Case Details
Citation
CHAN WING-YUEN v. THE QUEEN, CACC 192/1977
Case Number
CACC 192/1977
Court
Court of Appeal
(CA)
Decision Date
13 April 1977
Parties
Applicant(s):

CHAN Wing-yuen

Respondent(s):

The Queen

For Applicant(s):

C. Ching, Q.C. & A.M. Niamatullah (Yung, Yu, Yuen & Co.)

For Respondent(s):

authorities is to establish the principle that it is wrong for a judge or magistrate, in deciding whether a charge has been proved to the requisite standard in a criminal case, to balance the defence and prosecution stories against each other and to conclude that the case has been proved on the basis that the defence story must be rejected and that, consequently, the prosecution story must be accepted. Mr. Edwards; The evidence therefore boils down to the fact that a customary gift was given of $1,000 by Mr. Li to the defendant, hoping the defendant would make an honest report but having regard to the authorities (including Low v. R. 1961 H.K.L.R.; Keay v. R. 1956 40 H.K.L.R.; LUK Shun v. R. 1966 H.K.L.R. and Reg. v. Carr 1957 40 Criminal Appeal Reports) it is clear to me that the intention of the payer was clearly

CHAN WING-YUEN v. THE QUEEN

CACC 192/1977

Court of Appeal13 April 1977

Citation

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations