Dr Au assessed to
amount to 4% of whole person impairment. The fitting of hearing aid
was recommended.
Ophthalmology expert
40. Dr Tsui Chung Wan (“Dr Tsui”) was instructed on behalf of Hui and the
School as single joint ophthalmology expert. The expert examined Hui
on 17 August 2021. The expert report was dated 4 October 2021.
41. Hui’s problem was right eye discomfort and dryness due to incomplete
covering of right eyelid during blinking and sleep. He also
complained about the jerking movement of the eyes when looking towards
the right side, and that he would occasionally bump into people on his
right side in the street. Hui has been on regular artificial tear
supplement and lubricant ointment for the right eye exposure
keratopathy.
42. Dr Tsui detected that Hui’s best corrected visual acuity was right eye
1.0 and left eye 1.0 respectively, indicating no acuity-related visual
impairment. With the use of the Humphrey Field Analyzer, Dr Tsui
assessed Hui’s visual field defect resulted in about 26% visual field
impairment, which was a 5% impairment of the whole visual system and
5% impairment of whole person. Dr Tsui opined that from
the ophthalmological perspective, Hui should have normal ability in
performing activities of daily living with normal reserve capacity.
43. Dr Tsui opined that the condition of Hui’s right eye visual field
being overlapped by his left eye could be compensated and would be
unnoticeable in binocular visual field. His right eye temporal field
defect however could not be compensated. There was also horizontal
nystagmus on right gaze. As a result, Hui may experience slight
blurring of vision as well as some difficulty in reading fine prints,
perceiving depth and walking on uneven surface or crossing a busy
street. On account of these impairments, and purely for reference, Dr
Tsui assessed that Hui would suffer 10% loss of earning capacity.
Psychiatric experts
44. Dr Tsang Suk Kwan Jenny (“Dr Tsang”) and Dr Law Wun Tong (“Dr Law”)
were instructed on behalf of Hui and the School respectively as the
psychiatric experts. The joint examination was conducted on 10 August
2021. The experts produced their joint report dated 6 October 2021.
45. The psychiatric experts noted that Hui presented with insomnia,
irritability, crying, social withdrawal and depressed mood. They
agreed on the diagnosis of adjustment disorder with depressed mood,
which was wholly caused by the accident. Dr Tsang observed that Hui
felt helpless and hopeless when faced with decline in his abilities.
He felt high level of irritability, and the outburst took the form of
conduct such as smashing things onto the floor and throwing a chair in
July 2020. Hui would also quarrel with his younger sister.
46. The experts slightly differed on the prognosis.
47. Dr Tsang opined that the prognosis of Hui’s adjustment disorder would
hinge upon resolution of stressors being the multiple physical
impairments, memory and other cognitive impairment experienced by him.
He opined that Hui would continue to suffer from significant
irritability and temper outburst in the future. In view of his having
reached maximal medical improvement and the permanent physical
impairment being moderate to severe, Dr Tsang opined that the
prognosis of the adjustment disorder would be less favourable.
48. Whilst Dr Law agreed that the major stressor would be the
neurocognitive impairment, which was moderate and unfavourable,
he opined that Hui would gradually adapt to school life again and cope
with his study. The expert observed that Hui did show marked
impairment in his mood. He opined that the prognosis should be
guardedly favourable.
49. Dr Tsang assessed that Hui suffers from 8% permanent impairment on
psychiatric grounds, corresponding to minor residual symptoms with
some increased risk of decompensation under stressful situations. Dr
Law opined that Hui’s adjustment order belonged to the mild range,
amounting to 5% permanent impairment of whole person.
Plastic surgery experts
50. Dr Mok Chun On (“Dr Mok”) and Dr Ian Nicolson (“Dr Nicolson”) were
instructed as the plastic surgery experts on behalf of Hui and the
School respectively. The experts conducted the joint examination of
Hui on 26 August 2021. The experts produced their joint expert report
dated 21 October 2021.
51. The experts observed visible scars on Hui’s scalp and limbs caused by
the accident. They considered the long scar on the occipital scalp
was mostly covered by hair when properly groomed. The hypertrophic
scars on his limbs were minor, asymptomatic with no interference with
limb movement, and therefore no surgical intervention would be
necessary. They shared the view that these scars accounted for 1%
permanent impairment of whole person.
52. The experts agreed with the observations of the neurological experts
about the right facial paresis of Hui. They also noted his
lagophthalmos was managed by the specialist in the public hospital,
and no signs of desiccation or conjunctivitis was detected yet. The
suggestion by the treating specialist of plastic procedure like weight
implantation over the right eyelid was noted, which the expert opined
might be carried out in the public sector at reasonable nominal cost.
Occupational therapists
53. Mrs Tsang Lau Kit-ping Alice (“Mrs Tsang”) and Dr Cheng Shu-kei,
Andy (“Dr Cheng”) were instructed on behalf of Hui and the School
respectively as the occupational therapy experts. The experts
conducted their joint interview on 19 August 2021. They produced
their joint expert report dated 19 November 2021.
54. During the joint interview, Hui complained about unsteadiness and poor
balance when walking. He has been bumping into furniture at home.
His speed of doing things and agility have been reduced. There was
presence of tremor in both his hands, though much improved than the
condition after the accident. He was slow in writing, thinking and
speaking. He would require longer time before expressing his
thoughts. He would also require more time for examinations, with some
subjects needing up to 60% additional time. He has been excused from
physical education classes. He complained about trouble in closing
his eye completely and no vision in his right eye except for some
light. Information was obtained from the Mother, including that about
Hui’s experiences of nightmare and scream during the night, though
occurrence has much reduced.
55. The experts shared the observations that Hui was attentive and
motivated to perform instructed tasks. He did not show much emotion
and was slow in expressing himself. Comprehension was basically
acceptable for simple tasks but slightly poor for complicated
procedures. Speed of work was excessively slow and so was accuracy.
Physical balance was found to be slightly unwarrantable, and Hui could
not maintain single leg standing.
56. The occupational therapy experts made various recommendations on Hui’s
living conditions as well as solutions to remedy Hui’s disabilities
and impairment, psycho-social and family problems. They will be
particularised and discussed below.
ORAL EVIDENCE
57. Hui and the Mother gave evidence, essentially by adopting their
respective witness statements. Hui made his witness statements when
he was between 15 and 19 years old. The last one was dated
early 2024.
58. Hui’s father was supposed to but did not attend the hearing to
testify. Hence exclusion of his oral evidence by way of witness
statement.
59. The evidence of Hui and the Mother, considered together with their
information relayed to the medical experts mentioned above, reveals
that Hui was a normal, healthy and sportive boy prior to the accident.
He was academically sound, particularly in mathematics, and received
numerous open academic and extra-curricular activity awards. He was
grade 6 going on 7 on the piano. Apart from taking care of himself,
he helped out in family chores and looked after his younger sister.
60. In court, Hui gave an update on his current condition since his last
witness statement. He complained about epilepsy during sleep, and
could be awakened by muscle clamp suddenly. He would feel stressful,
with shaking hand when holding a bottle. According to the Mother,
medication to address his epilepsy was of little effect.
61. Hui is disturbed by his scar and facial palsy, rendering it hard for
him to open up or to properly express himself. He becomes reluctant.
He feels its impact on his human interaction as well as potential
employment due to concern about ability to impress during job
interview and performance. He loses temper on the family too.
62. According to the Mother, Hui has undergone an eyelid surgery recently
in January 2024 with unremarkable improvement to his inability to
fully close his right eye. The resultant irritation noted by the
medical experts mentioned above remains.
63. Hui feels his motivation has dropped, and tends to get tired easily.
This affects his study, and he has given blank answer during
examination. That said, Hui was at the time of the hearing in his
second year studying under the Joint University Programmes Admission
System. Currently he is studying economics, after having tried out
psychology during the first year. He admits that it would be better
to have a diploma qualification, but his goal and direction are at the
moment fluid.
64. This court had the opportunity of observing the ability of Hui to
articulate and to express himself as well as his demeanour, and finds
that it much aligns with that made by the medical experts mentioned
above, particularly the most recent opinion expressed by Dr Yu, the
neurological expert. Hui was clear but slow and monotone. His
current condition shows noticeable improvement since the time when the
experts examined him when he was about 16 years old.
65. The evidence of Hui and the Mother was of course uncontradicted. I
also see no other reason why their evidence, including that mentioned
above, should not be accepted, subject to evaluation against all the
other evidence.
PAIN, SUFFERING AND LOSS OF AMENITIES (PSLA)
66. Hui met the accident when he was 12 years old. Categorisation by the
neurological experts of Hui surviving the accident as near-miracle
speaks loudly about the seriousness of what fell on him. So do the
medical records. I find it safe to say the same regarding his
striving through his entire teen age under his post-accident
conditions. Pain from the injuries and the prolonged treatment aside,
that Hui would have to face the obvious compromise of what he used to
achieve, and expected to have been able to achieve but for the
accident, adds to his suffering. This has been manifested and readily
observed by the various medical experts as well as this court
listening to him during the hearing.
67. In Lee Ting Lam v Leung Kam Ming [1980] HKLR 657, the court
categorised seriousness of injuries in the ascending order of serious
injury, substantial injury, gross disability and disaster. The range
of award for each category was updated in Cheung Ka Man v Wong Yu
Huen [2023] 2 HKLRD 418 in light of inflation so that damages for:
1) “serious injury” is between $585,000 to $789,000;
2) “substantial injury” is between $789,000 to $966,000;
3) “gross disability” is between $966,000 to $1,463,000; and
4) “disaster” is $1,463,000 and above.
68. Hui claims that his case falls into the “gross disability” category
attracting an award of damages in the sum of HK$1,200,000.
69. No assistance on decided case as comparables were provided to this
court. Hence this court’s reference to cases including Chan Siu Lung
v Yip Kam Shui & Ors [2022] HKCFI 970; Lai Pui Ling suing by her
brother and next friend Lai Hin Ho v Ho Chi Keung [2016] HKCU 1190;
Siu Kin Keung Anthony v H&M Hennes & Mauritz Ltd HCPI 81/2011 (31
October 2012); Ngan Man Yuk v Lau Kwan Him & Anor [2005] HKCU 248; Lee
Wai Kin v Cheng Hon Kit Jacker HCPI 1488/2000 (6 July 2002); Lau Ming
Wah v Yau Ka Fai [1989] HKLY 481.
70. All the circumstances of Hui considered, including the serious
injuries, complicated treatment and hospitalisation period as well as
the pain and compromise of abilities and quality of life during his
post-accident upbringing and adulthood, I accept that the present case
belongs to the top end of the category of “substantial injury”. In
terms of quantification, which is not entirely a matter of strait-
jacketing, I find an award of HK$1,000,000, inflation by now factored
in, would be reasonable.
LOSS OF SERVICE
71. Loss of service is claimed pursuant to section 20C(4) of the Law
Amendment and Reform (Consolidation) Ordinance, Cap 23. The section
provides:
“Where injury is caused to any person by any wrongful act,
neglect or default which entitles him to maintain an action and
recover damages in respect thereof and which causes any
dependant of the injured person to be deprived of his gratuitous
services, the action may include a claim for damages by the
injured person for impairment of his ability to render such
services.”
72. A dependant is defined by subsection (5), which includes under (5)(d)
any parent of the injured person. Essentially, Hui claims damages on
the basis that his ability to render services to his parent(s) as his
dependant(s) was impaired by the accident. This in turn is based on
the household help he used to provide as mentioned above.
73. Whilst this court does not rule out that as a matter of fact, Hui was
dutiful in taking care of himself and in addition lending help to the
household chores before the accident, and that this was appreciated by
his parents who were working couple, the situation should nevertheless
be understood realistically against the fact that Hui was only a 12-
year-old boy at the time of the accident.
74. Hui would have developed into his teen age when his academic and
miscellaneous commitments would only have increased if one refers to
the scale of them and his ability to excel in them already by the time
of the accident. On balance, the situation of Hui by the time and
subsequent to the accident does not impress me as sufficing in
justifying an award for loss of the value of his service to the family
as such. I am therefore not prepared to award this item of claim.
SPECIAL DAMAGES
75. Hui claims for a total of HK$617,437.97 consisting of the following
items of expenses incurred by August 2024:
1) Medical expenses;
2) Miscellaneous expenses;
3) Travelling expenses;
4) Tonic food and Chinese medicine; and
5) Cost of repeating Form 1.
Medical expenses
76. Some 14 items of medical expenses are claimed, amounting to a total
sum exceeding HK$130,000. The treatment included occupational
therapy, physiotherapy, speech therapy, ENT consultation,
ophthalmological treatment, paediatric treatment, surgery, clinical
psychologist consultation, acupuncture and Chinese medicine. Receipts
were disclosed.
77. Expunging what appear to be duplicates, the receipts disclosed manage
to evidence a total sum of about HK$100,000 spent on medical expenses.
In view of the extensiveness and duration of the regular multiple
treatments needed by Hui, this court is prepared to give some leeway
for some medical expenses actually incurred but the relevant receipts
could no longer be produced. Within fair and reasonable range, a lump
sum of HK$120,000 is awarded under this item.
Miscellaneous expenses
78. A sum of about HK$160,000 is claimed for expenses incurred on diapers,
gymnasium membership for 6 months, piano room rental, medicinal
ointment, exercise equipment, private tutorial lessons, cotton wool
and rehabilitative eye gauze. This is nearly 3 times the amount as of
December 2021 pleaded in the previous version of statement of damages
dated early 2023. Importantly, the receipts disclosed only manage to
evidence a negligible fraction of the expenses claimed. This court is
prepared to accept that these expenses were incurred with the support
of medical recommendation and actual needs to address Hui’s recovery
and conditions. Hence the readiness of this court to award a
reasonable sum notwithstanding the lack of complete documentary proof.
79. As to the 6-month gym membership, this probably came about after his
cessation of physiotherapy and occupational therapy in December 2022,
as Dr Yu noted in his supplemental report in 2024. Otherwise, this
court would have been sceptical about the reasonableness of the
simultaneous attendance of physiotherapy and occupational therapy and
personal physical training at the private gym. As discussed below,
this would be the view taken insofar as the claim for these future
expenses is concerned.
80. This court is prepared to award a total sum of HK$100,000.
Travelling expenses
81. A total sum of slightly more than HK$70,000 is claimed for travelling
expenses. This court has no problem with the explanation about the
types and frequency of the travelling necessitated by the need and
condition of Hui. Nor is the lack of complete evidential proof beyond
reasonable understanding and acceptance. An amount of HK$70,000 is
allowed.
Tonic food and Chinese medicine
82. This is a substantial item, amounting to slightly more than
HK$254,000. This is more than 3 times the amount claimed as of
December 2021 pleaded in the previous version of statement of damages
filed in early 2023.
83. The principles are trite. Besides the expenses, their necessity and
reasonableness for the purpose of recovery or easing of the patient’s
condition should be properly proved by medical evidence. The Chinese
medicine might somehow come about upon such medical consultation.
There is indeed such medical report by the registered Chinese medicine
practitioner/acupuncturist treating Hui. However, the expenses on
other tonic food, as usual, were incurred in the absence of medical
recommendation and evidence of their necessity for the purpose
mentioned above. As such, the court normally considers making a
nominal award, taking into account the circumstances of the patient:
see for instance King Light Industrial Ltd v Lo Wai Keung [1994] 3 HKC
54.
84. All the circumstances considered, a nominal sum of HK$80,000 is
allowed.
Extra expenses for repeating Form 1
85. The amount claimed for stationery, books and school attire entailed by
the repetition of academic year in the sum of say HK$1,812 is allowed.
Total special damages
86. The total special damages are therefore HK$(120,000 + 100,000 + 70,000
+ 80,000 + 1,812) = HK$371,812.
VALUE OF SERVICES OF THE PARENTS
87. At the time of the accident, the Father worked as a
transportation/courier worker and allegedly earned about HK$14,000 per
month while the Mother worked as a jewellery saleslady allegedly
earning about HK$20,000 per month. According to the Mother, she and
the Father had to suspend working in order to care for Hui after the
accident. The Father resumed working 9 months later in August 2018.
The Mother did not do so until March 2019 but on a part-time basis.
Considering the circumstances of this case, I find the duration of the
parents sparing themselves from work, fully or partially, in order to
care for Hui to be reasonable.
88. Value of gratuitous service should be awarded on the basis of the
value of the earning capacity of the service provider which was given
up in order to provide the service: see Lai Chi Wai v Tong Hung Kwok &
Anor [2020] 6 HKC 1 at §140. In Lai Chi Wai, the court expressed his
reservation about attaching a value to such service by reference to
the hypothetical cost of hired domestic help. This court agreed with
that in Cheung Hay Shing v Dr Pang Ka Hung Peter & Anor [2026] HKCFI
2386 at §245. In other words, the value of service should be measured
by the loss of income due to the giving up of job or the opportunity
to work to the full capacity by the service provider.
89. The employer’s returns concerning the Father were disclosed at the
latest by his witness statement served in late 2020. Though his oral
evidence by way of witness statement is expunged, the documents
disclosed are referable evidence. The return for the tax year
2015/2016 shows the Father’s total income of HK$142,250 or monthly
HK$11,854. That of another employer of the Father for the tax year
2017/2018 (up to 1 March 2018, ie 11 months) shows a lower total
income of HK$98,063 or monthly HK$8,915. The Father did not attend
the hearing, and therefore did not get to elaborate or explain his pre-
accident average income level as pleaded, which does not align with
the most recent tax return by the time of the accident. In the
circumstances, I should adopt the actual income according to the
document as the applicable income for the purpose of assessing the
value of the Father’s service since the accident. Hence HK$8,915 x 9
months = HK$80,235.
90. According to the employer’s returns concerning the Mother for the tax
year 2017/2018 (up to the end of January 2018, ie 10 months in total),
working as a saleslady at the jewellery shop and a part-time waitress
at a restaurant brought her (not counting her retirement payment) an
average monthly income of approximately HK$18,000.
91. The claim as pleaded is for value of the Mother’s service measured by
her loss, including partial loss since resumption of work in 2019.
Her employers’ returns show that she resumed working for a jewellery
store in January 2019 until late 2020. She then did not resume
working for jewellery store until mid-2023. She also started working
for a property management company since October 2019. The tax returns
show her following average monthly income from these jobs during the
tax years since resumption of work in 2019:
Tax year Amount (HK$)
2019 5,767
2019/2020 10,061
2020/2021 11,310
2021/2022 8,528
2022/2023 8,306
2023/2024 13,036
92. In my judgment, the value of the Mother’s service since her resumption
of work in early 2019 may be measured by the partial loss of income
due to her inability to work to her full capacity in order to spare
herself to care for Hui. One however should not lose sight of the
situation between 2020 and 2023, which was the intervening COVID-19
pandemic. As commonly known, the pandemic would have impacted
particularly on the Mother’s pre-accident jobs in luxury retail and
restaurant. There is every reason for suspecting that she would have
been unable to work to her full capacity in those pre-accident jobs,
and thus subject to substantial reduction in income, during such
period even without the accident to her son.
93. The fact was that since her resumption of work in 2019, the tax
returns show that the Mother’s major source of income was from the
property management company she started to work for in late 2019.
They show no income from working for jewellery store(s) since late
2020 until mid-2023. That tends to testify as to the extent to which
she would have been able to work to her full capacity, and hence her
income, from her pre-accident lines of work during the pandemic.
94. In the circumstances, I would proceed to assess the value of the
Mother’s service on the following basis:
From the accident to the end of 2018
HK$18,000 x 13 months = HK$234,000
From January 2019 to end of March 2020
HK$18,000 x 15 months – HK$(17,302 + 120,727) =
HK$131,971
From April 2020 to end of March 2023
Loss of earning capacity not attributable to Hui
From April 2023 to end of March 2024
HK$18,000 x 12 months – HK$156,427 = HK$59,573
95. As such, the value of the parents’ service occasioned by the care need
of Hui was a total sum of HK$(80,235 + 234,000 + 131,971 + 59,573) =
HK$505,779.
FUTURE LOSS OF EARNING/LOSS OF EARNING CAPACITY
96. It is always difficult to assess the loss of earnings and earning
capacity of a plaintiff who was a minor at the time of the accident
and yet to enter the job market at the time of the assessment.
97. In Man Kwok Ngai, an infant by his next friend Man Kam Wong v Fong Hok
Wong & Anor HCPI 1033/2001 (26 March 2003), the circumstances were so
uncertain and speculative that the court refused to grant an award for
loss of earning capacity of the infant. In Law Yin Pok Bosco, a minor
by Lam Po Yee, his mother and next friend v Dr Chan Yee Shing aka Dr
Chan Yee Shing Alvin HCPI 369/2010 (20 November 2012) (upheld in this
aspect on appeal: [2014] 2 HKLRD 260), the court refused to grant any
award for future loss of earnings in the absence of evidence in
support of realistic contemplation of the alleged future career of the
infant. Both cases involved infants of tender age.
98. The injured minor in Chu Man Ting v Kwan Kam Kei & Anor [2003] 1 HKLRD
404 was about to commence teen age at the time of the accident.
Whilst acknowledging the difficulty, the court awarded a lump sum,
which was cross-checked with an estimation based on the
multiplier/multiplicand approach.
99. The above instances tell that each case depends on the view of its
circumstances which the court is entitled to take upon the evidence.
The difficulty in the present case was apparently acknowledged by
those formerly acting for Hui. In the previous version of statement
of damages, counsel then for the Mother/Hui acknowledged the
inappropriateness of applying the multiplicand/multiplier approach in
the circumstances. There and in the current version of statement of
damages, the pleaded claim is one for a lump sum of HK$3,000,000
representing the future diminution of earnings or loss of earning
capacity as well as delay by 1 year in entering the job market
suffered by Hui.
100. By way of pleading and submission in court, no explanation was given
for the lump sum as pleaded. I would therefore approach this head of
claim in 2 stages.
101. The first stage involves finding whether Hui would likely suffer
future loss of earnings/earning capacity as a result of his
disabilities.
102. As mentioned, the evidence abundantly showed that Hui exceled in
mathematics, constantly winning prizes in yearly open competitions
prior to the accident. He also won prizes in an annual open school
speech festival. He was good at piano, and on his way to grade 7 by
the time of the accident. School academic reports showed grade A in
most subjects, resulting in the same overall grade. Hui enjoyed good
reputation in personality and learning potential. The Mother aspired
for his son to becoming a musician or actuary while he himself stated
ambition of becoming a doctor or a lawyer or a comedian but for the
accident.
103. The post-accident condition and its impact on his development were
discussed above, and acutely noted by the medical experts. In view of
his pre-accident life and tendency as well as self-projection, the
consideration is not so much about the impact of the injuries and
residual disabilities on his physical ability to handle manual labour.
That would not have been his direction in any event. More probably
than not, it would be the impact on his capacity to take up and to
secure a white-collar job.
104. The compromise of his abilities and potential of achievement in his
secondary and tertiary education as well as advance education is
apparent. He managed to finish Form 6 at the School, and his
performance at the Hong Kong Diploma of Secondary Education
Examination (DSE) enabled him to be accepted by the Metropolitan
University (formerly Open University) through the Joint University
Programmes and Admission Services Office (JUPAS) in 2024. On the
balance of probabilities, I am satisfied that but for the accident,
Hui would have continued to perform reasonably well at school so as to
enable him to pursue his strength and interest in one of the
conventional top tier universities. Whilst there would have been and
would still be uncertainties in life, chances are that he should have
been able to embark his white-collar working life armed with a
reasonable tertiary education qualification better than what may now
be expected.
105. Once the above is accepted, the circumstances are distinguishable from
those previous cases mentioned above where the uncertainty and
significant speculative factor were present due to the very tender age
of the injured infants, and hence the reservation expressed by the
court in those instances. The situation of Hui in the present case is
different. As such, the court will just have to do the best, and the
impossibility of precision should not be let stand in the way of
deciding on a reasonable award for the recognised loss. Hence the
second stage of the consideration.
106. Hui is yet to enter the job market. His major study at the current
university, which changed substantially after his first academic year,
did not quite suffice in casting light on his probable job. As
mentioned, Hui and the Mother differed in their aspired achievable
occupation of Hui but for the accident. Importantly, the state of the
evidence does not suffice in founding a realistic basis for either of
their projections to be accepted as concrete. In the circumstances,
this court is only prepared to believe in the likelihood of Hui
securing a reasonable office job with pay commensurate with his
tertiary education level and qualification but for the accident.
107. Hui has in fact suffered delay of 1 year in entering the job market.
Further, he would likely suffer disadvantage in the relevant labour
market. In terms of the explanation in Moeliker v A Reyrolle & Co
Limited [1977] 1 WLR 132 and Chan Wai Tong v Li Ping Sum [1985] HKLR
176, this would take the form of a risk of inability to secure his
employment or the risk of under-employment in the future.
108. When all these circumstances are considered, it would appear that the
lump sum award claimed on behalf of Hui is not unreasonable. For what
is worth, had the exercise been an assessment by the multiplier-
multiplicand approach on the basis of the expected income difference,
it is likely that the resultant amount would not have been materially
less, in view of the substantial normal working lifespan of Hui which
is only about to commence, and hence the maximum applicable multiplier
in his case.
109. I therefore make an award as claimed under this head.
FUTURE EXPENSES
110. Future expenses are claimed for medical consultation and treatment,
training and tuition, domestic helper, aids, equipment and
consumables, accommodation, travelling and do-it-yourself (DIY)
replacement. They are respectively set out in the breakdown and
computation scheduled to the re-revised statement of damages. They
account for more than HK$21 million, and thus 80% of the total pleaded
claim.
111. The claim for these future expenses is advanced on the basis of the
alleged needs of Hui mostly for the rest of his natural lifespan, in
which case a multiplier of 32.87 is proposed for computation purpose.
This court does not take issue about the proposed multiplier on such
basis, but the fundamental beginning question is whether or not all of
these expenses could in fact be said to be necessitated by the
injuries and residual disabilities of Hui which would not have arisen
had the accident not happened. In my judgment, some per se and some,
in terms of extent, are questionable. I shall discuss them one by
one.
Future medical expenses
112. Hui is claiming a total of HK$2,463,737 under future medical expenses,
which was explained in Part A of the schedule to the re-revised
statement of damages. The expenses consist of:
1) ENT treatment
2) ophthalmological treatment;
3) psychiatric treatment;
4) physiotherapy;
5) occupational therapy;
6) speech therapy;
7) psychological therapy/counselling for the family;
8) facial reanimation surgery;
9) Follicular Unit Extraction (FUE) hair transplant;
10) Other consultations.
ENT treatment
113. Hui is claiming for ENT treatment expenses in the form of the cost of
hearing aid.
114. Dr Au, the single joint ENT expert, recommended the use of hearing aid
by Hui. However, the normal hearing aid would not be helpful as Hui
is profoundly deaf on the right side. Hence his recommendation for
the use of “CROS”, which is the aid for re-routing of sound input from
the left side. The expert discussed the pros and cons of the use of
this aid, which would also require test use and adaptation by Hui.
Subject to that, the quoted cost of a set, which the expert accepted,
would be HK$24,800.
115. This is a reasonable amount to be allowed on a lifetime basis.
According to the expert, the aid would need replacement every 4 to 5
years (say every 4.5 years). The cost of the aid will be
HK$24,800/4.5 years x 32.87 = say HK$181,150.
116. Batteries would be necessary. The battery would last for 100-120
hours. About 88 batteries would be needed per year. At HK$100 per 6
units, the total cost would be HK$100/6 x 88 = HK$1,466 per year. As
claimed, the battery cost will be HK$1,466 x 32.87 = HK$48,187.
117. The total cost of the hearing aid will be HK$181,150 + 48,187 =
HK$229,337.
Ophthalmological treatment
118. Hui was first assessed by ophthalmologist in late 2017, when his right
6th and 7th cranial nerve palsy were found to cause his exposure
keratopathy. Dr Tsui, the single joint ophthalmology expert, noted
that corrective surgery has been offered but the parents of Hui opted
for conservative treatment. The treating ophthalmologist reported
that as of mid-2019, Hui’s right exposure keratopathy has been
followed up and treated with artificial tear supplement and lubricant
ointment. The lid position was well and he had no diplopia or pain.
119. Dr Yu, in his supplemental neurological expert report, also observed
that corrective surgery for lagophthalmos was in fact performed
recently in January 2023. This was confirmed by the Mother in court,
who added that the effect was not remarkable.
120. In the circumstances, I see insufficient basis for believing on
balance that further corrective surgery would be necessary or
attempted. It would not be reasonable to make an award for this item
of claim in these circumstances.
Psychiatric treatment
121. The treatment and observations provided by the treating clinical
psychologist up to July 2019 were summarised under the section on
injuries and treatment above. She reported that given Hui’s
improvement and stable condition, no further follow up appointment was
arranged afterwards.
122. Notwithstanding that, Dr Tsang, the psychiatric expert instructed on
behalf of Hui, recommended monthly psychotherapy by clinical
psychologist for another 2-3 years to work on his anger management
issue while continuing counselling service and social skill training
by school social worker. This has the support of the joint opinion of
the neurological experts.
123. Dr Law, the psychiatric expert instructed on behalf of the School,
opined that Hui has reached maximal medical improvement so that
further psychiatric treatment would not be recommended. He considered
continuing school social worker counselling would be appropriate and
adequate.
124. The prospect of school social worker counselling would depend on
various factors. According to Hui, and as recorded by the medical
experts, that had apparently worked well during his secondary level.
However, that has ceased upon his graduation. The prospect and
effectiveness of such service, if available, when he is now in his
tertiary level of education has become uncertain in terms of evidence.
On the basis that this court accepts as his reasonable need for
clinical psychological assistance, Hui should be afforded with the
opportunity to do so in the future.
125. The neurological experts and Dr Tsang opined that such monthly
psychotherapy should last for 2 to 3 years, say 2.5 years, which would
cost HK$2,500 for an hourly session. The amount will be HK$2,500 x 12
x 2.5 years = HK$75,000. This is allowed.
Physiotherapy
126. The treating physiotherapist reported the progress of physiotherapy
provided to Hui up to later 2019, as summarised under the section on
injuries and treatment. Mrs Tsang and Dr Cheng, the occupational
therapy experts, recommended further physiotherapy but differed in
terms of the recommended frequency and duration. Mrs Tsang
recommended a total of 157 regular sessions whereas Dr Cheng, on the
other hand, disagreed that Hui would require physiotherapy
consultation on a regular basis. He added that occupational therapy
could also assist by providing the relevant training for gait and
balance. Dr Cheng’s recommendation has the support of the assessment
from the neurological perspective by the relevant experts. He
recommended a frequency of 1 session per week for 3 months, and thus a
total of 12 sessions of physiotherapy. The experts agreed on the
cost, which in the public sector would cost HK$135 for initial
assessment and HK$80 for follow up session.
127. I tend to agree with Dr Cheng. Given the history of physiotherapy
obtained in the public sector and its effectiveness as report by the
treating therapist, this court sees no reason for disturbing the
established pattern. The cost allowed will therefore be HK$135 +
HK$80 x 12 = HK$1,095.
Occupational therapy
128. The occupational therapy experts were ad idem on the need and
frequency of occupational therapy for Hui to train and to improve his
various functioning to cope with activities of daily life. They also
agreed on the cost. Such cost in the public sector would likewise be
HK$135 for initial assessment and HK$80 for each session. For similar
reason explained above, I am prepared to allow the item on the basis
of therapy in the public sector. Hence HK$135 + HK$80 x 129 sessions
= HK$10,455.
Speech therapy
129. The treatment and progress reported by the treating speech therapist
up to the end of 2019 were summarised under the section on injuries
and treatment. Hui has regained normal language functioning and his
swallowing function has improved. He remained mildly dysarthric,
characterised by mild imprecise articulation and monotonous speech
production. Oro-motor and speech training became the focus.
130. For speech and communication training, the occupational therapy
experts recommended further speech therapy but differed in terms of
duration. Based on Mrs Tsang’s recommendation, this item is being
claimed on the basis of lifelong need, which Dr Cheng disagreed (and
he advised that the exact number of sessions should be recommended by
a speech therapist). In view of the development of Hui in this
respect by and since the end of 2019, and what this court managed to
observe from a non-expert perspective during the hearing which was 6
years later, I share the reservation expressed by Dr Cheng.
131. I take into account the reasonableness of such further therapy in
assisting to equip Hui with the necessary proficiency and confidence
to enter the job market in a couple of years. Therefore, I am
prepared to make an award on the basis of a 12-month duration of
therapy, of which it would be 1 weekly session for 6 months (ie 24
sessions) and 2 sessions per month for the following 6 months (ie 12
sessions) (as recommended by Mrs Tsang).
132. For similar reason as explained under further physiotherapy and
occupational therapy above, the award will be made on the basis of
therapy in the public sector, ie HK$135 (initial assessment) + HK$80 x
36 sessions = HK$3,015.
Family psychological therapy/counselling
133. Psychological treatment for Hui was discussed above and award for that
made. The occupational therapists also recommended provision of
psychological support to Hui’s family for alleviating stress.
Mrs Tsang recommended 40 sessions for the family members, including
joint sessions with Hui, whereas Dr Cheng recommended 20 such
sessions. Taking the median, it will be 30 hourly sessions. The cost
in the private sector at the hourly rate of HK$2,250 (also the median
cost recommended) would become HK$2,250 x 30 sessions = HK$67,500.
Other specific psychological services
134. Other specific psychological services, such as education psychologist,
vocational psychologist and life coach, as well as medical
consultations for various specialties, for different life stages
suggested by Mrs Tsang, as opined by Dr Cheng, are largely projected
as possible needs in the absence of recommendation from the experts of
the specific disciplines. I refrain from allowing them.
Facial reanimation surgery
135. This item in the total cost of HK$250,000 is claimed on the basis of
the recommendation by Dr Chow Chun Kuen, ENT specialist, by way of his
quotation dated 7 July 2022 for a facial reanimation surgery. The
surgery is said to aim at restoring or replacing the lost facial
movement to correct the traumatic right facial nerve palsy with facial
asymmetry on smiling. However, such claim is not evidenced in
documentary form before this court.
136. As mentioned, Dr Au, who was the single joint ENT expert, explained in
his report dated 14 September 2021 that nerve grafting surgery was an
invasive process with unpredictable outcome, and the lapse of time by
now would tend to work against the prospect of efficacy of the
procedure. In any event, the parents were then reluctant about such
surgical intervention. The expert did not recommend this facial
reanimation surgery as now said to be recommended by this Dr Chow.
Nor was comment solicited from Dr Au about such alleged recent
recommendation. If one further takes into account the experience of
recent surgical intervention to the eyelid of Hui in 2023, which also
did not yield noticeable result, one doubts the probability of
incentive of Hui and his parents to attempt such further facial
surgery. At the hearing, the Mother somehow described her intention
to “preserve” the opportunity to do so.
