LI KWOK SAN v. AU YEUNG YUN CHI
[2026] HKDC 1359 · DCPI 1195/2024
District Court
DCPI 1195/2024 [2026] HKDC 1359 IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION PERSONAL INJURIES ACTION NO 1195 OF 2024 ------------------------- BETWEEN ------------------------- Before: Master J. Chow in Chambers (Open to Public) Date of Hearing: 20 October 2026 Date of Judgment: 13 November 2026 ---------------------------------------- ASSESSMENT OF DAMAGES ----------------------------------------- Introduction This is the assessment of damages of the Plaintiff’s (“the P’s”) personal injury claim against the Defendant (“the D”) arising from an assault occurred on 2 May 2021 (“the Incident”). The Proceedings The P stated in the Indorsement of Claim that he claims damages for personal injury arising from an assault caused by the D on the date of the Incident at the roadside near the refuse collection point of Kwong Tin Street, Chung Uk Tsuen, Tuen Mun, New Territories, Hong Kong. The P only claims damages on Pain, Suffering and Loss of Amenities (“PSLA”) $250,000 and Special Damages $10,380 against the D. In this action, the P did not adduce medical expert evidence. On 14 August 2024, the P’s solicitors reported to the Court in writing that the D was adjudged bankrupt by way of an order dated 25 July 2023 in HCB 335 of 2023. Leave to proceed the action against the D was granted by an order made by Master Jocelyn Leung dated 10 April 2025. Interlocutory judgment has been entered against the D on 30 May 2025. The D has never appeared in the Checklist Review hearings. On 19 March 2026, I set this case down for assessment of damages. The P’s solicitors filed an affirmation of service dated 12 October 2026 that of all documents, including Notice of Hearing of the Assessment of Damages on the D. I am satisfied the D has been duly served with all relevant documents and was aware of the hearing today. It is his choice not to appear and I shall proceed with the assessment in his absence. The P testified without calling other witnesses. The Incident The P did not file a Statement of Claim. The facts of the Incident appeared in his witness statement filed on 3 November 2025. The P was employed as a legal clerk at the material time, due to Covid, he also worked as a part time take-away delivery worker. On 2 May 2021, the D struck P’s nose with his forehead. The P sustained injury. Medical injuries and treatment Shortly after the Incident, the P was taken to the Accident & Emergency Department of Tuen Mun Hospital (“the AED of TMH”), where a physical examination showed tenderness and swelling over his nasal bridge. X-ray revealed fracture of his nasal bone. The P was referred to the Ear, Nose & Throat Clinic (“the ENT Clinic”) of the same hospital. On 4 May 2021, the P attended the ENT Clinic. The P complained of left side epistaxis initially which was subsided on the date of attendance. No nasal obstruction or visual disturbance was noted. The anterior rhinoscopy showed no septal hematoma. The nasal bridge was mildly deviated to the left side. Fiberoptical nasoendoscopy showed middle meatus was clear and nasopharynx was smooth. It was noted in the medical report of the ENT Clinic dated 2 August 2021 that the P has a past medical history of recurrent depression which was regularly followed up at the Psychiatry Unit of Castle Peak Hospital. Two days later, on 6 May 2021, the P went to Tin Shui Wai (Tin Yip Road) Community Health Centre. He complained of persistent nasal bone pain. He was treated and discharged on the same day. Sick leave was granted from 6 May 2021 to 8 May 2021 and 21 May 2021 to 23 May 2021. In a follow up treatment on 11 May 2021 in the ENT Clinic, physical examination revealed nasal bridge deviated to the left side. The infra-orbital nerve was intact. On 13 May 2021, the P has undergone a closed reduction under general anesthesia in Pok Oi Hospital. On 27 May 2021, the P went to JOYS Medical Centre for treatment. A CT scan over his nasal area showed a visible bone fracture, along with mucosal thickening but no malalignment. Sick leave was further granted from 27 May 2021 until 27 October 2021. Upon all consultations, the P was given a total of 179 days of sick leave. Pain, Suffering and Loss of Amenities (“PSLA”) At time of this assessment, the P is 53 years old. Prior to the Incident, the P has maintained good health. The P adopts his witness statement confirming the above medical treatments. The P testified at the hearing that he has no residual symptoms resulted from the Incident. He was only advised to do a medical check-up between 5-10 years from now. It is obvious the P’s injuries do not meet the “serious category” as defined in Lee Ting Nam v Leung Kam Ming [1980] HKLR 657. The “serious injury” category as defined in Lee Ting Lam as:- “It covers those cases where the injury leaves a disability which mars general activities and enjoyment of life, but allows reasonable mobility to the victim, for example, the loss of limb replaced by a satisfactory artificial device, or bad fractures leaving recurrent pain”. Reading from all the medical reports, the P’s injury is nowhere close to the bottom end of “serious injury category”. I consider the following cases where the plaintiffs therein were suffering injuries from a nasal bone fracture: Lo Hin Fong v. Chan Chi Shing (DCPI60/2001, 1 August 2002), a male plaintiff was attacked by his colleague and has suffered from fractured nasal bone. He has residual complaint of right nasal obstruction and discomfort. This plaintiff was awarded PSLA at $100,000. Yeung Shan Yee Sandy v Singway (BVI) Co Ltd and another (DCPI 1030/2005, 24 July 2006), a female plaintiff sustained laceration over her forehead and fractured nasal bone. Scar remained on her forehead and has developed deviated nasal septum. The Court took into account the impact of cosmetic appearance of the female plaintiff and has awarded PSLA at $200,000. Irving Matthew William and Anor v Man Chun Yeung and Anor (DCPI 2242/2013; 23 March 2016), a minor plaintiff sustained injury from a falling metal gate. There was tenderness and contusion over his nasal bridge and right thigh. A chip fracture was found over his nasal bone without deviation of nasal septum. The minor had a couple of follow up medical treatments without surgery. PSLA was awarded at $180,000. Lee Chi Ho v Lai Ying Tung Michael (DCPI 528/2022, 15 November 2024), a plaintiff security guard sustained nasal fracture and was later diagnosed with deviated nasal septum. He underwent septoplasty, rhinoplasty and turbinate reduction. The Court awarded $250,000 as PSLA damages. The above authorities demonstrated the range of nasal fracture injury PSLA award from $100,000 to $250,000. I accept these are accurate pointers in the present case. The P suffered from nasal bone fracture without permanent disability. He has undergone a minor surgery to cure the deviation of nasal bone. Minor residual pain is noted. No scar was left on his left face. He has no residual symptoms and was able to return to work after expiration of sick leave period. Lo Hin Fong was decided in 2002, taking into account inflation for over 20 years, the sum awarded here should be way beyond $100,000. It is more accurate for me to rely on Yeung Shan Yee Sandy, which was decided in 2006. However, the plaintiff therein has more serious residual symptom with a scar on her face. For this factor, the Court assessed PSLA award to be $200,000. The minor plaintiff Irving Matthew William and Anor has no cosmetic issues and no surgery was performed, solely on nasal bone fracture, PSLA award was made at $180,000. The plaintiff in Lee Chi Ho had undergone surgery, in that PSLA was awarded at $250,000. I understand the level of PSLA award is not a straight-jacket, however, on comparison of the 4 cited cases, the P’s injury falls somewhere between Yeung Shan Yee Sandy and Irving Matthew William. I am also aware the P’s injury is less serious than the plaintiffs in the above cases. Upon clarification of the P in this hearing, the P confirmed he has no residual symptoms. In this regard, the appropriate PSLA award shall be $180,000. Both authorities were decided more than a decade ago, considering inflation rate over the years, an award of $200,000 is appropriate as PSLA damages. Special Damages The P claims $10,380 special damages as medical expenses incurred in receiving medical treatment. I failed to see the P has given sufficient in establishing the same in his witness statement. In the assessment bundle lodged by the P’s solicitors, I am aware the following receipts, being (i) $945 medical charges paid to Hospital Authority and (ii) $8,600 medical charges paid to Joy Medical Centre Limited, making a total of $9,545. In this respect I accept the P has had various medical treatments and those charges incurred in total is $9,545. Summary of damages assessed To conclude, I award damages to the P as follows: Interest The P is entitled to interest on PSLA at a rate of 2% per annum from the date of issuance of the Writ of Summons to the date of judgment and thereafter at judgment rate until payment. Interest on special damages at half the judgment rate from the date of the Incident until the judgment and thereafter at judgment rate until payment. Costs I see nothing here to depart from the usual costs order. I order that the D do pay the P’s costs of the assessment of damages, including all costs reserved, with Certificate for Counsel to be taxed if not agreed. Mr Owen Tsoi of Messrs. Joseph M.K. Chow, Solicitors, for the Plaintiff The Defendant did not appear