Case Details
Citation
CHAN LAM-CHUN v. THE NATIONAL INSURANCE CO LTD, CACV 57/1976
Case Number
CACV 57/1976
Court
Court of Appeal
(CA)
Decision Date
26 July 1977
Parties
Applicant(s):

CHAN Lam-chun

Respondent(s):

THE NATIONAL INSURANCE CO., LTD

For Applicant(s):

Before receiving the request from the solicitors

For Respondent(s):

There was no reply from either the owner or the driver, so the defendants, again through their solicitors, sent two further letters to the owner, Chan Ying. These letters were sent by ordinary post. They were not registered. They were dated 8th and 20th March, 1971. Copies were not sent to the driver. In these two letters Chan Ying, the owner, is requested to attend at the office of the solicitors; The action was set down for trial on February 14th, 1973. But two days earlier counsel applied to a judge in Chambers on behalf of the solicitors; p.m. on the same afternoon, the solicitors; and the first defendant, the driver, appeared before the judge in Chambers. It appeared that on the previous occasion when Mr. Chang, counsel; was allowed to withdraw from the case only "the order" had been served on the driver. But since then the driver had been properly served with a summons which he had answered. The judge saw the solicitors; the solicitors for the insurance company still acting in pursuance of their rights under Condition (2) of the policy entered a defence. This defence attributed the blame for the accident to a burst tyre on the car in question. There was evidence that a tyre was found to be burst after the accident but no evidence that its bursting had caused the accident and yet this was the fact pleaded by the solicitors; This defence is dated the 12th April 1972 so that notwithstanding the breach of the driver and owner which I have found took place some 12 months earlier the solicitors; were actively engaged in defending the negligence action. Their doing so must necessarily have put the appellant to considerable trouble and expense in preparing for trial. Up to 12th April 1972 however the solicitors; owner and driver were ordered to pay the costs of this amendment. In seeking it then the respondents put the owner and driver to theoretical expense. It was made without consultation with the owner and driver to whom the solicitors concerned still owed a duty in contract. The negligence action was to come on for hearing on the 12th February 1973 but it was not until the 10th February 1973 that the solicitors; to be for the defendants. It seems to me clear from all this that throughout the respondents' solicitors were acting as agents; of the respondents' solicitors who were still on record as solicitors for the owner and driver applied for a further adjournment. He was refused it. Though the respondents' solicitors remained on the record as solicitors for the owner and the driver counsel was permitted to withdraw from the case. Evidence was called and the evidence of seven witnesses was given. At 2.30 p.m. on the 14th February, 1973 the solicitor; In summary the owner and driver were in breach of clauses 2 and 9 of the policy at the latest by the end of March 1971, but the respondents a full year later were purporting to exercise their entitlement to take over and conduct in the names of the owner and driver the defence of the claim. They did so without any regard whatsoever for the interests of the driver notwithstanding that the solicitors; In my view it took place as soon as an appearance was entered for by its entry the owner and the driver were placed in a position where they could become liable for costs in the future - a liability which eventually crystallized. Furthermore it is impossible to escape the conclusion that every act in the proceedings done by the respondents' solicitors was done by them as agents

CHAN LAM-CHUN v. THE NATIONAL INSURANCE CO LTD

CACV 57/1976

Court of Appeal26 July 1977

Citation

Court

Procedural posture

Issues

Holdings

Legal principles

Disposition

Key citations