137. All the circumstances considered, I am not satisfied that the
reasonably necessity of this item is proved.
FUE hair transplant
138. Hui is claiming for HK$189,000 in total for the entire course of FUE
hair transplant treatment in accordance with the quotation issued by
Wellness Medical dated 8 July 2022. There is lack of expert support
for this item of claim. On the contrary, as Dr Mok and Dr Nicholson,
the plastic surgery experts, observed in their report, the scar on the
occipital scalp is mostly covered by hair when properly groomed. This
is verifiable by reference to the photographs and Hui’s own presence
in court during the hearing. Inclusive of the scar on other parts,
the scars accounted for 1% of impairment of the whole person. All the
circumstances considered, I am not satisfied that this item of claim
is reasonable.
Other medical consultation
139. Mrs Tsang recommended an annual sum of HK$20,000 for medical
consultations for the rest of Hui’s life from various specialists
including eye specialists, audiologists, plastic surgeons,
neurologists, etc. Hence the total of HK$657,400 claimed. All these
lack support and actual recommendations by the experts of the relevant
disciplines. I therefore share the reservation of Dr Cheng, and do
not allow this.
Total future medical expenses
140. The total future medical expenses will therefore be HK$(229,337 +
75,000 + 1,095 + 10,455 + 3,015 + 67,500) = HK$386,402.
Future training and tuition
141. A total of HK$1,388,460 is claimed for future training and tuition.
According to Part B of the schedule to the re-revised statement of
damages, this consists of gym membership and personal training as well
as private tuition and special provision for extra-curricular
activities for secondary and tertiary education.
Gym and personal training
142. Hui is claiming for a gym membership for lifetime and personal trainer
session twice a week for 1-hour session for 5 years. Dr Cheng
suggested that this item is optional if training programme is provided
by physiotherapist or occupational therapists is in place.
143. I tend to agree with Dr Cheng. As discussed, this court is given to
understand that Hui’s enrolment with personal training at the gym for
6 months happened after he has ceased occupational therapy at one
point. However, when his present claim for resumption of
physiotherapy and, more importantly, occupational therapy in the
future, as discussed above, is allowed to a reasonable extent, the
award of damages to cover the additional cost of further personal
physical training at the gym simultaneously with the professional
therapy could not be justified.
Private tuition
144. A total of HK$360,000 is claimed for private tuition, for both
secondary and tertiary educations, and extra-curricular activities.
However, one must not lose sight of the fact that Hui is indeed
already in his second year of tertiary education. In the absence of
evidence of the kind and availability of private tuition available at
his stage of education, this item of claim should not be allowed on an
apparently academic basis.
Future domestic helper
145. A total sum of HK$6,300,440 is claimed for the expenses on employing
domestic helper for the rest of his life. The breakdown and
computation were set out in Part C of the re-revised statement of
damages.
146. The occupational therapists observed that Hui is basically independent
in everyday activities, though he would require assistance for some
household activities. In extraordinary situations, he might need
support for instrumental activities of daily life. Mrs Tsang opined
that such support should take the form of lifelong hired domestic help
whereas Dr Cheng opined that training in instrumental activities of
daily living would be more appropriate than lifelong reliance on hired
domestic help. As to Dr Cheng’s recommendation, Mrs Tsang did not
strictly differ, but only expressed reservation about the uncertain
success in such training when Hui grows to adulthood.
147. I am prepared to share the reservation expressed by Mrs Tsang insofar
as the early stage of Hui’s life is concerned. Except for that, I am
inclined to the view of Dr Cheng who essentially pointed out the
potential undesirability of indulging Hui into reliance on domestic
help instead of striving for independence when he does possess the
physical potential of achieving some success.
148. Fundamentally, the claim is apparently premised on the assumption that
hired domestic help would not have come about in the rest of Hui’s
life but for his injury and disabilities. On the contrary, I tend to
believe in the probability that but for the accident, Hui would have
moved out to live on his own, which might in any event entail hired
domestic help when he would have become financially independent. On
this basis, I assume that this could have happened on the 5th
anniversary of his commencing work life but for the accident. Hence 7
years from now. I am therefore prepared to allow the claim for the
cost of hired domestic help while he would continue to reside with his
parents and sister until then, which would also entail the need for
such hired help to assist not just him but also his family in his
circumstances.
149. Inclusive of the incidental expenses, the annual amount to be spent on
hired domestic help (exclusive of relief helper, which is not allowed)
would be about HK$66,000. The amount allowed would thus be HK$66,000
x 7 years = HK$462,000.
Future aids, equipment & consumables
150. A total sum of HK$342,833.80 is claimed for future aids, equipment and
consumables as set out in Part D of the schedule to the re-revised
statement of damages.
151. For future expenses for aids and equipment, it includes expenses of
shower chair, grab rails, hearing aid, cognitive equipment, treadmill
with maintenance and exerciser for upper and lower limbs.
The occupational therapy experts had different views regarding the
necessity for the first of these items. I tend to agree with Dr Cheng
that in view of the reasonable ability of Hui in independent self-care
such as bathing and toileting, these items are not necessary. Cost of
hearing aid as what ENT treatment entails is allowed above.
152. Save as aforesaid, the experts agreed on the reasonable necessity of
the other items, which I would allow. Hence HK$(2,000 + 2,080 + 350)
x 32.87 = say HK$145,614.
153. Expenses for consumables claimed consist of eye drop, eye gel, gauze,
disposable, antiseptic sterile packs, dressing sets, applicator
sticks, cotton wool balls sterile, sterile gauze, micropore, wound
dressings and IP camera. Except for eye drop, eye gel and gauze, the
other items were disagreed by Dr Cheng. I share his reservation, as
these items were projected as additional need if and when wound or
abrasion occurs. However, the medical and medical expert evidence do
not suggest the likelihood of exceptional frequency of wound and
abrasion to be suffered by Hui in his remaining life. As such, these
items of wound dressing consumables would have been incurred as
commonplace family items, and therefore could not be said to be
necessitated by the disabilities of Hui.
154. The cost of the eye drop, eye gel and gauze are allowed at the sum of
HK$(3,000 + 550) x 32.87 = say HK$116,689.
155. The total sum allowed under this head is HK$(145,614 + 116,689) =
HK$262,303.
Future accommodation expenses
156. A total of HK$9,996,588.75 is claimed for future accommodation
expenses, consisting monthly rental and incidental estate agency
expenses for the rest of Hui’s life. The breakdown and computation
were set out in Part E of the re-revised statement of damages.
157. Essentially the claim is based on the recommendation of the
occupational therapy experts for bigger living space accommodating the
privacy and domestic help needs of Hui. The above discussion in
respect of the claim for the future cost of domestic help refers. The
same may be said about the claim for the future cost of accommodation.
I see insufficient basis for projecting that Hui would have remained
staying in his current residence with the parents and sister during
his remaining life but for the accident. Put another way, it is only
realistic to project the likelihood that Hui would have afforded
moving out, and that he would do so, when he became financially
independent at one stage after having entered the job market but for
the accident. It cannot be said that the cost of alternative
accommodation would not have come about at all but for the accident
and his disabilities.
158. In the circumstances, I am prepared to give weight to the
recommendation for the need for alternative accommodation immediately
and for the future until what would have been the time when Hui would
have likely moved out but for the accident. Assuming that this, but
for the accident, would have been on his 5th anniversary of
commencement of work life, which would be 7 years from now, a sum
representing the rental for that period could be allowed to compensate
for the bringing forward of the incurring of such expenses.
159. Though actual evidence of the monthly rental rate of HK$25,000 claimed
was not provided, I am prepared to accept the rate as reasonable for
the present purpose. The cost of rented accommodation for 7 years
would be HK$25,000 x 12 x 7 = HK$2,100,000. Factoring in the
incidental expenses, a total lump sum of HK$2,150,000 is allowed.
Future travelling expenses
160. An amount of HK$854,620 is claimed for future travelling expenses as
set out in Part F of the schedule to the re-revised statement of
damages.
161. Based on Mrs Tsang’s recommendation for an additional transportation
allowance of HK$500 per week for Hui, a total sum of HK$854,620 is
claimed, effectively representing the amount for life. This was not
shared by Dr Cheng.
162. One must not lose sight of the clear medical and medical expert
evidence regarding the degree of independence and ability to ambulate
as well as the management of public transportation of Hui. Reasonable
transportation expenses should be allowed for his attending medical
consultations or treatment sessions on such basis. All the
circumstances considered, a lump sum of HK$15,000 is allowed under
this head.
Future DIY expenses
163. A total of HK$32,870 is claimed as set out in Part G of the schedule
to the re-revised statement of damages.
164. This is claimed purportedly on the force of the occupational therapy
expert opinion. However, what the relevant expert report tells is
mere recommendation of this item by the expert engaged on behalf of
Hui whereas that engaged on behalf of the School did not endorse.
Importantly, the basis for this item of claim was somehow explained by
those acting for Hui in the pleading which could only be their own
interpretation of what might have explained this item recommended.
The expert was silent in the report to that extent.
165. Even on the basis as explained in the pleading, the alleged premise is
that Hui would have carried out DIY work in his life which has become
impossible due to his disabilities. Yet there is insufficient, if
any, evidence in support of any pattern or likelihood of such
projection with reference to Hui’s pre-accident life as a child.
166. All the circumstances considered, I find this item of claim at the
alleged yearly rate of HK$1,000 too speculative and not properly
substantiated.
SUMMARY
167. In summary, the award will be as follows:
|Items |Amount (HK$) |
|PSLA |1,000,000 |
|Loss of service |Nil |
|Special Damages |371,812 |
|Value of services provided by parents |505,779 |
|Future loss of earnings/earning capacity|3,000,000 |
|Future Expenses | |
|Medical expenses |386,402 |
|Training and private tuition |Nil |
|Costs of domestic help |462,000 |
|Aids, equipment and consumables |262,303 |
|Accommodation arrangements |2,150,000 |
|Transportation |15,000 |
|DIY expenses |Nil |
|Total: |8,153,296 |
INTEREST
168. Interest on general damages (PSLA award) shall run from the date of
writ to today at 2% per annum. Interest on incurred special damages
shall run from the date of the accident until today at half judgment
rate. Interest from the date hereof runs at the judgment rate.
CONCLUSION AND ORDER
169. Damages are assessed at the sum of HK$8,153,296 with interest as
aforesaid. Hence judgment in such assessed amount against Au.
170. Costs of the action on liability against Au are covered by the
interlocutory judgment entered on 15 September 2020. I make a nisi
order that Au shall further pay Hui’s costs of the assessment of
damages proceedings against him, to be taxed if not agreed. The own
costs of the Mother and then Hui as the plaintiff during the legal aid
period shall be taxed in accordance with legal aid regulations. In
the absence of any application to vary in 14 days, the nisi costs
order shall become absolute without further order.
171. Enforcement of the judgment by Hui against Au shall be subject to any
credit which may have to be given due to the settlement between Hui
and the School. Enforcement of the School’s judgment against Au for
contribution/indemnity shall also be subject to the terms of its
settlement with Hui. In view of that, insofar as any further order on
the basis of the above assessment is necessary, Hui and the School
have liberty within 21 days to apply.
172. Whilst Hui acts in person and the hearing was conducted in Punti, the
documents in the assessment of damages bundle and his own opening
submission lodged were in English. Hence this judgment in English.
(Simon Leung)
Judge of the Court of First Instance
High Court
The Plaintiff appeared in person
The 1st Defendant acting in person, absent
The 2nd Defendant, represented by Deacons, absent
-----------------------
[1] For the avoidance of doubt, this court has refrained from viewing the
court document pertaining to the terms of settlement between Hui and the
School, which was somehow included in the assessment hearing bundle. The
same has been directed to be removed.
-----------------------
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V