SINO ESTATES MANAGEMENT LTD v. CHUN MAN TSUN
[2026] HKLdT 39 · LDBM 157/2025
LDBM 157/2025
[2026] HKLdT 39
IN THE LANDS TRIBUNAL OF THE
HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION
BUILDING MANAGEMENT APPLICATION NO 157 OF 2025
___________________
BETWEEN
|SINO ESTATES MANAGEMENT |Applicant |
|LIMITED | |
|and | |
|CHUN MAN TSUN |Respondent |
___________________
|Before: |Her Honour Judge Michelle Lam |
| |Presiding Officer of the Lands Tribunal |
|Dates of Trial: |26 June 2026 |
|Date of Judgment: |29 June 2026 |
|J U D G M E N T |
INTRODUCTION
1. This is the Applicant’s application for an injunction order against
the Respondent for the purpose of restraining the Respondent from placing
any matter or thing or allowing any matter or thing to be placed (other
than motor vehicle) in a car parking space owned by the Respondent
(“Subject Space”).
BACKGROUND
2. The Subject Space is registered at the Land Registry as car parking
space no. 171 on carpark level, Dynasty Heights, No. 2 Yin Ping Road,
Kowloon.
3. The management of the Dynasty Heights (“Development”) is governed by
the Deed of Mutual Covenant and Management Agreement dated 19th January
1999 (“DMC”), which was registered in the Land Registry on 13 February
1999. Upon the execution of the DMC and pursuant to Clause 9 of it, the
Applicant has since been named and appointed as the “Manager” of the
Development under the DMC.
4. The Respondent has been the sole registered owner of the Subject
Space holding 2 equal undivided 8781th parts or shares of and in the
Development by virtue of an assignment dated 2 July 1999. The location of
the Subject Space is shown coloured pink in the Plan (“Subject Plan”)
annexed to the said assignment. The Respondent is also the registered
owner of one of the residential units of the Development.
5. In the present action, it is the Applicant’s claim that
notwithstanding its repeated requests and warnings, the Respondent has been
continuously in breach of the covenants under the DMC by placing, leaving
or causing/ allowing to be placed or left, at the Subject Space, matters or
things other than motor vehicle, necessitating an injunction order to stop,
remedy and prevent such breach.
6. The Applicant has arranged its sole witness, Mr Luk Man Wai (“Luk”),
to give evidence in the trial. Luk has been engaged as the Property
Manager of the Development since 20 May 2019.
SERVICE OF DOCUMENTS
7. According to the five affirmations of service filed by the Applicant,
the Notice of Application, Form 31, the Checklist, the witness statement of
Luk, the order dated 10 February 2026, the skeleton submissions and the
trial bundle have been properly served on the Respondent. On the other
hand, the Notice of Hearing and the Notice of Trial have also been sent to
the Respondent unreturned.
8. In the circumstances, I am satisfied that the Respondent should have
been aware of the progress of this action and this trial. He however has
not attended any hearing or this trial. Nor has he filed any Notice of
Opposition or documents for the purpose of this action. I therefore
allowed the trial to be proceeded in the absence of the Respondent.
DMC
9. The DMC contains the following clauses which are relevant to the
present action: -
i) Clause 4 provides: -
“The Owner or Owners for the time being of each Undivided Share
shall at all times hereafter be bound by and shall observe and
perform the covenants, provisions and restrictions contained
herein and in the FOURTH SCHEDULE hereto so far as the same
relate to such Undivided Share held by him or them and shall
hold each Undivided Share subject to the easements, rights and
privileges set out in the FIFTH SCHEDULE hereto.”
ii) Clause 36 provides: -
“The management of the Development shall subject to Clause 9 of
this Deed be undertaken by the Manager and each Owner hereby
APPOINTS the Manager as agent for all Owners in respect of any
matter concerning the Common Areas and Facilities duly
authorized in accordance with the provisions of this Deed with
full power of delegation to enforce the provisions of this Deed
against the other Owner or Owners. In addition to the other
powers expressly provided in this Deed, the Manager shall have
full and unrestricted authority to do all such acts and things
as may be necessary to expedient for or in connection with the
Development and the management thereof including in particular
but without in any way limiting the generality of the foregoing:-
……
(ae) To enforce the due observance and performance by the Owners
of the terms and conditions of the Conditions of this Deed and
to take action in respect of any breach thereof including the
commencement, conduct and defence of legal proceedings and the
registration and enforcement of charges as herein mentioned;”
iii) Clause 29 of the 4th Schedule provides: -
“No owner shall use the Car Parking Spaces in the Development
for any purpose other than for the purpose of parking licensed
motor vehicles only and no articles, goods or other things
except motor vehicles shall be allowed thereon. The Car Parking
Spaces shall be used solely for the purpose of parking licensed
motor vehicles belonging to the Owners or the residents of the
Residential Accommodation or their bona fide visitors.”
THE APPLICABLE LAW
10. An injunction is a discretionary remedy. It should be granted where
the defendant is continuing to breach an obligation undertaken in a deed of
mutual covenant unless there are good reasons not to: The Incorporated
Owners of Yee Fung Garden v Basic Tech Limited and Tin Shing Company
Limited HCA6622/1998 unreported 23 January 2003 §130.
DISCUSSION
11. Being the registered owner of the Subject Space holding undivided
shares of the Development, the Applicant is one of the co-owners of the
Development and accordingly, shall be bound by and shall observe and
perform the covenants, provisions and restrictions contained in the DMC.
12. Under Clause 29 of the 4th Schedule to the DMC, the Respondent is not
allowed to use the Subject Space for any purpose other than parking
licensed motor vehicles and no articles, goods or things except motor
vehicles shall be allowed thereon.
13. On the evidence before me, it is clear to me that since at least
around August 2022, the Respondent has been placing, leaving, or causing/
allowing to be placed or left, at the Subject Space, matters or things,
other than motor vehicle, as evidenced by a number of letters and
photographs (“Subject Photographs”) issued or taken during the period
between 5 August 2022 and 17 March 2026 as exhibited to Luk’s witness
statement.
14. During this trial, Luk also gave evidence in Court that he had
personally visited the Subject Space on various occasions and confirmed
that the Subject Space as shown in the Subject Plan is at the space with
boundary outlined by white paint with its number “171” painted on the floor
as shown in the Subject Photographs.
15. As depicted in the Subject Photographs, it can be seen that since at
least around 29 May 2023, various matters and things have been placed or
left at the rear end of the Subject Space, near the wall adjacent to the
rear end of the Subject Space. They include but not limited to a bicycle,
some carton boxes containing unidentified items, a luggage, some
fluorescent tubes, a cabinet and some other unidentified objects.
16. Recently, the photographs taken on 17 March 2026 show that a number
of folded carton boxes, furniture, some rolls of paper, some paintings,
some fluorescent tubes, a feather duster, some umbrellas and some other
unidentified objects in some large carton boxes were placed at the Subject
Space.
17. Worse still, due to the space of the Subject Space was reduced by
those things and matters placed thereat, the motor vehicle parked thereat
extruded from the boundary of the Subject Space and actually encroached the
area of the common pathway of the car park lot.
18. Luk gave further evidence (with photographs in support) in court that
he had conducted another inspection to the Subject Space on 25 June 2026.
During the inspection, he found a wooden chest, some ceramic articles, a
carpet and an umbrella were placed at the Subject space.
19. Given Luk’s evidence is detailed and well supported by
contemporaneous documentary proof and in the absence of any evidence to
suggest otherwise, I have no reason not to accept his evidence. Thus
considered, I accept the submission of Mr Ng, solicitor acting for the
Applicant, that by placing those matters and objects or allowing them to be
placed or left at the Subject Space, the Respondent has been in clear
breach of Clause 29 of the 4th Schedule to the DMC and the breach is
continuing.
20. In further consideration of the facts that: -
(a) the Respondent has been in breach of a restrictive covenant of
the DMC;
(b) the breach has been continuing for more than three years despite
the Applicant’s numerous requests and warnings, i.e. by way of
five letters issued by the Applicant or its solicitors to the
Respondent;
(c) the breach is continuing and there is no indication that the
breach will cease in the near future;
(d) the Development is a densely populated estate, and its owners
shall abide by the DMC to ensure each other’s rights are not
infringed;
(e) the Applicant has received complaints from other owners about
the Respondent’s unreasonable conducts;
(f) Pursuant to Clauses 9 and 36 of the DMC, the Applicant is duty-
bound to enforce the covenants and provisions of the DMC as well
as to ensure proper management of the Development and its
failure to do so may have adverse impact on it, the Development
and the owners.
I am of the view that the injunctions sought should be granted
for there have been no good reasons not to. Absent any
suggestion or evidence to suggest otherwise, there is no good
reason for the Respondent to place matters or things or allow
them to be left at the Subject Space, which amount to a clear
breach of Clause 29 of the 4th Schedule to the DMC.
21. Further, I share the view of Mr Ng that the efforts and costs
required of the Respondent complying with the injunctions are apparently
minimal. All the Respondent has to do is to remove the things and matters,
which are not huge fixtures or structures, and obviously could be easily
removed from the Subject Space.
22. At the end of the trial, further time has been given to the Applicant
to define and clarify the scope of the injunction sought. Having taken
further instructions from the Applicant, Mr Ng subsequently clarified and
further confirmed in writing that the scope of the injunction is confined
to the floor area and ground space of the Subject Space.
ORDER
23. Having considered the Applicant’s submissions and all the relevant
evidence before me, I am satisfied that the Applicant has successfully
proved its claim with solid evidence. I make the following order: -
1) An injunction that the Respondent, whether by himself or by the
servants or agents appointed by the Respondent or otherwise
howsoever, be restrained from placing or leaving, or causing/
allowing to be placed or left, any articles, items, matters or
things other than motor vehicle, at the Subject Space.
2) A mandatory injunction that the Respondent do remove all
the articles, items, matters or things, other than motor
vehicle, from the Subject Space at his own cost and expenses
within 14 days from the service of this Order.
COSTS
24. As to costs, the general rule is that costs should follow the event.
There are no special circumstances in this action to depart from the
general rule.
25. Having considered all the relevant circumstances and the Statement of
Costs of the Applicant, I make an order that the Respondent do pay the
Applicant the costs of this action, including all costs reserved and the
costs of the trial, summarily assessed at HK$40,000.
26. I thank Mr Ng for his assistance.
|Michelle LAM |
|Presiding Officer |
|Lands Tribunal |
Mr Michael C.W. Ng, of Liu, Chan & Lam, for the applicant
The Respondent was not represented and did not appear
-----------------------
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V
-----------------------
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V