Case Details

Citation

XCHRX TSE JEEKEEN v. "H.K. ALLIANCE IN SUPPORT OF PATRIOTIC DEMOCRATIC MOVEMENT OF CHINA" & ITS CHAIRMAN MR SZETO WAH AND OTHERS, HCA 22164/1998

Case Number

HCA 22164/1998

Court

Court of First Instance

(CFI)

Decision Date

24 March 1999

Parties

Applicant(s):

TSE JEEKEEN

For Respondent(s):

Mr John Clancey of M/s Ho, Tse, Wai & Partners

XCHRX TSE JEEKEEN v. "H.K. ALLIANCE IN SUPPORT OF PATRIOTIC DEMOCRATIC MOVEMENT OF CHINA" & ITS CHAIRMAN MR SZETO WAH AND OTHERS

HCA 22164/1998

Court of First Instance24 March 1999

HCA022164/1998 XCHRX TSE JEEKEEN v. "H.K. ALLIANCE IN SUPPORT OF PATRIOTIC DEMOCRATIC MOVEMENT OF CHINA" & ITS CHAIRMAN MR SZETO WAH AND OTHERS

HCA022164/1998

HCA22164/98

IN THE HIGH COURT OF THE

HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION

COURT OF FIRST INSTANCE

ACTION NO.22164 OF 1998

-------------

BETWEEN
	TSE JEEKEEN	Plaintiff

	AND

	1. "H.K. ALLIANCE IN SUPPORT OF PATRIOTIC DEMOCRATIC MOVEMENT OF CHINA" & ITS CHAIRMAN MR SZETO WAH 2. "H.K. DEMOCRATIC PARTY" & ITS CHAIRMAN MR LEE CHUI MING (MARTIN) 3. MR CHEUNG MAN KWONG, PRESIDENT OF "THE HONG KONG PROFESSIONAL TEACHER'S UNION" 4. "APRIL 5 ACTION" & ITS LEADER MR LEUNG KWOK HUNG	Defendants

--------------

Coram : Hon Mr Justice Cheung in Chambers

Date of hearing : 24 March 1999

Date of delivery of judgment : 24 March 1999

-----------------------

J U D G M E N T

-----------------------

1. In this action, the Plaintiff is repeating the same case he has pleaded in High Court Action No.13938/97. That case was struck out for disclosing no reasonable cause of action and the Plaintiff's application for leave to appeal to the Court of Final Appeal was rejected.

2. It is an abuse of the process of the Court to litigate again the same matter which had been struck out. The present action was, in my view, properly struck out by the Master and the appeal is dismissed.

	(P. Cheung)
	Judge of the Court of the First Instance, High Court

Representation:

Plaintiff in person, present

Mr John Clancey of M/s Ho, Tse, Wai & Partners, for the Defendants

Remarks:
On appeal by the Plaintiff to the Court of Appeal: Appeal dismissed. Please refer to the Appeal judgment CACV000090/1999.

Citation

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations

Appeal history

XCHRX TSE JEEKEEN v. "H.K. ALLIANCE IN SUPPORT OF PATRIOTIC DEMOCRATIC MOVEMENT OF CHINA" & ITS CHAIRMAN MR SZETO WAH AND OTHERS
CFI · 24 Mar 1999
This judgment
TSE JEEKEEN v. "H.K. ALLIANCE IN SUPPORT OF PATRIOTIC DEMOCRATIC MOVEMENT OF CHINA" & ITS CHAIRMAN MR SZETO WAH AND OTHERS
CA · 26 May 1999
On appeal from
TSE JEEKEEN v. "H.K. ALLIANCE IN SUPPORT OF PATRIOTIC DEMOCRATIC MOVEMENT OF CHINA" & ITS CHAIRMAN MR SZETO WAH AND OTHERS
CA · 2 Sept 1999
On appeal from
TSE JEEKEEN v. "HK ALLIANCE IN SUPPORT OF PATRIOTIC MOVEMENT OF CHINA" & ITS CHAIRMAN MR SZETO WAH AND OTHERS
CFA · 1 Nov 1999
On appeal from