Case Details
Citation
RE ON LOK CO, HCMP 1/1945
Case Number
HCMP 1/1945
Court
Court of First Instance
(CFI)
Decision Date
14 January 1946
Parties
Applicant(s):

him and the Applicants, which agreement disentitles the Applicants to an order under either Article 5(a) or 5(b) of the Proclamation. 9. Having disposed of the last paragraph of the Findings, what is the real ground for the refusal by the Tribunal to make the order sought? It is this: that a tenancy agreement was entered into between the parties. 10. At this point, it would be convenient to mention the position of an Appellate Court on questions of fact. 11. On an appeal from the decision of the Judge sitting without a Jury where the matter in question in one of fact, the Court is to exercise its jurisdiction as a Tribunal of Appeal on matters of fact as well as on matters of law. Where the question at issue is the proper inference to be drawn from facts which are not in doubt, the Appellate Court is in as good a position to decide the question as the Judge at the trial is. 12. The above, from Powell v. Streatham Nursing Home, 1935 A.C. p. 243, is a sufficient enunciation of the principles to be applied where, as in this case, the findings do not depend on any question as to the veracity of witnesses. And the Appellate Court is in no worse position if this is to be treated as a decision by a judge and jury: see the same case at p.250 and 1939 Yearly Practice at p. 1243. 13. Now, what is the evidence in this case? It is this: 14. Lam Ping Ho's evidence: "The premises were let to Chan Kwai at a monthly rent of Y. 25.00. Chan Kwai applied to me to be the tenant of the premises and I agreed to accept the sum of Y25.00 per month as the rent." "I was not authorised to enter into tenancy agreement. But the tenancy of Chan Kwai was agreed to by the Manager, Ku Shiu Ting. I was not present at the interview but I was satisfied that Chan Kwai had been authorised by the Manager to occupy the premises." 15. Ku Shui Ting's evidence: "I agree to the answers by Lam Ping Ho in reply to questions put by the Chairman. But under the circumstances, I thought I had better accept Y25.00 than nothing at all." 16. Pausing here for a moment, I would remark that had the evidence stopped there, then in my opinion there could be no other conclusion than that Applicants must succeed, for up to this point there is nothing to show more than that Chan Kwai became a tenant solely because of the acceptance by the landlord of rent. 17. Were it not for subsection 5(b), the acceptance of rent as shown by the evidence quoted would be abundant evidence from which an agreement could be inferred which afforded protection against eviction to the tenant. By virtue of the subsection however, this is not so. 18. In effect, the subsection declares that an agreement such as would defeat the landlord's right to an order for eviction does not arise from the acceptance of rent solely, i.e. without anything more. This "something more" may be a variety of things. It may for example be that the landlord had agreed to the tenant remaining in possession for a certain period; it may be a stipulation that the tenant should effect certain repairs; and it may be (as expressly provided in the subsection) acquiescence by the continued acceptance of rent after a certain date. The circumstances in each case would have to be considered. 19. Is there this "something more" in the present case? 20. In my view there is. It lies in the evidence that Chan Kwai's rent was subsequently increased to Y90.00 per month, and later still to Y180.00. Had the landlord continued to accept the rent of Y25.00 per month then, to use a colloquialism, he could be said to be making the best of a bad job, and therefore within subsection 5(b). But the moment there is a demand for higher rent acceded to by the tenant, then there is that "something more", in this case as agreement to accept him as such, which takes the case out of the subsection. 21. I am well aware that the section deals with a person who " became a tenant solely etc.", wherefore it may be argued that in any event the tenant in this case is not protected, his tenancy in the first case having arisen solely by the acceptance of rent. Such an argument would not impress me. Can a trespasser be ousted on the ground of his original trespass, when his title is founded on an agreement with the landlord arrived at subsequent to the tort? 22. How, although this increase in rent is not mentioned in the Findings as one of the reasons for the conclusion that there was an agreement between the parties, I am not certain whether it was not an element considered by the Tribunal. 23. Paras. 8 & 9 of the Findings are as follows: "8. In view of the evidence given both by the Applicants and the Opponent, the Tribunal is of the opinion that the Applicants have not made out a case for eviction. On the evidence, the Tribunal holds that there had been a tenancy agreement with the Opponent, Chai Kwai, during the Japanese occupation. It was not suggested that the Applicants were compelled or forced to accept the Opponent, Chan Kwai, as tenant. 9. The main ground for wanting to evict the tenant is that the Applicants wished to have the premises for the accomodation of their employees. The Tribunal holds that this is not a ground for eviction under Article 5(a) or (b) of the Proclamation No. 15. The Tribunal is of the opinion that for an application for eviction under Article 5(b) to succeed, there must be some evidence that the premises had been occupied without the consent of the landlord. In this case there is no such evidence." 24. Mr Silva argued that the last sentence of para. 9 of the Findings can only relate back to para. 8. 25. If as suggested by Mr. Silva, these paragraphs mean that in order to succeed the

For Applicant(s):

involves an allegation that the Respondent, Chan Kwai, is not Chan Kwai, but an imposter; that the alleged impostor is not in occupation of the premises; and that the sole occupants are Hong Kin Wan, the second Respondent, and his family. This imposture first became known to Applicants at the hearing when, they allege, they first saw the Opponent who claimed to be Chan Kwai, and was not disclosed to the solicitor

Judges
  • Leo D'Almada

RE ON LOK CO

HCMP 1/1945

Court of First Instance14 January 1946
Judges:Leo D'Almada

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations